Anions as Dynamic Probes for Ionic Liquid Mixtures

Chain-length dependent organisation in mixtures of hydrogenous and fluorous ionic liquids

As part of an ongoing study of the structure and properties of mixtures of ionic liquids in which one component has a hydrocarbon chain and the other a semiperfluorocarbon chain, we now report a study of the mixtures [C8MIM]1-x[C10MIM-F17]x[Tf2N], [C10MIM]1-x[C8MIM-F13]x[Tf2N] and [C10MIM]1-x[C10MIM-F17]x[Tf2N], where [C8MIM][Tf2N] is 1-methyl-3-octylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide, [C10MIM][Tf2N] is 1-decyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide, [C8MIM-F13][Tf2N] is 1-(1H,1H,2H,2H-perfluorooctyl)-3-methylimidizolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide and [C10MIM-F17][Tf2N] is 1-(1H,1H,2H,2H-perfluorodecyl)-3-methylimidizolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide. The mixtures were investigated using small-angle X-ray (SAXS) and neutron (SANS) scattering complemented by molecular dynamics simulations (with viscosity and surface tension measurements also possible for the mixtures [C10MIM]1-x[C8MIM-F13]x[Tf2N]). Unlike previous studies of [C8MIM]1-x[C8MIM-F13]x[Tf2N], where no strong evidence of alkyl/fluoroalkyl chain segregation or triphilic behaviour was seen (Elstone et al., J. Phys. Chem. B, 2023, 127, 7394-7407), these new mixtures show the formation of small aggregates of varying sizes of each component, even though all were co-miscible across the full range of compositions. Thus, while a clear polar non-polar peak (PNPP) was observed at large or small values of x, at intermediate compositions the small-angle neutron scattering at low q was dominated by scattering from these small aggregates, while at other compositions, there was little or no evidence of the PNPP. The origins of this behaviour are discussed in terms of inter-chain interactions.

AC-Modulated XPS Enables to Externally Control the Electrical Field Distributions on Metal Electrode/Ionic Liquid Devices

X-Ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS) has been utilized to extract local electrical potential profiles by recording core-level binding energy shifts upon application of the AC [square-wave (SQW)] bias with different frequencies. An electrochemical system consisting of a coplanar capacitor with a polyethylene membrane (PEM) coated with the Ionic Liquid (IL) N,N-diethyl-N-methyl-N-(2-methoxyethyl) ammonium bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide (DEME-TFSI) as the electrolyte is investigated. Analyses are carried out in operando, such that XPS measurements are recorded simultaneously with current measurements. ILs have complex charging/discharging processes, in addition to the formation of Electrical Double Layers (EDL) at the interfaces, and certain properties of these processes can be captured using AC modulation within appropriate time windows of observation. Herein, we select two frequencies, namely, 10 kHz and 0.1 Hz, to separate effects of the fast polarization and slow migratory motions, respectively. Moreover, the local potential developments after adding two equivalent series resistors at three different physical positions of the device have been carefully evaluated from the binding energy shifts in the F 1s peak representing the anion of the IL. This circuit modification allows us to quantify the AC currents passing through the device, as well as the system's impedance, in addition to revealing the potential variations due the IR drops. The complex AC-modulated local XPS data recorded can also be faithfully reproduced using the unmodulated F 1s spectrum and by convoluting it with electrical circuit output provided by the LT-Spice software. The outcome of these efforts is a more realistic equivalent circuit model, which can be related to chemical/physical makeup of the electrochemical system. An important finding of this methodology emerges as the possibility to induce additional local electrical field developments within the device, the directions of which can be reversed controllably.

Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Relaxation Pathways in Electrolytes for Energy Storage

Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) spin relaxation times have been an instrumental tool in deciphering the local environment of ionic species, the various interactions they engender and the effect of these interactions on their dynamics in conducting media. Of particular importance has been their application in studying the wide range of electrolytes for energy storage, on which this review is based. Here we highlight some of the research carried out on electrolytes in recent years using NMR relaxometry techniques. Specifically, we highlight studies on liquid electrolytes, such as ionic liquids and organic solvents; on semi-solid-state electrolytes, such as ionogels and polymer gels; and on solid electrolytes such as glasses, glass ceramics and polymers. Although this review focuses on a small selection of materials, we believe they demonstrate the breadth of application and the invaluable nature of NMR relaxometry.

Size-Polydisperse Model Ionic Liquid in Bulk

The static and the dynamic properties of a size-polydisperse model ionic liquid is studied using molecular dynamics simulations. Here, the size of the anions is derived from a Gaussian distribution while keeping cation size fixed, resulting in a system that closely corresponds to IL mixtures with a common cation. We systematically explore the behavior of thermodynamic transition temperatures, spatial ordering of ions, and the resulting screening behavior as a function of polydispersity index, δ. We observe a nonmonotonic dependence of transition temperatures on δ, and this nonmonotonic behavior is also reflected in other properties such as screening length. Furthermore, from the radial distribution function analysis it is found that, upon varying δ, the spatial ordering of cations is affected, while no such changes is seen for anion. On the other hand, the analysis of ion motion through mean-square displacement show that for all δ values considered both inertial and diffusive regimes are observed (as expected in the liquid state). However, in contrast to the neutral counterpart, the overall relaxation time of the polydisperse IL system increases (and hence decreasing diffusion coefficient) with increasing δ.

