Catalytic CO Oxidation by Gas-Phase Metal Oxide Clusters

Machine Learning for Experimental Reactivity of a Set of Metal Clusters toward C-H Activation

Understanding the mechanisms of C-H activation of alkanes is a very important research topic. The reactions of metal clusters with alkanes have been extensively studied to reveal the electronic features governing C-H activation, while the experimental cluster reactivity was qualitatively interpreted case by case in the literature. Herein, we prepared and mass-selected over 100 rhodium-based clusters (RhxVyOz- and RhxCoyOz-) to react with light alkanes, enabling the determination of reaction rate constants spanning six orders of magnitude. A satisfactory model being able to quantitatively describe the rate data in terms of multiple cluster electronic features (average electron occupancy of valence s orbitals, the minimum natural charge on the metal atom, cluster polarizability, and energy gap involved in the agostic interaction) has been constructed through a machine learning approach. This study demonstrates that the general mechanisms governing the very important process of C-H activation by diverse metal centers can be discovered by interpreting experimental data with artificial intelligence.

CO Oxidation Promoted by NO Adsorption on RhMn2O3- Cluster Anions

CO oxidation represents an important model reaction in the gas phase to provide a clear structure-reactivity relationship in related heterogeneous catalysis. Herein, in combination with mass spectrometry experiments and quantum-chemical calculations, we identified that the RhMn2O3- cluster cannot oxidize CO into gas-phase CO2 at room temperature, while the NO preadsorbed products RhMn2O3-[(NO)1,2] are highly reactive in CO oxidation. This discovery is helpful to get a fundamental understanding on the reaction behavior in real-world three-way catalytic conditions where different kinds of reactants coexist. Theoretical calculations were performed to rationalize the crucial roles of preadsorbed NO where the strongly attached NO on the Rh atom can greatly stabilize the products RhMn2O2-[(NO)1,2] during CO oxidation and at the same time works together with the Rh atom to store electrons that stay originally in the attached CO2- unit. The leading result is that the desorption of CO2, which is the rate-determining step of CO oxidation by RhMn2O3-, can be greatly facilitated on the reactions of RhMn2O3-[(NO)1,2] with CO.

Photoelectron velocity map imaging spectroscopy of group 14 elements and iron tetracarbonyl anionic clusters MFe(CO)4- (M = Si, Ge, Sn)

The heteronuclear group 14 M-iron tetracarbonyl clusters MFe(CO)4- (M = Si, Ge, Sn) anions have been generated in the gas phase by laser ablation of M-Fe alloys and detected by mass and photoelectron spectroscopy. With the support of quantum chemical calculations, the geometric and electronic structures of MFe(CO)4- (M = Si, Ge, Sn) are elucidated, which shows that all the MFe(CO)4- clusters have the M-Fe bonded, iron-centered, and carbonyl-terminal M-Fe(CO)4 structure with the C2v symmetry and a 2B2 ground state. The M-Fe bond can be considered a double bond, which includes one σ electron sharing bond and one π dative bond. The C-O bonds in those anionic clusters are calculated to be elongated to different extents, and in particular, the C-O bonds in SiFe(CO)4- are elongated more. The Si-Fe alloy thus turns out to be a better collocation to activate the C-O bonds in the gas phase among group 14. The present findings have important implications for the rational development of high-performance catalysts with isolated metal atoms/clusters dispersed on supports.

Filtration of the preferred catalyst for reverse water-gas shift among Rhn- (n = 3-11) clusters by mass spectrometry under variable temperatures

The key to optimizing energy-consuming catalytic conversions lies in acquiring a fundamental understanding of the nature of the active sites and the mechanisms of elementary steps at an atomically precise level, while it is challenging to capture the crucial step that determines the overall temperature of a real-life catalytic reaction. Herein, benefiting from a newly-developed high-temperature ion trap reactor, the reverse water-gas shift (CO₂ + H₂ → CO + H₂O) reaction catalyzed by the Rh_n^- (n = 3-11) clusters was investigated under variable temperatures (298-783 K) and the critical temperature that each elementary step (Rh_n^- + CO₂ and Rh_nO^- + H₂) requires to take place was identified. The Rh₄^- cluster strikingly surpasses other Rh_n^- clusters to drive the catalysis at a mild starting temperature (∼440 K). This finding represents the first example that a specifically sized cluster catalyst that works under an optimum condition can be accurately filtered by using state-of-the-art mass spectrometric experiments and rationalized by quantum-chemical calculations.

