Electron Binding in a Superatom with a Repulsive Coulomb Barrier: The Case of [Ag44(SC6H3F2)30]4- in the Gas Phase

Recent developments in the investigation of driving forces for transforming coinage metal nanoclusters

Metal nanoclusters serve as an emerging class of modular nanomaterials. The transformation of metal nanoclusters has been fully reflected in their studies from every aspect, including the structural evolution analysis, physicochemical property regulation, and practical application promotion. In this review, we highlight the driving forces for transforming atomically precise metal nanoclusters and summarize the related transforming principles and fundamentals. Several driving forces for transforming nanoclusters are meticulously reviewed herein: ligand-exchange-induced transformations, metal-exchange-induced transformations, intercluster reactions, photochemical transformations, oxidation/reduction-induced transformations, and other factors (intrinsic instability, pH, temperature, and metal salts) triggering transformations. The exploitation of transforming principles to customize the preparations, structures, physicochemical properties, and practical applications of metal nanoclusters is also disclosed. At the end of this review, we provide our perspectives and highlight the challenges remaining for future research on the transformation of metal nanoclusters. Our intended audience is the broader scientific community interested in metal nanoclusters, and we believe that this review will provide researchers with a comprehensive synthetic toolbox and insights on the research fundamentals needed to realize more cluster-based nanomaterials with customized compositions, structures, and properties.

Probing the surface-active sites of metal nanoclusters with atomic precision: a case study of Au5Ag11

The determination of surface-active sites in metal nanoclusters is of great significance for the in-depth understanding of structural evolutions and physicochemical property mechanisms. In this work, the surface-active sites of the Au5Ag11(DMBT)8(DPPOE)2 cluster template towards metal-/ligand-exchange reactions were unambiguously identified at the atomic level. The active-site tailoring of this nanocluster gave rise to three derivative nanoclusters, Au5Ag9Cu2(DMBT)8(DPPOE)2, Au5Ag11(DMBT)6(DCBT)2(DPPOE)2, and Au5Ag11(DCBT)8(DPPOE)2. The single-crystal structural analysis revealed that all these M16 (M = Au/Ag/Cu) clusters exhibited almost the same framework. Besides, the surface-active site tailoring contributed to significant changes in optical absorptions and emissions of these metal nanoclusters. The findings in this work not only provide an in-depth understanding of the active-site tailoring of cluster surface structures but also develop an intriguing template that enables us to grasp the structure-property correlations at the atomic level.

Electron Affinities of Ligated Icosahedral M13 Superatoms Revisited by Gas-Phase Anion Photoelectron Spectroscopy

The electron binding energies of the ligand-protected gold/silver-based cluster anions, [Au₂₅(SR)₁₈]^-, [XAg₂₄(SR')₁₈]^2- (X = Ag⁺, Au⁺, Pd⁰, or Pt⁰), and [PdAu₂₄(C≡CR″)₁₈]^2- having icosahedral M₁₃ superatomic cores, were reexamined by gas-phase photoelectron spectroscopy (PES) on a significantly intensified mass-selected ion beam. Laser fluence-dependent PE spectra and pump-probe PES revealed that the previous PE spectra were contaminated by PE signals due to the two-photon electron detachment via long-lived photoexcited states. Although the adiabatic electron affinities (AEAs) of the corresponding oxidized forms were found to be 1-2 eV larger than those previously reported, the effects of doping and ligation were not qualitatively affected. (1) The AEA of the Ag₁₃ superatom (∼4 eV) was not appreciably affected by doping a Au atom at the center but was reduced by ∼2 eV by doping Pd or Pt, and (2) the AEA of PdAu₁₂ protected by Au₂(C≡CR″)₃ units was much larger than that of PdAg₁₂ protected by Ag₂(SR')₃ units.

