How Different Molecular Architectures Influence the Dynamics of H-Bonded Structures in Glass-Forming Monohydroxy Alcohols

High-Pressure and Temperature Effects on the Clustering Ability of Monohydroxy Alcohols

This study examined the clustering behavior of monohydroxy alcohols, where hydrogen-bonded clusters of up to a hundred molecules on the nanoscale can form. By performing X-ray diffraction experiments at different temperatures and under high pressure, we investigated how these conditions affect the ability of alcohols to form clusters. The pioneering high-pressure experiment performed on liquid alcohols contributes to the emerging knowledge in this field. Implementation of molecular dynamics simulations yielded excellent agreement with the experimental results, enabling the analysis of theoretical models. Here we show that at the same global density achieved either by alteration of pressure or temperature, the local aggregation of molecules at the nanoscale may significantly differ. Surprisingly, high pressure not only promotes the formation of hydrogen-bonded clusters but also induces the serious reorganization of molecules. This research represents a milestone in understanding association under extreme thermodynamic conditions in other hydrogen bonding systems such as water.

Comment on "Universal features in the lifetime distribution of clusters in hydrogen-bonding liquids" by I. Jukić, M. Požar, B. Lovrinčević and A. Perera, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 2021, , 19537

In the article published by Jukić et al. [I. Jukić et al., Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 2021, 23, 19537], the authors discovered a specific lifetime distribution of hydrogen bonds in some pure hydrogen-bonding liquids. The distribution derived by computer simulations in the range of 0-0.15 ps consists of three characteristic peaks. They call the first maximum the 'dimer peak', the second the 'cluster peak', and the third the 'topology peak'. In the article in question, mostly linear- and circular-cluster-forming mono-ols were simulated to show that the third peak is universal in these H-bonding substances. Moreover, the topology of the clusters, which was wrongly assumed to be detected in the tertiary lifetime peak, is instead seen in the distribution of the first maximum.

Experimental and Computational Approach to Studying Supramolecular Structures in Propanol and Its Halogen Derivatives

A series of four alcohols, n-propanol and its halogen (Cl, Br, and I) derivatives, were selected to study the effects of variation in polarity and halogen-driven interactions on the hydrogen bonding pattern and supramolecular structure by means of experimental and theoretical methods. It was demonstrated on both grounds that the average strength of H-bonds remains the same but dissociation enthalpy, the size of molecular nanoassemblies, as well as long-range correlations between dipoles vary with the molecular weight of halogen atom. Further molecular dynamics simulations indicated that it is connected to the variation in the molecular order introduced by specific halogen-based hydrogen bonds and halogen-halogen interactions. Our results also provided important experimental evidence supporting the assumption of the transient chain model on the molecular origin of the structural process in self-assembling alcohols.

On the relationship between the Debye process in dielectric response and a dissociation-association phenomenon in phenyl alcohols

In this paper, we have examined a series of phenyl-substituted primary monohydroxy alcohols (phenyl alcohols, PhAs), from ethanol to hexanol by means of dielectric and Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopies supported by the mechanical investigations. The combination of both dielectric and mechanical data allows calculation of the energy barrier, E_a, for dissociation by the Rubinstein approach developed to describe the dynamical properties of self-assembling macromolecules. It was observed that the determined activation energy remains constant, |E_a,RM| ∼ 12.9-14.2 kJ mol^-1, regardless of the molecular weight of the examined material. Surprisingly, the obtained values agree very well with E_a of the dissociation process determined from the FTIR data analysed within the van't Hoff relationship, where E_a,vH ∼ 9.13-13.64 kJ mol^-1. Thus, the observed agreement between E_a determined by both applied approaches clearly implies that in the case of the examined series of PhAs, the dielectric Debye-like process is governed by the association-dissociation phenomenon as proposed by the transient chain model.

Aromaticity effect on supramolecular aggregation. Aromatic vs. cyclic monohydroxy alcohols

In this paper, the steric hindrance effect related to the presence of either a cyclic or aromatic ring on the self-association process in the series of monohydroxy alcohols (MAs), from cyclohexanemethanol to 4-cyclohexyl-1-butanol and from benzyl alcohol to 4-phenyl-1-butanol, was studied using X-Ray Diffraction (XRD), Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC), Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy, Broadband Dielectric Spectroscopy (BDS) and the Pendant Drop (PD) methods. Based on FTIR results, it was shown that phenyl alcohol (PhA) and cyclohexyl alcohol (CA) derivatives reveal substantial differences in the association degree, the activation energy of dissociation, and the homogeneity of supramolecular nanoassociates suggesting that the phenyl ring exerts a stronger steric impact on the self-assembling of molecules than cyclohexyl one. Additionally, XRD data revealed that phenyl moiety introduces more heterogeneity in the organization of molecules compared to the cyclic one. The changes in the self-association process of alcohols were also reflected in differences in the molecular dynamics of the H-bonded aggregates, as well as in the Kirkwood factor, defining the long-range correlation between dipoles, which were slightly higher for CAs with respect to those determined for PhAs. Unexpectedly it was also found that the surface layers of PhAs were more organized than those formed by CAs. Thus, these findings provided insight into the impact of aromaticity on the self-assembly process, H-bonding pattern, supramolecular structure, and intermolecular dynamics of the studied alcohols.

