Rotational Orientation Effects in NO(X) + Ar Inelastic Collisions

Determination of collision mechanisms at low energies using four-vector correlations

In molecular dynamics, a fundamental question is how the outcome of a collision depends on the relative orientation of the collision partners before their interaction begins (the stereodynamics of the process). The preference for a particular orientation of the reactant complex is intimately related to the idea of a collision mechanism and the possibility of control, as revealed in recent experiments. Indeed, this preference holds not only for chemical reactions involving complex polyatomic molecules, but also for the simplest inelastic atom-diatom collisions at cold collision energies. In this work, we report how the outcome of rotationally inelastic collisions between two D2 molecules can be controlled by changing the alignment of their internuclear axes under the same or different polarization vectors. Our results demonstrate that a higher degree of control can be achieved when two internuclear axes are aligned, especially when both molecules are relaxed in the collision. The possibility of control extends to very low energies, even to the ultracold regime, when no control could be achieved just by the alignment of the internuclear axis of one of the colliding partners.

Stereodynamical Control of Cold Collisions between Two Aligned D_{2} Molecules

Resonant scattering of optically state-prepared and aligned molecules in the cold regime allows the most detailed interrogation and control of bimolecular collisions. This technique has recently been applied to collisions of two aligned ortho-D_{2} molecules prepared in the j=2 rotational level of the v=2 vibrational manifold using the Stark-induced adiabatic Raman passage technique. Here, we develop the theoretical formalism for describing four-vector correlations in collisions of two aligned molecules and apply our approach to state-prepared D_{2}(v=2,j=2)+D_{2}(v=2,j=2)→D_{2}(v=2,j=2)+D_{2}(v=2,j=0) collisions, making possible the simulations of the experimental results from first principles. Key features of the experimental angular distributions are reproduced and attributed primarily to a partial wave resonance with orbital angular momentum ℓ=4.

Correlated rotational excitations in NO–CO inelastic collisions

We present a joint experimental and theoretical study of rotationally inelastic collisions between NO ( X2Π1/2, ν = 0, j = 1/2, f) radicals and CO ( X1Σ+, ν = 0, j = 0) molecules at a collision energy of 220 cm−1. State-to-state scattering images for excitation of NO radicals into various final states were measured with high resolution by combining the Stark deceleration and velocity map imaging techniques. The high image resolution afforded the observation of correlated rotational excitations of NO–CO pairs, which revealed a number of striking scattering phenomena. The so-called “parity-pair” transitions in NO are found to have similar differential cross sections, independent of the concurrent excitation of CO, extending this well-known effect for collisions between NO and rare gas atoms into the realm of bimolecular collisions. Forward scattering is found for collisions that induce a large amount of rotational energy transfer (in either NO, CO, or both), which require low impact parameters to induce sufficient energy transfer. This observation is interpreted in terms of the recently discovered hard collision glory scattering mechanism, which predicts the forward bending of initially backward receding trajectories if the energy uptake in the collision is substantial in relation to the collision energy. The experimental results are in good agreement with the predictions from coupled-channels quantum scattering calculations based on an ab initio NO–CO potential energy surface.

Role of Low Energy Resonances in the Stereodynamics of Cold He + D2 Collisions

In recent experiments using the Stark-induced adiabatic Raman passage technique, Zhou et al. ( J. Chem. Phys. 2021, 154, 104309; Science 2021, 374, 960-964) measured the product's angular distribution for the collisions between He and aligned D₂ molecules at cold collision energies. The signatures of the angular distributions were attributed to an [Formula: see text] = 2 resonance that governs scattering at low energies. A first-principles quantum mechanical treatment of this problem is presented here using a highly accurate interaction potential for the He-H₂ system. Our results predict a very intense [Formula: see text] = 1 resonance at low energies, leading to angular distributions that differ from those measured in the experiment. A good agreement with the experiment is achieved only when the [Formula: see text] = 1 resonance is artificially removed, for example, by excluding the lowest energies present in the experimental velocity distribution. Our analysis revealed that neither the position nor the intensity of the [Formula: see text] = 1 resonance significantly changes when the interaction potential is modified within its predicted uncertainties. Energy-resolved measurements may help to resolve the discrepancy.

