Reactivity of Neutral Tantalum Sulfide Clusters Ta3Sn (n = 0-4) with N2

Effect of External Electric Field on Nitrogen Activation on a Trimetal Cluster

Efficient nitrogen (N2) fixation and activation under mild conditions are crucial for modern society. External electric fields (Felectric) can significantly affect N2 activation. In this work, the effect of Felectric on N2 activation by Nb3 clusters supported in a sumanene bowl was studied by density functional theory calculations. Four typical systems at different stages of N-N activation were studied, including two intermediates and two transition states. The impact of Felectric on various properties related to N2 activation was investigated, including the N-N bond length, overlap population density of states (OPDOS), total energy of the system, adsorption energy of N2, decomposition of energy changes, and electron transfer. The sumanene not only functions as a support and protective substrate, but also serves as a donor or acceptor under different Felectric conditions. Negative Felectric is beneficial to N-N bond activation because it promotes electron transfer to the N-N region and improves the d-π* orbital hybridization between metals and N2 in the activation process. Positive Felectric improves d-π* orbital hybridization only when the N-N is nearly dissociated. The microscopic mechanism of Felectric's effects provides insight into N2 activation and theoretical guidance for the design of catalytic reaction conditions for nitrogen reduction reactions (NRR).

Cryo IR spectroscopy and cryo kinetics of dinitrogen activation and cleavage by small tantalum cluster cations

We investigate small tantalum clusters Tan+, n = 2-4, for their capability to cleave N2 adsorption spontaneously. We utilize infrared photon dissociation (IR-PD) spectroscopy of isolated and size selected clusters under cryogenic conditions within a buffer gas filled ion trap, and we augment our experiments by quantum chemical simulations (at DFT level). All Tan+ clusters, n = 2-4, seem to cleave N2 efficiently. We confirm and extend a previous study under ambient conditions on Ta2+ cluster [Geng et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 115, 11680-11687 (2018)]. Our cryo studies and the concomitant DFT simulations of the tantalum trimer Ta3+ suggest cleavage of the first and activation of the second and third N2 molecule across surmountable barriers and along much-involved multidimensional reaction paths. We unravel the underlying reaction processes and the intermediates involved. The study of the N2 adsorbate complexes of Ta4+ presented here extends our earlier study and previously published spectra from (4,m), m = 1-5 [Fries et al., Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 23(19), 11345-11354 (2021)], up to m = 12. We confirm the priory published double activation and nitride formation, succeeded by single side-on N2 coordination. Significant red shifts of IR-PD bands from these side-on coordinated μ2-κN:κN,N N2 ligands correlate with the degree of tilting towards the second coordinating Ta center. All subsequently attaching N2 adsorbates onto Ta4+ coordinate in an end-on fashion, and we find clear evidence for co-existence of end-on coordination isomers. The study of stepwise N2 adsorption revealed adsorption limits m(max) of [Tan(N2)m]+ which increase with n, and kinetic fits revealed significant N2 desorption rates upon higher N2 loads. The enhanced absolute rate constants of the very first adsorbate steps kabs(n,0) of the small Ta3+ and Ta4+ clusters independently suggest dissociative N2 adsorption and likely N2 cleavage into Ta nitrides.

Superior Reactivity of Molybdenum-Sulfur Cluster Anions Mo5S2- and Mo5S3- toward Dinitrogen

Inspired by the fact that Mo is a key element in biological nitrogenase, a series of gas-phase MoxSy- cluster anions are prepared and their reactivity toward N2 is investigated by the combination of mass spectrometry, photoelectron imaging spectroscopy, and density functional theory calculations. The Mo5S2- and Mo5S3- cluster anions show remarkable reactivity compared with the anionic species reported previously. The spectroscopic results in conjunction with theoretical analysis reveal that a facile cleavage of N≡N bonds takes place on Mo5S2- and Mo5S3-. The large dissociative adsorption energy of N2 and the favorable entrance channel for initial N2 approaching are proposed as two decisive factors for the superior reactivity of Mo5S2- and Mo5S3-. Besides, the modulation of S ligands on the reactivity of metal centers with N2 is proposed. The highly reactive metal-sulfur species may be obtained by the coordination of two to three sulfur atoms to bare metal clusters so that an appropriate combination of electronic structures and charge distributions can be achieved.

