Secondary Coordination Sphere Design to Modify Transport of Protons and CO2

Multi-phosphine-chelated iron-carbide clusters via redox-promoted ligand exchange on an inert hexa-iron-carbide carbonyl cluster, [Fe6(μ6-C)(μ2-CO)4(CO)12]2

We report the reactivity, structures and spectroscopic characterization of reactions of phosphine-based ligands (mono-, di- and tri-dentate) with iron-carbide carbonyl clusters. Historically, the archetype of this cluster class, namely [Fe6(μ6-C)(μ2-CO)4(CO)12]2-, can be prepared on a gram-scale but is resistant to simple ligand substitution reactions. This limitation has precluded the relevance of iron-carbide clusters relating to organometallics, catalysis and the nitrogenase active site cluster. Herein, we aimed to derive a simple and reliable method to accomplish CO → L (where L = phosphine or other general ligands) substitution reactions without harsh reagents or multi-step synthetic strategies. Ultimately, our goal was ligand-based chelation of an Fe n (μ n -C) core to achieve more synthetic control over multi-iron-carbide motifs relevant to the nitrogenase active site. We report that the key intermediate is the PSEPT-non-conforming cluster [Fe6(μ6-C)(CO)16] (2: 84 electrons), which can be generated in situ by the outer-sphere oxidation of [Fe6(μ6-C)(CO)16]2- (1: closo, 86 electrons) with 2 equiv. of [Fc]PF6. The reaction of 2 with excess PPh3 generates a singly substituted neutral cluster [Fe5(μ5-C)(CO)14PPh3] (4), similar to the reported reactivity of the substitutionally active cluster [Fe5(μ5-C)(CO)15] with monodentate phosphines (Cooke & Mays, 1990). In contrast, the reaction of 2 with flexible, bidentate phosphines (DPPE and DPPP) generates a wide range of unisolable products. However, the rigid bidentate phosphine bis(diphenylphosphino)benzene (bdpb) disproportionates the cluster into non-ligated Fe3-carbide anions paired with a bdpb-supported Fe(ii) cation, which co-crystallize in [Fe3(μ3-CH)(μ3-CO)(CO)9]2[Fe(MeCN)2(bdpb)2] (6). A successful reaction of 2 with the tripodal ligand Triphos generates the first multi-iron-chelated, authentic carbide cluster of the formula [Fe4(μ4-C)(κ3-Triphos)(CO)10] (9). DFT analysis of the key (oxidized) intermediate 2 suggests that its (μ6-C)Fe6 framework remains fully intact but is distorted into an axially compressed, 'ruffled' octahedron distinct from the parent closo cluster 1. Oxidation of the cluster in non-coordinating solvent allows for the isolation and crystallization of the CO-saturated, intact closo-analogue [Fe6(μ6-C)(CO)17] (3), indicating that the intact (μ6-C)Fe6 motif is retained during initial oxidation with [Fc]PF6. Overall, we demonstrate that redox modulation beneficially 'bends' Wade-Mingo's rules via the generation of electron-starved (non-PSEPT) intermediates, which are the key intermediates in promoting facile CO → L substitution reactions in iron-carbide-carbonyl clusters.

From Biomimicking to Bioinspired Design of Electrocatalysts for CO2 Reduction to C1 Products

The electrochemical reduction of CO2 (CO2 RR) is a promising approach to maintain a carbon cycle balance and produce value-added chemicals. However, CO2 RR technology is far from mature, since the conventional CO2 RR electrocatalysts suffer from low activity (leading to currents <10 mA cm-2 in an H-cell), stability (<120 h), and selectivity. Hence, they cannot meet the requirements for commercial applications (>200 mA cm-2 , >8000 h, >90 % selectivity). Significant improvements are possible by taking inspiration from nature, considering biological organisms that efficiently catalyze the CO2 to various products. In this minireview, we present recent examples of enzyme-inspired and enzyme-mimicking CO2 RR electrocatalysts enabling the production of C1 products with high faradaic efficiency (FE). At present, these designs do not typically follow a methodical approach, but rather focus on isolated features of biological systems. To achieve disruptive change, we advocate a systematic design methodology that leverages fundamental mechanisms associated with desired properties in nature and adapts them to the context of engineering applications.

