Indigenous Proline is a Two-Dimensional Safety-Relief Valve in Balancing Specific Amino Acids in Rice under Hexavalent Chromium Stress

Biochemical insights into proline metabolism and its contribution to the endurant cell wall structure under metal stress

The cell wall serves as the primary barrier against the entry of heavy metal ions into cells. However, excessive accumulation of heavy metals within plants can lead to alterations in the spatial structure and physical properties of the cell wall, thereby affecting the capacity of plants to capture heavy metals. Proline (Pro) is involved in the synthesis of the cell wall, modulating the stability and integrity of its structure. Extensins, core proteins that maintain the cell wall structure, are proline/hydroxyproline-rich glycoproteins that contain the characteristic sequence Ser-[Pro]3-5. They act as intermediates in the regulation of biological processes such as cell wall synthesis, assembly, and signal transduction, typically forming a network structure of cell wall proteins through cross-linking with pectin. This network is essential for the self-assembly expansion of the plant cell wall and plays an indispensable role in cell wall stress signal transduction through its interaction with intracellular signalling molecules. However, the mechanisms by which Pro affects the synthesis of cell wall structural proteins, cell wall assembly, and the sensing of cell wall stress under heavy metal stress remain unclear. This review, from the perspectives of biochemistry and molecular biology, comprehensively elaborates on the impact of Pro and Pro-rich proteins on the structure and function of the cell wall. These findings emphasize the mechanism by which Pro enhances the ability of the cell wall to capture heavy metals, providing new research ideas for the use of genetic engineering to manipulate cell wall synthesis and repair, thereby reducing the phytotoxicity of heavy metals.

Cytokinin and indole-3-acetic acid crosstalk is indispensable for silicon mediated chromium stress tolerance in roots of wheat seedlings

The rising heavy metal contamination of soils imposes toxic impacts on plants as well as other life forms. One such highly toxic and carcinogenic heavy metal is hexavalent chromium [Cr(VI)] that has been reported to prominently retard the plant growth. The present study investigated the potential of silicon (Si, 10 µM) to alleviate the toxicity of Cr(VI) (25 µM) on roots of wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) seedlings. Application of Si to Cr(VI)-stressed wheat seedlings improved their overall growth parameters. This study also reveals the involvement of two phytohormones, namely auxin and cytokinin and their crosstalk in Si-mediated mitigation of the toxic impacts of Cr(VI) in wheat seedlings. The application of cytokinin alone to wheat seedlings under Cr(VI) stress reduced the intensity of toxic effects of Cr(VI). In combination with Si, cytokinin application to Cr(VI)-stressed wheat seedlings significantly minimized the decrease induced by Cr(VI) in different parameters such as root-shoot length (10.8% and 13%, respectively), root-shoot fresh mass (11.3% and 10.1%, respectively), and total chlorophyll and carotenoids content (13.4% and 6.8%, respectively) with respect to the control. This treatment also maintained the regulation of proline metabolism (proline content, and P5CS and PDH activities), ascorbate-glutathione (AsA-GSH) cycle and nutrient homeostasis. The protective effect of Si and cytokinin against Cr(VI) stress was minimized upon supplementation of an inhibitor of polar auxin transport- 2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid (TIBA) which suggested a potential involvement of auxin in Si and cytokinin-mediated mitigation of Cr(VI) toxicity. The exogenous addition of a natural auxin - indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) confirmed auxin is an active member of a signaling cascade along with cytokinin that aids in Si-mediated Cr(VI) toxicity alleviation as IAA application reversed the negative impacts of TIBA on wheat roots treated with Cr(VI), cytokinin and Si. The results of this research are also confirmed by the gene expression analysis conducted for nutrient transporters (Lsi1, CCaMK, MHX, SULT1 and ZIP1) and enzymes involved in the AsA-GSH cycle (APX, GR, DHAR and MDHAR). The overall results of this research indicate towards possible induction of a crosstalk between cytokinin and IAA upon Si supplementation which in turn stimulates physiological, biochemical and molecular changes to exhibit protective effects against Cr(VI) stress. Further, the information obtained suggests probable employment of Si, cytokinin and IAA alone or combined in agriculture to maintain plant productivity under Cr(VI) stress and data regarding expression of key genes can be used to develop new crop varieties with enhanced resistance against Cr(VI) stress together with its reduced load in seedlings.

