The Q-Cycle Mechanism of the bc1 Complex: A Biologist’s Perspective on Atomistic Studies

The cytochrome b6f complex: plastoquinol oxidation and regulation of electron transport in chloroplasts

In oxygenic photosynthetic systems, the cytochrome b6f (Cytb6f) complex (plastoquinol:plastocyanin oxidoreductase) is a heart of the hub that provides connectivity between photosystems (PS) II and I. In this review, the structure and function of the Cytb6f complex are briefly outlined, being focused on the mechanisms of a bifurcated (two-electron) oxidation of plastoquinol (PQH2). In plant chloroplasts, under a wide range of experimental conditions (pH and temperature), a diffusion of PQH2 from PSII to the Cytb6f does not limit the intersystem electron transport. The overall rate of PQH2 turnover is determined mainly by the first step of the bifurcated oxidation of PQH2 at the catalytic site Qo, i.e., the reaction of electron transfer from PQH2 to the Fe2S2 cluster of the high-potential Rieske iron-sulfur protein (ISP). This point has been supported by the quantum chemical analysis of PQH2 oxidation within the framework of a model system including the Fe2S2 cluster of the ISP and surrounding amino acids, the low-potential heme b6L, Glu78 and 2,3,5-trimethylbenzoquinol (the tail-less analog of PQH2). Other structure-function relationships and mechanisms of electron transport regulation of oxygenic photosynthesis associated with the Cytb6f complex are briefly outlined: pH-dependent control of the intersystem electron transport and the regulatory balance between the operation of linear and cyclic electron transfer chains.

Charge Regulation in a Rieske Proton Pump Pinpoints Zero, One, and Two Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer

The degree to which redox-driven proton pumps regulate net charge during electron transfer (ΔZ_ET) remains undetermined due to difficulties in measuring the net charge of solvated proteins. Values of ΔZ_ET can reflect reorganization energies or redox potentials associated with ET and can be used to distinguish ET from proton(s)-coupled electron transfer (PCET). Here, we synthesized protein "charge ladders" of a Rieske [2Fe-2S] subunit from Thermus thermophilus (truncTtRp) and made 120 electrostatic measurements of ΔZ_ET across pH. Across pH 5-10, truncTtRp is suspected of transitioning from ET to PCET, and then to two proton-coupled ET (2PCET). Upon reduction, we found that truncTtRp became more negative at pH 6.0 by one unit (ΔZ_ET = -1.01 ± 0.14), consistent with single ET; was isoelectric at pH 8.8 (ΔZ_ET = -0.01 ± 0.45), consistent with PCET; and became more positive at pH 10.6 (ΔZ_ET = +1.37 ± 0.60), consistent with 2PCET. These ΔZ_ET values are attributed to protonation of H154 and H134. Across pH, redox potentials of TtRp (measured previously) correlated with protonation energies of H154 and H134 and ΔZ_ET for truncTtRp, supporting a discrete proton pumping mechanism for Rieske proteins at the Fe-coordinating histidines.

Analysis of the conformational heterogeneity of the Rieske iron-sulfur protein in complex III2 by cryo-EM

Movement of the Rieske domain of the iron-sulfur protein is essential for intramolecular electron transfer within complex III₂ (CIII₂) of the respiratory chain as it bridges a gap in the cofactor chain towards the electron acceptor cytochrome c. We present cryo-EM structures of CIII₂ from Yarrowia lipolytica at resolutions up to 2.0 Å under different conditions, with different redox states of the cofactors of the high-potential chain. All possible permutations of three primary positions were observed, indicating that the two halves of the dimeric complex act independently. Addition of the substrate analogue decylubiquinone to CIII₂ with a reduced high-potential chain increased the occupancy of the Q_o site. The extent of Rieske domain interactions through hydrogen bonds to the cytochrome b and cytochrome c₁ subunits varied depending on the redox state and substrate. In the absence of quinols, the reduced Rieske domain interacted more closely with cytochrome b and cytochrome c₁ than in the oxidized state. Upon addition of the inhibitor antimycin A, the heterogeneity of the cd₁-helix and ef-loop increased, which may be indicative of a long-range effect on the Rieske domain.