Proton transfer kinetics of transition metal hydride complexes and implications for fuel-forming reactions

Proton transfer reactions involving transition metal hydride complexes are prevalent in a number of catalytic fuel-forming reactions, where the proton transfer kinetics to or from the metal center can have significant impacts on the efficiency, selectivity, and stability associated with the catalytic cycle. This review correlates the often slow proton transfer rate constants of transition metal hydride complexes to their electronic and structural descriptors and provides perspective on how to exploit these parameters to control proton transfer kinetics to and from the metal center. A toolbox of techniques for experimental determination of proton transfer rate constants is discussed, and case studies where proton transfer rate constant determination informs fuel-forming reactions are highlighted. Opportunities for extending proton transfer kinetic measurements to additional systems are presented, and the importance of synergizing the thermodynamics and kinetics of proton transfer involving transition metal hydride complexes is emphasized.

Exploring the Parameters Controlling Product Selectivity in Electrochemical CO2 Reduction in Competition with Hydrogen Evolution Employing Manganese Bipyridine Complexes

Selective reduction of CO₂ is an efficient solution for producing nonfossil-based chemical feedstocks and simultaneously alleviating the increasing atmospheric concentration of this greenhouse gas. With this aim, molecular electrocatalysts are being extensively studied, although selectivity remains an issue. In this work, a combined experimental-computational study explores how the molecular structure of Mn-based complexes determines the dominant product in the reduction of CO₂ to HCOOH, CO, and H₂. In contrast to previous Mn(bpy-R)(CO)₃Br catalysts containing alkyl amines in the vicinity of the Br ligand, here, we report that bpy-based macrocycles locking these amines at the side opposite to the Br ligand change the product selectivity from HCOOH to H₂. Ab initio molecular dynamics simulations of the active species showed that free rotation of the Mn(CO)₃ moiety allows for the approach of the protonated amine to the reactive center yielding a Mn-hydride intermediate, which is the key in the formation of H₂ and HCOOH. Additional studies with DFT methods showed that the macrocyclic moiety hinders the insertion of CO₂ to the metal hydride favoring the formation of H₂ over HCOOH. Further, our results suggest that the minor CO product observed experimentally is formed when CO₂ adds to Mn on the side opposite to the amine ligand before protonation. These results show how product selectivity can be modulated by ligand design in Mn-based catalysts, providing atomistic details that can be leveraged in the development of a fully selective system.

Pre-Equilibrium Reaction Mechanism as a Strategy to Enhance Rate and Lower Overpotential in Electrocatalysis

Pre-equilibrium reaction kinetics enable the overall rate of a catalytic reaction to be orders of magnitude faster than the rate-determining step. Herein, we demonstrate how pre-equilibrium kinetics can be applied to breaking the linear free-energy relationship (LFER) for electrocatalysis, leading to rate enhancement 5 orders of magnitude and lowering of overpotential to approximately thermoneutral. This approach is applied to pre-equilibrium formation of a metal-hydride intermediate to achieve fast formate formation rates from CO₂ reduction without loss of selectivity (i.e., H₂ evolution). Fast pre-equilibrium metal-hydride formation, at 10⁸ M^-1 s^-1, boosts the CO₂ electroreduction to formate rate up to 296 s^-1. Compared with molecular catalysts that have similar overpotential, this rate is enhanced by 5 orders of magnitude. As an alternative comparison, overpotential is lowered by ∼50 mV compared to catalysts with a similar rate. The principles elucidated here to obtain pre-equilibrium reaction kinetics via catalyst design are general. Design and development that builds on these principles should be possible in both molecular homogeneous and heterogeneous electrocatalysis.

Surface and Interface Coordination Chemistry Learned from Model Heterogeneous Metal Nanocatalysts: From Atomically Dispersed Catalysts to Atomically Precise Clusters

The surface and interface coordination structures of heterogeneous metal catalysts are crucial to their catalytic performance. However, the complicated surface and interface structures of heterogeneous catalysts make it challenging to identify the molecular-level structure of their active sites and thus precisely control their performance. To address this challenge, atomically dispersed metal catalysts (ADMCs) and ligand-protected atomically precise metal clusters (APMCs) have been emerging as two important classes of model heterogeneous catalysts in recent years, helping to build bridge between homogeneous and heterogeneous catalysis. This review illustrates how the surface and interface coordination chemistry of these two types of model catalysts determines the catalytic performance from multiple dimensions. The section of ADMCs starts with the local coordination structure of metal sites at the metal-support interface, and then focuses on the effects of coordinating atoms, including their basicity and hardness/softness. Studies are also summarized to discuss the cooperativity achieved by dual metal sites and remote effects. In the section of APMCs, the roles of surface ligands and supports in determining the catalytic activity, selectivity, and stability of APMCs are illustrated. Finally, some personal perspectives on the further development of surface coordination and interface chemistry for model heterogeneous metal catalysts are presented.

