Activation and Inactivation of the FLT3 Kinase: Pathway Intermediates and the Free Energy of Transition

Understanding mechanisms of resistance to FLT3 inhibitors in adult FLT3-mutated Acute Myeloid Leukemia (AML) to guide treatment strategy

The presence of FLT3 mutations, including the most common FLT3-ITD (internal tandem duplications) and FLT3-TKD (tyrosine kinase domain), is associated with an unfavorable prognosis in patients affected by Acute Myeloid Leukemia (AML). In this setting, in recent years, new FLT3-inhibitors have demonstrated efficacy in improving survival and treatment response. Nevertheless, the development of primary and secondary mechanisms of resistance poses a significant obstacle to their efficacy. Understanding these mechanisms is crucial for developing novel therapeutic approaches to overcome resistance and improve the outcomes of patients. In this context, the use of novel FLT3 inhibitors and the combination of different targeted therapies have been studied. This review provides an update on the molecular alterations involved in FLT3 AML mechanisms of resistance, exploring how the molecular monitoring may be used to guide treatment strategy in FLT3-mutated AML.

FLT3 inhibitors and novel therapeutic strategies to reverse AML resistance: An updated comprehensive review

FMS-like tyrosine kinase 3 (FLT3) mutations occur in almost 30% of acute myeloid leukemia (AML) patients. Despite the initial clinical efficacy of FLT3 inhibitors, many treated AML patients with mutated FLT3 eventually relapse. This review critically discusses the opportunities and challenges of FLT3-targeted therapies and sheds light on their drug interactions as well as potential biomarkers. Furthermore, we focus on the molecular mechanisms underlying the resistance of FLT3 internal tandem duplication (FLT3-ITD) AMLs to FLT3 inhibitors alongside novel therapeutic strategies to reverse resistance. Notably, dynamic heterogeneous patterns of clonal selection and evolution contribute to the resistance of FLT3-ITD AMLs to FLT3 inhibitors. Ongoing preclinical research and clinical trials are actively directed towards devising rational "personalized" or "patient-tailored" combinatorial therapeutic regimens to effectively treat patients with FLT3 mutated AML.

Efficient Interrogation of the Kinetic Barriers Demarcating Catalytic States of a Tyrosine Kinase with Optimal Physical Descriptors and Mixture Models

Computer simulations are increasingly used to access thermo-kinetic information underlying structural transformation of protein kinases. Such information are necessary to probe their roles in disease progression and interactions with drug targets. However, the investigations are frequently challenged by forbiddingly high computational expense, and by the lack of standard protocols for the design of low dimensional physical descriptors that encode system features important for transitions. Here, we consider the demarcating characteristics of the different states of Abelson tyrosine kinase associated with distinct catalytic activity to construct a set of physically meaningful, orthogonal collective variables that preserve the slow modes of the system. Independent sampling of each metastable state is followed by the estimation of global partition function along the appropriate physical descriptors using the modified Expectation Maximized Molecular Dynamics method. The resultant free energy barriers are in excellent agreement with experimentally known rate-limiting dynamics and activation energy computed with conventional enhanced sampling methods. We discuss possible directions for further development and applications.

Resistance to a tyrosine kinase inhibitor mediated by changes to the conformation space of the kinase

Gilteritinib is a highly selective and effective inhibitor of the FLT3/ITD mutated protein, and is used successfully in treating acute myeloid leukaemia (AML). Unfortunately, tumour cells gradually develop resistance to gilteritinib due to mutations in the molecular drug target. The atomistic details behind this observed resistance are not clear, since the protein structure of the complex is only available in the inactive state, while the drug binds better to the active state. To overcome this limitation, we used a computer-aided approach where we docked gilteritinib to the active site of FLT3/ITD and calculated the Gibbs free energy difference between the binding energies of the parental and mutant enzymes. These calculations agreed with experimental estimations for one mutation (F691L) but not the other (D698N). To further understand how these mutations operate, we used metadynamics simulations to study the conformational landscape of the activation process. Both mutants show a lower activation energy barrier which suggests that they are more likely to adopt an active state until inhibited, making the mutant enzymes more active. This suggests that a higher efficiency of tyrosine kinases contributes to resistance not only against type 2 but also against type 1 kinase inhibitors.

