Nucleotide Selectivity at a Preinsertion Checkpoint of T7 RNA Polymerase Transcription Elongation

Dissecting nucleotide selectivity in viral RNA polymerases

Designing antiviral therapeutics is of great concern per current pandemics caused by novel coronavirus or SARS-CoV-2. The core polymerase enzyme in the viral replication/transcription machinery is generally conserved and serves well for drug target. In this work we briefly review structural biology and computational clues on representative single-subunit viral polymerases that are more or less connected with SARS-CoV-2 RNA dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp), in particular, to elucidate how nucleotide substrates and potential drug analogs are selected in the viral genome synthesis. To do that, we first survey two well studied RdRps from Polio virus and hepatitis C virus in regard to structural motifs and key residues that have been identified for the nucleotide selectivity. Then we focus on related structural and biochemical characteristics discovered for the SARS-CoV-2 RdRp. To further compare, we summarize what we have learned computationally from phage T7 RNA polymerase (RNAP) on its stepwise nucleotide selectivity, and extend discussion to a structurally similar human mitochondria RNAP, which deserves special attention as it cannot be adversely affected by antiviral treatments. We also include viral phi29 DNA polymerase for comparison, which has both helicase and proofreading activities on top of nucleotide selectivity for replication fidelity control. The helicase and proofreading functions are achieved by protein components in addition to RdRp in the coronavirus replication-transcription machine, with the proofreading strategy important for the fidelity control in synthesizing a comparatively large viral genome.

Compatibility and Fidelity of Mirror-Image Thymidine in Transcription Events by T7 RNA Polymerase

Due to highly enzymatic d-stereoselectivity, l-nucleotides (l-2'-deoxynucleoside 5'-triphosphates [l-dNTPs]) are not natural targets of polymerases. In this study, we synthesized series of l-thymidine (l-T)-modified DNA strands and evaluated the processivity of nucleotide incorporation for transcription by T7 RNA polymerase (RNAP) with an l-T-containing template. When single l-T was introduced into the transcribed region, transcription proceeded to afford the full-length transcript with different efficiencies. However, introduction of l-T into the non-transcribed region did not exhibit a noticeable change in the transcription efficiency. Surprisingly, when two consecutive or internal l-Ts were introduced into the transcribed region, no transcripts were detected. Compared to natural template, significant lags in NTP incorporation into the template T+4/N and T+7/N (where the number corresponds to the site of l-T position, and + means downstream of the transcribed region) were detected by kinetic analysis. Furthermore, affinity of template T+4/N was almost the same with T/N, whereas affinity of T+7/N was apparently increased. Furthermore, no mismatch opposite to l-T in the template was detected in transcription reactions via gel fidelity analysis. These results demonstrate the effects of chiral l-T in DNA on the efficiency and fidelity of RNA transcription mediated by T7 RNAP, which provides important knowledge about how mirror-image thymidine perturbs the flow of genetic information during RNA transcription and development of diseases caused by gene mutation.

5-Formylcytosine-induced DNA-peptide cross-links reduce transcription efficiency, but do not cause transcription errors in human cells

5-Formylcytosine (5fC) is an endogenous epigenetic DNA mark introduced via enzymatic oxidation of 5-methyl-dC in DNA. We and others recently reported that 5fC can form reversible DNA-protein conjugates with histone proteins, likely contributing to regulation of nucleosomal organization and gene expression. The protein component of DNA-protein cross-links can be proteolytically degraded, resulting in smaller DNA-peptide cross-links. Unlike full-size DNA-protein cross-links that completely block replication and transcription, DNA-peptide cross-links can be bypassed by DNA and RNA polymerases and can potentially be repaired via the nucleotide excision repair (NER) pathway. In the present work, we constructed plasmid molecules containing reductively stabilized, site-specific 5fC-polypeptide lesions and employed a quantitative MS-based assay to assess their effects on transcription in cells. Our results revealed that the presence of DNA-peptide cross-link significantly inhibits transcription in human HEK293T cells but does not induce transcription errors. Furthermore, transcription efficiency was similar in WT and NER-deficient human cell lines, suggesting that the 5fC-polypeptide lesion is a weak substrate for NER. This finding was confirmed by in vitro NER assays in cell-free extracts from human HeLa cells, suggesting that another mechanism is required for 5fC-polypeptide lesion removal. In summary, our findings indicate that 5fC-mediated DNA-peptide cross-links dramatically reduce transcription efficiency, are poor NER substrates, and do not cause transcription errors.