Effect of confinement on the dynamics of 1-propanol and other monohydroxy alcohols

We report the effect of confinement on the dynamics of three monohydroxy alcohols (1-propanol, 2-ethyl-1-hexanol, and 4-methyl-3-heptanol) differing in their chemical structure and, consequently, in the dielectric strength of the "Debye" process. Density functional theory calculations in bulk 1-propanol identified both linear and ring-like associations composed of up to five repeat units. The simulation results revealed that the ring structures, with a low dipole moment (∼2 D), are energetically preferred over the linear assemblies with a dipole moment of 2.18 D per repeat unit. Under confinement in nanoporous alumina (in templates with pore diameters ranging from 400 to 20 nm), all dynamic processes were found to speed up irrespective of the molecular architecture. The characteristic freezing temperatures of the α and the Debye-like processes followed the pore size dependence: T_a,D=T_a,D ^bulk-A/d^1/2, where d is the pore diameter. The characteristic "freezing" temperatures for the Debye-like (the slow process for confined 1-propanol is non-Debye) and the α-processes decrease, respectively, by 6.5 and 13 K in confined 1-propanol, by 9.5 and 19 K in confined 2-ethyl-1-hexanol, and by 9 and 23 K in confined 4-methyl-3-heptanol within the same 25 nm pores. In 2-ethyl-1-hexanol, confinement reduced the number of linearly associated repeats from approximately heptamers in the bulk to dimers within 25 pores. In addition, the slower process in bulk 2-ethyl-1-hexanol and 4-methyl-3-heptanol, where the signal is dominated by ring-like supramolecular assemblies, is clearly non-Debye. The results suggest that the effect of confinement is dominant in the latter assemblies.

Isomeric effects in structure formation and dielectric dynamics of different octanols

The understanding of the microstructure of associated liquids promoted by hydrogen-bonding and constrained by steric hindrance is highly relevant in chemistry, physics, biology and for many aspects of daily life. In this study we use a combination of X-ray diffraction, dielectric spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations to reveal temperature induced changes in the microstructure of different octanol isomers, i.e., linear 1-octanol and branched 2-, 3- and 4-octanol. In all octanols, the hydroxyl groups form the basis of chain-, cyclic- or loop-like bonded structures that are separated by outwardly directed alkyl chains. This clustering is analyzed through the scattering pre-peaks observed from X-ray scattering and simulations. The charge ordering which pilots OH aggregation can be linked to the strength of the Debye process observed in dielectric spectroscopy. Interestingly, all methods used here converge to the same interpretation: as one moves from 1-octanol to the branched octanols, the cluster structure evolves from loose large aggregates to a larger number of smaller, tighter aggregates. All alcohols exhibit a peculiar temperature dependence of both the pre-peak and Debye process, which can be understood as a change in microstructure promoted by chain association with increased chain length possibly assisted by ring-opening effects. All these results tend to support the intuitive picture of the entropic constraint provided by branching through the alkyl tails and highlight its capital entropic role in supramolecular assembly.

Is a Dissociation Process Underlying the Molecular Origin of the Debye Process in Monohydroxy Alcohols?

Herein, we investigated the molecular dynamics as well as intramolecular interactions in two primary monohydroxy alcohols (MA), 2-ethyl-1-hexanol (2EHOH) and n-butanol (nBOH), by means of broad-band dielectric (BDS) and Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy. The modeling data obtained from dielectric studies within the Rubinstein approach [ Macromolecules 2013, 46, 7525-7541] originally developed to describe the dynamical properties of self-assembling macromolecules allowed us to calculate the energy barrier (Ea) of dissociation from the temperature dependences of relaxation times of Debye and structural processes. We found Ea ∼ 19.4 ± 0.8 and 5.3 ± 0.4 kJ/mol for the former and latter systems, respectively. On the other hand, FTIR data analyzed within the van't Hoff relationship yielded the energy barriers for dissociation Ea ∼ 20.3 ± 2.1 and 12.4 ± 1.6 kJ/mol for 2EHOH and nBOH, respectively. Hence, there was almost a perfect agreement between the values of Ea estimated from dielectric and FTIR studies for the 2EHOH, while some notable discrepancy was noted for the second alcohol. A quite significant difference in the activation barrier of dissociation indicates that there are probably supramolecular clusters of varying geometry or a ring-chain-like equilibrium is strongly affected in both alcohols. Nevertheless, our analysis showed that the association/dissociation processes undergoing within nanoassociates are one of the main factors underlying the molecular origin of the Debye process, supporting the transient chain model.

