Interfacial tension does not drive asymmetric nanoscale electrowetting on graphene

Relation between Double Layer Structure, Capacitance, and Surface Tension in Electrowetting of Graphene and Aqueous Electrolytes

Deciphering the mechanisms of charge storage on carbon-based materials is pivotal for the development of next-generation electrochemical energy storage systems. Graphene, the building block of graphitic electrodes, is an ideal model for probing such processes on a fundamental level. Herein, we investigate the thermodynamics of the graphene/aqueous electrolyte interface by utilizing a multiscale quantum mechanics-classical molecular dynamics (QM/MD) approach to provide insights into the effect of alkali metal ion (Li+) concentration on the interfacial tension (γSL) of the charged graphene/electrolyte interface. We demonstrate that the dependence of γSL on the applied surface charge exhibits an asymmetric behavior relative to the neutral surface. At the positively charged graphene sheet, the electrowetting response is amplified by electrolyte concentration, resulting in a strongly hydrophilic surface. On the contrary, at negative potential bias, γSL shows a weaker response to the charging of the electrode. Changes in γSL greatly affect the total areal capacitance predicted by the Young-Lippmann equation but have a negligible impact on the simulated total areal capacitance, indicating that the EDL structure is not directly correlated with the wettability of the surface and different interfacial mechanisms drive the two phenomena. The proposed model is validated experimentally by studying the electrowetting response of highly oriented pyrolytic graphite over a wide range of electrolyte concentrations. Our work presents the first combined theoretical and experimental study on electrowetting using carbon surfaces, introducing new conceptual routes for the investigation of wetting phenomena under potential bias.

Molecular insights into the electrowetting behavior of aqueous ionic liquids

Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations were applied to investigate the wettability of aqueous hydrophilic and hydrophobic imidazolium-based ionic liquid (IL) nano-droplets on a graphite surface under a perpendicular electric field. Imminent transformation in the droplet configuration was observed at E = 0.08 V Å^-1 both for hydrophobic ILs 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [EMIM][NTF₂] and SPC/E water droplets. However, for the hydrophilic IL, 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [EMIM][BF₄], the droplet was entirely elongated to column-shaped at E = 0.09 V Å^-1 for lower weight percentages of ILs and at E = 0.15 V Å^-1 for a higher weight percentage of ILs (i.e., 50 wt%). We explored the impact of the electric field through various parameters such as mass and charge density distribution across the droplet, contact angle of the droplet, orientation of water dipoles, and hydrogen bond analysis. The external electric field was found to influence the orientation of water dipoles and the accumulation of charge at various interfaces was observed with an increase in an electric field, which finally leads to shape deformation and depletion of ions from the liquid-vapor interface of the droplet. However, this behavior strongly depends on the hydrophilicity or hydrophobicity of the ILs and thus, is critically examined for both the ILs.

Nanotexture Shape and Surface Energy Impact on Electroadhesive Human-Machine Interface Performance

With the ubiquity of touch screens and the commercialization of electroadhesion-based surface haptic devices, modeling tools that capture the multiphysical phenomena within the finger-device interface and their interaction are critical to design devices that achieve higher performance and reliability at lower cost. While electroadhesion has successfully demonstrated the capability to change tactile perception through friction modulation, the mechanism of electroadhesion in the finger-device interface is still unclear, partly due to the complex interfacial physics including contact deformation, capillary formation, electric field, and their complicated coupling effects that have not been addressed comprehensively. A multiphysics model is presented here to predict the friction force for finger-surface tactile interactions at the nanoscale. The nanoscopic multiphysical phenomena are coupled to study the impacts of nanotexture and surface energy in the touch interface. With macroscopic friction force measurements as verification, the model is further used to propose textures that have maximum electroadhesion effect and minimum sensitivity to relative humidity and user perspiration rate. This model can guide the performance improvement of future electroadhesion-based surface haptic devices and other touch-based human-machine interfaces.

Evaluation of the Electrowetting Effect on the Interfacial Mechanics between Human Corneocytes and Nanoasperities

A large subset of haptic surfaces employs electroadhesion to modulate both adhesion and friction at a sliding finger interface. The current theory of electroadhesion assumes that the applied electric field pulls the skin into stronger contact, increasing friction by increasing the real contact area, yet it is unknown what role environmental moisture plays in the effect. This paper uses atomic force microscopy (AFM)to determine the effect of humidity on the adhesion and friction between the single nanoscale asperity and individual human finger corneocytes. An analytical model of the total effective load of the AFM tip is developed to explain the humidity-voltage dependence of nanoscale adhesion and friction at contacting asperities. The results show that the electrowetting effect at the interface at high humidity accounts for 35% of the adhesive force but less than 8% of the total friction, implying that the electrowetting effect can be enhanced by optimizing surface topography to promote the formation and rupture of liquid menisci.

Wettability of cellulose surfaces under the influence of an external electric field

HYPOTHESIS

Interfacial tensions play an important role in dewatering of hydrophilic materials like nanofibrillated cellulose, and are affected by the molecular organization of water at the interface. Application of an electric field influences the orientation of water molecules along the field direction. Hence, it should be possible to alter the interfacial free energies to tune the wettability of cellulose surface through application of an external electric field thus, aiding the dewatering process.