T7 RNA Polymerase Discriminates Correct and Incorrect Nucleoside Triphosphates by Free Energy

RNA polymerase (RNAP) is the primary machine responsible for transcription. Its ability to distinguish between correct (cognate) and incorrect (noncognate) nucleoside triphosphates (NTPs) is important for fidelity control in transcription. In this work, we investigated the substrate selection mechanism of T7 RNAP from the perspective of energetics. The dissociation free energies were determined for matched and unmatched base pairs in the preinsertion complex using the umbrella sampling method. A clear hydrogen-bond-rupture peak is observed in the potential of mean force curve for a matched base pair, whereas no such peaks are present in the position of mean force profiles for unmatched ones. The free-energy barrier could prevent correct substrates from being separated from the active site. Therefore, when NTPs diffuse into the active site, correct ones will stay for chemistry once they establish effective base pairing contacts with the template nucleotide, whereas incorrect ones will be withdrawn from the active site and rejected back to solution. This result provides an important energy evidence for the substrate selection mechanism of RNAP. Then we elucidated energetics and molecular details for correct NTP binding to the active site of the insertion complex. Our observations reveal that strong interactions act on the triphosphate of NTP to constrain its movement, whereas relatively weak interactions serve to position the base in the correct conformation. Triple interactions, hydrophobic contacts from residues M635 and Y639, base stacking from the 3' RNA terminal nucleotide, and base pairing from the template nucleotide act together to position the NTP base in a catalytically competent conformation. At last, we observed that incorrect NTPs cannot be as well-stabilized as the correct one in the active site when they are misincorporated in the insertion site. It is expected that our work can be helpful for comprehensively understanding details of this basic step in genetic transcription.

Determining selection free energetics from nucleotide pre-insertion to insertion in viral T7 RNA polymerase transcription fidelity control

An elongation cycle of a transcribing RNA polymerase (RNAP) usually consists of multiple kinetics steps, so there exist multiple kinetic checkpoints where non-cognate nucleotides can be selected against. We conducted comprehensive free energy calculations on various nucleotide insertions for viral T7 RNAP employing all-atom molecular dynamics simulations. By comparing insertion free energy profiles between the non-cognate nucleotide species (rGTP and dATP) and a cognate one (rATP), we obtained selection free energetics from the nucleotide pre-insertion to the insertion checkpoints, and further inferred the selection energetics down to the catalytic stage. We find that the insertion of base mismatch rGTP proceeds mainly through an off-path along which both pre-insertion screening and insertion inhibition play significant roles. In comparison, the selection against dATP is found to go through an off-path pre-insertion screening along with an on-path insertion inhibition. Interestingly, we notice that two magnesium ions switch roles of leave and stay during the dATP on-path insertion. Finally, we infer that substantial selection energetic is still required to catalytically inhibit the mismatched rGTP to achieve an elongation error rate ∼10-4 or lower; while no catalytic selection seems to be further needed against dATP to obtain an error rate ∼10-2.

C, Da LT, Yu J. A Viral T7 RNA Polymerase Ratcheting Along DNA With Fidelity Control

RNA polymerase (RNAP) from bacteriophage T7 is a representative single-subunit viral RNAP that can transcribe with high promoter activities without assistances from transcription factors. We accordingly studied this small transcription machine computationally as a model system to understand underlying mechanisms of mechano-chemical coupling and fidelity control in the RNAP transcription elongation. Here we summarize our computational work from several recent publications to demonstrate first how T7 RNAP translocates via Brownian alike motions along DNA right after the catalytic product release. Then we show how the backward translocation motions are prevented at post-translocation upon successful nucleotide incorporation, which is also subject to stepwise nucleotide selection and acts as a pawl for "selective ratcheting". The structural dynamics and energetics features revealed from our atomistic molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and related analyses on the single-subunit T7 RNAP thus provided detailed and quantitative characterizations on the Brownian-ratchet working scenario of a prototypical transcription machine with sophisticated nucleotide selectivity for fidelity control. The presented mechanisms can be more or less general for structurally similar viral or mitochondrial RNAPs and some of DNA polymerases, or even for the RNAP engine of the more complicated transcription machinery in higher organisms.

Balancing Non-Equilibrium Driving with Nucleotide Selectivity at Kinetic Checkpoints in Polymerase Fidelity Control

High fidelity gene transcription and replication require kinetic discrimination of nucleotide substrate species by RNA and DNA polymerases under chemical non-equilibrium conditions. It is known that sufficiently large free energy driving force is needed for each polymerization or elongation cycle to maintain far-from-equilibrium to achieve low error rates. Considering that each cycle consists of multiple kinetic steps with different transition rates, one expects that the kinetic modulations by polymerases are not evenly conducted at each step. We show that accelerations at different kinetic steps impact quite differently to the overall elongation characteristics. In particular, for forward transitions that discriminate cognate and non-cognate nucleotide species to serve as kinetic selection checkpoints, the transition cannot be accelerated too quickly nor retained too slowly to obtain low error rates, as balancing is needed between the nucleotide selectivity and the non-equilibrium driving. Such a balance is not the same as the speed-accuracy tradeoff in which high accuracy is always obtained at sacrifice of speed. For illustration purposes, we used three-state and five-state models of nucleotide addition in the polymerase elongation and show how the non-equilibrium steady state characteristics change upon variations on stepwise forward or backward kinetics. Notably, by using the multi-step elongation schemes and parameters from T7 RNA polymerase transcription elongation, we demonstrate that individual transitions serving as selection checkpoints need to proceed at moderate rates in order to sustain the necessary non-equilibrium drives as well as to allow nucleotide selections for an optimal error control. We also illustrate why rate-limiting conformational transitions of the enzyme likely play a significant role in the error reduction.