Enhancing the Performance of Global Optimization of Platinum Cluster Structures by Transfer Learning in a Deep Neural Network

The global optimization of metal cluster structures is an important research field. The traditional deep neural network (T-DNN) global optimization method is a good way to find out the global minimum (GM) of metal cluster structures, but a large number of samples are required. We developed a new global optimization method which is the combination of the DNN and transfer learning (DNN-TL). The DNN-TL method transfers the DNN parameters of the small-sized cluster to the DNN of the large-sized cluster to greatly reduce the number of samples. For the global optimization of Pt₉ and Pt₁₃ clusters in this research, the T-DNN method requires about 3-10 times more samples than the DNN-TL method, and the DNN-TL method saves about 70-80% of time. We also found that the average amplitude of parameter changes in the T-DNN training is about 2 times larger than that in the DNN-TL training, which rationalizes the effectiveness of transfer learning. The average fitting errors of the DNN trained by the DNN-TL method can be even smaller than those by the T-DNN method because of the reliability of transfer learning. Finally, we successfully obtained the GM structures of Pt_n (n = 8-14) clusters by the DNN-TL method.

Thermal Methane Conversion to Formaldehyde Mediated by NiAlO3+ in the Gas Phase

Understanding the active sites and reaction mechanisms of Ni-based catalysts, such as Ni/Al₂O₃, toward methane is a prerequisite for improving their rational design. Here, the gas-phase reactivity of NiAlO₃⁺ cations toward CH₄ is studied using mass spectrometry combined with density functional theory. Similar to our previous study on NiAl₂O₄⁺, we find evidence for the formation of both the methyl radical (CH₃^•) and formaldehyde (CH₂O). The first step for methane activation is hydrogen atom abstraction by the terminal oxygen radical Ni(O)₂AlO^• from methane forming a [Ni(O)₂AlOH⁺, ^•CH₃] complex and leaving the Ni-oxidation state unchanged. The second C-H bond is subsequently activated by the association of a bridged Ni-O^2--Al. The oxidation state of the Ni atom is reduced from +3 to +1 during the formation of formaldehyde. Compared to Al₂O₃⁺/CH₄ and YAlO₃⁺/CH₄ systems, the Ni-atom substitution increases the overall reaction rate by roughly an order of magnitude and yields a CH₃^•/CH₂O branching ratio of 0.62/0.38. The present study provides molecular-level insights into the highly efficient gas-phase reaction mechanism contributing to an improved understanding of methane conversion by Ni/Al₂O₃ catalysts.

Gas-phase reactions driven by polarized metal-metal bonding in atomic clusters

Multimetallic catalysts exhibit great potential in the activation and catalytic transformation of small molecules. The polarized metal-metal bonds have been gradually recognized to account for the reactivity of multimetallic catalysts due to the synergistic effect of different metal centers. Gas-phase reactions on atomic clusters that compositionally resemble the active sites on related condensed-phase catalysts provide a widely accepted strategy to clarify the nature of polarized metal-metal bonds and the mechanistic details of elementary steps involved in the catalysis driven by this unique chemical bonding. This perspective review concerns the progress in the fundamental understanding of industrially and environmentally important reactions that are closely related to the polarized metal-metal bonds in clusters at a strictly molecular level. The following topics have been summarized and discussed: (1) catalytic CO oxidation with O₂, H₂O, and NO as oxidants (2) and the activation of other inert molecules (e.g., CH₄, CO₂, and N₂) mediated with clusters featuring polarized metal-metal bonding. It turns out that the findings in the gas phase parallel the catalytic behaviors of condensed-phase catalysts and the knowledge can prove to be essential in inspiring future design of promising catalysts.

