Iron Carbide-Sulfide Carbonyl Clusters

Water-catalyzed iron-molybdenum carbyne formation in bimetallic acetylene transformation

Transition metal carbyne complexes are of fundamental importance in carbon-carbon bond formation, alkyne metathesis, and alkyne coupling reactions. Most reported iron carbyne complexes are stabilized by incorporating heteroatoms. Here we show the synthesis of bioinspired FeMo heterobimetallic carbyne complexes by the conversion of C2H2 through a diverse series of intermediates. Key reactions discovered include the reduction of a μ-η2:η2-C2H2 ligand with a hydride to produce a vinyl ligand (μ-η1:η2-CH = CH2), tautomerization of the vinyl ligand to a carbyne (μ-CCH3), and protonation of either the vinyl or the carbyne compound to form a hydrido carbyne heterobimetallic complex. Mechanistic studies unveil the pivotal role of H2O as a proton shuttle, facilitating the proton transfer that converts the vinyl group to a bridging carbyne.

Multi-phosphine-chelated iron-carbide clusters via redox-promoted ligand exchange on an inert hexa-iron-carbide carbonyl cluster, [Fe6(μ6-C)(μ2-CO)4(CO)12]2

We report the reactivity, structures and spectroscopic characterization of reactions of phosphine-based ligands (mono-, di- and tri-dentate) with iron-carbide carbonyl clusters. Historically, the archetype of this cluster class, namely [Fe6(μ6-C)(μ2-CO)4(CO)12]2-, can be prepared on a gram-scale but is resistant to simple ligand substitution reactions. This limitation has precluded the relevance of iron-carbide clusters relating to organometallics, catalysis and the nitrogenase active site cluster. Herein, we aimed to derive a simple and reliable method to accomplish CO → L (where L = phosphine or other general ligands) substitution reactions without harsh reagents or multi-step synthetic strategies. Ultimately, our goal was ligand-based chelation of an Fe n (μ n -C) core to achieve more synthetic control over multi-iron-carbide motifs relevant to the nitrogenase active site. We report that the key intermediate is the PSEPT-non-conforming cluster [Fe6(μ6-C)(CO)16] (2: 84 electrons), which can be generated in situ by the outer-sphere oxidation of [Fe6(μ6-C)(CO)16]2- (1: closo, 86 electrons) with 2 equiv. of [Fc]PF6. The reaction of 2 with excess PPh3 generates a singly substituted neutral cluster [Fe5(μ5-C)(CO)14PPh3] (4), similar to the reported reactivity of the substitutionally active cluster [Fe5(μ5-C)(CO)15] with monodentate phosphines (Cooke & Mays, 1990). In contrast, the reaction of 2 with flexible, bidentate phosphines (DPPE and DPPP) generates a wide range of unisolable products. However, the rigid bidentate phosphine bis(diphenylphosphino)benzene (bdpb) disproportionates the cluster into non-ligated Fe3-carbide anions paired with a bdpb-supported Fe(ii) cation, which co-crystallize in [Fe3(μ3-CH)(μ3-CO)(CO)9]2[Fe(MeCN)2(bdpb)2] (6). A successful reaction of 2 with the tripodal ligand Triphos generates the first multi-iron-chelated, authentic carbide cluster of the formula [Fe4(μ4-C)(κ3-Triphos)(CO)10] (9). DFT analysis of the key (oxidized) intermediate 2 suggests that its (μ6-C)Fe6 framework remains fully intact but is distorted into an axially compressed, 'ruffled' octahedron distinct from the parent closo cluster 1. Oxidation of the cluster in non-coordinating solvent allows for the isolation and crystallization of the CO-saturated, intact closo-analogue [Fe6(μ6-C)(CO)17] (3), indicating that the intact (μ6-C)Fe6 motif is retained during initial oxidation with [Fc]PF6. Overall, we demonstrate that redox modulation beneficially 'bends' Wade-Mingo's rules via the generation of electron-starved (non-PSEPT) intermediates, which are the key intermediates in promoting facile CO → L substitution reactions in iron-carbide-carbonyl clusters.