“FLipping” the Story: FLT3-Mutated Acute Myeloid Leukemia and the Evolving Role of FLT3 Inhibitors

Simple Summary

Patients with acute myeloid leukemia (AML) may have a number of different mutations. Those with mutations in the FLT3 gene have a higher risk of relapse and death than those lacking these mutations. FLT3 is a key receptor on the surface of AML cells, which drives cell survival and growth. Although activation of this receptor is normally tightly controlled, in AML, FLT3 mutations allow it to activate itself, independent of external control. Over the past 5 years, a number of new drugs have been developed to specifically target these mutations. In this article, we discuss these drugs and their uses, as well as the mechanisms by which AML cells may gain resistance to them and how that resistance can be overcome.

Abstract

The treatment of many types of cancers, including acute myeloid leukemia (AML), has been revolutionized by the development of therapeutics targeted at crucial molecular drivers of oncogenesis. In contrast to broad, relatively indiscriminate conventional chemotherapy, these targeted agents precisely disrupt key pathways within cancer cells. FMS-like tyrosine kinase 3 (FLT3)—encoding a critical regulator of hematopoiesis—is the most frequently mutated gene in patients with AML, and these mutations herald reduced survival and increased relapse in these patients. Approximately 30% of newly diagnosed AML carries an FLT3 mutation; of these, approximately three-quarters are internal tandem duplication (ITD) mutations, and the remainder are tyrosine kinase domain (TKD) mutations. In contrast to its usual, tightly controlled expression, FLT3-ITD mutants allow constitutive, “run-away” activation of a large number of key downstream pathways which promote cellular proliferation and survival. Targeted inhibition of FLT3 is, therefore, a promising therapeutic avenue. In April 2017, midostaurin became both the first FLT3 inhibitor and the first targeted therapy of any kind in AML to be approved by the US FDA. The use of FLT3 inhibitors has continued to grow as clinical trials continue to demonstrate the efficacy of this class of agents, with an expanding number available for use as both experimental standard-of-care usage. This review examines the biology of FLT3 and its downstream pathways, the mechanism of FLT3 inhibition, the development of the FLT3 inhibitors as a class and uses of the agents currently available clinically, and the mechanisms by which resistance to FLT3 inhibition may both develop and be overcome.

Evaluation of residue variability in a conformation-specific context and during evolutionary sequence reconstruction narrows drug resistance selection in Abl1 tyrosine kinase

Diseases with readily available therapies may eventually prevail against the specific treatment by the acquisition of resistance. The constitutively active Abl1 tyrosine kinase known to cause chronic myeloid leukemia is an example, where patients may experience relapse after small inhibitor drug treatment. Mutations in the Abl1 tyrosine kinase domain (Abl1‐KD) are a critical source of resistance and their emergence depends on the conformational states that have been observed experimentally: the inactive state, the active state, and the intermediate inactive state that resembles Src kinase. Understanding how resistant positions and amino acid identities are determined by selection pressure during drug treatment is necessary to improve future drug development or treatment decisions. We carry out in silico site‐saturation mutagenesis over the Abl1‐KD structure in a conformational context to evaluate the in situ and conformational stability energy upon mutation. Out of the 11 studied resistant positions, we determined that 7 of the resistant mutations favored the active conformation of Abl1‐KD with respect to the inactive state. When, instead, the sequence optimization was modeled simultaneously at resistant positions, we recovered five known resistant mutations in the active conformation. These results suggested that the Abl1 resistance mechanism targeted substitutions that favored the active conformation. Further sequence variability, explored by ancestral reconstruction in Abl1‐KD, showed that neutral genetic drift, with respect to amino acid variability, was specifically diminished in the resistant positions. Since resistant mutations are susceptible to chance with a certain probability of fixation, combining methodologies outlined here may narrow and limit the available sequence space for resistance to emerge, resulting in more robust therapeutic treatments over time.