Phenyl Ring: A Steric Hindrance or a Source of Different Hydrogen Bonding Patterns in Self-Organizing Systems?

A series of five alcohols (3-methyl-2-butanol, 1-cyclopropylethanol, 1-cyclopentylethanol, 1-cyclohexylethanol, and 1-phenylethanol) was used to study the impact of the size of steric hindrance and its aromaticity on self-assembling phenomena in the liquid phase. In this Letter, we have explicitly shown that the phenyl ring exerts a much stronger effect on the self-organization of molecules via the O-H···O scheme than any other type of steric hindrance, leading to a significant decline in the size and concentration of the H-bonded clusters. Given the combination of calorimetric, dielectric, infrared, and diffraction studies, this phenomenon was ascribed to its additional proton-acceptor function for the competitive intermolecular O-H···π interactions. The consequence of this is a different packing of molecules on the short- and medium-range scale.

Unusual Debye relaxation in 4-methyl-2-pentanol evidenced by high-pressure dielectric studies

The Debye relaxation is the main signal in the dielectric measurements of monoalcohols arising from the hydrogen-bonded superstructures, but its physics remains to be cleared. In this work, a monoalcohol of 4-methyl-2-pentanol is studied using dielectric spectroscopies recorded at high pressures. The dynamic parameters of the Debye and structural relaxations are extracted. The calculation of the Kirkwood factor of the Debye relaxation indicates chain-like H-bond molecular configurations. Remarkably, we found that both ratios of the relaxation strength and relaxation time between the Debye and structural dynamics, Δε _D/Δε _α and τ _D/τ _α , decreases upon compression, indicating a positive correlation. This is different from the results reported in primary 2-ethyl-1-hexanol and secondary 4-methyl-3-heptanol, where the two ratios are inversely correlated. The discussion and interpretation of these different results are provided.

Density Scaling Based Detection of Thermodynamic Regions of Complex Intermolecular Interactions Characterizing Supramolecular Structures

In this paper, applying the density scaling idea to an associated liquid 4-methyl-2-pentanol used as an example, we identify different pressure-volume-temperature ranges within which molecular dynamics is dominated by either complex H-bonded networks most probably leading to supramolecular structures or non-specific intermolecular interactions like van der Waals forces. In this way, we show that the density scaling law for molecular dynamics near the glass transition provides a sensitive tool to detect thermodynamic regions characterized by intermolecular interactions of different type and complexity for a given material in the wide pressure-volume-temperature domain even if its typical form with constant scaling exponent is not obeyed. Moreover, we quantify the observed decoupling between dielectric and mechanical relaxations of the material in the density scaling regime. The suggested methods of analyses and their interpretations open new prospects for formulating models based on proper effective intermolecular potentials describing physicochemical phenomena near the glass transition.

Studies on the internal medium-range ordering and high pressure dynamics in modified ibuprofens

Broadband dielectric spectroscopy (BDS), combined with the X-ray diffraction (XRD) and Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) techniques, was used to study the dynamics of the primary (α) relaxation process and slow mode (SM), as well as structural properties and intermolecular interactions, in the methyl-, isopropyl-, hexyl-, and benzyl derivative of a well-known pharmaceutical, ibuprofen (IBU). Unexpectedly, the XRD and FTIR methods revealed the formation of medium-range ordering together with some molecular organization, which probably leads to the creation of small aggregates at the scale of several microns at lower temperatures. Moreover, high pressure dielectric experiments revealed that the SM (observed in the ambient pressure data) is not detected in the loss spectra of compressed IBU esters, which is consistent with the results reported previously for propylene carbonate and dioxolane derivatives. This finding can be interpreted as connected to either the comparable time scale of the structural dynamics and slow mode or suppression of the motions responsible for the latter process at elevated pressure. Additionally, it was found that the pressure coefficient of the glass transition temperature (dTg/dp) and activation volume (ΔV) change with molecular weight (Mw) in a non-monotonic way. It might be related to various chemical structures, conformations, and intermolecular interactions, as well as different architecture of supramolecular aggregates in the investigated compounds.