Highly Activated Terminal Carbon Monoxide Ligand in an Iron-Sulfur Cluster Model of FeMco with Intermediate Local Spin State at Fe

Nitrogenases, the enzymes that convert N2 to NH3, also catalyze the reductive coupling of CO to yield hydrocarbons. CO-coordinated species of nitrogenase clusters have been isolated and used to infer mechanistic information. However, synthetic FeS clusters displaying CO ligands remain rare, which limits benchmarking. Starting from a synthetic cluster that models a cubane portion of the FeMo cofactor (FeMoco), including a bridging carbyne ligand, we report a heterometallic tungsten-iron-sulfur cluster with a single terminal CO coordination in two oxidation states with a high level of CO activation (νCO = 1851 and 1751 cm-1). The local Fe coordination environment (2S, 1C, 1CO) is identical to that in the protein making this system a suitable benchmark. Computational studies find an unusual intermediate spin electronic configuration at the Fe sites promoted by the presence the carbyne ligand. This electronic feature is partly responsible for the high degree of CO activation in the reduced cluster.

Highly Reduced Ruthenium Carbide Carbonyl Clusters: Synthesis, Molecular Structure, Reactivity, Electrochemistry, and Computational Investigation of [Ru6C(CO)15]4

The reaction of [Ru6C(CO)16]2- (1) with NaOH in DMSO resulted in the formation of a highly reduced [Ru6C(CO)15]4- (2), which was readily protonated by acids, such as HBF4·Et2O, to [HRu6C(CO)15]3- (3). Oxidation of 2 with [Cp2Fe][PF6] or [C7H7][BF4] in CH3CN resulted in [Ru6C(CO)15(CH3CN)]2- (5), which was quantitatively converted into 1 after exposure to CO atmosphere. The reaction of 2 with a mild methylating agent such as CH3,I afforded the purported [Ru6C(CO)14(COCH3)]3- (6). By employing a stronger reagent, that is, CF3SO3CH3, a mixture of [HRu6C(CO)16]- (4), [H3Ru6C(CO)15]- (7), and [Ru6C(CO)15(CH3CNCH3)]- (8) was obtained. The molecular structures of 2-5, 7, and 8 were determined by single-crystal X-ray diffraction as their [NEt4]4[2]·CH3CN, [NEt4]3[3], [NEt4][4], [NEt4]2[5], [NEt4][7], and [NEt4][8]·solv salts. The carbyne-carbide cluster 6 was partially characterized by IR spectroscopy and ESI-MS, and its structure was computationally predicted using DFT methods. The redox behavior of 2 and 3 was investigated by electrochemical and IR spectroelectrochemical methods. Computational studies were performed in order to unravel structural and thermodynamic aspects of these octahedral Ru-carbide carbonyl clusters displaying miscellaneous ligands and charges in comparison with related iron derivatives.

Sulfur-Ligated [2Fe-2C] Clusters as Synthetic Model Systems for Nitrogenase

Metal clusters featuring carbon and sulfur donors have coordination environments comparable to the active site of nitrogenase enzymes. Here, we report a series of di-iron clusters supported by the dianionic yldiide ligands, in which the Fe sites are bridged by two μ2-C atoms and four pendant S donors.The [L2Fe2] (L = {[Ph2P(S)]2C}2-) cluster is isolable in two oxidation levels, all-ferrous Fe2II and mixed-valence FeIIFeIII. The mixed-valence cluster displays two peaks in the Mössbauer spectra, indicating slow electron transfer between the two sites. The addition of the Lewis base 4-dimethylaminopyridine to the Fe2II cluster results in coordination with only one of the two Fe sites, even in the presence of an excess base. Conversely, the cluster reacts with 8 equiv of isocyanide tBuNC to give a monometallic complex featuring a new C-C bond between the ligand backbone and the isocyanide. The electronic structure descriptions of these complexes are further supported by X-ray absorption and resonant X-ray emission spectroscopies.