Dual External Field-Engineered Hyperhalogen

Hyperhalogens, a superatom featuring the highest known electron affinity (EA), have promising applications in the synthesis of superoxidizers. Contributions regarding the identified numbers and corresponding design strategies of hyperhalogens, however, are scarce. Herein, a novel and noninvasive dual external field (DEF) strategy, including the ligand field and oriented external electric field (OEEF), is proposed to construct hyperhalogens. The DEF strategy was shown to possess the power to increase Au₈'s EA, forming the hyperhalogen. Strikingly, the ligation process can increase the cluster's stability, while OEEF can realize the precise and continuous regulation of the cluster's EA. Moreover, besides the model Au₈ system, an experimentally synthesized Ag₁₇ nanocluster was also investigated, further demonstrating the reliability of the proposed strategy. Considering the crucial role of ligands in the liquid synthesis of clusters and the convenient source of OEEF, such a DEF strategy may greatly increase the synthesis and applications of hyperhalogens in the condensed phase.

Critical Role of CF3 Groups in the Electronic Stabilization of [PdAu24(C≡CC6H3(CF3)2)18]2- as Revealed by Gas-Phase Anion Photoelectron Spectroscopy

The role of alkynyl ligands with electron-withdrawing nature in the stability of metal clusters was investigated by gas-phase anion photoelectron spectroscopy (PES) on heteroleptic cluster anions [PdAu₂₄(C≡CAr^F)_18-x(C≡CPh)_x]^2- (Ar^F = 3,5-(CF₃)₂C₆H₃). Gas-phase PES on the cluster anions with specific x (= 0-6) revealed that electron binding energies decreased linearly with x, indicating that the electron-withdrawing CF₃ substituents on the alkynyl ligand played a critical role in the electronic stabilization of [PdAu₂₄(C≡CAr^F)₁₈]^2-. Density functional theory calculations reproduced the decrease of electron binding energies and rationally explained the ligand effect by a mechanism similar to the modulation of the work function of gold films by organic monolayers.

A reasonable approach for the generation of hollow icosahedral kernels in metal nanoclusters

Although the hollow icosahedral M₁₂ kernel has been extensively observed in metal nanoclusters, its origin remains a mystery. Here we report a reasonable avenue for the generation of the hollow icosahedron: the kernel collapse from several small nano-building blocks to an integrated hollow icosahedron. On the basis of the Au alloying processes from Ag₂₈Cu₁₂(SR)₂₄ to the template-maintained Au_xAg_28-xCu₁₂(SR)₂₄ and then to the template-transformed Au₁₂Cu_yAg_32-y(SR)₃₀, the kernel evolution/collapse from “tetrahedral Ag₄ + 4^∗Ag₃” to “tetrahedral Au₄ + 4^∗M₃ (M = Au/Ag)” and then to “hollow icosahedral Au₁₂” is mapped out. Significantly, the “kernel collapse” from small-sized nano-building blocks to large-sized nanostructures not only unveils the formation of hollow icosahedral M₁₂ in this work, but also might be a very common approach in constructing metallic kernels of nanoclusters and nanoparticles (not limited to the M₁₂ structure).

The origin of the hollow icosahedral M₁₂ kernel in metal nanoclusters is under debate. Here the authors demonstrate the Au alloying-induced kernel collapse from small-sized nano-building blocks as a viable approach for the generation of hollow icosahedral M₁₂ kernel in metal nanoclusters.

Toward quantitative electronic structure in small gold nanoclusters

Ligand-protected gold nanoclusters (AuNCs) feature a dense but finite electronic structure that can be rationalized using qualitative descriptions such as the well-known superatomic model and predicted using quantum chemical calculations. However, the lack of well-resolved experimental probes of a AuNC electronic structure has made the task of evaluating the accuracy of electronic structure descriptions challenging. We compare electronic absorption spectra computed using time-dependent density functional theory to recently collected high resolution experimental spectra of Au₉(PPh₃)₈ ³⁺ and Au₈(PPh₃)₇ ²⁺ AuNCs with strikingly similar features. After applying a simple scaling correction, the computed spectrum of Au₈(PPh₃)₇ ²⁺ yields a suitable match, allowing us to assign low-energy metal-metal transitions in the experimental spectrum. No similar match is obtained after following the same procedure for two previously reported isomers for Au₉(PPh₃)₈ ³⁺, suggesting either a deficiency in the calculations or the presence of an additional isomer. Instead, we propose assignments for Au₉(PPh₃)₈ ³⁺ based off of similarities Au₈(PPh₃)₇ ²⁺. We further model these clusters using a simple particle-in-a-box analysis for an asymmetrical ellipsoidal superatomic core, which allows us to reproduce the same transitions and extract an effective core size and shape that agrees well with that expected from crystal structures. This suggests that the superatomic model, which is typically employed to explain the qualitative features of nanocluster electronic structures, remains valid even for small AuNCs with highly aspherical cores.