A guide to secondary coordination sphere editing

This tutorial review showcases recent (2015-2021) work describing ligand construction as it relates to the design of secondary coordination spheres (SCSs). Metalloenzymes, for example, utilize SCSs to stabilize reactive substrates, shuttle small molecules, and alter redox properties, promoting functional activity. In the realm of biomimetic chemistry, specific incorporation of SCS residues (e.g., Brønsted or Lewis acid/bases, crown ethers, redox groups etc.) has been shown to be equally critical to function. This contribution illustrates how fundamental advances in organic and inorganic chemistry have been used for the construction of such SCSs. These imaginative contributions have driven exciting findings in many transformations relevant to clean fuel generation, including small molecule (e.g., H⁺, N₂, CO₂, NO_x, O₂) reduction. In most cases, these reactions occur cooperatively, where both metal and ligand are requisite for substrate activation.

Outer-coordination sphere in multi-H+/multi-e-molecular electrocatalysis

Electrocatalysis is an indispensable technique for small-molecule transformations, which are essential for the sustainability of society. Electrocatalysis utilizes electricity as an energy source for chemical reactions. Hydrogen is considered the “fuel for the future,” and designing electrocatalysts for hydrogen production has thus become critical. Furthermore, fuel cells are promising energy solutions that require robust electrocatalysts for key fuel cell reactions such as the interconversion of oxygen to water. Concerns regarding the rising concentration of atmospheric carbon dioxide have prompted the search for CO₂ conversion methods. One promising approach is the electrochemical conversion of CO₂ into commodity chemicals and/or liquid fuels, but such chemistry is highly energy demanding because of the thermodynamic stability of CO₂. All of the above-mentioned electrocatalytic processes rely on the selective input of multiple protons (H⁺) and electrons (e^–) to yield the desired products. Biological enzymes evolved in nature to perform such redox catalysis and have inspired the design of catalysts at the molecular and atomic levels. While it is synthetically challenging to mimic the exact biological environment, incorporating functional outer coordination spheres into molecular catalysts has shown promise for advancing multi-H⁺ and multi-e^– electrocatalysis. From this Perspective, herein, catalysts with outer coordination sphere(s) are selected as the inspiration for developing new catalysts, particularly for the reductive conversion of H⁺, O₂, and CO₂, which are highly relevant to sustainability. The recent progress in electrocatalysis and opportunities to explore beyond the second coordination sphere are also emphasized.

Switching Catalyst Selectivity via the Introduction of a Pendant Nitrophenyl Group

The conversion of abundant small molecules to value-added products serves as an attractive method to store renewable energy in chemical bonds. A family of macrocyclic cobalt aminopyridine complexes was previously reported to reduce CO₂ to CO with 98% faradaic efficiency through the formation of hydrogen-bonding networks and with the number of secondary amines affecting catalyst performance. One of these aminopyridine macrocycles, (NH)₁(NMe)₃-bridged calix[4]pyridine (L⁵), was modified with a nitrophenyl group to form L^NO2 and metalated with a cobalt(II) precursor to generate CoL^NO2, which would allow for probing the positioning and steric effects on catalysis. The addition of a nitrophenyl moiety to the ligand backbone results in a drastic shift in selectivity. Large current increases in the presence of added protons and CoL^NO2 are observed under both N₂ and CO₂. The current increases under N₂ are ∼30 times larger than the ones under CO₂, suggesting a change in the selectivity of CoL^NO2 to favor H₂ production versus CO₂ reduction. H₂ is determined to be the dominant reduction product by gas chromatography, reaching faradaic efficiencies up to 76% under N₂ with TFE and 71% under CO₂ with H₂O, in addition to small amounts of formate. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) reveals the presence of a cobalt-containing heterogeneous deposit on the working electrode surface, indicating the addition of the nitrophenyl group reduces the electrochemical stability of the catalyst. These observed catalytic behaviors are demonstrably different relative to the tetra-NH bridged macrocycle, which shows 98% faradaic efficiency for CO₂-to-CO conversion with TFE, highlighting the importance of pendant hydrogen bond donors and electrochemically robust functional groups for selective CO₂ conversion.