Correlations in rotational energy transfer for NO-D2 inelastic collisions

We present a combined experimental and theoretical study of state-to-state inelastic collisions between NO (X ²Π_1/2, j = 1/2, f) radicals and D₂ (j = 0, 1, 2, 3) molecules at collision energies of 100 cm^-1 and 750 cm^-1. Using the combination of Stark deceleration and velocity map imaging, we fully resolve pair-correlated excitations in the scattered molecules. Both spin-orbit conserving and spin-orbit changing transitions in the NO radical are measured, while the coincident rotational excitation (j = 0 → j = 2) and rotational de-excitation (j = 2 → j = 0 and j = 3 → j = 1) in D₂ are observed. De-excitation of D₂ shows a strong dependence on the spin-orbit excitation of NO. We observe translation-to-rotation energy transfer as well as direct rotation-to-rotation energy transfer at the lowest collision energy probed. The experimental results are in good agreement with cross sections obtained from quantum coupled-channels calculations based on recent NO-D₂ potential energy surfaces. The observed trends in the correlated scattering cross sections are understood in terms of the NO-D₂ quadrupole-quadrupole interaction.

Steric Effects in the Inelastic Scattering of NO(X) + Ar: Side-on Orientation

The rotationally inelastic collisions of NO(X) with Ar, in which the NO bond-axis is oriented side-on (i.e., perpendicular) to the incoming collision partner, are investigated experimentally and theoretically. The NO(X) molecules are selected in the |j = 0.5, Ω = 0.5, ε = -1, f⟩ state prior to bond-axis orientation in a static electric field. The scattered NO products are then state selectively detected using velocity-map ion imaging. The experimental bond-axis orientation resolved differential cross sections and integral steric asymmetries are compared with quantum mechanical calculations, and are shown to be in good agreement. The strength of the orientation field is shown to affect the structure observed in the differential cross sections, and to some extent also the steric preference, depending on the ratio of the initial e and f Λ-doublets in the superposition determined by the orientation field. Classical and quantum calculations are compared and used to rationalize the structures observed in the differential cross sections. It is found that these structures are due to quantum mechanical interference effects, which differ for the two possible orientations of the NO molecule due to the anisotropy of the potential energy surface probed in the side-on orientation. Side-on collisions are shown to maximize and afford a high degree of control over the scattering intensity at small scattering angles (θ < 90°), while end-on collisions are predicted to dominate in the backward scattered region (θ > 90°).

Direct observation of product-pair correlations in rotationally inelastic collisions of ND3 with D2

We present a combined experimental and theoretical study of state-to-state inelastic scattering of ND₃(j = 1₁^-) with D₂ (j = 0, 1, 2, 3) molecules at collision energies around 800 cm^-1. Using a crossed molecular beam apparatus which employs the combination of Stark deceleration and velocity map imaging, we observe the correlated rotational excitations of both collision partners. For D₂, both elastic (Δj_D2 = 0), inelastic excitation (j = 0 →j = 2) and inelastic de-excitation (j = 2 →j = 0) processes are observed. For a number of final ND₃ states, inelastic channels in which D₂ is rotationally excited or de-excited appear surprisingly strong. The experimental results are in excellent agreement with the predictions from quantum scattering calculations which are based on an ab initio ND₃-D₂ potential energy surface.