The molecular mechanisms behind activation of FLT3 in acute myeloid leukemia and resistance to therapy by selective inhibitors

Acute myeloid leukemia is an aggressive cancer, which, in spite of increasingly better understanding of its genetic background remains difficult to treat. Mutations in the FLT3 gene are observed in ≈30% of the patients. Most of these mutations are internal tandem duplications (ITDs) of a sequence within the protein coding region, an activation mechanism that is almost non-existent with other genes and cancers. As patients each carry their own unique set of mutations, it is challenging to understand how ITDs activate the protein, and ascertain the risk for each individual patient. Available treatment options are limited due to development of drug resistance. Here, recent studies are reviewed that help to better understand the molecular mechanism behind activation of the FLT3 protein due to mutations. It is argued that difference in mutation sequences and especially location might be coupled to prognosis. When it comes to FLT3 inhibitors, key differences between them can be attributed to the mode of inhibition (type-1 and type-2 inhibitors), effective inhibitory coefficient in the blood plasma and off-target binding. Accounting for the position and length of insertions may in the future be used to predict prognosis and rationalise treatment. Development of new inhibitors must take into account the potential for resistance mutations. Inhibitors aimed at multiple specific targets are currently being developed. These, and as well as combination therapies will hopefully lead to longer periods during which targeted FLT3 therapy will remain effective.

Activation of Abl1 Kinase Explored Using Well-Tempered Metadynamics Simulations on an Essential Dynamics Sampled Path

Well-tempered metadynamics (wT-metaD) simulations using path collective variables (CVs) have been successfully applied in recent years to explore conformational transitions in protein kinases and other biomolecular systems. While this methodology has the advantage of describing the transitions with a limited number of predefined path CVs, it requires as an input a reference path connecting the initial and target states of the system. It is desirable to automate the path generation using approaches that do not rely on the choice of geometric CVs to describe the transition of interest. To this end, we developed an approach that couples essential dynamics sampling with wT-metaD simulations. We used this newly developed procedure to explore the activation mechanism of Abl1 kinase and compute the associated free energy barriers. Through these simulations, we identified a three-step mechanism for the activation that involved two metastable intermediates that possessed a partially open activation loop and differed primarily in the “in” or “out” conformation of the aspartate residue of the DFG motif. One of these states is similar to a conformation that was detected in previous spectroscopic studies of Abl1 kinase, albeit its mechanistic role in the activation was hitherto not well understood. The present study establishes its intermediary role in the activation and predicts a rate-determining free energy barrier of 13.8 kcal/mol that is in good agreement with previous experimental and computational estimates. Overall, our study demonstrates the usability of essential dynamics sampling as a path CV in wT-metaD to conveniently study conformational transitions and accurately calculate the associated barriers.

Combating drug resistance in acute myeloid leukaemia by drug rotations: the effects of quizartinib and pexidartinib

BACKGROUND

Acute myeloid leukaemia (AML) is an aggressive blood cancer. In approximately 30% of the cases, driver mutations in the FLT3 gene are identified. FLT3 inhibitors are used in treatment of such patients together with cytotoxic drugs or (in refractory AML) as single agents. Unfortunately, resistance to FLT3 inhibitors limits their efficacy. Resistance is often due to secondary mutations in the gene encoding the molecular target. The gatekeeper mutation F691L confers resistance to specific FLT3 inhibitors such as quizartinib, but pexidartinib is much less resistance to this mutation. Pexidartinib alone is however sensitive to many other resistance mutations. In chronic myeloid leukaemia (CML), it has been suggested that rotation between drugs with a different landscape of resistance mutations might postpone the emergence of resistance.

METHODS

We studied the effect of quizartinib and pexidartinib in AML cell lines that express FLT3 (MOLM-14 and MV4-11). Using a rotation protocol, we further examined whether the emergence of resistance could be postponed. Computational modelling was used to analyse the onset of resistance and suggest which mutations are most likely to occur in a quantitative fashion.

RESULTS

The cells were sensitive to both inhibitors but quickly developed resistance that could be inherited, suggesting a genetic origin. Rotation protocols were not useful to postpone the emergence of resistance, which implies that such protocols, or changing from pexidartinib to quizartinib (or vice-versa) should not be used in patients. The computational modelling led to similar conclusions and suggested that F691L is the most common mutation to occur with quizartinib, and also when both drugs are used in rotation.

CONCLUSIONS

AML patients are not likely to benefit from a quizartinib/pexidartinib rotation protocol. A combination of tyrosine kinase inhibitors (with different molecular targets) might be more useful in the future. Development of specific FLT3 inhibitors that are less sensitive to resistance mutations might also lead to a better outcome.

