3-Oxo-hexahydro-1H-isoindole-4-carboxylic Acid as a Drug Chiral Bicyclic Scaffold: Structure-Based Design and Preparation of Conformationally Constrained Covalent and Noncovalent Prolyl Oligopeptidase Inhibitors

Computational and biophysical methods for the discovery and optimization of covalent drugs

Drugs that act by covalently attaching to their targets have been used to treat human diseases for over a hundred years. However, the deliberate design of covalent drugs was discouraged due to concerns of toxicity and off-target effects. Recent successes in covalent drug discovery have sparked fresh interest in this field. New screening and testing methods aimed at covalent inhibitors can play pivotal roles in facilitating the discovery process. This feature article focuses on computational and biophysical advances originating from our labs over the past decade and how these approaches have contributed to the design of prolyl oligopeptidase (POP) and SARS-CoV-2 3CLpro covalent inhibitors.

Docking Ligands into Flexible and Solvated Macromolecules. 8. Forming New Bonds─Challenges and Opportunities

Over the years, structure-based design programs and specifically docking small molecules to proteins have become prominent in drug discovery. However, many of these computational tools have been developed to primarily dock enzyme inhibitors (and ligands to other protein classes) relying heavily on hydrogen bonds and electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions. In reality, many drug targets either feature metal ions, can be targeted covalently, or are simply not even proteins (e.g., nucleic acids). Herein, we describe several new features that we have implemented into Fitted to broaden its applicability to a wide range of covalent enzyme inhibitors and to metalloenzymes, where metal coordination is essential for drug binding. This updated version of our docking program was tested for its ability to predict the correct binding mode of drug-sized molecules in a large variety of proteins. We also report new datasets that were essential to demonstrate areas of success and those where additional efforts are required. This resource could be used by other program developers to assess their own software.

Design, synthesis and in vitro evaluation of novel SARS-CoV-2 3CLpro covalent inhibitors

Severe diseases such as the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, as well as the previous SARS and MERS outbreaks, are the result of coronavirus infections and have demonstrated the urgent need for antiviral drugs to combat these deadly viruses. Due to its essential role in viral replication and function, 3CL^pro (main coronaviruses cysteine-protease) has been identified as a promising target for the development of antiviral drugs. Previously reported SARS-CoV 3CL^pro non-covalent inhibitors were used as a starting point for the development of covalent inhibitors of SARS-CoV-2 3CL^pro. We report herein our efforts in the design and synthesis of submicromolar covalent inhibitors when the enzymatic activity of the viral protease was used as a screening platform.

The latest automated docking technologies for novel drug discovery

INTRODUCTION

Molecular docking has been consolidated as one of the most important methods in the molecular modeling field. It has been recognized as a prominent tool in the study of protein-ligand complexes, to describe intermolecular interactions, to accurately predict poses of multiple ligands, to discover novel promising bioactive compounds. Molecular docking methods have evolved in terms of their accuracy and reliability; but there are pending issues to solve for improving the connection between the docking results and the experimental evidence.

AREAS COVERED

In this article, the author reviews very recent innovative molecular docking applications with special emphasis on reverse docking, treatment of protein flexibility, the use of experimental data to guide the selection of docking poses, the application of Quantum mechanics(QM) in docking, and covalent docking.

EXPERT OPINION

There are several issues being worked on in recent years that will lead to important breakthroughs in molecular docking methods in the near future These developments are related to more efficient exploration of large datasets and receptor conformations, advances in electronic description, and the use of structural information for guiding the selection of results.

Torsional Energy Barriers of Biaryls Could Be Predicted by Electron Richness/Deficiency of Aromatic Rings; Advancement of Molecular Mechanics toward Atom-Type Independence

Biaryl molecules are ubiquitous pharmacophores found in natural products and pharmaceuticals. In spite of this, existing molecular mechanics force fields are unable to accurately reproduce their torsional energy profiles, except for a few well-parametrized cases. This effectively limits the ability of structure-based drug design methods to correctly identify hits involving biaryls with confidence (e.g., during virtual screening, employing docking and/or molecular dynamics simulations). Continuing in our endeavor to quantify organic chemistry principles, we showed that the torsional energy profile of biaryl compounds could be computed on-the-fly based on the electron richness/deficiency of the aromatic rings. This method, called H-TEQ 4.0, was developed using a set of 131 biaryls. It was subsequently validated on a separate set of 100 diverse biaryls, including multisubstituted, bicyclic and tricyclic druglike molecules, and produced an average root-mean-square error (RMSE) of 0.95 kcal·mol^-1. For comparison, GAFF2 produced an RMSE of 3.88 kcal·mol^-1, owing to problems associated with the transferability of torsion parameters. The success of H-TEQ 4.0 provided further evidence that force fields could transition to become atom-type independent, providing that the correct chemical principles are used. Overall, this method solved the problem of transferability of biaryl torsion parameters, while simultaneously improving the overall accuracy of the force field.

