Contribution of Different Molecules and Moieties to the Surface Tension in Aqueous Surfactant Solutions. II: Role of the Size and Charge Sign of the Counterions

Does the Sign of Charge Affect the Surface Affinity of Simple Ions?

The role the charge sign of simple ions plays in determining their surface affinity in aqueous solutions is investigated by computer simulation methods. For this purpose, the free surface of aqueous solutions of fictitious salts is simulated at finite concentration both with nonpolarizable point-charge and polarizable Gaussian-charge potential models. The salts consist of monovalent cations and anions that are, apart from the sign of their charge, identical to each other. In particular, we consider the small Na⁺ and the large I^- ions together with their charge-inverted counterparts. In an attempt to avoid the interference even between the behavior of cations and anions, we also simulate systems containing only one of the above ions, and determine the free energy profile of these ions across the liquid-vapor interface of water at infinite dilution by potential of mean force (PMF) calculations. The obtained results reveal that, in the case of small ions, the anion is hydrated considerably stronger than the cation due to the close approach of water H atoms, bearing a positive fractional charge. As a consequence, the surface affinity of a small anion is even smaller than that of its cationic counterpart. However, considering that small ions are effectively repelled from the water surface, the importance of this difference is negligible. Further, a change in the hydration energy trends of the two oppositely charged ions is observed with their increasing size. This change is largely attributed to the fact that, with increasing ion size, the factor of 2 in the magnitude of the fractional charge of the closely approaching water atoms (i.e., O around cations and H around anions) outweighs the closer approach of the H than the O atom in the hydration energy. Thus, for large ions, being already surface active themselves, the surface affinity of the anion is larger than that of its positively charged counterpart. Further, such a difference is seen even in the case when the sign of the surface potential favors the adsorption of cations.

Surface Affinity of Tetramethylammonium Iodide in Aqueous Solutions: A Combined Experimental and Computer Simulation Study

The surface affinity of tetramethylammonium iodide (TMAI) in aqueous solutions is investigated by surface tension measurements and molecular dynamics computer simulations. Experiments, performed in the entire composition range of solubility using the pendant drop method with two different setups, clearly reveal that TMAI is a weakly capillary active salt. Computer simulations performed with the AMBER force field reproduce the experimental data very well, while two other major force fields (i.e., CHARMM and OPLS) can still reproduce the experimental trend qualitatively; however, even qualitative reproduction of the experimental trend requires scaling down the ion charges according to the Leontyev-Stuchebrukhov correction. On the other hand, the GROMOS force field fails in reproducing the experimentally confirmed capillary activity of TMAI. Molecular dynamics simulation results show that, among the two ions, iodide has a clearly larger surface affinity than tetramethylammonium (TMA⁺). Further, the adsorption of the I^- anions is strictly limited to the first molecular layer beneath the liquid-vapor interface, which is followed by several layers of their depletion. On the other hand, the net negative charge of the surface layer, caused by the excess amount of I^- with respect to TMA⁺, is compensated by a diffuse layer of adsorbed TMA⁺ cations, extending to or beyond the fourth molecular layer beneath the liquid surface.

Understanding specific ion effects and the Hofmeister series

Specific ion effects (SIE), encompassing the Hofmeister Series, have been known for more than 130 years since Hofmeister and Lewith's foundational work. SIEs are ubiquitous and are observed across the medical, biological, chemical and industrial sciences. Nevertheless, no general predictive theory has yet been able to explain ion specificity across these fields; it remains impossible to predict when, how, and to what magnitude, a SIE will be observed. In part, this is due to the complexity of real systems in which ions, counterions, solvents and cosolutes all play varying roles, which give rise to anomalies and reversals in anticipated SIEs. Herein we review the historical explanations for SIE in water and the key ion properties that have been attributed to them. Systems where the Hofmeister series is perturbed or reversed are explored, as is the behaviour of ions at the liquid-vapour interface. We discuss SIEs in mixed electrolytes, nonaqueous solvents, and in highly concentrated electrolyte solutions - exciting frontiers in this field with particular relevance to biological and electrochemical applications. We conclude the perspective by summarising the challenges and opportunities facing this SIE research that highlight potential pathways towards a general predictive theory of SIE.

Computer Simulation of the Surface of Aqueous Ionic and Surfactant Solutions

The surface of aqueous solutions of simple salts was not the main focus of scientific attention for a long while. Considerable interest in studying such systems has only emerged in the past two decades, following the pioneering finding that large halide ions, such as I^-, exhibit considerable surface affinity. Since then, a number of issues have been clarified; however, there are still several unresolved points (e.g., the effect of various salts on lateral water diffusion at the surface) in this respect. Computer simulation studies of the field have largely benefited from the appearance of intrinsic surface analysis methods, by which the particles staying right at the boundary of the two phases can be unambiguously identified. Considering complex ions instead of simple ones opens a number of interesting questions, both from the theoretical point of view and from that of the applications. Besides reviewing the state-of-the-art of intrinsic surface analysis methods as well as the most important advances and open questions concerning the surface of simple ionic solutions, we focus on two such systems in this Perspective, namely, the surface of aqueous mixtures of room temperature ionic liquids and that of ionic surfactants. In the case of the former systems, for which computer simulation studies have still scarcely been reported, we summarize the theoretical advances that could trigger such investigations, which might well be of importance also from the point of view of industrial applications. Computer simulation methods are, on the other hand, widely used in studies of the surface of surfactant solutions. Here we review the most important theoretical advances and issues to be addressed and discuss two areas of applications, namely, the inclusion of information gathered from such simulations in large scale atmospheric models and the better understanding of the airborne transmission of viruses, such as SARS-CoV-2.