Mixed-metal nanoparticles: phase transitions and diffusion in Au-VO clusters

Nanoparticles with diameters in the range of a few nanometers, consisting of gold and vanadium oxide, are synthesized by sequential doping of cold helium droplets in a molecular beam apparatus and deposited on solid carbon substrates. After surface deposition, the samples are removed and various measurement techniques are applied to characterize the created particles: scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) at atomic resolution, temperature dependent STEM and TEM up to 650 °C, energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDXS) and electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS). In previous experiments we have shown that pure V₂O₅ nanoparticles can be generated by sublimation from the bulk and deposited without affecting their original stoichiometry. Interestingly, our follow-up attempts to create Au@V₂O₅ core@shell particles do not yield the expected encapsulated structure. Instead, Janus particles of Au and V₂O₅ with diameters between 10 and 20 nm are identified after deposition. At the interface of the Au and the V₂O₅ parts we observe an epitaxial-like growth of the vanadium oxide next to the Au structure. To test the temperature stability of these Janus-type particles, the samples are heated in situ during the STEM measurements from room temperature up to 650 °C, where a reduction from V₂O₅ to V₂O₃ is followed by a restructuring of the gold atoms to form a Wulff-shaped cluster layer. The temperature dependent dynamic interplay between gold and vanadium oxide in structures of only a few nanometer size is the central topic of this contribution to the Faraday Discussion.

Facile CO bond cleavage on polynuclear vanadium nitride clusters V4N5. Phys Chem Chem Phys 2022;24:29765-29771. [PMID: 36458914 DOI: 10.1039/d2cp04304a] [Citation(s) in RCA: 0] [Impact Index Per Article: 0]

Identifying the structural configurations of precursors for CO dissociation is fundamentally interesting and industrially important in the fields of, e.g., Fischer-Tropsch synthesis. Herein, we demonstrated that CO could be dissociated on polynuclear vanadium nitride V₄N₅^- clusters at room temperature, and a key intermediate, with CO in a N-assisted tilted bridge coordination where the C-O bond ruptures easily, was discovered. The reaction was characterized by mass spectrometry, photoelectron spectroscopy, and quantum-chemistry calculations, and the nature of the adsorbed CO on product V₄N₅CO^- was further characterized by a collision-induced dissociation experiment. Theoretical analysis evidences that CO dissociation is predominantly governed by the low-coordinated V and N atoms on the (V₃N₄)VN^- cluster and the V₃N₄ moiety resembles a support. This finding strongly suggests that a novel mode for facile CO dissociation was identified in a gas-phase cluster study.

Water-Gas Shift Catalyzed by Iridium-Vanadium Oxide Clusters IrVO2- with Iridium in a Rare Oxidation State of -II

The discovery of compounds containing transition metals with an unusual and well-established oxidation state is vital to enrich our horizon on formal oxidation state. Herein, benefiting from the study of the water-gas shift reaction (CO + H₂O → CO₂ + H₂) mediated with the iridium-vanadium oxide cluster IrVO₂^-, the missing -II oxidation state of iridium was identified. The reactions were performed by using our newly developed double ion trap reactors that can spatially separate the addition of reactants and are characterized by mass spectrometry and quantum-chemical calculations. This finding makes an important step that all the proposed 13 oxidation states of iridium (+IX to -III) have been known. The iridium atom in the IrVO₂^- cluster features the Ir═V double bond and resembles chemically the coordinated oxygen atom. A reactivity study demonstrated that the flexible role switch of iridium between an oxygen-atom like (Ir^-IIVO₂^-) and a transition-metal-atom like behavior (Ir^+IIVO₃^-) in different species can drive the water-gas shift reaction in the gas phase under ambient conditions. This result parallels and well rationalizes the extraordinary reactivity of oxide-supported iridium single-atom catalysts in related condensed-phase reactions.