Gaseous signaling molecule H2S as a multitasking signal molecule in ROS metabolism of Oryza sativa under thiocyanate (SCN-) pollution

The induction of disruption in the electronic transport chain by thiocyanate (SCN-) leads to an excessive generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) within rice (Oryza sativa). Hydrogen sulfide (H2S) assumes a crucial role as a gaseous signaling molecule, holding significant potential in alleviating SCN--related stress. Nevertheless, there remains a dearth of understanding regarding the intricate interplay between H2S and ROS in Oryza sativa amidst SCN- pollution. In this investigation, a hydroponics-based experiment was meticulously devised to explore how H2S-mediated modifications influence the genetic feedback network governing ROS metabolism within the subcellular organelles of Oryza sativa when exposed to varying effective concentrations (EC20: 24 mg SCN/L; EC50: 96 mg SCN/L; EC75: 300 mg SCN/L) of SCN-. The findings unveiled the enhanced capacity of Oryza sativa to uptake SCN- under H2S + SCN- treatments in comparison to SCN- treatments alone. Notably, the relative growth rate (RGR) of seedlings subjected to H2S + SCN- exhibited a superior performance when contrasted with seedlings exposed solely to SCN-. Furthermore, the application of exogenous H2S yielded a significant reduction in ROS levels within Oryza sativa tissues during SCN- exposure. To elucidate the intricacies of gene regulation governing ROS metabolism at the mRNA level, the 52 targeted genes were categorized into four distinct types, namely: initial regulatory ROS generation genes (ROS-I), direct ROS scavenging genes (ROS-II), indirect ROS scavenging genes (ROS-III), and lipid oxidation genes (ROS-IV). On the whole, exogenous H2S exhibited the capacity to activate the majority of ROS-I ∼ ROS-IV genes within both Oryza sativa tissues at the EC20 concentration of SCN-. However, genetic positive/negative feedback networks emphasized the pivotal role of ROS-II genes in governing ROS metabolism within Oryza sativa. Notably, these genes were predominantly activated within the cytoplasm, chloroplasts, mitochondria, peroxisomes, and the cell wall.

Proline interacts with Ca2+-dependent signaling to enhance chromium tolerance in rice by manipulating nitrate reductase and sucrose phosphate synthase

The entrance of chromium (Cr) into the agricultural system would exert a negative influence on the carbon/nitrogen metabolism (CNM) of plants. In this study, we investigated the role of exogenous proline-mediated Ca2+-dependent signaling in the regulation of CNM in rice subjected to Cr(VI) stress, with emphasis on the involvement of nitrate reductase (NR) and sucrose phosphate synthase (SPS). Results demonstrated that proline effectively mitigated the growth inhibition of rice imposed by Cr(VI) stress, which is achieved by a reduction in cytoplasmic Ca and Cr content and the activation of the downstream Ca2+-dependent signaling pathway. Additionally, proline displayed a positive effect in modulating the expression and activities of NR and SPS under Cr(VI) stress, which are attributed to the cross-regulation between calcium-dependent protein kinases (CDPKs) and 14-3-3 proteins (14-3-3s). Consequently, nitrogen use efficiency and sucrose content in rice under Cr(VI) + proline treatments were higher than Cr(VI) treatments. Gene expression variation factors underscored that the regulation of proline on NR is crucial to the Ca2+-dependent signaling pathway, initiated by the interaction between CDPKs and 14-3-3s in rice plants during Cr(VI) stress. These results reveal that proline interacts with Ca2+-dependent signaling pathways to enhance Cr tolerance in rice by regulating NR and SPS.