Synthesis of a Fe3-Carbyne Motif by Oxidation of an Alkyl Ligated Iron-Sulfur (WFe3S3) Cluster

The presence of a carbide ligand in the active site of nitrogenases remains an unusual example of organometallic chemistry employed by a protein. Carbide incorporation into the MFe7S9C cluster involves complex biosynthesis, but analogous synthetic methodologies are limited. Herein, we present a new synthetic strategy for incorporating carbon based bridging ligands into iron-sulfur clusters. Starting from a halide precursor, a WFe3S3 cluster displaying three terminal alkyl ligands and an open Fe3 face was prepared. Oxidation results in loss of alkane and formation of a μ3-carbyne. Characterization of these clusters and mechanistic studies are presented.

Partial synthetic models of FeMoco with sulfide and carbyne ligands: Effect of interstitial atom in nitrogenase active site

Nitrogen-fixing organisms perform dinitrogen reduction to ammonia at an Fe-M (M = Mo, Fe, or V) cofactor (FeMco) of nitrogenase. FeMco displays eight metal centers bridged by sulfides and a carbide having the MFe₇S₈C cluster composition. The role of the carbide ligand, a unique motif in protein active sites, remains poorly understood. Toward addressing how the carbon bridge affects the physical and chemical properties of the cluster, we isolated synthetic models of subsite MFe₃S₃C displaying sulfides and a chelating carbyne ligand. We developed synthetic protocols for structurally related clusters, [Tp*M'Fe₃S₃X]^n-, where M' = Mo or W, the bridging ligand X = CR, N, NR, S, and Tp* = Tris(3,5-dimethyl-1-pyrazolyl)hydroborate, to study the effects of the identity of the heterometal and the bridging X group on structure and electrochemistry. While the nature of M' results in minor changes, the chelating, μ₃-bridging carbyne has a large impact on reduction potentials, being up to 1 V more reducing compared to nonchelating N and S analogs.

Transition Metal Carbide Complexes

Carbide complexes remain a rare class of molecules. Their paucity does not reflect exceptional instability but is rather due to the generally narrow scope of synthetic procedures for constructing carbide complexes. The preparation of carbide complexes typically revolves around generating L_nM-CE_x fragments, followed by cleavage of the C-E bonds of the coordinated carbon-based ligands (the alternative being direct C atom transfer). Prime examples involve deoxygenation of carbonyl ligands and deprotonation of methyl ligands, but several other p-block fragments can be cleaved off to afford carbide ligands. This Review outlines synthetic strategies toward terminal carbide complexes, bridging carbide complexes, as well as carbide-carbonyl cluster complexes. It then surveys the reactivity of carbide complexes, covering stoichiometric reactions where the carbide ligands act as C₁ reagents, engage in cross-coupling reactions, and enact Fischer-Tropsch-like chemistry; in addition, we discuss carbide complexes in the context of catalysis. Finally, we examine spectroscopic features of carbide complexes, which helps to establish the presence of the carbide functionality and address its electronic structure.

Structure, reactivity, and spectroscopy of nitrogenase-related synthetic and biological clusters

The reduction of dinitrogen (N2) is essential for its incorporation into nucleic acids and amino acids, which are vital to life on earth. Nitrogenases convert atmospheric dinitrogen to two ammonia molecules (NH3) under ambient conditions. The catalytic active sites of these enzymes (known as FeM-cofactor clusters, where M = Mo, V, Fe) are the sites of N2 binding and activation and have been a source of great interest for chemists for decades. In this review, recent studies on nitrogenase-related synthetic molecular complexes and biological clusters are discussed, with a focus on their reactivity and spectroscopic characterization. The molecular models that are discussed span from simple mononuclear iron complexes to multinuclear iron complexes and heterometallic iron complexes. In addition, recent work on the extracted biological cofactors is discussed. An emphasis is placed on how these studies have contributed towards our understanding of the electronic structure and mechanism of nitrogenases.