Pattern and Dynamics of FLT3 Duplications

FMS-like tyrosine kinase 3 (FLT3) is mutated in ∼30% of patients that suffer from acute myeloid leukemia (AML). In about 25% of all AML patients, in-frame insertions are observed in the sequence. Most of those insertions are internal tandem duplications (ITDs) of a sequence from the protein. The characteristics of such mutations in terms of length, sequence, and location were hitherto studied in different populations, but not in a comprehensive mutation database. Here, in-frame insertions into the FLT3 gene were extracted from the Catalogue of Somatic Mutations in Cancer (COSMIC) database. These were analyzed with respect to the length, location, and sequence of the mutations. Furthermore, characteristic strings (sequences) of different lengths were identified. Mutations were shown to occur most often in the juxtamembrane zipper (JM-Z) domain of FLT3, followed by the hinge domain and first tyrosine kinase domain (TKD1), upstream of the phosphate-binding loop (P-loop). Interestingly, there are specific hot spot residues where insertions are more likely to occur. The insertions vary in length between one and 67 amino acids, with the largest insertions spanning the phosphate binding loop. Insertions that occur downstream of the P-loop are shorter. Our analysis further shows that acidic and aromatic residues are enriched in the insertions. Finally, molecular dynamics simulations were run for FLT3 with ITD insertions in the hinge and tyrosine kinase domains. On the basis of the findings, a mechanism is proposed for activation by ITDs, according to which there is no direct coupling between the length of the insertion and the activity of the mutated protein. The effect of insertions on the sensitivity of FLT3 to kinase inhibitors is discussed based on our findings.

Deciphering the molecular mechanism of FLT3 resistance mutations

FMS-like tyrosine kinase 3 (FLT3) has been found to be mutated in ~ 30% of acute myeloid leukaemia patients. Small-molecule inhibitors targeting FLT3 that are currently approved or still undergoing clinical trials are subject to drug resistance due to FLT3 mutations. How these mutations lead to drug resistance is hitherto poorly understood. Herein, we studied the molecular mechanism of the drug resistance mutations D835N, Y842S and M664I, which confer resistance against the most advanced inhibitors, quizartinib and PLX3397 (pexidartinib), using enzyme kinetics and computer simulations. In vitro kinase assays were performed to measure the comparative catalytic activity of the native protein and the mutants, using a bacterial expression system developed to this aim. Our results reveal that the differential drug sensitivity profiles can be rationalised by the dynamics of the protein-drug interactions and perturbation of the intraprotein contacts upon mutations. Drug binding induced a single conformation in the native protein, whereas multiple conformations were observed otherwise (in the mutants or in the absence of drugs). The end-point kinetics measurements indicated that the three resistant mutants conferred catalytic activity that is at least as high as that of the reference without such mutations. Overall, our calculations and measurements suggest that the structural dynamics of the drug-resistant mutants that affect the active state and the increased conformational freedom of the remaining inactive drug-bound population are the two major factors that contribute to drug resistance in FLT3 harbouring cancer cells. Our results explain the mechanism of drug resistance mutations and can aid to the design of more effective tyrosine kinase inhibitors.

Conformational modifications induced by internal tandem duplications on the FLT3 kinase and juxtamembrane domains

The aberrant expression of FLT3 tyrosine kinase is associated primarily with acute myeloid leukaemia. This blood malignancy is often related to the onset of internal tandem duplications (ITDs) in the native sequence of the protein. The ITDs occur mainly in the juxtamembrane domain of the protein and alter the normal activity of the enzyme. In this work, we have studied the native form of FLT3 and six mutants by molecular dynamics simulations. The catalytic activity of FLT3 is exerted by the tyrosine kinase domain (KD) and regulated by the juxtamembrane (JM) domain. Analysis of the dynamics of these two domains have shown that the introduction of ITDs in the JM domain alters both structural and dynamic parameters. The presence of ITDs allowed the protein to span a larger portion of the conformational space, particularly in the JM domain and the activation loop. The FLT3 mutants were found to adopt more stable configurations than the native enzyme. This was due to the different arrangements assumed by the JM domain. Larger fluctuations of the activation loop were found in four of the six mutants. In the native FLT3, the key residue Tyr572 is involved in a strong and stable interaction with an ion pair. This interaction, which is thought to keep the JM in place hence regulating the activity of the enzyme, was found to break in all FLT3 mutants.