Transcriptome reveals the crucial role of exogenous hydrogen sulfide in alleviation of thiocyanate (SCN-) toxicity in rice seedlings

Application of exogenous hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) is a novel strategy for alleviation of the adverse effects caused by abiotic stresses. However, little is known about H₂S-mediated global molecular response of rice seedlings to thiocyanate (SCN^-) exposure. Herein, a hydroponic experiment was carried out to investigate the crucial role of exogenous H₂S in alleviation of SCN^- toxicity generated at different effective concentrations (EC₂₀: 24.0 mg SCN/L, EC₅₀: 96.0 mg SCN/L, and EC₇₅: 300.0 mg SCN/L) in rice seedlings through transcriptome analysis. The results showed that the total numbers of differentially expressed genes (DEGs, upregulated genes/downregulated genes) in rice roots were 755/313, 1114/3303, and 2184/7427, while they were 427/292, 2134/526, and 2378/890 in rice shoots at EC₂₀, EC₅₀, and EC₇₅ of SCN^-, respectively. When exogenous H₂S was supplied to rice seedlings exposed to SCN^-, the total number of DEGs (upregulated genes/downregulated genes) in rice roots was 1158/316, 1943/2959, and 1737/5392, while it was 2067/937, 2689/683, and 3492/1062 in rice shoots at EC₂₀, EC₅₀, and EC₇₅ of SCN^-, respectively. Upregulated DEGs in shoots were positively correlated with SCN^- concentration in the presence of exogenous H₂S, suggesting its crucial role in regulating the phytotoxicity of SCN^-. Gene function and pathway enrichment analyses showed that exogenous H₂S triggered "secondary metabolite synthesis," "metabolic pathways," and "signal transduction mechanisms" in rice seedlings corresponding to different effective concentrations of SCN^- exposure.

Spatial-temporal variations of proline and related amino acids reveal distinct nitrogenous utilization strategies in rice during detoxification of exogenous cyanide

Cyanide (CN^-) pollution in agricultural systems impairs amino acid metabolism in rice plants, hence decreasing their quality and yield. Meanwhile, little is known about the effects of CN^- assimilation on the innate pool of proline (Pro) and its synthesis-related amino acids (Pro-AAs) in rice plants. In this study, a hydroponic experiment was carried out to investigate the effect of exogenous KCN on indigenous levels of Pro-AAs, i.e., Pro, glutamate (Glu), arginine (Arg), and ornithine (Orn) in rice seedlings fertilized with either nitrate (NO₃^-) or ammonium (NH₄⁺) through the biochemical and RT-qPCR analysis. At the same KCN treatment concentration, the relative growth rate of NH₄⁺-fed rice seedlings was considerably higher than that of NO₃^--fed rice seedlings, but the residual concentration of CN^- in NH₄⁺-fed rice tissues was lower than that of NO₃^--fed rice tissues. Based on the UPLC and stoichiometry molar ratio calculations, it is evident that the Glu pathway contributed significantly to Pro synthesis in rice under KCN + NO₃^- treatments; whereas the Orn pathway governed the synthesis of Pro in rice under KCN + NH₄⁺ treatments. Moreover, transcriptional and bioinformatics analysis revealed that NH₄⁺ fertilization resulted in spatial-temporal differences in the genetic response in rice tissue during detoxification of CN^- compared with KCN + NO₃^- treatments. These findings suggested that the innate level of Pro serves as "a fishing float" to balance the flux between Pro and Pro-AAs in exogenous KCN-treated rice plants under different nitrogenous nutritional conditions.