Metal carbonyl clusters of groups 8-10: synthesis and catalysis

In this review article, we discuss advances in the chemistry of metal carbonyl clusters (MCCs) spanning the last three decades, with an emphasis on the more recent reports and those involving groups 8-10 elements. Synthetic methods have advanced and been refined, leading to higher-nuclearity clusters and a wider array of structures and nuclearities. Our understanding of the electronic structure in MCCs has advanced to a point where molecular chemistry tools and other advanced tools can probe their properties at a level of detail that surpasses that possible with other nanomaterials and solid-state materials. MCCs therefore advance our understanding of structure-property-reactivity correlations in other higher-nuclearity materials. With respect to catalysis, this article focuses only on homogeneous applications, but it includes both thermally and electrochemically driven catalysis. Applications in thermally driven catalysis have found success where the reaction conditions stabilise the compounds toward loss of CO. In more recent years, MCCs, which exhibit delocalised bonding and possess many electron-withdrawing CO ligands, have emerged as very stable and effective for reductive electrocatalysis reactions since reduction often strengthens M-C(O) bonds and since room-temperature reaction conditions are sufficient for driving the electrocatalysis.

Single-Step Sulfur Insertions into Iron Carbide Carbonyl Clusters: Unlocking the Synthetic Door to FeMoco Analogues

The one-step syntheses, X-ray structures, and spectroscopic characterization of synthetic iron clusters, bearing either inorganic sulfides or thiolate with interstitial carbide motifs, are reported. Treatment of iron carbide carbonyl clusters [Fe_n (μ_n -C)(CO)_m ]^x (n=5,6; m=15,16; x=0,-2) with electrophilic sulfur sources (S₂ Cl₂ , S₈ ) results in the formation of several μ₄ -S dimers of clusters, and moreover, iron-sulfide-(sulfocarbide) clusters. The core sulfocarbide unit {C-S}^4- serves as a structural model for a proposed intermediate in the radical S-adenosyl-L-methionine biogenesis of the M-cluster. Furthermore, the electrophilic sulfur strategy has been extended to provide the first ever thiolato-iron-carbide complex: an analogous reaction with toluylsulfenyl chloride affords the cluster [Fe₅ (μ₅ -C)(SC₇ H₇ )(CO)₁₃ ]^- . The strategy described herein provides a breakthrough towards developing syntheses of biomimetic iron-sulfur-carbide clusters like FeMoco.

Construction of Synthetic Models for Nitrogenase-Relevant NifB Biogenesis Intermediates and Iron-Carbide-Sulfide Clusters

The family of nitrogenase enzymes catalyzes the reduction of atmospheric dinitrogen (N2) to ammonia under remarkably benign conditions of temperature, pressure, and pH. Therefore, the development of synthetic complexes or materials that can similarly perform this reaction is of critical interest. The primary obstacle for obtaining realistic synthetic models of the active site iron-sulfur-carbide cluster (e.g., FeMoco) is the incorporation of a truly inorganic carbide. This review summarizes the present state of knowledge regarding biological and chemical (synthetic) incorporation of carbide into iron-sulfur clusters. This includes the Nif cluster of proteins and associated biochemistry involved in the endogenous biogenesis of FeMoco. We focus on the chemical (synthetic) incorporation portion of our own efforts to incorporate and modify C1 units in iron/sulfur clusters. We also highlight recent contributions from other research groups in the area toward C1 and/or inorganic carbide insertion.