The bio-based methyl coumalate involved Morita–Baylis–Hillman reaction

An efficient and sustainable method to prepare pharmaceutically important pyrone derivatives under very mild conditions, from bio-based methyl coumalate, is reported.

Investigation of novel chemical scaffolds targeting prolyl oligopeptidase for neurological therapeutics

Prolyl oligopeptidase (POP) is a potential therapeutic target for treatment of several neurological disorders and α-synucleinopathies including Parkinson's disease. Most of the known POP inhibitors failed in the clinical trials due to poor pharmacokinetic properties and blood-brain impermeability. Therefore, a training set of 30 structurally diverse compounds with a wide range of inhibitory activity against POP was used to generate a quantitative pharmacophore model, Hypo 3, to identify potential POP inhibitors with desirable drug-like properties. Validations through test set, cost analysis, and Fisher's randomization methods proved that Hypo 3 accurately predicted the known inhibitors among inactive compounds. Hypo 3 was employed as 3D query for virtual screening on an in-house drug-like chemical database containing compounds with good brain permeability and ADMET parameters. Database screening with Hypo 3 resulted in 99 compounds that were narrowed down to 21 compounds through molecular docking. Among them, five compounds were identified in our earlier studies, while two compounds showed in vitro POP inhibition. The current study proposed new 16 virtually screened compounds as potential inhibitors against POP that possess Gold docking score in the range of 64.61-75.74 and Chemscore of -32.25 to -38.35. Furthermore, the top scoring four hit compounds were subjected to molecular dynamics simulations to reveal their appropriate binding modes and assessing binding free energies. The hit compounds interacted with POP effectively via hydrogen bonds with important active site residues along with hydrophobic interactions. Moreover, the hit compounds had key inter-molecular interactions and better binding free energies as compared to the reference inhibitor. A potential new hydrogen bond interaction was discovered between Hit 2 with the Arg252 residue of POP. To conclude, we propose four hit compounds with new structural scaffolds against POP for the lead development of POP-based therapeutics for neurological disorders.

Docking of Covalent Ligands: Challenges and Approaches

Covalent ligands have recently regained considerable attention in drug discovery. The rational design of such ligands, however, is still faced with particular challenges, mostly related to the fact that covalent bond formation is a quantum mechanical phenomenon which cannot adequately be handled by the force fields or empirical approaches typically used for noncovalent protein-ligand interactions. Although the necessity for quantum chemical approaches is clear, they cannot yet routinely be applied on large data sets of ligands or for a broader exploration of binding modes in docking calculations. On the other hand, technical solutions for performing docking calculations with covalent ligands are available, but their scope is normally quite limited. Scoring functions typically neglect the contribution from covalent bond formation completely. In this situation, the question arises how to approach covalent ligands and which methods to choose for their docking and design.

Rapid measurement of inhibitor binding kinetics by isothermal titration calorimetry

Although drug development typically focuses on binding thermodynamics, recent studies suggest that kinetic properties can strongly impact a drug candidate’s efficacy. Robust techniques for measuring inhibitor association and dissociation rates are therefore essential. To address this need, we have developed a pair of complementary isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) techniques for measuring the kinetics of enzyme inhibition. The advantages of ITC over standard techniques include speed, generality, and versatility; ITC also measures the rate of catalysis directly, making it ideal for quantifying rapid, inhibitor-dependent changes in enzyme activity. We used our methods to study the reversible covalent and non-covalent inhibitors of prolyl oligopeptidase (POP). We extracted kinetics spanning three orders of magnitude, including those too rapid for standard methods, and measured sub-nM binding affinities below the typical ITC limit. These results shed light on the inhibition of POP and demonstrate the general utility of ITC-based enzyme inhibition kinetic measurements.

There is growing evidence that the kinetics of interactions between inhibitors and their targets can strongly impact therapeutic efficacy. Here the authors describe an isothermal titration calorimetry-based method that can rapidly quantify inhibition kinetics and measure sub-nM binding affinities.

Measuring Rapid Time-Scale Reaction Kinetics Using Isothermal Titration Calorimetry

Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) is a powerful tool for acquiring both thermodynamic and kinetic data for biological interactions including molecular recognition and enzymatic catalysis. ITC-based kinetics measurements typically focus on reactions taking place over long time scales (tens of minutes or hours) in order to avoid complications due to the finite length of time needed detect heat flow in the calorimeter cell. While progress has been made toward analyzing more rapid reaction kinetics by ITC, the capabilities and limitations of this approach have not been thoroughly tested to date. Here, we report that the time resolution of commercial instruments is on the order of 0.2 s or less. We successfully performed rapid ITC kinetics assays with durations of just tens of seconds using the enzyme trypsin. This is substantially shorter than previous ITC enzyme measurements. However, we noticed that for short reaction durations, standard assumptions regarding the ITC instrument response led to significant deviations between calculated and measured ITC peak shapes. To address this issue, we developed an ITC empirical response model (ITC-ERM) that quantitatively reproduces ITC peak shapes for all reaction durations. Applying the ITC-ERM approach to another enzyme (prolyl oligopeptidase), we unexpectedly discovered non-Michaelis-Menten kinetics in short time-scale measurements that are absent in more typical long time-scale experiments and are obscured in short time-scale experiments when standard assumptions regarding the instrument response are made. This highlights the potential of ITC measurements of rapid time scale kinetics in conjunction with the ITC-ERM approach to shed new light on biological dynamics.