Evaluating the significance of amino acids (AAs) in cyanide-treated rice plants under different nitrogen fertilization using the relative importance index of AA

The biosynthesis of amino acids (AAs) in plants is affected by different nitrogen (N) sources. The effects of exogenous cyanide (KCN) on the concentrations and profiles of AAs in rice seedlings were carried out in the presence of nitrate (+NO₃^-)/ammonium (+NH₄⁺) or N deficiency (-N). Targeted metabolomics analysis indicated that the highest accumulation of AAs in CN^--treated rice seedlings was detected in the "CN^-+NH₄⁺" treatments than in other treatments, wherein the doses of exogenous KCN did not significantly affect the total amount of AAs in rice seedlings at the same N fertilized condition. The total content of AAs in rice shoots under "CN^-+NH₄⁺" treatments was higher than other treatments, while the total content of AAs in rice roots under "CN^-+NO₃^-" treatments was higher than other treatments. Also, the profiles of 21 AAs in CN^--treated rice seedlings showed tissue-specific under different N fertilization. The relative importance index (RII) of AA was used to evaluate the importance of AAs in CN^--treated rice seedlings under different N fertilization. The common AAs with higher RII values were compared between three different treatments of KCN (e.g., 0, 1, and 2 mg CN/L). Under "CN^-+(-N)" treatments, Ala, Asp, Glu, Val, and Gly (Ala, Gly, Val, and Lys) were the common AAs in rice roots (shoots). Under "CN^-+NO₃^-" treatments, Ala, Glu, Asp, Ser, and Thr (Asp, Ala, Thr, Ser, and Asn) were the common AAs with higher RII values in rice roots (shoots) between all CN^- treatments. Under "CN^-+NH₄⁺" treatments, Asp, Gln, Asn, and Ala (Asp, Glu, and Thr) were the common AAs with higher RII values in rice roots (shoots) between all CN^- treatments. These results suggested that using the RII to describe the change and fluctuation of AAs in rice plants may reflect the different N utilization strategies in response to exogenous CN^- exposure.

Transcriptional analysis of heavy metal P1B-ATPases (HMAs) elucidates competitive interaction in metal transport between cadmium and mineral elements in rice plants

Cadmium (Cd) pollution has become a major threat to crop production and quality globally. The heavy metal P_1B-ATPases (HMAs) play a crucial role in metal transport in plants. In the present study, we investigated the interaction in metal transport by HMAs between Cd and mineral elements in rice plants. Rice seedlings were treated with cadmium nitrate either in the nutrient solution ("Cd+M") or in the ultrapure water ("Cd-M"). Result showed that phytotoxicity of Cd to rice seedlings was evident from both Cd treatments, judged by relative growth rate (RGR), where more severe repression (p < 0.05) of RGR was observed in the "Cd-M" treatments than the "Cd+M" treatments. More Cd (p < 0.05) was accumulated in rice tissues from the "Cd-M" treatments than the "Cd+M" treatments, while there is a significant difference (p < 0.05) in distribution and translocation of mineral elements in rice tissues between the "Cd+M" and the "Cd-M" treatments. RT-qPCR analysis displayed that the expression patterns of HMAs related genes were quite different between "Cd+M" and "Cd-M" treatments, suggesting their different regulatory effects during the transport of Cd and mineral elements within rice plants. The competition in metal transport by HMAs mainly occurs between Cd and micro-elements of Zn and Cu in rice tissues during Cd exposure. Overall, this study provides new evidence to clarify the different translocation mechanisms of HMAs in metal transport between Cd and mineral elements in rice seedlings during Cd exposure.

Improving yield and quality of rice under acid rain stress by regulating nitrogen assimilation with exogenous Ca2

Acid rain threatens crop yield and nutritional quality, and Ca²⁺ can regulate plant responses to abiotic stresses. To improve the yield and nutritional quality of crops under acid rain stress, we applied exogenous Ca²⁺ to regulate nitrogen assimilation in rice seedlings under simulated acid rain stress (pH 4.5 or 3.0), taking yield and nutritional quality of rice as evaluation criteria. We found that Ca²⁺ (5 mM) maintained the total nitrogen content of rice at the seedling and booting stages to alleviate the inhibitory effect of simulated acid rain on rice yield. Meanwhile, Ca²⁺ improved the activity of glutamate synthase to eliminate the disruption of glutamine synthetase/glutamate synthase balance under simulated acid rain. It decreased the efficiency of nitrogen assimilation, thereby reducing the inhibition of essential amino acid content in rice. The mitigation effect on simulated acid rain at pH 4.5 was better than that of simulated acid rain at pH 3.0. Overall, Ca²⁺ may reduce the negative effect of acid rain on the yield and nutritional quality of crops.