Reactions of [Fe6C(CO)14(S)]2-: Cluster Growth, Redox, Sulfiding

Redox reactions, substitutions, and metalations are reported for the iron carbido sulfide [Fe6C(CO)14(S)]2- ([1]2-). Dianion [1]2- oxidized to [Fe6C(CO)16(S)]0 ([2]0) upon treatment with of [Fe(C5H5)2]BF4 or HBF4 (H2 formation) under an atmosphere of CO. Reaction of [2]0 with tBuNC gave [Fe6C(S)(CO)13(tBuNC)5], consisting of Fe5C(CO)13 and [Fe(tBuNC)5]2+ subunits linked by a μ3-S2-. The Fe7CS cluster [Fe7C(CO)17(S)]2- formed upon treatment of (Ph4P)2[1] with Fe(benzylideneacetone)(CO)3. The Fe7 species is an edge-fused cluster with [Fe6C(CO)10(μ-CO)4] and Fe(CO)3 subunits joined by μ3-S and two Fe-Fe bonds. The analogous reaction using Mo(CO)4(norbornadiene) gave [MoFe6C(CO)18(S)]2-. In this cluster, the Mo center is located in the octahedral subunit. Treatment of [1]2- with SO2 afforded [Fe6C(S)(SO2)(CO)13]2-. This cluster features an Fe6C core decorated with μ3-S and μ2-SO2 ligands. These experiments were undertaken in an effort to connect organometallic clusters to FeMoco.

The Spectroscopy of Nitrogenases

Nitrogenases are responsible for biological nitrogen fixation, a crucial step in the biogeochemical nitrogen cycle. These enzymes utilize a two-component protein system and a series of iron-sulfur clusters to perform this reaction, culminating at the FeMco active site (M = Mo, V, Fe), which is capable of binding and reducing N2 to 2NH3. In this review, we summarize how different spectroscopic approaches have shed light on various aspects of these enzymes, including their structure, mechanism, alternative reactivity, and maturation. Synthetic model chemistry and theory have also played significant roles in developing our present understanding of these systems and are discussed in the context of their contributions to interpreting the nature of nitrogenases. Despite years of significant progress, there is still much to be learned from these enzymes through spectroscopic means, and we highlight where further spectroscopic investigations are needed.

Facile hydrogen atom abstraction and sulfide formation in a methyl-thiolate capped iron–sulfur–carbonyl cluster

SAM mediated methyl transfer and subsequent hydrogen atom abstraction are key steps in the biogenesis of nitrogenase. A model system was utilized to demonstrate facile C–H abstraction from a methyl-thiolate containing iron–sulfur cluster with TEMPO.

The influences of carbon donor ligands on biomimetic multi-iron complexes for N2 reduction

The active site clusters of nitrogenase enzymes possess the only examples of carbides in biology. These are the only biological FeS clusters that are capable of reducing N₂ to NH₄⁺, implicating the central carbon and its interaction with Fe as important in the mechanism of N₂ reduction. This biological question motivates study of the influence of carbon donors on the electronic structure and reactivity of unsaturated, high-spin iron centers. Here, we present functional and structural models that test the impacts of carbon donors and sulfide donors in simpler iron compounds. We report the first example of a diiron complex that is bridged by an alkylidene and a sulfide, which serves as a high-fidelity structural and spectroscopic model of a two-iron portion of the active-site cluster (FeMoco) in the resting state of Mo-nitrogenase. The model complexes have antiferromagnetically coupled pairs of high-spin iron centers, and sulfur K-edge X-ray absorption spectroscopy shows comparable covalency of the sulfide for C and S bridged species. The sulfur-bridged compound does not interact with N₂ even upon reduction, but upon removal of the sulfide it becomes capable of reducing N₂ to NH₄⁺ with the addition of protons and electrons. This provides synthetic support for sulfide extrusion in the activation of nitrogenase cofactors.

High-spin diiron alkylidenes give insight into the electronic structure and functional relevance of carbon in the FeMoco active site of nitrogenase.