Nonlinear electrical and rheological spectroscopies identify structural and supramolecular relaxations in a model peptide

Supercooled liquid secondary amides display an electrical absorption peak characterized by an almost Debye-like shape, indicative of a close-to-exponential polarization response. This response, believed to be supramolecular in nature, is so enormously intense that the amide's structural process, contributing only a few percent to the total relaxation strength, is hard to resolve reliably using standard dielectric spectroscopy. To overcome this issue, nonlinear dielectric spectroscopy involving field-induced structural recovery and temperature-induced physical aging, was applied near the calorimetric glass transition of a mixture of N-methylformamide and N-ethylacetamide. Without the need to rely on cumbersome deconvolution procedures, it is thus demonstrated that the supramolecular response is by a factor of 6 slower than the structural relaxation. Conversely, in linear rheological experiments only the structural relaxation could be resolved, but not the supramolecular one. However, medium-amplitude oscillatory shear experiments carried out at 160 K do reveal the supramolecular process. Hence, the combination of linear and nonlinear mechanical measurements corroborates the dielectrically uncovered spectral separation of the two processes.

Local dielectric response in 1-propanol: α-relaxation versus relaxation of mesoscale structures

Understanding how the local dielectric response is affected by the supramolecular Debye process in 1-propanol.

Inflection point in the Debye relaxation time of 2-butyl-1-octanol

We report a striking anomaly in the pressure dependent Debye-relaxation time of the branched monohydroxy alcohol 2-butyl-1-octanol. Evidence of a crossover from slower to faster than exponential pressure dependency was obtained at different temperatures via high pressure broadband dielectric spectroscopy. At the same time, viscosity measurements reveal similar behavior in the viscosity, respectively, the structural relaxation time, indicating a similar origin of the phenomena.

Studying molecular dynamics of the slow, structural, and secondary relaxation processes in series of substituted ibuprofens

In this paper, the molecular dynamics of a series of ester derivatives of ibuprofen (IBU), in which the hydrogen atom from the hydroxyl group was substituted by the methyl, isopropyl, hexyl, and benzyl moieties, has been investigated using Broadband dielectric (BD), Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), and Raman spectroscopies. We found that except for benzyl IBU (Ben-IBU), an additional process (slow mode, SM) appears in dielectric spectra in all examined compounds. It is worth noting that this relaxation process was observed for the first time in non-modified IBU (a Debye relaxation). According to suggestions by Affouard and Correia [J. Phys. Chem. B. 114, 11397 (2010)] as well as further studies by Adrjanowicz et al. [J. Chem. Phys. 139, 111103 (2013)] on Met-IBU, it was attributed to synperiplanar-antiperiplanar conformational changes within the molecule. Herein, we have shown that with an increasing molecular weight of the substituent, the relaxation times of the SM become longer and its activation energy significantly increases. Moreover, this new relaxation mode was found to be broader than a simple Debye relaxation in Iso-IBU and Hex-IBU. Additional complementary NMR studies indicated that either there is a significant slowdown of the rotation around the O=C-O-R moiety or this kind of movement is completely suppressed in the case of Ben-IBU. Therefore, the SM is not observed in the dielectric loss spectra of this compound. Finally, we carried out isothermal experiments on the samples which have a different thermal history. Interestingly, it turned out that the relaxation times of the structural processes are slightly shorter with respect to those obtained from temperature dependent measurements. This effect was the most prominent in the case of Hex-IBU, while for Ben-IBU, it was not observed at all. Additional time-dependent measurements revealed the ongoing equilibration manifested by the continuous shift of the structural process, until it finally reached its equilibrium position. Further Raman investigations showed that this effect may be related to the rotational/conformational equilibration of the long hexyl chains. Our results are the first ones demonstrating that the structural process is sensitive to the conformational equilibration occurring in the specific highly viscous systems.

Describing Temperature-Dependent Self-Diffusion Coefficients and Fluidity of 1- and 3-Alcohols with the Compensated Arrhenius Formalism

The location of the hydroxyl group in monohydroxy alcohols greatly affects the temperature dependence of the liquid structure due to hydrogen bonding. Temperature-dependent self-diffusion coefficients, fluidity (the inverse of viscosity), dielectric constant, and density have been measured for several 1-alcohols and 3-alcohols with varying alkyl chain lengths. The data are modeled using the compensated Arrhenius formalism (CAF). The CAF follows a modified transition state theory using an Arrhenius-like expression to describe the transport property, which consists of a Boltzmann factor containing an energy of activation, Ea, and an exponential prefactor containing the temperature-dependent solution dielectric constant, εs(T). Both 1- and 3-alcohols show the Ea of diffusion coefficients (approximately 43 kJ mol(-1)) is higher than the Ea of fluidity (approximately 35 kJ mol(-1)). The temperature dependence of the exponential prefactor in these associated liquids is explained using the dielectric constant and the Kirkwood-Frölich correlation factor, gk. It is argued that the dielectric constant must be used to account for the additional temperature dependence due to variations in the liquid structure (e.g., hydrogen bonding) for the CAF to accurately model the transport property.