Chromium in plant growth and development: Toxicity, tolerance and hormesis

Research over the last three decades showed that chromium, particularly the oxyanion chromate Cr(VI) behaves as a toxic environmental pollutant that strongly damages plants due to oxidative stress, disruption of nutrient uptake, photosynthesis and metabolism, and ultimately, represses growth and development. However, mild Cr(VI) concentrations promote growth, induce adventitious root formation, reinforce the root cap, and produce twin roots from single root meristems under conditions that compromise cell viability, indicating its important role as a driver for root organogenesis. In recent years, considerable advance has been made towards deciphering the molecular mechanisms for root sensing of chromate, including the identification of regulatory proteins such as SOLITARY ROOT and MEDIATOR 18 that orchestrate the multilevel dynamics of the oxyanion. Cr(VI) decreases the expression of several glutamate receptors, whereas amino acids such as glutamate, cysteine and proline confer protection to plants from hexavalent chromium stress. The crosstalk between plant hormones, including auxin, ethylene, and jasmonic acid enables tissues to balance growth and defense under Cr(VI)-induced oxidative damage, which may be useful to better adapt crops to biotic and abiotic challenges. The highly contrasting responses of plants manifested at the transcriptional and translational levels depend on the concentration of chromate in the media, and fit well with the concept of hormesis, an adaptive mechanism that primes plants for resistance to environmental challenges, toxins or pollutants. Here, we review the contrasting facets of Cr(VI) in plants including the cellular, hormonal and molecular aspects that mechanistically separate its toxic effects from biostimulant outputs.

Proline-mediated modulation on DNA repair pathway in rice seedlings under chromium stress by integrating gene chip and co-expression network analysis

Chromium (Cr) stress can cause oxidative burst to plants. Application of exogenous proline (Pro) is one of the most effective approaches to improve the tolerance of plants to Cr stress. In this study, we integrated the data of gene chip with co-expression network analysis to identify the key pathways involved in the DNA repair processes in rice seedlings under Cr(VI) stress. Based on KEGG pathway analysis, 158 genes identified are activated in five different types of DNA repair pathways, namely base excision repair (BER, 20 genes), mismatch repair (MMR, 30 genes), nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ, 8 genes), nucleotide excision repair (NER, 56 genes) and homologous recombination (HR, 44 genes). Co-expression network analysis showed that genes activated in DNA repair pathways were categorized into six different modules, wherein Module 1 (45.36%), Module 2 (27.84%) and Module 3 (19.59%) carried more weight than others. Integrating the data of gene chip and co-expression network analysis indicated that coordinated actions of HR and NER pathways are mainly associated with DNA repair processes in Cr(VI)-treated rice seedlings supplied with exogenous Pro. OsCSB, OsXPG, OsBRIP1, OsRAD51C, OsRAD51A2, OsRPA, OsTOPBP1C, OsTOP3, and OsXRCC3 activated in the HR pathway had a stronger impact on repairing DNA damage induced by Cr(VI) stress in rice seedlings supplied with exogenous Pro, while OsXPB1, OsTTDA2, OsTFIIH1, OsXPC, OsRAD23, OsDSS1, and OsRPA located at the NER pathway showed more contribution to repairing DNA damage than others.