Spectroscopic X-ray and Mössbauer Characterization of M6 and M5 Iron(Molybdenum)-Carbonyl Carbide Clusters: High Carbide-Iron Covalency Enhances Local Iron Site Electron Density Despite Cluster Oxidation

The present study employs a suite of spectroscopic techniques to evaluate the electronic and bonding characteristics of the interstitial carbide in a set of iron-carbonyl-carbide clusters, one of which is substituted with a molybdenum atom. The M₆C and M₅C clusters are the dianions (Et₄N)₂[Fe₆(μ₆-C)(μ₂-CO)₂(CO)₁₄] (1), [K(benzo-18-crown-6)]₂[Fe₅(μ₅-C)(μ₂-CO)₁(CO)₁₃] (2), and [K(benzo-18-crown-6)]₂[Fe₅Mo(μ₆-C)(μ₂-CO)₂(CO)₁₅] (3). Because 1 and 2 have the same overall cluster charge (2−) but different numbers of iron sites (1: 6 sites → 2: 5 sites), the metal atoms of 2 are formally oxidized compared to those in 1. Despite this, Mössbauer studies indicate that the iron sites in 2 possess significantly greater electron density (lower spectroscopic oxidation state) compared with those in 1. Iron K-edge X-ray absorption and valence-to-core X-ray emission spectroscopy measurements, paired with density functional theory spectral calculations, revealed the presence of significant metal-to-metal and carbide 2p-based character in the filled valence and low-lying unfilled electronic manifolds. In all of the above experiments, the presence of the molybdenum atom in 3 (Fe₅Mo) results in somewhat unremarkable spectroscopic properties that are essentially a “hybrid” of 1 (Fe₆) and 2 (Fe₅). The overall electronic portrait that emerges illustrates that the central inorganic carbide ligand is essential for distributing charge and maximizing electronic communication throughout the cluster. It is evident that the carbide coordination environment is quite flexible and adaptive: it can drastically modify the covalency of individual Fe–C bonds based on local structural changes and redox manipulation of the clusters. In light of these findings, our data and calculations suggest a potential role for the central carbon atom in FeMoco, which likely performs a similar function in order to maintain cluster integrity through multiple redox and ligand binding events.

An in-depth spectroscopic investigation of a series of iron-carbonyl carbide complexes: [Fe₆C] (1), [Fe₅C] (2), and [Fe₅CMo] (3) is described. Using Mössbauer spectroscopy, valence-to-core X-ray emission spectroscopy, and high-energy-resolution fluorescence-detected X-ray absorption spectroscopy, we detail the ability of the conserved central carbon atom in maintaining cluster stability despite dramatic geometric rearrangements. Our study suggests a potential role for the interstitial carbide in FeMoco as an electronic modulator, allowing for charge and ligand accumulation under turnover conditions.

Nitrogenase-Relevant Reactivity of a Synthetic Iron-Sulfur-Carbon Site

Simple synthetic compounds with only S and C donors offer a ligation environment similar to the active site of nitrogenase (FeMoco) and thus demonstrate reasonable mechanisms and geometries for N₂ binding and reduction in nature. We recently reported the first example of N₂ binding at a mononuclear iron site supported by only S and C donors. In this work, we report experiments that examine the mechanism of N₂ binding in this system. The reduction of an iron(II) tris(thiolate) complex with 1 equiv of KC₈ leads to a thermally unstable intermediate, and a combination of Mössbauer, EPR, and X-ray absorption spectroscopies identifies it as a high-spin (S = 3/2) iron(I) species that maintains coordination of all three sulfur atoms. DFT calculations suggest that this iron(I) intermediate has a pseudotetrahedral geometry that resembles the S₃C iron coordination environment of the belt iron sites in the resting state of the FeMoco. Further reduction to the iron(0) oxidation level under argon causes the dissociation of one of the thiolate donors and gives an η⁶-arene species which reacts with N₂. Thus, in this system the loss of thiolate and binding of N₂ require reduction beyond the iron(I) level to the iron(0) level. Further reduction of the iron(0)-N₂ complex gives a reactive, formally iron(-I) species. Treatment of the putative iron(-I) complex with weak acids gives low yields of ammonia and hydrazine, demonstrating that these nitrogenase products can be generated from N₂ at a synthetic Fe-S-C site. Catalytic N₂ reduction is not observed, which is attributed to protonation of the supporting ligand and degradation of the complex via ligand dissociation. Identification of the challenges in this system gives insight into the design features needed for functional biomimetic complexes.