Cresting the Coulomb Barrier of Polyanionic Metal Clusters

Combining photoelectron spectroscopy with tunable laser pulse excitation allows us to characterize the Coulomb barrier potential of multiply negatively charged silver clusters. The spectra of mass- and charge-selected polyanionic systems, with z=2-5 excess electrons, show a characteristic dependence on the excitation energy, which emphasizes the role of electron tunneling through the barrier. By evaluating experimental data from an 800-atom system, the electron yield is parametrized with respect to tunneling near the photoemission threshold. This analysis results in the first experimentally based potential energy functions of polyanionic metal clusters.

Atom-by-Atom Evolution of the Same Ligand-Protected Au21, Au22, Au22Cd1, and Au24 Nanocluster Series

Atom-by-atom manipulation on metal nanoclusters (NCs) has long been desired, as the resulting series of NCs can provide insightful understanding of how a single atom affects the structure and properties as well as the evolution with size. Here, we report crystallizations of Au22(SAdm)16 and Au22Cd1(SAdm)16 (SAdm = adamantanethiolate) which link up with Au21(SAdm)15 and Au24(SAdm)16 NCs and form an atom-by-atom evolving series protected by the same ligand. Structurally, Au22(SAdm)16 has an Au3(SAdm)4 surface motif which is longer than the Au2(SAdm)3 on Au21(SAdm)15, whereas Au22Cd1(SAdm)16 lacks one staple Au atom compared to Au24(SAdm)16 and thus the surface structure is reconstructed. A single Cd atom triggers the structural transition from Au22 with a 10-atom bioctahedral kernel to Au22Cd1 with a 13-atom cuboctahedral kernel, and correspondingly, the optical properties are dramatically changed. The photoexcited carrier lifetime demonstrates that the optical properties and excited state relaxation are highly sensitive at the single atom level. By contrast, little change in both ionization potential and electron affinity is found in this series of NCs by theoretical calculations, indicating the electronic properties are independent of adding a single atom in this series. The work provides a paradigm that the NCs with continuous metal atom numbers are accessible and crystallizable when meticulously designed, and the optical properties are more affected at the single atom level than the electronic properties.

Ligand-protected gold/silver superatoms: current status and emerging trends

Monolayer-protected gold/silver clusters have attracted much interest as nano-scale building units for novel functional materials owing to their nonbulk-like structures and size-specific properties. They can be viewed as ligand-protected superatoms because their magic stabilities and fundamental properties are well explained in the framework of the jellium model. In the last decade, the number of ligand-protected superatoms with atomically-defined structures has been increasing rapidly thanks to the well-established synthesis and structural determination by X-ray crystallography. This perspective summarizes the current status and emerging trends in synthesis and characterization of superatoms. The topics related to synthesis include (1) development of targeted synthesis based on transformation, (2) enhancement of robustness and synthetic yield for practical applications, and (3) development of controlled fusion and assembly of well-defined superatoms to create new properties. New characterization approaches are also introduced such as (1) mass spectrometry and laser spectroscopies in the gas phase, (2) determination of static and dynamic structures, and (3) computational analysis by machine learning. Finally, future challenges and prospects are discussed for further promotion and development of materials science of superatoms.

This perspective summarizes the current status and emerging trends in synthesis and characterization of ligand-protected gold/silver superatoms.

A topological isomer of the Au25(SR)18- nanocluster

Energetically low-lying structural isomers of the much-studied thiolate-protected gold cluster Au25(SR)18- are discovered from extensive (80 ns) molecular dynamics (MD) simulations using the reactive molecular force field ReaxFF and confirmed by density functional theory (DFT). A particularly interesting isomer is found, which is topologically connected to the known crystal structure by a low-barrier collective rotation of the icosahedral Au13 core. The isomerization takes place without breaking of any Au-S bonds. The predicted isomer is essentially iso-energetic with the known Au25(SR)18- structure, but has a distinctly different optical spectrum. It has a significantly larger collision cross-section as compared to that of the known structure, which suggests it could be detectable in gas phase ion-mobility mass spectrometry.