Characterizing the Hydration Properties of Proton Binding Sites in the ATP Synthase c-Rings of Bacillus Species

Variations of the Mycobacterium abscessus F-ATP synthase subunit a-c interface alter binding and potency of the anti-TB drug bedaquiline

The anti-tuberculosis therapeutic bedaquiline (BDQ) is used against Mycobacterium abscessus. In M. abscessus BDQ is only bacteriostatic and less potent compared to M. tuberculosis or M. smegmatis. Here we demonstrate its reduced ATP synthesis inhibition against M. abscessus inside-out vesicles, including the F1FO-ATP synthase. Molecular dynamics simulations and binding free energy calculations highlight the differences in drug-binding of the M. abscessus and M. smegmatis FO-domain at the lagging site, where the drug deploys its mechanistic action, inhibiting ATP synthesis. These data pave the way for improved anti-M. abscessus BDQ analogs.

Binding properties of the anti-TB drugs bedaquiline and TBAJ-876 to a mycobacterial F-ATP synthase

Tuberculosis (TB), the deadly disease caused by Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb), kills more people worldwide than any other bacterial infectious disease. There has been a recent resurgence of TB drug discovery activities, resulting in the identification of a number of novel enzyme inhibitors. Many of these inhibitors target the electron transport chain complexes and the F₁F_O-ATP synthase; these enzymes represent new target spaces for drug discovery, since the generation of ATP is essential for the bacterial pathogen's physiology, persistence, and pathogenicity. The anti-TB drug bedaquiline (BDQ) targets the Mtb F-ATP synthase and is used as salvage therapy against this disease. Medicinal chemistry efforts to improve the physio-chemical properties of BDQ resulted in the discovery of 3,5-dialkoxypyridine (DARQ) analogs to which TBAJ-876 belongs. TBAJ-876, a clinical development candidate, shows attractive in vitro and in vivo antitubercular activity. Both BDQ and TBAJ-876 inhibit the mycobacterial F₁F_O-ATP synthase by stopping rotation of the c-ring turbine within the F_O domain, thereby preventing proton translocation and ATP synthesis to occur. While structural data for the BDQ bound state are available, no structural information about TBAJ-876 binding have been described. In this study, we show how TBAJ-876 binds to the F_O domain of the M. smegmatis F₁F_O-ATP synthase. We further calculate the binding free energy of both drugs bound to their target and predict an increased affinity of TBAJ-876 for the F_O domain. This approach will be useful in future efforts to design new and highly potent DARQ analogs targeting F-ATP synthases of Mtb, nontuberculosis mycobacteria (NTM) as well as the M. leprosis complex.

•

BDQ inhibits mycobacterial F-ATP synthase.

•

TBAJ-876 is a BDQ analogue with improved affinity for the enzyme.

•

Simulations help to structurally clarify the F_O domain binding sites of TBAJ-876.

•

Insights will help guide development of multidrug-resistant tuberculosis drugs.

A second shell residue modulates a conserved ATP-binding site with radically different affinities for ATP

BACKGROUND

Prediction of ligand binding and design of new function in enzymes is a time-consuming and expensive process. Crystallography gives the impression that proteins adopt a fixed shape, yet enzymes are functionally dynamic. Molecular dynamics offers the possibility of probing protein movement while predicting ligand binding. Accordingly, we choose the bacterial F₁F_o ATP synthase ε subunit to unravel why ATP affinity by ε subunits from Bacillus subtilis and Bacillus PS3 differs ~500-fold, despite sharing identical sequences at the ATP-binding site.

METHODS

We first used the Bacillus PS3 ε subunit structure to model the B. subtilis ε subunit structure and used this to explore the utility of molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to predict the influence of residues outside the ATP binding site. To verify the MD predictions, point mutants were made and ATP binding studies were employed.

RESULTS

MD simulations predicted that E102 in the B. subtilis ε subunit, outside of the ATP binding site, influences ATP binding affinity. Engineering E102 to alanine or arginine revealed a ~10 or ~54 fold increase in ATP binding, respectively, confirming the MD prediction that E102 drastically influences ATP binding affinity.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings reveal how MD can predict how changes in the "second shell" residues around substrate binding sites influence affinity in simple protein structures. Our results reveal why seemingly identical ε subunits in different ATP synthases have radically different ATP binding affinities.

GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE

This study may lead to greater utility of molecular dynamics as a tool for protein design and exploration of protein design and function.