Activation of Dinitrogen Promoted by Adsorption of C6H6 on Fe2VC- Cluster Anions

The introduction of organic ligands is one of the effective strategies to improve the stability and reactivity of metal clusters. Herein, the enhanced reactivity of benzene-ligated cluster anions Fe₂VC(C₆H₆)^- with respect to naked Fe₂VC^- is identified. Structural characterization suggests that C₆H₆ is molecularly bound to the dual metal site in Fe₂VC(C₆H₆)^-. Mechanistic details reveal that the cleavage of N≡N is feasible in Fe₂VC(C₆H₆)^-/N₂ but hindered by an overall positive barrier in the Fe₂VC^-/N₂ system. Further analysis discloses that the ligated C₆H₆ regulates the compositions and energy levels of the active orbitals of the metal clusters. More importantly, C₆H₆ serves as an electron reservoir for the reduction of N₂ to lower the crucial energy barrier of N≡N splitting. This work demonstrates that the flexibility of C₆H₆ in terms of withdrawing and donating electrons is crucial to regulating the electronic structures of the metal cluster and enhancing the reactivity.

Effects of Field Strength and Silver Nanowire Size on Plasmon-Enhanced N2 Dissociation

Dissociation of the nitrogen molecule via plasmon-enhanced catalysis using noble metal nanoparticles has been investigated both experimentally and computationally in recent years. However, the mechanism of plasmon-enhanced nitrogen dissociation is still not very clear. In this work, we apply theoretical approaches to examine the dissociation of a nitrogen molecule on atomically thin Ag_n nanowires (n = 6, 8, 10, 12) and a Ag₁₉⁺ nanorod. Ehrenfest dynamics provides information about the motion of nuclei during the dynamics process and real-time TDDFT calculations show the electronic transitions and population of electrons over the first 10 s of fs time scale. The activation and dissociation of nitrogen are typically enhanced when the electric field strength increases. However, the enhancement is not always monotonic with field strength. As the length of the Ag wire increases, nitrogen is typically easier to dissociate and thus requires lower field strengths, even though the plasmon frequency is lower. The Ag₁₉⁺ nanorod leads to faster dissociation of N₂ than the atomically thin nanowires. Overall, our detailed study yields insights into the mechanisms involved in plasmon-enhanced N₂ dissociation, as well as provides information about factors that can be used to improve adsorbate activation.

Trimetallic clusters in the sumanene bowl for dinitrogen activation

It is of great importance to find catalysts for the nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) with high stability and reactivity. A series of M₃ clusters (M = Ti, Zr, V, and Nb) supported on sumanene (C₂₁H₁₂) were designed as potential catalysts for the NRR by taking advantage of the high reactivity of trimetallic clusters and the unique geometric and electronic properties of sumanene, a bowl-like organic molecule. Detailed mechanisms of NN bond cleavage on C₂₁H₁₂-M₃ were investigated by DFT calculations and compared with those on bare M₃ clusters. M₃ in the sumanene bowl is very stable with large binding energies, which prohibits the cohesion of M₃ into M₆. In the bowl, M₃ has a (quasi-) equilateral triangle structure with lengthened M-M bonds, which is particularly beneficial to the N₂ transfer process on Ti₃ and V₃ clusters. The N-N bond can be dissociated by both M₃ and C₂₁H₁₂-M₃ clusters without the overall energy barriers. A blurring effect is found in which some geometric and electronic properties of different metal types become similar when M₃ is supported on the substrate. Our work demonstrates that sumanene is a suitable substrate to support M₃ in the activation of N₂ with enhanced stability and maintained a high level of reactivity compared to bare M₃.

Recent Progress in Dinitrogen Activation by Gas-Phase Metal Species

Understanding the mechanisms to activate and functionalize dinitrogen (N₂) is of great importance for the rational design of nitrogen-fixation catalysts. Reactions of gas-phase species with N₂ are being actively studied to understand the bond activation and formation processes at a strictly molecular level. This Perspective provides an overview of the recent progress in combined experimental and theoretical studies on the activation and functionalization of N₂ by gas-phase metal species. New mechanistic insights into N₂ molecular adsorption, N≡N cleavage, and N-X (X = C, B, and H) formation have been introduced, in which the new reaction channels of ejecting neutral metal fragments and the coupling reactions of N₂ with other molecules are highlighted. Finally, the current challenges and outlooks of N₂ activation in the gas phase are discussed as well.

