Fragment Binding Pose Predictions Using Unbiased Simulations and Markov-State Models

Predicting fragment binding modes using customized Lennard-Jones potentials in short molecular dynamics simulations

Reliable in silico prediction of fragment binding modes remains a challenge in current drug design research. Due to their small size and generally low binding affinity, fragments can potentially interact with their target proteins in different ways. In the current study, we propose a workflow aimed at predicting favorable fragment binding sites and binding poses through multiple short molecular dynamics simulations. Tailored Lennard-Jones potentials enable the simulation of systems with high concentrations of identical fragment molecules surrounding their respective target proteins. In the present study, descriptors and binding free energy calculations were implemented to filter out the desired fragment position. The proposed method was tested for its performance using four epigenetic target proteins and their respective fragment binders and showed high accuracy in identifying the binding sites as well as predicting the native binding modes. The approach presented here represents an alternative method for the prediction of fragment binding modes and may be useful in fragment-based drug discovery when the corresponding experimental structural data are limited.

Capturing the Effects of Single Atom Substitutions on the Inhibition Efficiency of Glycogen Synthase Kinase-3β Inhibitors via Markov State Modeling and Experiments

Small modifications in the chemical structure of ligands are known to dramatically change their ability to inhibit the activity of a protein. Unraveling the mechanisms that govern these dramatic changes requires scrutinizing the dynamics of protein-ligand binding and unbinding at the atomic level. As an exemplary case, we have studied Glycogen Synthase Kinase-3β (GSK-3β), a multifunctional kinase that has been implicated in a host of pathological processes. As such, there is a keen interest in identifying ligands that inhibit GSK-3β activity. One family of compounds that are highly selective and potent inhibitors of GSK-3β is exemplified by a molecule termed COB-187. COB-187 consists of a five-member heterocyclic ring with a thione at C2, a pyridine substituted methyl at N3, and a hydroxyl and phenyl at C4. We have studied the inhibition of GSK-3β by COB-187-related ligands that differ in a single heavy atom from each other (either in the location of nitrogen in their pyridine ring, or with the pyridine ring replaced by a phenyl ring), or in the length of the alkyl group joining the pyridine and the N3. The inhibition experiments show a large range of half-maximal inhibitory concentration (IC50) values from 10 nM to 10 μM, implying that these ligands exhibit vastly different propensities to inhibit GSK-3β. To explain these differences, we perform Markov State Modeling (MSM) using fully atomistic simulations. Our MSM results are in excellent agreement with the experiments in that they accurately capture differences in the binding propensities of the ligands. The simulations show that the binding propensities are related to the ligands' ability to attain a compact conformation where their two aromatic rings are spatially close. We rationalize this result by sampling numerous binding and unbinding events via funnel metadynamics simulations, which show that indeed while approaching the bound state, the ligands prefer to be in their compact conformation. We find that the presence of nitrogen in the aromatic ring increases the probability of attaining the compact conformation. Protein-ligand binding is understood to be dictated by the energetics of interactions and entropic factors, like the release of bound water from the binding pockets. This work shows that changes in the conformational distribution of ligands due to atom-level modifications in the structure play an important role in protein-ligand binding.

Ligandability assessment of the C-terminal Rel-homology domain of NFAT1

Transcription factors are generally considered challenging, if not "undruggable", targets but they promise new therapeutic options due to their fundamental involvement in many diseases. In this study, we aim to assess the ligandability of the C-terminal Rel-homology domain of nuclear factor of activated T cells 1 (NFAT1), a TF implicated in T-cell regulation. Using a combination of experimental and computational approaches, we demonstrate that small molecule fragments can indeed bind to this protein domain. The newly identified binder is the first small molecule binder to NFAT1 validated with biophysical methods and an elucidated binding mode by X-ray crystallography. The reported eutomer/distomer pair provides a strong basis for potential exploration of higher potency binders on the path toward degrader or glue modalities.