Mixing Ionic Liquids Affects the Kinetics and Thermodynamics of the Oxygen/Superoxide Redox Couple in the Context of Oxygen Sensing

The electrochemical oxygen reduction reaction is vital for applications such as fuel cells, metal air batteries and for oxygen gas sensing. Oxygen undergoes a 1-electron reduction process in dry ionic liquids (ILs) to form the electrogenerated superoxide ion that is solvated and stabilized by IL cations. In this work, the oxygen/superoxide (O₂/O₂ ^•-) redox couple has been used to understand the effect of mixing ILs with different cations in the context of developing designer electrolytes for oxygen sensing, by employing cyclic voltammetry at both gold and platinum electrodes. Different cations with a range of sizes, geometries and aromatic/aliphatic character were studied with a common bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide ([NTf₂]^-) anion. Diethylmethylsulfonium ([S_2,2,1]⁺), N-butyl-N-methylpyrrolidinum ([C₄mpyrr]⁺) and tetradecyltrihexylphosphonium ([P_14,6,6,6]⁺) cations were mixed with a common 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium ([C₄mim]⁺) cation at mole fractions (x) of [C₄mim]⁺ of 0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, and 1. Both the redox kinetics and thermodynamics were found to be highly dependent on the cation structure and the electrode material used. Large deviations from "ideal" mixtures were observed for mixtures of [C₄mim][NTf₂] with [C₄mpyrr][NTf₂] on gold electrodes, suggesting a much higher amount of [C₄mim]⁺ ions near the electrode surface despite the large excess of [C₄mpyrr]⁺ in the bulk. The electrical double layer structure was probed for a mixture of [C₄mim]_0.2[C₄mpyrr]_0.8[NTf₂] using atomic force microscopy measurements on Au, revealing that the first layer was more like [C₄mim][NTf₂] than [C₄mpyrr][NTf₂]. Unusually fast kinetics for O₂/O₂ ^•- in mixtures of [C₄mim]⁺ with [P_14,6,6,6]⁺ were also observed in the electrochemistry results, which warrants further follow-up studies to elucidate this promising behavior. Overall, it is important to understand the effect on the kinetic and thermodynamic properties of electrochemical reactions when mixing solvents, to aid in the creation of designer electrolytes with favorable properties for their intended application.

The structuring effect of the alkyl domains on the polar network of ionic liquid mixtures: a molecular dynamics study

By using molecular dynamics simulations, we investigate the structural and dynamic properties of mixtures of 1,3-dimethylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide, [C₁C₁im][Tf₂N] and 1-dodecyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide, [C₁₂C₁im][Tf₂N] (also C₁ and C₁₂ in short). Such mixtures feature an imidazolium bistriflimide salt with a very short alkyl chain, not giving rise to any nano-segregation as a pure component, with another one with a longer alkyl chain that exhibits a substantial nano-segregation as a pure liquid. As the mole fraction of the long-chain component C₁₂ is increased, the so-called pre-peak of the structure factor S(q), occurring in the region 1-3 nm^-1, shows a shift to higher values of the wavevector q, mirroring a decrease of the corresponding correlation length. Moreover, the intensity of the pre-peak strongly increases with the C₁₂ concentration. These results are in very good agreement with experimental X-ray scattering data in the literature. On the other hand, the diffusion of the ions is found to exhibit a simple behaviour consistent with the increased viscosity of the mixture, and these results are also in good agreement with NMR experimental data from the literature. The simulation results are rationalized as caused by a structuring effect, similar to the hydrophobic effect, of the alkyl domains of the C₁₂ component dissolved in the "solvent" represented by the C₁ cation, the Tf₂N^- anion and the C₁₂ cation head. In short, the exclusion of the alkyl chains from the polar network, a process mostly governed by electrostatic interactions, favours the formation of hydrophobic domains, which in turn exert a structuring effect on the ions of the polar domains, favouring a stronger ionic interaction. This is finally reflected in a shorter correlation length and a higher intensity of the pre-peak of the structure factor S(q) as the C₁₂ mole fraction is increased. At variance with the microscopic structure, the diffusion of all three types of ions is not strongly influenced by the nano-segregation and is essentially dependent on the viscosity of the mixture.

Recent advances in NMR spectroscopy of ionic liquids

This review presents recent developments in the application of NMR spectroscopic techniques in the study of ionic liquids. NMR has been the primary tool not only for the structural characterization of ionic liquids, but also for the study of dynamics. The presence of a host of NMR active nuclei in ionic liquids permits widespread use of multinuclear NMR experiments. Chemical shifts and multinuclear coupling constants are used routinely for the structure elucidation of ionic liquids and of products formed by their covalent interactions with other materials. Also, the availability of a multitude of NMR techniques has facilitated the study of dynamical processes in them. These include the use of NOESY to study inter-ionic interactions, pulsed-field gradient techniques for probing transport properties, and relaxation measurements to elucidate rotational dynamics. This review will focus on the application of each of these techniques to investigate ionic liquids.