Multiple CO2 reduction mediated by heteronuclear metal carbide cluster anions RhTaC2. Dalton Trans 2022;51:11491-11498. [PMID: 35833563 DOI: 10.1039/d2dt01612e] [Citation(s) in RCA: 0] [Impact Index Per Article: 0]

Noble metals dispersed on transition-metal carbides exhibit extraordinary activity in CO₂ catalytic conversion and bimetallic carbides generated at the interface were proposed to contribute to the observed activity. Heteronuclear metal carbide clusters (HMCCs) that compositionally resemble the bimetallic carbides are suitable models to get a fundamental understanding of the reactivity of the related condensed-phase catalysts, while the reaction of HMCCs with CO₂ has not been touched in the gas phase. Herein, benefiting from the newly designed double ion trap reactors, the reaction of laser-ablation generated and mass-selected RhTaC₂^- clusters with CO₂ was studied. The experimental results identified that RhTaC₂^- can reduce four CO₂ molecules consecutively and generate the product RhTaC₂O₄^-. The pivotal roles of Rh-Ta synergy and the C₂ ligand in driving CO₂ reduction were rationalized by theoretical calculations. The presence of an attached CO unit on the product RhTaC₂O₄^- was evidenced by the collision-induced dissociation experiment, providing a fundamental strategy to alleviate carbon deposition under a CO₂ atmosphere at elevated temperatures.

Reverse water-gas shift reaction catalyzed by diatomic rhodium anions

The reverse water-gas shift (RWGS, CO₂ + H₂ → CO + H₂O, ΔH₂₉₈ = +0.44 eV) reaction mediated by the diatomic anion Rh₂^- was successfully constructed. The generation of a gas-phase H₂O molecule and ion product [Rh₂(CO)_ads]^- was identified unambiguously at room temperature and the only elementary step that requires extra energy to complete the catalysis is the desorption of CO from [Rh₂(CO)_ads]^-. This experimentally identified Rh₂^- anion represents the first gas-phase species that can drive the RWGS reaction because it is challenging to design effective routes to yield H₂O from CO₂ and H₂. The reactions were performed by using our newly developed double ion trap reactors and characterized by mass spectrometry, photoelectron spectroscopy, and high-level quantum-chemical calculations. We found that the order that the reactants (CO₂ or D₂) were fed into the reactor did not have a pronounced impact on the reactivity and the final product distribution (D₂O and Rh₂CO^-). The atomically precise insights into the key steps to guide the reaction toward the RWGS direction were provided.

Water Gas Shift Reaction Catalyzed by Rhodium-Manganese Oxide Cluster Anions

Fundamental understanding of the nature of active sites in real-life water gas shift (WGS) catalysts that can convert CO and H₂O into CO₂ and H₂ is crucial to engineer related catalysts performing under ambient conditions. Herein, we identified that the WGS reaction can be, in principle, catalyzed by rhodium-manganese oxide clusters Rh₂MnO_1,2^- in the gas phase at room temperature. This is the first example of the construction of such a potential catalysis in cluster science because it is challenging to discover clusters that can abstract the oxygen from H₂O and then supply the anchored oxygen to oxidize CO. The WGS reaction was characterized by mass spectrometry, photoelectron spectroscopy, and quantum-chemical calculations. The coordinated oxygen in Rh₂MnO_1,2^- is paramount for the generation of an electron-rich Mn⁺-Rh^- bond that is critical to capture and reduce H₂O and giving rise to a polarized Rh⁺-Rh^- bond that functions as the real redox center to drive the WGS reaction.

An IrVO4+ Cluster Catalytically Oxidizes Four CO Molecules: Importance of Ir-V Multiple Bonding

The generation and characterization of multiple metal-metal (M-M) bonds between early and late transition metals is vital to correlate the nature of multiple M-M bonds with the related reactivity in catalysis, while the examples with multiple M-M bonds have been rarely reported. Herein, we identified that the quadruple bonding interactions were formed in a gas-phase ion IrV⁺ with a dramatically short Ir-V bond. Oxidation of four CO molecules by IrVO₄⁺ is a highly exothermic process driven by the generation of stable products IrV⁺ and CO₂, and then IrV⁺ can be oxidized by N₂O to regenerate IrVO₄⁺. This finding overturns the general impression that vanadium oxide clusters are unwilling to oxidize multiple CO molecules because of the strong V-O bond and that at most two oxygen atoms can be supplied from a single V-containing cluster in CO oxidation. This study emphasizes the potential importance of heterobimetallic multiple M-M bonds in related heterogeneous catalysis.