Comparison of Nitrogen Activation on Trinuclear Niobium and Tungsten Sulfide Clusters Nb3Sn and W3Sn (n = 0-3): A DFT Study

The reaction of N 2 with trinuclear niobium and tungsten sulfide clusters Nb 3 S n and W 3 S n ( n = 0-3) was systematically studied by density functional theory calculations . Dissociations of N-N bonds on these clusters are all thermodynamically allowed but with different reactivity in kinetics. The reactivity of Nb 3 S n is generally higher than that of W 3 S n . In the favorite reaction pathways, the adsorbed N 2 changes the adsorption sites from one metal atom to the bridge site of two metal atoms, then on the hollow site of three metal atoms, and at that place, the N-N bond dissociates. As the number of ligand S atoms increases, the reactivity of Nb 3 S n decreases because of the hindering effect of S atoms, while W 3 S and W 3 S 2 have the highest reactivity among four W 3 S n clusters. The Mayer bond order, bond length, vibrational frequency, and electronic charges of the adsorbed N 2 are analyzed along the reaction pathways to show the activation process of the N-N bond in reactions. The charge transfer from the clusters to the N 2 antibonding orbitals plays an essential role in N-N bond activation, which is more significant in Nb 3 S n than in W 3 S n , leading to the higher reactivity of Nb 3 S n . The reaction mechanisms found in this work may provide important theoretical guidance for the further rational design of related catalytic systems for nitrogen reduction reactions (NRR).

15 N/14N isotopic exchange in the dissociative adsorption of N2 on tantalum nitride cluster anions Ta3N3−

Adsorption and activation of dinitrogen (N2) is an indispensable process in nitrogen fixation. Metal nitride species continue to attract attention as a promising catalyst for ammonia synthesis. However, the detailed mechanisms at a molecular level between reactive nitride species and N2 remain unclear at elevated temperature, which is important to understand the temperature effect and narrow the gap between the gas phase system and condensed phase system. Herein, the 14N/15N isotopic exchange in the reaction between tantalum nitride cluster anions Ta314N3− and 15N2 leading to the regeneration of 14N2/14N15N was observed at elevated temperature (393−593 K) using mass spectrometry. With the aid of theoretical calculations, the exchange mechanism and the effect of temperature to promote the dissociation of N2 on Ta3N3− were elucidated. A comparison experiment for Ta314N4−/15N2 couple indicated that only desorption of 15N2 from Ta314N415N2− took place at elevated temperature. The different exchange behavior can be well understood by the fact that nitrogen vacancy is a requisite for the dinitrogen activation over metal nitride species. This study may shed light on understanding the role of nitrogen vacancy in nitride species for ammonia synthesis and provide clues in designing effective catalysts for nitrogen fixation.

Facile N≡N Bond Cleavage by Anionic Trimetallic Clusters V3-x Tax C4 - (x=0-3): A DFT Study

Activation of N₂ on anionic trimetallic V_3-x Ta_x C₄ ^- (x=0-3) clusters was theoretically studied employing density functional theory. For all studied clusters, initial adsorption of N₂ (end-on) on one of the metal atoms (denoted as Site 1) is transferred to an of end-on: side-on: side-on coordination on three metal atoms, prior to N₂ dissociation. The whole reaction is exothermic and has no global energy barriers, indicating that the dissociation of N₂ is facile under mild conditions. The reaction process can be divided into two processes: N₂ transfer (TRF) and N-N dissociation (DIS). For V-series clusters, which has a V atom on Site 1, the rate-determining step is DIS, while for Ta-series clusters with a Ta on Site 1, TRF may be the rate-determining step or has energy barriers similar to those of DIS. The overall energy barriers for heteronuclear V₂ TaC₄ ^- and VTa₂ C₄ ^- clusters are lower than those for homonuclear V₃ C₄ ^- and Ta₃ C₄ ^- , showing that the doping effect is beneficial for the activation and dissociation of N₂ . In particular, V-Ta₂ C₄ ^- has low energy barriers in both TRF and DIS, and it has the highest N₂ adsorption energy and a high reaction heat release. Therefore, a trimetallic heteronuclear V-series cluster, V-Ta₂ C₄ ^- , is suggested to have high reactivity to N₂ activation, and may serve as a prototype for designing related catalysts at a molecular level.