Hydrogen Bond Redistribution Effects in Mixtures of Protic Ionic Liquids Sharing the Same Cation: Non-ideal Mixing with Large Negative Mixing Enthalpies

We report a joint experimental and theoretical study characterising the hydrogen bond (HB) redistribution in mixtures of two different protic ionic liquids (PILs) sharing the same cation: triethylammonium-methanesulfonate ([TEA][OMs]) and...

The Intermolecular NOE Depends on Isotope Selection: Short Range vs Long Range Behavior

The nuclear Overhauser effect (NOE) is a powerful tool in molecular structure elucidation, combining the subtle chemical shift of NMR and three-dimensional information independent of chemical connectivity. Its usage for intermolecular studies, however, is fundamentally limited by an unspecific long-ranged interaction behavior. This joint experimental and computational work shows that proper selection of interacting isotopes can overcome these limitations: Isotopes with strongly differing gyromagnetic ratios give rise to short-ranged intermolecular NOEs. In this light, existing NOE experiments need to be re-evaluated and future ones can be designed accordingly. Thus, a new chapter on intermolecular structure elucidation is opened.

Xenon Diffusion in Ionic Liquids with Blurred Nanodomain Separation

The dynamics of xenon gas, loaded in a series of 1-alkyl-3-methylimidazolium based ionic liquids, probes the formation of increasingly blurred polar/apolar nanodomains as a function of the anion type and the cation chain length. Exploiting ¹²⁹ Xe NMR spectroscopy techniques, like Pulse Gradient Spin Echo (PGSE) and inversion recovery (IR), the diffusion motion and relaxation times are determined for 1-alkyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [C_n C₁ im][TFSI]. A correlation between the ILs nano-structure and both xenon diffusivity and relaxation times, as well as chemical shifts, is outlined. Interestingly, comparison with previous results of the same properties in the homologous imidazolium chlorides and hexafluorophospate shows an opposite trend with the alkyl chain length. Classical molecular dynamics (MD) simulations are used to calculate the xenon and cation and anion diffusion coefficients in the same systems, including imidazolium cations with longer chains (n=4, 6, 8 … 20). An almost quantitative agreement with the experiments validates the MD simulations and, at the same time, provides the necessary structural and dynamic microscopic insights on the nano-segregation and diffusion of xenon in bistriflimide, chloride and hexafluorphosphate salts allowing to observe and rationalize the shaping effect of the cation in the nanostructure.

Liquid structure and dynamics in the choline acetate:urea 1:2 deep eutectic solvent

We report on the thermodynamic, structural, and dynamic properties of a recently proposed deep eutectic solvent, formed by choline acetate (ChAc) and urea (U) at the stoichiometric ratio 1:2, hereinafter indicated as ChAc:U. Although the crystalline phase melts at 36-38 °C depending on the heating rate, ChAc:U can be easily supercooled at sub-ambient conditions, thus maintaining at the liquid state, with a glass-liquid transition at about -50 °C. Synchrotron high energy x-ray scattering experiments provide the experimental data for supporting a reverse Monte Carlo analysis to extract structural information at the atomistic level. This exploration of the liquid structure of ChAc:U reveals the major role played by hydrogen bonding in determining interspecies correlations: both acetate and urea are strong hydrogen bond acceptor sites, while both choline hydroxyl and urea act as HB donors. All ChAc:U moieties are involved in mutual interactions, with acetate and urea strongly interacting through hydrogen bonding, while choline being mostly involved in van der Waals mediated interactions. Such a structural situation is mirrored by the dynamic evidences obtained by means of ¹H nuclear magnetic resonance techniques, which show how urea and acetate species experience higher translational activation energy than choline, fingerprinting their stronger commitments into the extended hydrogen bonding network established in ChAc:U.

Interplay of Structure and Dynamics in Lithium/Ionic Liquid Electrolytes: Experiment and Molecular Simulation

Despite their promising use in electrochemical and electrokinetic devices, ionic-liquid-based electrolytes often exhibit complex behavior arising from a subtle interplay of their structure and dynamics. Here, we report a joint experimental and molecular simulation study of such electrolytes obtained by mixing 1-butyl 3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate with lithium tetrafluoroborate. More in detail, experiments consisting of X-ray scattering, pulsed field gradient NMR, and complex impedance spectroscopy are analyzed in the light of molecular dynamics simulations to probe the structural, dynamical, and electrochemical properties of this ionic-liquid-based electrolyte. Lithium addition promotes the nanostructuration of the liquid as evidenced from the appearance of a scattering prepeak that becomes more pronounced. Microscopically, using the partial structure factors determined from molecular dynamics, this prepeak is shown to correspond to the formation of well-ordered positive/negative charge series and also large aggregates (Li_n(BF₄)_4-m)^(4-m+n)-, which develop upon lithium addition. Such nanoscale ordering entails a drastic decrease in both the molecular mobility and ionic conductivity. In particular, the marked association of Li⁺ cations with four BF₄^- anions and long ion pairing times, which are promoted upon lithium addition, are found to severely hinder the Li⁺ transport properties.