Evolution of quinol oxidation within the heme‑copper oxidoreductase superfamily

The heme‑copper oxidoreductase (HCO) superfamily is a large superfamily of terminal respiratory enzymes that are widely distributed across the three domains of life. The superfamily includes biochemically diverse oxygen reductases and nitric oxide reductases that are pivotal in the pathways of aerobic respiration and denitrification. The adaptation of HCOs to use quinol as the electron donor instead of cytochrome c has significant implication for the respiratory flexibility and energetic efficiency of the respiratory chains that include them. In this work, we explore the adaptation of this scaffold to two different electron donors, cytochromes c and quinols, with extensive sequence analysis of these enzymes from publicly available datasets. Our work shows that quinol oxidation evolved independently within the HCO superfamily at least seven times. Enzymes from only two of these independently evolved clades have been biochemically well-characterized. Combining structural modeling with sequence analysis, we identify putative quinol binding sites in each of the novel quinol oxidases. Our analysis of experimental and modeling data suggests that the quinol binding site appears to have evolved at the same structural position within the scaffold more than once.

An uncharacteristically low-potential flavin governs the energy landscape of electron bifurcation

Nature has long been an inspiration for materials design, as it exemplifies exquisite control of both matter and energy. Electron bifurcation, a mechanism employed in biological systems to drive thermodynamically unfavorable and energetically challenging chemical reactions, is one such example. A key feature of bifurcating enzymes is the ability of a single redox cofactor to distribute a pair of electrons across two spatially separated electron transfer pathways. Here, we report on the empirical determination of both the one-electron potential and two-electron potential of the bifurcating flavin cofactor in the NADH-dependent ferredoxin-NADP⁺ oxidoreductase I (NfnSL) enzyme. Insights arising from the defined energy landscape of this bifurcation site may underlie the design of synthetic catalysts capable of generating high-energy intermediates.

Electron bifurcation, an energy-conserving process utilized extensively throughout all domains of life, represents an elegant means of generating high-energy products from substrates with less reducing potential. The coordinated coupling of exergonic and endergonic reactions has been shown to operate over an electrochemical potential of ∼1.3 V through the activity of a unique flavin cofactor in the enzyme NADH-dependent ferredoxin-NADP⁺ oxidoreductase I. The inferred energy landscape has features unprecedented in biochemistry and presents novel energetic challenges, the most intriguing being a large thermodynamically uphill step for the first electron transfer of the bifurcation reaction. However, ambiguities in the energy landscape at the bifurcating site deriving from overlapping flavin spectral signatures have impeded a comprehensive understanding of the specific mechanistic contributions afforded by thermodynamic and kinetic factors. Here, we elucidate an uncharacteristically low two-electron potential of the bifurcating flavin, resolving the energetic challenge of the first bifurcation event.

The allosteric protein interactions in the proton-motive function of mammalian redox enzymes of the respiratory chain

Insight into mammalian respiratory complexes defines the role of allosteric protein interactions in their proton-motive activity. In cytochrome c oxidase (CxIV) conformational change of subunit I, caused by O₂ binding to heme a₃²⁺-Cu_B⁺ and reduction, and stereochemical transitions coupled to oxidation/reduction of heme a and Cu_A, combined with electrostatic effects, determine the proton pumping activity. In ubiquinone-cytochrome c oxidoreductase (CxIII) conformational movement of Fe-S protein between cytochromes b and c₁ is the key element of the proton-motive activity. In NADH-ubiquinone oxidoreductase (CxI) ubiquinone binding and reduction result in conformational changes of subunits in the quinone reaction structure which initiate proton pumping.