How reactant polarization can be used to change the effect of interference on reactive collisions

It is common knowledge that integral and differential cross sections (DCSs) are strongly dependent on the spatial distribution of the molecular axis of the reactants. Hence, by controlling the axis distribution, it is possible to either promote or hinder the yield of products into specific final states or scattering angles. This idea has been successfully implemented in experiments by polarizing the internuclear axis before the reaction takes place, either by manipulating the rotational angular distribution or by the Stark effect in the presence of an orienting field. When there is a dominant reaction mechanism, characterized by a set of impact parameters and angles of attack, it is expected that a preparation that helps the system to reach the transition state associated with that mechanism will promote the reaction, whilst a different preparation would generally impair the reaction. However, when two or more competing mechanisms via interference contribute to the reaction into specific scattering angles and final states, it is not evident which would be the effect of changing the axis preparation. To address this problem, throughout this article we have simulated the effect that different experimental preparations have on the DCSs for the H + D2 reaction at relatively high energies, for which it has been shown that several competing mechanisms give rise to interference that shapes the DCS. To this aim, we have extended the formulation of the polarization dependent DCS to calculate polarization dependent generalized deflection functions of ranks greater than zero. Our results show that interference is very sensitive to changes in the internuclear axis preparation, and that the shape of the DCS can be controlled exquisitely.

Imaging inelastic scattering of CO with argon: polarization dependent differential cross sections

Rotationally inelastic scattering of carbon monoxide (CO) with argon at a collision energy of 700 cm⁻¹ has been investigated by measuring polarization dependent differential scattering cross sections (PDDCSs) for rotationally excited CO molecules using a crossed molecular beam apparatus coupled with velocity-map ion imaging.

Correlated energy transfer in rotationally and spin-orbit inelastic collisions of NO(X2Π1/2, j = 1/2f) with O2(X3Σg-)

We present a combined experimental and theoretical study of state-to-state inelastic scattering of NO(X2Π1/2, j = 1/2f) with O2(X3Σg-) molecules at a collision energy of 480 cm-1, focusing in particular on the observation and interpretation of correlated excitations in both NO and O2. Various final states of the NO radical, in both spin-orbit manifolds, were measured with high resolution using a crossed molecular beam apparatus which employs a combination of Stark deceleration and velocity map imaging. Velocity map imaging directly measures both the angular distribution and the radial velocity distribution of the scattered NO molecules, which probes the kinetic energy uptake or release and hence correlated excitations of NO-O2 pairs. Simultaneous excitations of NO and O2 were resolved for all studied final states of NO. In all cases, the experimental results excellently agree with the results of simulations based on quantum scattering calculations. Trends are discussed by analyzing the scattering wave functions from the calculations.

State-to-State Differential Cross Sections for Inelastic Collisions of NO Radicals with para-H2 and ortho-D2

We present state-to-state differential cross sections for collisions of NO molecules (X²Π_1/2, j = 1/2f) with para-H₂ and ortho-D₂ molecules, at a collision energy of 510 and 450 cm^–1, respectively. The angular scattering distributions for various final states of the NO radical are measured with high resolution using a crossed molecular beam apparatus that employs the combination of Stark deceleration and velocity map imaging. Rotational rainbows as well as diffraction oscillations are fully resolved in the scattering images. The observed angular scattering distributions are in excellent agreement with the cross sections obtained from quantum close-coupling scattering calculations based on recently computed NO–H₂ potential energy surfaces, except for excitation of NO into the j = 7/2f channel. For this particular inelastic channel, a significant discrepancy with theory is observed, despite various additional measurements and calculations, at present, not understood.

Stereodynamics in NO(X) + Ar inelastic collisions

The effect of orientation of the NO(X) bond axis prior to rotationally inelastic collisions with Ar has been investigated experimentally and theoretically. A modification to conventional velocity-map imaging ion optics is described, which allows the orientation of hexapole state-selected NO(X) using a static electric field, followed by velocity map imaging of the resonantly ionized scattered products. Bond orientation resolved differential cross sections are measured experimentally for a series of spin-orbit conserving transitions and compared with quantum mechanical calculations. The agreement between experimental results and those from quantum mechanical calculations is generally good. Parity pairs, which have previously been observed in collisions of unpolarized NO with various rare gases, are not observed due to the coherent superposition of the two j = 1/2, Ω = 1/2 Λ-doublet levels in the orienting field. The normalized difference differential cross sections are found to depend predominantly on the final rotational state, and are not very sensitive to the final Λ-doublet level. The differential steric effect has also been investigated theoretically, by means of quantum mechanical and classical calculations. Classically, the differential steric effect can be understood by considering the steric requirement for different types of trajectories that contribute to different regions of the differential cross section. However, classical effects cannot account quantitatively for the differential steric asymmetry observed in NO(X) + Ar collisions, which reflects quantum interference from scattering at either end of the molecule. This quantum interference effect is dominated by the repulsive region of the potential.