Effects of Protonation State on Electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction by a Cobalt Aminopyridine Macrocyclic Complex

A critical component in the reduction of CO₂ to CO and H₂O is the delivery of 2 equiv of protons and electrons to the CO₂ molecule. The timing and sequencing of these proton and electron transfer steps are essential factors in directing the activity and selectivity for catalytic CO₂ reduction. In previous studies, we have reported a series of macrocyclic aminopyridine cobalt complexes capable of reducing CO₂ to CO with high faradaic efficiencies. Kinetic investigations reveal a relationship between the observed rate constant (k_obs) and the number of pendant amine hydrogen bond donors minus one, suggesting the presence of a deprotonated active catalytic state. Herein, we investigate the feasibility of these proposed deprotonated complexes toward CO₂ reduction. Two deprotonated derivatives, Co(L^4-) and Co(L^2-), of the tetraamino macrocycle Co(L) were independently synthesized and structurally characterized revealing extensive delocalization of the negative charge upon deprotonation. ¹H nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and ultraviolet-visible titration studies confirm that under catalytic conditions, the active form of the catalyst gradually becomes deprotonated, supporting thus the n_donor - 1 relationship with k_obs. Electrochemical studies of Co(L^4-) reveal that this deprotonated analogue is competent for electrocatalysis upon addition of an exogenous weak acid source, such as 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol, resulting in faradaic efficiencies for CO₂-to-CO conversion identical to those observed with the fully protonated derivative (>98%).

Activating the Fe(I) State of Iron Porphyrinoid with Second-Sphere Proton Transfer Residues for Selective Reduction of CO2 to HCOOH via Fe(III/II)-COOH Intermediate(s)

The ability to tune the selectivity of CO₂ reduction by first-row transition metal-based complexes via the inclusion of second-sphere effects heralds exciting and sought-after possibilities. On the basis of the mechanistic understanding of CO₂ reduction by iron porphyrins developed by trapping and characterizing the intermediates involved ( J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2015, 137, 11214), a porphyrinoid ligand is envisaged to switch the selectivity of the iron porphyrins by reducing CO₂ from CO to HCOOH as well as lower the overpotential to the process. The results show that the iron porphyrinoid designed can catalyze the reduction of CO₂ to HCOOH using water as the proton source with 97% yield with no detectable H₂ or CO. The iron porphyrinoid can activate CO₂ in its Fe(I) state resulting in very low overpotential for CO₂ reduction in contrast to all reported iron porphyrins, which can reduce CO₂ in their Fe(0) state. Intermediates involved in CO₂ reduction, Fe(III)-COOH and a Fe(II)-COOH, are identified with in situ FTIR-SEC and subsequently chemically generated and characterized using FTIR, resonance Raman, and Mössbauer spectroscopy. The mechanism of the reaction helps elucidate a key role played by a closely placed proton transfer residue in aiding CO₂ binding to Fe(I), stabilizing the intermediates, and determining the fate of a rate-determining Fe(II)-COOH intermediate.

Metal carbonyl clusters of groups 8-10: synthesis and catalysis

In this review article, we discuss advances in the chemistry of metal carbonyl clusters (MCCs) spanning the last three decades, with an emphasis on the more recent reports and those involving groups 8-10 elements. Synthetic methods have advanced and been refined, leading to higher-nuclearity clusters and a wider array of structures and nuclearities. Our understanding of the electronic structure in MCCs has advanced to a point where molecular chemistry tools and other advanced tools can probe their properties at a level of detail that surpasses that possible with other nanomaterials and solid-state materials. MCCs therefore advance our understanding of structure-property-reactivity correlations in other higher-nuclearity materials. With respect to catalysis, this article focuses only on homogeneous applications, but it includes both thermally and electrochemically driven catalysis. Applications in thermally driven catalysis have found success where the reaction conditions stabilise the compounds toward loss of CO. In more recent years, MCCs, which exhibit delocalised bonding and possess many electron-withdrawing CO ligands, have emerged as very stable and effective for reductive electrocatalysis reactions since reduction often strengthens M-C(O) bonds and since room-temperature reaction conditions are sufficient for driving the electrocatalysis.

Alkali Metal Adducts of an Iron(0) Complex and Their Synergistic FLP-Type Activation of Aliphatic C-X Bonds

We report the formation and full characterization of weak adducts between Li⁺ and Na⁺ cations and a neutral iron(0) complex, [Fe(CO)₃(PMe₃)₂] (1), supported by weakly coordinating [BAr^F₂₀] anions, [1·M][BAr^F₂₀] (M = Li, Na). The adducts are found to synergistically activate aliphatic C-X bonds (X = F, Cl, Br, I, OMs, OTf), leading to the formation of iron(II) organyl compounds of the type [FeR(CO)₃(PMe₃)₂][BAr^F₂₀], of which several were isolated and fully characterized. Stoichiometric reactions with the resulting iron(II) organyl compounds show that this system can be utilized for homocoupling and cross-coupling reactions and the formation of new C-E bonds (E = C, H, O, N, S). Further, we utilize [1·M][BAr^F₂₀] as a catalyst in a simple hydrodehalogenation reaction under mild conditions to showcase its potential use in catalytic reactions. Finally, the mechanism of activation is probed using DFT and kinetic experiments that reveal that the alkali metal and iron(0) center cooperate to cleave C-X via a mechanism closely related to intramolecular FLP activation.