Covalent inhibitors design and discovery

In the history of therapeutics, covalent drugs occupy a very distinct category. While representing a significant fraction of the drugs on the market, very few have been deliberately designed to interact covalently with their biological target. In this review, the prevalence of covalent drugs will first be briefly covered, followed by an introduction to their mechanisms of action and more detailed discussions of their discovery and the development of safe and efficient covalent enzyme inhibitors. All stages of a drug discovery program will be covered, from target considerations to lead optimization, strategies to tune reactivity and computational methods. The goal of this article is to provide an overview of the field and to outline good practices that are needed for the proper assessment and development of covalent inhibitors as well as a good understanding of the potential and limitations of current computational methods for the design of covalent drugs.

Modeling covalent-modifier drugs

In this review, we present a summary of how computer modeling has been used in the development of covalent-modifier drugs. Covalent-modifier drugs bind by forming a chemical bond with their target. This covalent binding can improve the selectivity of the drug for a target with complementary reactivity and result in increased binding affinities due to the strength of the covalent bond formed. In some cases, this results in irreversible inhibition of the target, but some targeted covalent inhibitor (TCI) drugs bind covalently but reversibly. Computer modeling is widely used in drug discovery, but different computational methods must be used to model covalent modifiers because of the chemical bonds formed. Structural and bioinformatic analysis has identified sites of modification that could yield selectivity for a chosen target. Docking methods, which are used to rank binding poses of large sets of inhibitors, have been augmented to support the formation of protein-ligand bonds and are now capable of predicting the binding pose of covalent modifiers accurately. The pK_a's of amino acids can be calculated in order to assess their reactivity towards electrophiles. QM/MM methods have been used to model the reaction mechanisms of covalent modification. The continued development of these tools will allow computation to aid in the development of new covalent-modifier drugs. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Biophysics in Canada, edited by Lewis Kay, John Baenziger, Albert Berghuis and Peter Tieleman.

Medicinal Chemistry Projects Requiring Imaginative Structure-Based Drug Design Methods

Computational methods for docking small molecules to proteins are prominent in drug discovery. There are hundreds, if not thousands, of documented examples-and several pertinent cases within our research program. Fifteen years ago, our first docking-guided drug design project yielded nanomolar metalloproteinase inhibitors and illustrated the potential of structure-based drug design. Subsequent applications of docking programs to the design of integrin antagonists, BACE-1 inhibitors, and aminoglycosides binding to bacterial RNA demonstrated that available docking programs needed significant improvement. At that time, docking programs primarily considered flexible ligands and rigid proteins. We demonstrated that accounting for protein flexibility, employing displaceable water molecules, and using ligand-based pharmacophores improved the docking accuracy of existing methods-enabling the design of bioactive molecules. The success prompted the development of our own program, Fitted, implementing all of these aspects. The primary motivation has always been to respond to the needs of drug design studies; the majority of the concepts behind the evolution of Fitted are rooted in medicinal chemistry projects and collaborations. Several examples follow: (1) Searching for HDAC inhibitors led us to develop methods considering drug-zinc coordination and its effect on the pKa of surrounding residues. (2) Targeting covalent prolyl oligopeptidase (POP) inhibitors prompted an update to Fitted to identify reactive groups and form bonds with a given residue (e.g., a catalytic residue) when the geometry allows it. Fitted-the first fully automated covalent docking program-was successfully applied to the discovery of four new classes of covalent POP inhibitors. As a result, efficient stereoselective syntheses of a few screening hits were prioritized rather than synthesizing large chemical libraries-yielding nanomolar inhibitors. (3) In order to study the metabolism of POP inhibitors by cytochrome P450 enzymes (CYPs)-for toxicology studies-the program Impacts was derived from Fitted and helped us to reveal a complex metabolism with unforeseen stereocenter isomerizations. These efforts, combined with those of other docking software developers, have strengthened our understanding of the complex drug-protein binding process while providing the medicinal chemistry community with useful tools that have led to drug discoveries. In this Account, we describe our contributions over the past 15 years-within their historical context-to the design of drug candidates, including BACE-1 inhibitors, POP covalent inhibitors, G-quadruplex binders, and aminoglycosides binding to nucleic acids. We also remark the necessary developments of docking programs, specifically Fitted, that enabled structure-based design to flourish and yielded multiple fruitful, rational medicinal chemistry campaigns.