Modeling the Energy Landscape of Side Reactions in the Cytochrome bc1 Complex

Much of the metabolic molecular machinery responsible for energy transduction processes in living organisms revolves around a series of electron and proton transfer processes. The highly redox active enzymes can, however, also pose a risk of unwanted side reactions leading to reactive oxygen species, which are harmful to cells and are a factor in aging and age-related diseases. Using extensive quantum and classical computational modeling, we here show evidence of a particular superoxide production mechanism through stray reactions between molecular oxygen and a semiquinone reaction intermediate bound in the mitochondrial complex III of the electron transport chain, also known as the cytochrome b c 1 complex. Free energy calculations indicate a favorable electron transfer from semiquinone occurring at low rates under normal circumstances. Furthermore, simulations of the product state reveal that superoxide formed at the Q _o -site exclusively leaves the b c 1 complex at the positive side of the membrane and escapes into the intermembrane space of mitochondria, providing a critical clue in further studies of the harmful effects of mitochondrial superoxide production.

The High-Spin Heme b L Mutant Exposes Dominant Reaction Leading to the Formation of the Semiquinone Spin-Coupled to the [2Fe-2S]+ Cluster at the Qo Site of Rhodobacter capsulatus Cytochrome bc 1

Cytochrome bc ₁ (mitochondrial complex III) catalyzes electron transfer from quinols to cytochrome c and couples this reaction with proton translocation across lipid membrane; thus, it contributes to the generation of protonmotive force used for the synthesis of ATP. The energetic efficiency of the enzyme relies on a bifurcation reaction taking place at the Q_o site which upon oxidation of ubiquinol directs one electron to the Rieske 2Fe2S cluster and the other to heme b _L. The molecular mechanism of this reaction remains unclear. A semiquinone spin-coupled to the reduced 2Fe2S cluster (SQ_o-2Fe2S) was identified as a state associated with the operation of the Q_o site. To get insights into the mechanism of the formation of this state, we first constructed a mutant in which one of the histidine ligands of the iron ion of heme b _L Rhodobacter capsulatus cytochrome bc ₁ was replaced by asparagine (H198N). This converted the low-spin, low-potential heme into the high-spin, high-potential species which is unable to support enzymatic turnover. We performed a comparative analysis of redox titrations of antimycin-supplemented bacterial photosynthetic membranes containing native enzyme and the mutant. The titrations revealed that H198N failed to generate detectable amounts of SQ_o-2Fe2S under neither equilibrium (in dark) nor nonequilibrium (in light), whereas the native enzyme generated clearly detectable SQ_o-2Fe2S in light. This provided further support for the mechanism in which the back electron transfer from heme b _L to a ubiquinone bound at the Q_o site is mainly responsible for the formation of semiquinone trapped in the SQ_o-2Fe2S state in R. capusulatus cytochrome bc ₁.

The modified Q-cycle: A look back at its development and forward to a functional model

On looking back at a lifetime of research, it is interesting to see, in the light of current progress, how things came to be, and to speculate on how things might be. I am delighted in the context of the Mitchell prize to have that excuse to present this necessarily personal view of developments in areas of my interests. I have focused on the Q-cycle and a few examples showing wider ramifications, since that had been the main interest of the lab in the 20 years since structures became available, - a watershed event in determining our molecular perspective. I have reviewed the evidence for our model for the mechanism of the first electron transfer of the bifurcated reaction at the Q_o-site, which I think is compelling. In reviewing progress in understanding the second electron transfer, I have revisited some controversies to justify important conclusions which appear, from the literature, not to have been taken seriously. I hope this does not come over as nitpicking. The conclusions are important to the final section in which I develop an internally consistent mechanism for turnovers of the complex leading to a state similar to that observed in recent rapid-mix/freeze-quench experiments, reported three years ago. The final model is necessarily speculative but is open to test.

The role of thermodynamic features on the functional activity of electron bifurcating enzymes

Electron bifurcation is a biological mechanism to drive a thermodynamically unfavorable redox reaction through direct coupling with an exergonic reaction. This process allows microorganisms to generate high energy reducing equivalents in order to sustain life and is often found in anaerobic metabolism, where the energy economy of the cell is poor. Recent work has revealed details of the redox energy landscapes for a variety of electron bifurcating enzymes, greatly expanding the understanding of how energy is transformed by this unique mechanism. Here we highlight the plasticity of these emerging landscapes, what is known regarding their mechanistic underpinnings, and provide a context for interpreting their biochemical activity within the physiological framework. We conclude with an outlook for propelling the field toward an integrative understanding of the impact of electron bifurcation.