Extracting binding energies and binding modes from biomolecular simulations of fragment binding to endothiapepsin

Fragment-based drug discovery (FBDD) aims to discover a set of small binding fragments that may be subsequently linked together. Therefore, in-depth knowledge of the individual fragments' structural and energetic binding properties is essential. In addition to experimental techniques, the direct simulation of fragment binding by molecular dynamics (MD) simulations became popular to characterize fragment binding. However, former studies showed that long simulation times and high computational demands per fragment are needed, which limits applicability in FBDD. Here, we performed short, unbiased MD simulations of direct fragment binding to endothiapepsin, a well-characterized model system of pepsin-like aspartic proteases. To evaluate the strengths and limitations of short MD simulations for the structural and energetic characterization of fragment binding, we predicted the fragments' absolute free energies and binding poses based on the direct simulations of fragment binding and compared the predictions to experimental data. The predicted absolute free energies are in fair agreement with the experiment. Combining the MD data with binding mode predictions from molecular docking approaches helped to correctly identify the most promising fragments for further chemical optimization. Importantly, all computations and predictions were done within 5 days, suggesting that MD simulations may become a viable tool in FBDD projects.

Predicting Protein-Ligand Binding and Unbinding Kinetics with Biased MD Simulations and Coarse-Graining of Dynamics: Current State and Challenges

The prediction of drug-target binding and unbinding kinetics that occur on time scales between milliseconds and several hours is a prime challenge for biased molecular dynamics simulation approaches. This Perspective gives a concise summary of the theory and the current state-of-the-art of such predictions via biased simulations, of insights into the molecular mechanisms defining binding and unbinding kinetics as well as of the extraordinary challenges predictions of ligand kinetics pose in comparison to binding free energy predictions.

Evaluating the use of absolute binding free energy in the fragment optimisation process

Key to the fragment optimisation process within drug design is the need to accurately capture the changes in affinity that are associated with a given set of chemical modifications. Due to the weakly binding nature of fragments, this has proven to be a challenging task, despite recent advancements in leveraging experimental and computational methods. In this work, we evaluate the use of Absolute Binding Free Energy (ABFE) calculations in guiding fragment optimisation decisions, retrospectively calculating binding free energies for 59 ligands across 4 fragment elaboration campaigns. We first demonstrate that ABFEs can be used to accurately rank fragment-sized binders with an overall Spearman's r of 0.89 and a Kendall τ of 0.67, although often deviating from experiment in absolute free energy values with an RMSE of 2.75 kcal/mol. We then also show that in several cases, retrospective fragment optimisation decisions can be supported by the ABFE calculations. Comparing against cheaper endpoint methods, namely Nwat-MM/GBSA, we find that ABFEs offer better ranking power and correlation metrics. Our results indicate that ABFE calculations can usefully guide fragment elaborations to maximise affinity.

fastDRH: a webserver to predict and analyze protein-ligand complexes based on molecular docking and MM/PB(GB)SA computation

Predicting the native or near-native binding pose of a small molecule within a protein binding pocket is an extremely important task in structure-based drug design, especially in the hit-to-lead and lead optimization phases. In this study, fastDRH, a free and open accessed web server, was developed to predict and analyze protein-ligand complex structures. In fastDRH server, AutoDock Vina and AutoDock-GPU docking engines, structure-truncated MM/PB(GB)SA free energy calculation procedures and multiple poses based per-residue energy decomposition analysis were well integrated into a user-friendly and multifunctional online platform. Benefit from the modular architecture, users can flexibly use one or more of three features, including molecular docking, docking pose rescoring and hotspot residue prediction, to obtain the key information clearly based on a result analysis panel supported by 3Dmol.js and Apache ECharts. In terms of protein-ligand binding mode prediction, the integrated structure-truncated MM/PB(GB)SA rescoring procedures exhibit a success rate of >80% in benchmark, which is much better than the AutoDock Vina (~70%). For hotspot residue identification, our multiple poses based per-residue energy decomposition analysis strategy is a more reliable solution than the one using only a single pose, and the performance of our solution has been experimentally validated in several drug discovery projects. To summarize, the fastDRH server is a useful tool for predicting the ligand binding mode and the hotspot residue of protein for ligand binding. The fastDRH server is accessible free of charge at http://cadd.zju.edu.cn/fastdrh/.

HT-SuMD: making molecular dynamics simulations suitable for fragment-based screening. A comparative study with NMR

Fragment-based lead discovery (FBLD) is one of the most efficient methods to develop new drugs. We present here a new computational protocol called High-Throughput Supervised Molecular Dynamics (HT-SuMD), which makes it possible to automatically screen up to thousands of fragments, representing therefore a new valuable resource to prioritise fragments in FBLD campaigns. The protocol was applied to Bcl-XL, an oncological protein target involved in the regulation of apoptosis through protein-protein interactions. Initially, HT-SuMD performances were validated against a robust NMR-based screening, using the same set of 100 fragments. These independent results showed a remarkable agreement between the two methods. Then, a virtual screening on a larger library of additional 300 fragments was carried out and the best hits were validated by NMR. Remarkably, all the in silico selected fragments were confirmed as Bcl-XL binders. This represents, to date, the largest computational fragments screening entirely based on MD.