Integral steric asymmetry in the inelastic scattering of NO(X2Π)

The integral steric asymmetry for the inelastic scattering of NO(X) by a variety of collision partners was recorded using a crossed molecular beam apparatus. The initial state of the NO(X, v = 0, j = 1/2, Ω=1/2, ϵ=-1,f) molecule was selected using a hexapole electric field, before the NO bond axis was oriented in a static electric field, allowing probing of the scattering of the collision partner at either the N- or O-end of the molecule. Scattered NO molecules were state selectively probed using (1 + 1') resonantly enhanced multiphoton ionisation, coupled with velocity-map ion imaging. Experimental integral steric asymmetries are presented for NO(X) + Ar, for both spin-orbit manifolds, and Kr, for the spin-orbit conserving manifold. The integral steric asymmetry for spin-orbit conserving and changing transitions of the NO(X) + O₂ system is also presented. Close-coupled quantum mechanical scattering calculations employing well-tested ab initio potential energy surfaces were able to reproduce the steric asymmetry observed for the NO-rare gas systems. Quantum mechanical scattering and quasi-classical trajectory calculations were further used to help interpret the integral steric asymmetry for NO + O₂. Whilst the main features of the integral steric asymmetry of NO with the rare gases are also observed for the O₂ collision partner, some subtle differences provide insight into the form of the underlying potentials for the more complex system.

Experimental testing of ab initio potential energy surfaces: Stereodynamics of NO(A2Σ+) + Ne inelastic scattering at multiple collision energies

We present a crossed molecular beam velocity-map ion imaging study of state-to-state rotational energy transfer of NO(A²Σ⁺, v = 0, N = 0, j = 0.5) in collisions with Ne atoms. From these measurements, we report differential cross sections and angle-resolved rotational angular momentum alignment moments for product states N' = 3 and 5-10 for collisions at an average energy of 523 cm^-1, and N' = 3 and 5-14 for collisions at an average energy of 1309 cm^-1, respectively. The experimental results are compared to the results of close-coupled quantum scattering calculations on two literature ab initio potential energy surfaces (PESs) [Pajón-Suárez et al., Chem. Phys. Lett. 429, 389 (2006) and Cybulski and Fernández, J. Phys. Chem. A 116, 7319 (2012)]. The differential cross sections from both experiment and theory show clear rotational rainbow structures at both collision energies, and comparison of the angles observed for the rainbow peaks leads to the conclusion that Cybulski and Fernández PES better represents the NO(A²Σ⁺)-Ne interaction at the collision energies used here. Sharp, forward scattered (<10°), peaks are observed in the experimental differential cross sections for a wide range of N' at both collision energies, which are not reproduced by theory on either PES. We identify these as L-type rainbows, characteristic of attractive interactions, and consistent with a shallow well in the collinear Ne-N-O geometry, similar to that calculated for the NO(A²Σ⁺)-Ar surface [Kłos et al., J. Chem. Phys. 129, 244303 (2008)], but absent from both of the NO(A²Σ⁺)-Ne surfaces tested here. The angle-resolved alignment moments calculated by quantum scattering theory are generally in good agreement with the experimental results, but both experiment and quantum scattering theories are dramatically different to the predictions of a classical rigid-shell, kinematic-apse conservation model. Strong oscillations are resolved in the experimental alignment moments as a function of scattering angle, confirming and extending the preliminary report of this behavior [Steill et al., J. Phys. Chem. A 117, 8163 (2013)]. These oscillations are correlated with structure in the differential cross section, suggesting an interference effect is responsible for their appearance.