Cadmium-Induced Cytotoxicity: Effects on Mitochondrial Electron Transport Chain

Cadmium (Cd) is a well-known heavy metal and environmental toxicant and pollutant worldwide, being largely present in every kind of item such as plastic (toys), battery, paints, ceramics, contaminated water, air, soil, food, fertilizers, and cigarette smoke. Nowadays, it represents an important research area for the scientific community mainly for its effects on public health. Due to a half-life ranging between 15 and 30 years, Cd owns the ability to accumulate in organs and tissues, exerting deleterious effects. Thus, even at low doses, a Cd prolonged exposure may cause a multiorgan toxicity. Mitochondria are key intracellular targets for Cd-induced cytotoxicity, but the underlying mechanisms are not fully elucidated. The present review is aimed to clarify the effects of Cd on mitochondria and, particularly, on the mitochondrial electron transport chain.

Universal free-energy landscape produces efficient and reversible electron bifurcation

For decades, it was unknown how electron-bifurcating systems in nature prevented energy-wasting short-circuiting reactions that have large driving forces, so synthetic electron-bifurcating molecular machines could not be designed and built. The underpinning free-energy landscapes for electron bifurcation were also enigmatic. We predict that a simple and universal free-energy landscape enables electron bifurcation, and we show that it enables high-efficiency bifurcation with limited short-circuiting (the EB scheme). The landscape relies on steep free-energy slopes in the two redox branches to insulate against short-circuiting using an electron occupancy blockade effect, without relying on nuanced changes in the microscopic rate constants for the short-circuiting reactions. The EB scheme thus unifies a body of observations on biological catalysis and energy conversion, and the scheme provides a blueprint to guide future campaigns to establish synthetic electron bifurcation machines.

On the beneficent thickness of water

In the 1930s, Lars Onsager published his famous 'reciprocal relations' describing free energy conversion processes. Importantly, these relations were derived on the assumption that the fluxes of the processes involved in the conversion were proportional to the forces (free energy gradients) driving them. For chemical reactions, however, this condition holds only for systems operating close to equilibrium-indeed very close; nominally requiring driving forces to be smaller than k B T. Fairly soon thereafter, however, it was quite inexplicably observed that in at least some biological conversions both the reciprocal relations and linear flux-force dependency appeared to be obeyed no matter how far from equilibrium the system was being driven. No successful explanation of how this 'paradoxical' behaviour could occur has emerged and it has remained a mystery. We here argue, however, that this anomalous behaviour is simply a gift of water, of its viscosity in particular; a gift, moreover, without which life almost certainly could not have emerged. And a gift whose appreciation we primarily owe to recent work by Prof. R. Dean Astumian who, as providence has kindly seen to it, was led to the relevant insights by the later work of Onsager himself.

Electron bifurcation: progress and grand challenges

Electron bifurcation moves electrons from a two-electron donor to reduce two spatially separated one-electron acceptors.

A new era for electron bifurcation

Electron bifurcation, or the coupling of exergonic and endergonic oxidation-reduction reactions, was discovered by Peter Mitchell and provides an elegant mechanism to rationalize and understand the logic that underpins the Q cycle of the respiratory chain. Thought to be a unique reaction of respiratory complex III for nearly 40 years, about a decade ago Wolfgang Buckel and Rudolf Thauer discovered that flavin-based electron bifurcation is also an important component of anaerobic microbial metabolism. Their discovery spawned a surge of research activity, providing a basis to understand flavin-based bifurcation, forging fundamental parallels with Mitchell's Q cycle and leading to the proposal of metal-based bifurcating enzymes. New insights into the mechanism of electron bifurcation provide a foundation to establish the unifying principles and essential elements of this fascinating biochemical phenomenon.