Quantification of the Electrostatic Effect on Redox Potential by Positive Charges in a Catalyst Microenvironment

Charged functional groups in the secondary coordination sphere (SCS) of a heterogeneous nanoparticle or homogeneous electrocatalyst are of growing interest due to enhancements in reactivity that derive from specific interactions that stabilize substrate binding or charged intermediates. At the same time, accurate benchmarking of electrocatalyst systems most often depends on the development of linear free-energy scaling relationships. However, the thermodynamic axis in those kinetic-thermodynamic correlations is most often obtained by a direct electrochemical measurement of the catalyst redox potential and might be influenced by electrostatic effects of a charged SCS. In this report, we systematically probe positive charges in a SCS and their electrostatic contributions to the electrocatalyst redox potential. A series of 11 iron carbonyl clusters modified with charged and uncharged ligands was probed, and a linear correlation between the ν_CO absorption band energy and electrochemical redox potentials is observed except where the SCS is positively charged.

Effects of Appended Poly(ethylene glycol) on Electrochemical CO2 Reduction by an Iron Porphyrin Complex

Electrochemical carbon dioxide (CO₂) reduction is a sustainable approach for transforming atmospheric CO₂ into chemical feedstocks and fuels. To overcome the kinetic barriers of electrocatalytic CO₂ reduction, catalysts with high selectivity, activity, and stability are needed. Here, we report an iron porphyrin complex, FePEGP, with a poly(ethylene glycol) unit in the second coordination sphere, as a highly selective and active electrocatalyst for the electrochemical reduction of CO₂ to carbon monoxide (CO). Controlled-potential electrolysis using FePEGP showed a Faradaic efficiency of 98% and a current density of -7.8 mA/cm² at -2.2 V versus Fc/Fc⁺ in acetonitrile using water as the proton source. The maximum turnover frequency was calculated to be 1.4 × 10⁵ s^-1 using foot-of-the-wave analysis. Distinct from most other catalysts, the kinetic isotope effect (KIE) study revealed that the protonation step of the Fe-CO₂ adduct is not involved in the rate-limiting step. This model shows that the PEG unit as the secondary coordination sphere enhances the catalytic kinetics and thus is an effective design for electrocatalytic CO₂ reduction.

Enhanced Electrocatalytic Activity of a Zinc Porphyrin for CO2 Reduction: Cooperative Effects of Triazole Units in the Second Coordination Sphere

The control of the second coordination sphere in a coordination complex plays an important role in improving catalytic efficiency. Herein, we report a zinc porphyrin complex ZnPor8T with multiple flexible triazole units comprising the second coordination sphere, as an electrocatalyst for the highly selective electrochemical reduction of carbon dioxide (CO₂ ) to carbon monoxide (CO). This electrocatalyst converted CO₂ to CO with a Faradaic efficiency of 99 % and a current density of -6.2 mA cm^-2 at -2.4 V vs. Fc/Fc⁺ in N,N-dimethylformamide using water as the proton source. Structure-function relationship studies were carried out on ZnPor8T analogs containing different numbers of triazole units and distinct triazole geometries; these unveiled that the triazole units function cooperatively to stabilize the CO₂ -catalyst adduct in order to facilitate intramolecular proton transfer. Our findings demonstrate that incorporating triazole units that function in a cooperative manner is a versatile strategy to enhance the activity of electrocatalytic CO₂ conversion.

Electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction with a Half-Sandwich Cobalt Catalyst: Selectivity towards CO

We present herein a Cp*Co(III)-half-sandwich catalyst system for electrocatalytic CO₂ reduction in aqueous acetonitrile solution. In addition to an electron-donating Cp* ligand (Cp*=pentamethylcyclopentadienyl), the catalyst featured a proton-responsive pyridyl-benzimidazole-based N,N-bidentate ligand. Owing to the presence of a relatively electron-rich Co center, the reduced Co(I)-state was made prone to activate the electrophilic carbon center of CO₂ . At the same time, the proton-responsive benzimidazole scaffold was susceptible to facilitate proton-transfer during the subsequent reduction of CO₂ . The above factors rendered the present catalyst active toward producing CO as the major product over the other potential 2e/2H⁺ reduced product HCOOH, in contrast to the only known similar half-sandwich CpCo(III)-based CO₂ -reduction catalysts which produced HCOOH selectively. The system exhibited a Faradaic efficiency (FE) of about 70% while the overpotential for CO production was found to be 0.78 V, as determined by controlled-potential electrolysis.