A Computational Workflow for the Identification of Novel Fragments Acting as Inhibitors of the Activity of Protein Kinase CK1δ

Fragment-Based Drug Discovery (FBDD) has become, in recent years, a consolidated approach in the drug discovery process, leading to several drug candidates under investigation in clinical trials and some approved drugs. Among these successful applications of the FBDD approach, kinases represent a class of targets where this strategy has demonstrated its real potential with the approved kinase inhibitor Vemurafenib. In the Kinase family, protein kinase CK1 isoform δ (CK1δ) has become a promising target in the treatment of different neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer’s disease, Parkinson’s disease, and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. In the present work, we set up and applied a computational workflow for the identification of putative fragment binders in large virtual databases. To validate the method, the selected compounds were tested in vitro to assess the CK1δ inhibition.

Computational identification of potential chemoprophylactic agents according to dynamic behavior of peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma

Peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma (PPARγ) is an attractive target for chemoprevention of lung carcinoma, however its highly dynamic nature has plagued drug development for decades, with difficulties in receptor modeling for structure-based design. In this work, an integrated receptor-based virtual screening (VS) strategy was applied to identify PPARγ agonists as chemoprophylactic agents by using extensive docking and conformational sampling methods. Our results showed that the conformational plasticity of PPARγ, especially the H2 & S245 loop, H2' & Ω loop and AF-2 surface, is markedly affected by binding of full/partial agonists. To fully take the dynamic behavior of PPARγ into account, the VS approach effectively sorts out five commercial agents with reported antineoplastic properties. Among them, ZINC03775146 (gusperimus) and ZINC14087743 (miltefosine) might be novel PPARγ agonists with the potential for chemoprophylaxis, that simultaneously take part in a flexible switch of the AF-2 surface and state change of the Ω loop. Furthermore, the dynamic structural coupling between the H2 & S245 and H2' & Ω loops offers enticing hope for PPARγ-targeted therapeutics, by blocking kinase accessibility to PPARγ. These results might aid the development of chemopreventive drugs, and the integrated VS strategy could be conducive to drug design for highly flexible biomacromolecules.

Connecting dynamic reweighting Algorithms: Derivation of the dynamic reweighting family tree

Thermally driven processes of molecular systems include transitions of energy barriers on the microsecond timescales and higher. Sufficient sampling of such processes with molecular dynamics simulations is challenging and often requires accelerating slow transitions using external biasing potentials. Different dynamic reweighting algorithms have been proposed in the past few years to recover the unbiased kinetics from biased systems. However, it remains an open question if and how these dynamic reweighting approaches are connected. In this work, we establish the link between the two main reweighting types, i.e., path-based and energy-based reweighting. We derive a path-based correction factor for the energy-based dynamic histogram analysis method, thus connecting the previously separate reweighting types. We show that the correction factor can be used to combine the advantages of path-based and energy-based reweighting algorithms: it is integrator independent, more robust, and at the same time able to reweight time-dependent biases. We can furthermore demonstrate the relationship between two independently derived path-based reweighting algorithms. Our theoretical findings are verified on a one-dimensional four-well system. By connecting different dynamic reweighting algorithms, this work helps to clarify the strengths and limitations of the different methods and enables a more robust usage of the combined types.

The rise of molecular simulations in fragment-based drug design (FBDD): an overview

Fragment-based drug discovery (FBDD) is an innovative approach, progressively more applied in the academic and industrial context, to enhance hit identification for previously considered undruggable biological targets. In particular, FBDD discovers low-molecular-weight (LMW) ligands (<300Da) able to bind to therapeutically relevant macromolecules in an affinity range from the micromolar (μM) to millimolar (mM). X-ray crystallography (XRC) and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy are commonly the methods of choice to obtain 3D information about the bound ligand-protein complex, but this can occasionally be problematic, mainly for early, low-affinity fragments. The recent development of computational fragment-based approaches provides a further strategy for improving the identification of fragment hits. In this review, we summarize the state of the art of molecular dynamics simulations approaches used in FBDD, and discuss limitations and future perspectives for these approaches.