Dissecting the pattern of proton release from partial process involved in ubihydroquinone oxidation in the Q-cycle

A key feature of the modified Q-cycle of the cytochrome bc₁ and related complexes is a bifurcation of QH₂ oxidation involving electron transfer to two different acceptor chains, each coupled to proton release. We have studied the kinetics of proton release in chromatophore vesicles from Rhodobacter sphaeroides, using the pH-sensitive dye neutral red to follow pH changes inside on activation of the photosynthetic chain, focusing on the bifurcated reaction, in which 4H⁺are released on complete turnover of the Q-cycle (2H⁺/ubiquinol (QH₂) oxidized). We identified different partial processes of the Q_o-site reaction, isolated through use of specific inhibitors, and correlated proton release with electron transfer processes by spectrophotometric measurement of cytochromes or electrochromic response. In the presence of myxothiazol or azoxystrobin, the proton release observed reflected oxidation of the Rieske iron‑sulfur protein. In the absence of Q_o-site inhibitors, the pH change measured represented the convolution of this proton release with release of protons on turnover of the Q_o-site, involving formation of the ES-complex and oxidation of the semiquinone intermediate. Turnover also regenerated the reduced iron-sulfur protein, available for further oxidation on a second turnover. Proton release was well-matched with the rate limiting step on oxidation of QH₂ on both turnovers. However, a minor lag in proton release found at pH 7 but not at pH 8 might suggest that a process linked to rapid proton release on oxidation of the intermediate semiquinone involves a group with a pK in that range.

On the nature of organic and inorganic centers that bifurcate electrons, coupling exergonic and endergonic oxidation–reduction reactions

Bifurcating electrons to couple endergonic and exergonic electron-transfer reactions has been shown to have a key role in energy conserving redox enzymes.

Analysis of a Functional Dimer Model of Ubiquinol Cytochrome c Oxidoreductase

Ubiquinol cytochrome c oxidoreductase (bc₁ complex) serves as an important electron junction in many respiratory systems. It funnels electrons coming from NADH and ubiquinol to cytochrome c, but it is also capable of producing significant amounts of the free radical superoxide. In situ and in other experimental systems, the enzyme exists as a dimer. But until recently, it was believed to operate as a functional monomer. Here we show that a functional dimer model is capable of explaining both kinetic and superoxide production rate data. The model consists of six electronic states characterized by the number of electrons deposited on the complex. It is fully reversible and strictly adheres to the thermodynamics governing the reactions. A total of nine independent data sets were used to parameterize the model. To explain the data with a consistent set of parameters, it was necessary to incorporate intramonomer Coulombic effects between hemes b_L and b_H and intermonomer Coulombic effects between b_L hemes. The fitted repulsion energies fall within the theoretical range of electrostatic calculations. In addition, model analysis demonstrates that the Q pool is mostly oxidized under normal physiological operation but can switch to a more reduced state when reverse electron transport conditions are in place.

Mild phenotypes and proper supercomplex assembly in human cells carrying the homoplasmic m.15557G > A mutation in cytochrome b gene

Respiratory complex III (CIII) is the first enzymatic bottleneck of the mitochondrial respiratory chain both in its native dimeric form and in supercomplexes. The mammalian CIII comprises 11 subunits among which cytochrome b is central in the catalytic core, where oxidation of ubiquinol occurs at the Qo site. The Qo- or PEWY-motif of cytochrome b is the most conserved through species. Importantly, the highly conserved glutamate at position 271 (Glu271) has never been studied in higher eukaryotes so far and its role in the Q-cycle remains debated. Here, we showed that the homoplasmic m.15557G > A/MT-CYB, which causes the p.Glu271Lys amino acid substitution predicted to dramatically affect CIII, induces a mild mitochondrial dysfunction in human transmitochondrial cybrids. Indeed, we found that the severity of such mutation is mitigated by the proper assembly of CIII into supercomplexes, which may favor an optimal substrate channeling and buffer superoxide production in vitro.