Rhodium chemistry: A gas phase cluster study

Due to the extraordinary catalytic activity in redox reactions, the noble metal, rhodium, has substantial industrial and laboratory applications in the production of value-added chemicals, synthesis of biomedicine, removal of automotive exhaust gas, and so on. The main drawback of rhodium catalysts is its high-cost, so it is of great importance to maximize the atomic efficiency of the precious metal by recognizing the structure-activity relationship of catalytically active sites and clarifying the root cause of the exceptional performance. This Perspective concerns the significant progress on the fundamental understanding of rhodium chemistry at a strictly molecular level by the joint experimental and computational study of the reactivity of isolated Rh-based gas phase clusters that can serve as ideal models for the active sites of condensed-phase catalysts. The substrates cover the important organic and inorganic molecules including CH₄, CO, NO, N₂, and H₂. The electronic origin for the reactivity evolution of bare Rh_x ^q clusters as a function of size is revealed. The doping effect and support effect as well as the synergistic effect among heteroatoms on the reactivity and product selectivity of Rh-containing species are discussed. The ingenious employment of diverse experimental techniques to assist the Rh₁- and Rh₂-doped clusters in catalyzing the challenging endothermic reactions is also emphasized. It turns out that the chemical behavior of Rh identified from the gas phase cluster study parallels the performance of condensed-phase rhodium catalysts. The mechanistic aspects derived from Rh-based cluster systems may provide new clues for the design of better performing rhodium catalysts including the single Rh atom catalysts.

Activation of Carbon Dioxide by CoCDn- (n = 0-4) Anions

Laser ablation generated CoCD_n^- (n = 0-4) anions were mass selected and then reacted with CO₂ in an ion trap reactor. The reactions were characterized by mass spectrometry and quantum chemical calculations. The experimental results demonstrated that the CoC^- anion can convert CO₂ into CO. In contrast, the bare Co^- anion is inert toward CO₂. Coordinated D ligands can modify the reactivity of CoCD_1-4^- in which CoCD_1-3^- can reduce CO₂ into CO selectively and CoCD₄^- can only adsorb CO₂. The crucial roles of the coordinated C and D ligands to tune the reactivity of CoCD_n^- (n = 0-4) toward CO₂ were rationalized by theoretical calculations. Note that the hydrogenation process that is usually observed in the reactions of gas-phase metal hydrides with CO₂ is completely suppressed for the reactions CoCD_n^- + CO₂. This study provides insights into the molecular-level origin for the observations that CO can be selectively generated from CO₂ catalyzed by cobalt-containing carbides in heterogeneous catalysis.

Exploring Cu/Al cluster growth and reactivity: from embryonic building blocks to intermetalloid, open-shell superatoms

Cluster growth reactions in the system [Cu5](Mes)5 + [Al4](Cp*)4 (Mes = mesitylene, Cp* = pentamethylcyclopentadiene) were explored and monitored by in situ LIFDI-MS and 1H-NMR. Feedback into experimental design allowed for an informed choice and precise adjustment of reaction conditions and led to isolation of the intermetallic cluster [Cu4Al4](Cp*)5(Mes) (1). Cluster 1 reacts with excess 3-hexyne to yield the triangular cluster [Cu2Al](Cp*)3 (2). The two embryonic [Cu4Al4](Cp*)5(Mes) and [Cu2Al](Cp*)3 clusters 1 and 2, respectively, were shown to be intermediates in the formation of an inseparable composite of the closely related clusters [Cu7Al6](Cp*)6 (3), [HCu7Al6](Cp*)6 (3H) and [Cu8Al6](Cp*)6 (4), which just differ by one Cu core atom. The radical nature of the open-shell superatomic [Cu7Al6](Cp*)6 cluster 3 is reflected in its reactivity towards addition of one Cu core atom leading to the closed shell superatom [Cu8Al6](Cp*)6 (4), and as well by its ability to undergo σ(C-H) and σ(Si-H) activation reactions of C6H5CH3 (toluene) and (TMS)3SiH (TMS = tris(trimethylsilyl)).