Mathematical quantification of interactive complexity of transcription factors involved in proline-mediated regulative strategies in Oryza sativa under chromium stress

Involvement of transcription factor (TFs) in governing genes at transcription or post transcription level is known to have affirmative impact on plant physiological and morphological development, especially during environmental abuse. Application of exogenous proline (Pro) is one among the effective approaches to strengthen plant resistance against stresses. However, Pro-mediated regulative strategies of TFs in responses to the chromium (Cr) in rice plants through the gene interaction network are still not clear. In the current study, Pro-mediated interactive complexity of various TFs (i.e., MYB, NAC, WRKY, bHLH, and bZIP) under hexavalent chromium [Cr(VI)] was investigated using Agilent 4 × 44 K rice gene chip and gene interactive probability model (GIPM). Results showed that exogenous Pro had a negligible effect on Cr uptake in rice plants, while a small positive response in biomass accretion of rice seedlings was observed under Cr(VI)+Pro treatments which was to certain extend greater than single Cr(VI) treatments. Rice microarray analysis showed that Cr(VI) significantly (p < 0.05) repressed the expression of TFs in the rice roots and shoots, while the application of exogenous Pro significantly (p < 0.05) up-regulated the expression levels of some TFs in rice tissues. Mathematical modularization indicated that Pro-mediated interaction between MYB and NAC carried more weightage than other TFs in rice roots and shoots under Cr(VI) stress. Overall, our study provides convincing evidence to confirm a positive role of exogenous Pro on reducing the negative impact exerted by Cr(VI) on rice plants through regulating expression and interaction of different TFs.

Effect of biochar on the uptake, translocation and phytotoxicity of chromium in a soil-barley pot system

Remediation of Cr-contaminated soils with biochar is an effective method, but its effect on plant detoxification has not been clarified, and the translocation pathways of different chemical forms of Cr in the soil-plant system have not been quantitatively evaluated. This study investigated the effects of magnetically modified Enteromorpha prolifera biochar (FBC) on Cr uptake, translocation and phytotoxicity in the soil and barley (Hordeum vulgare L.). When the FBC dosage increased to 30 g·kg^-1, the content of bioavailable Cr in the soil decreased by 56.82%. Additionally, the contents of Cr in H. vulgare decreased by 53.22%, and growth recovered to the normal level. Partial least squares path modelling (PLS-PM) was applied to establish two influence paths to explain how FBC impacted the whole system of soil and plants upon Cr exposure. The phytotoxic effect path of Cr suggested that FBC decreased the contents of Cr in soil and H. vulgare and then recovered growth by alleviating oxidative stress (β = -0.45) and promoting chlorophyll synthesis (β = 0.53) in shoots. The translocation and conversion path of Cr further indicated that Cr in the shoots was converted into low-migration forms and mainly trapped in cell walls and vacuoles rather than in organelles, consequently decreasing the phytotoxicity of Cr (β = -0.73). These two soil-plant paths offer new insights into the application of biochar and plants in Cr-contaminated soils.

Proline-mediated regulation on jasmonate signals repressed anthocyanin accumulation through the MYB-bHLH-WDR complex in rice under chromium exposure

Toxic metal-induced overaccumulation of anthocyanin (ATH) in plants can oxidize proteins and break DNA. Herein, the role of exogenous proline (Pro) on the repression of ATH accumulation in rice seedlings during hexavalent chromium [Cr(VI)] exposure was studied. Results indicated that exogenous Pro-mediated regulation of jasmonate signals activated the MYB-bHLH-WDR complex to repress ATH accumulation in rice tissues under Cr(VI) stress. Biochemical and transcript analysis indicated that exogenous Pro promoted the synthesis of jasmonic acid (JA) and its molecularly active metabolite jasmonic acid isoleucine (JA-Ile) in rice tissues under Cr(VI) stress. Increment in the endogenous level of jasmonates positively triggered the expression of genes responsible for the JA signaling pathway and activated the MYB-bHLH-WDR complex, eventually repressing the glycosylation of anthocyanidin to form ATH in rice tissues. In conclusion, exogenous proline-mediated regulation on jasmonate signals was tissue-specific under Cr(VI) stress and a more positive effect was detected in shoots rather than roots.