Advancing Inorganic Coordination Chemistry by Spectroscopy of Isolated Molecules: Methods and Applications

A unique feature of the work carried out in the Collaborative Research Center 3MET continues to be its emphasis on innovative, advanced experimental methods which hyphenate mass-selection with further analytical tools such as laser spectroscopy for the study of isolated molecular ions. This allows to probe the intrinsic properties of the species of interest free of perturbing solvent or matrix effects. This review explains these methods and uses examples from past and ongoing 3MET studies of specific classes of multicenter metal complexes to illustrate how coordination chemistry can be advanced by applying them. As a corollary, we will show how the challenges involved in providing well-defined, for example monoisomeric, samples of the molecular ions have helped to further improve the methods themselves thus also making them applicable to many other areas of chemistry.

Dual Iron Sites in Activation of N2 by Iron-Sulfur Cluster Anions Fe5S2- and Fe5S3. J Phys Chem Lett 2021;12:9269-9274. [PMID: 34533969 DOI: 10.1021/acs.jpclett.1c02683]

Inspired by the fact that the active centers of natural nitrogenases are polynuclear iron-sulfur clusters, the reactivity of isolated iron-sulfur clusters toward N₂ has received considerable attention to gain fundamental insights into the activation of the N≡N triple bond. Herein, a series of gas-phase iron-sulfur cluster anions Fe_xS_y^- (x = 1-8, y = 0-x) were prepared and their reactivities toward N₂ were investigated systematically by mass spectrometry. Among the 44 investigated clusters, only Fe₅S₂^- and Fe₅S₃^- showed superior reactivity toward N₂. Theoretical results revealed that N₂ binds molecularly to the iron sites of Fe₅S_2,3^- in a common end-on coordination mode with an unprecedented back-donation interaction from the localized d-d bonding orbitals of Fe-Fe sites to the π* antibonding orbitals of N₂. This is the first example to disclose the significant contribution of the dual metal sites rather than the single metal atom to N₂ adsorption in the prevalent end-on binding mode.

Non-Dissociative Activation of Chemisorbed Dinitrogen on One or Two Vanadium Atoms Supported by a Mo6 S8 Cluster

Adsorption of N₂ on Mo₆ S₈ ^q _V_x clusters (x=0, 1, 2; q=0, ±1) were systematically studied by density functional theory calculations with dispersion corrections. It was found that the N₂ can be chemisorbed and undergo non-dissociative activation on single or double metal atoms. The adsorption and activation are influenced by metal types (V or Mo), N₂ coordination modes and charge states of the clusters. Particularly, anionic Mo₆ S₈ ^- _V₂ clusters have remarkable ability to fix and activate N₂ . In Mo₆ S₈ ^- _V₂ , two V atoms prefer to adsorb on two adjacent S-Mo-S hollow sites, leading to the formation of a supported V…V unit. The N₂ is bridged side-on coordinated with these two V atoms with high adsorption energy and significant charge transfer. The bond order, bond length and vibration frequency of the adsorbed N₂ are close to those of a N-N single bond.

Rhodium chemistry: A gas phase cluster study

Due to the extraordinary catalytic activity in redox reactions, the noble metal, rhodium, has substantial industrial and laboratory applications in the production of value-added chemicals, synthesis of biomedicine, removal of automotive exhaust gas, and so on. The main drawback of rhodium catalysts is its high-cost, so it is of great importance to maximize the atomic efficiency of the precious metal by recognizing the structure-activity relationship of catalytically active sites and clarifying the root cause of the exceptional performance. This Perspective concerns the significant progress on the fundamental understanding of rhodium chemistry at a strictly molecular level by the joint experimental and computational study of the reactivity of isolated Rh-based gas phase clusters that can serve as ideal models for the active sites of condensed-phase catalysts. The substrates cover the important organic and inorganic molecules including CH₄, CO, NO, N₂, and H₂. The electronic origin for the reactivity evolution of bare Rh_x ^q clusters as a function of size is revealed. The doping effect and support effect as well as the synergistic effect among heteroatoms on the reactivity and product selectivity of Rh-containing species are discussed. The ingenious employment of diverse experimental techniques to assist the Rh₁- and Rh₂-doped clusters in catalyzing the challenging endothermic reactions is also emphasized. It turns out that the chemical behavior of Rh identified from the gas phase cluster study parallels the performance of condensed-phase rhodium catalysts. The mechanistic aspects derived from Rh-based cluster systems may provide new clues for the design of better performing rhodium catalysts including the single Rh atom catalysts.