Neutral noble-metal-free VCoO2 and CrCoO2 cluster catalysts for CO oxidation by O2

Neutral noble-metal-free metal oxide cluster catalysts (VCoO₂ and CrCoO₂) were developed for multiple CO oxidation reactions by O₂.

Non-stoichiometric molybdenum sulfide clusters and their reactions with the hydrogen molecule

The empty bridge site of Mo–Mo in non-stoichiometric molybdenum sulfide clusters may act a bridge for H atom transfer and be beneficial for hydrogen evolution reaction.

Dinitrogen Activation and Functionalization by Heteronuclear Metal Cluster Anions FeV2C2- at Room Temperature

It is of great importance to study the mechanisms to activate dinitrogen (N₂), the very inert molecule, under mild conditions. Gas-phase metal clusters are being actively generated to react with N₂ to identify new reaction types and mechanisms. Herein, an unprecedented, mechanistically unique metal atom (Fe or V) ejection in the thermal reaction of FeV₂C₂^- with N₂ has been identified using mass spectrometry, photoelectron imaging spectroscopy, and quantum chemistry calculations. Strong evidence suggests that the complete cleavage of the N≡N triple bond and subsequent functionalization of two N atoms via C-N coupling were achieved in this reaction. The complementary cooperation between V atoms with strong electron-donating ability and an Fe atom with large electron-withdrawing ability as well as the geometric flexibility of the Fe-V-V ring drives the whole reaction. The important role of C ligands in N≡N cleavage was also revealed. This study emphasizes the importance of heteronuclear metal systems for N₂ fixation.

Reactivity of Iron Hydride Anions Fe2Hn- (n = 0-3) with Carbon Dioxide

The hydrogenation of CO₂ into value-added complexes is of great importance for both environmental and economic issues. Metal hydrides are good models for the active sites to explore the nature of CO₂ hydrogenation; however, the fundamental insights into C-H bond formation are still far from clear because of the complexity of real-life catalysts. Herein, gas-phase reactions of the Fe₂H_n^- (n = 0-3) anions with CO₂ were investigated using mass spectrometry and quantum chemical calculations. The experimental results showed that the reduction of CO₂ into CO dominates all of these reactions, whereas Fe₂H^- and Fe₂H₂^- can induce the hydrogenation of CO₂ effectively to give rise to products Fe(HCO₂)^- and HFe(HCO₂)^-, respectively. The mechanistic aspects and the reactivity of Fe₂H_n^- with an increased number of H atoms in CO₂ hydrogenation were rationalized by theoretical calculations.

An Eight-Atom Iridium-Aluminum Oxide Cluster IrAlO6+ Catalytically Oxidizes Six CO Molecules

Fundamental understanding regarding oxygen storage capacity involving how and why an active site can buffer a large number of oxygen atoms in redox processes is vital to the design of advanced oxygen storage materials, while it is challenging because of the complexity of heterogeneous catalysis. Herein, we identified that an eight-atom iridium-aluminum oxide cluster IrAlO₆⁺ can transfer all the oxygen atoms to catalytically oxidize six CO molecules. This finding represents a breakthrough in cluster catalysis where at most three oxygen atoms from a heteronuclear metal oxide cluster can be catalytically involved in CO oxidation. We found that oxygen prefers to be stored on aluminum to form an O₃^-• radical in the energetically unfavorable IrAlO₆⁺ isomer and generate the low-coordinated iridium that is pivotal to capturing CO and triggering the catalysis. The powerful electron cycling capability of iridium and the cooperative iridium-aluminum interplay are emphasized to drive the oxygen atom-transfer behavior.