SIMULATIONS

Molecular dynamics simulations of cellulose surface in contact with water under the influence of an external electric field have been conducted with GLYCAM-06 forcefield. The effect of variation in electric field intensity and directions on the spreading coefficient has been addressed via orientational preference of water molecules and interfacial free energy analyses.

FINDINGS

The application of electric field influences the interfacial free energy difference at the cellulose-water interface. The spreading coefficient increases with the electric field directed parallel to the cellulose-water interface while it decreases in the perpendicular electric field. Variation in interfacial free energies seems to explain the change in contact angle adequately in presence of an electric field. The wettability of cellulose surface can be tuned by the application of an external electric field.

Synergistic effects of the tip effect and electric adsorption on the enhanced electrowetting-on-dielectric performance of structured ZnO surfaces

To improve the spreading ability of water droplet on structured surface, the tip effect is proposed to enhance the local electric field near the cone tip under the voltage application, and further increases the horizontal force on the water droplet.

Electro-wetting of a nanoscale water droplet on a polar solid surface in electric fields

Water molecules interact with a polar surface in an electric field to realign their point dipoles, which determine the spreading behaviors of the droplets.

Doping-Driven Wettability of Two-Dimensional Materials: A Multiscale Theory

Engineering molecular interactions at two-dimensional (2D) materials interfaces enables new technological opportunities in functional surfaces and molecular epitaxy. Understanding the wettability of 2D materials represents the crucial first step toward quantifying the interplay between the interfacial forces and electric potential of 2D materials interfaces. Here we develop the first theoretical framework to model the wettability of the doped 2D materials by properly bridging the multiscale physical phenomena at the 2D interfaces, including (i) the change of 2D materials surface energy (atomistic scale, several angstroms), (ii) the molecular reorientation of liquid molecules adjacent to the interface (molecular scale, 10⁰-10¹ nm), and (iii) the electrical double layer (EDL) formed in the liquid phase (mesoscopic scales, 10⁰-10⁴ nm). The latter two effects are found to be the major mechanisms responsible for the contact angle change upon doping, while the surface energy change of a pure 2D material has no net effect on the wetting property. When the doping level is electrostatically tuned, we demonstrate that 2D materials with high quantum capacitances (e.g., transition metal dichalcogenides, TMDCs) possess a wider range of tunability in the interfacial tension, under the same applied gate voltage. Furthermore, practical considerations such as defects and airborne contamination are also quantitatively discussed. Our analysis implies that the doping level can be another variable to modulate the wettability at 2D materials interfaces, as well as the molecular packing behavior on a 2D material-coated surface, essentially facilitating the interfacial engineering of 2D materials.

Charge Induced Dynamics of Water in a Graphene-Mica Slit Pore

We use atomic force microscopy to in situ investigate the dynamic behavior of confined water at the interface between graphene and mica. The graphene is either uncharged, negatively charged, or positively charged. At high humidity, a third water layer will intercalate between graphene and mica. When graphene is negatively charged, the interface fills faster with a complete three layer water film, compared to uncharged graphene. As charged positively, the third water layer dewets the interface, either by evaporation into the ambient or by the formation of three-dimensional droplets under the graphene, on top of the bilayer. Our experimental findings reveal novel phenomena of water at the nanoscale, which are interesting from a fundamental point of view and demonstrate the direct control over the wetting properties of the graphene/water interface.

Low-Voltage Voltammetric Electrowetting of Graphite Surfaces by Ion Intercalation/Deintercalation

We demonstrate low-voltage electrowetting at the surface of freshly cleaved highly oriented pyrolytic graphite (HOPG). Using cyclic voltammetry (CV), electrowetting of a droplet of a sodium perchlorate solution is observed at moderately positive potentials on high-quality (low step edge coverage) HOPG, leading to significant changes in the contact angle and relative contact diameter that are comparable to the results of the widely studied electrowetting on dielectric (EWOD) system, but over a much lower voltage range. The electrowetting behavior is found to be reasonably fast, reversible, and repeatable for at least 20 cyclic scans (maximum tested). In contrast to classical electrowetting, e.g., EWOD, the electrowetting of the droplet on HOPG occurs with the intercalation/deintercalation of anions between the graphene layers of graphite, driven by the applied potential, observed in the CV response, and detected by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy. The electrowetting behavior is strongly influenced by those factors that affect the extent of the intercalation/deintercalation of ions on graphite, such as potential range scan rate, potential polarity, quality of the HOPG substrate (step edge density and step height), and type of anion in the solution. In addition to perchlorate, sulfate salts also promote electrowetting, but some other salts do not. Our findings suggest a new mechanism for electrowetting based on ion intercalation, and the results are important to fundamental electrochemistry as well as to diversifying the means by which electrowetting can be controlled and applied.

Mechanism for Asymmetric Nanoscale Electrowetting of an Ionic Liquid on Graphene

The electrowetting behavior of 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate ([bmim][BF4]) confined between two oppositely charged graphene layers is investigated using molecular dynamics simulations. By introducing charges on the surface, counterions are attracted to the surface and co-ions are repelled from it, leading to the reduction of the solid-liquid interfacial free energy and consequently the contact angle. Recently, we have shown that changes in the contact angle upon charging the surface are asymmetric with respect to surface polarity and opposite to the changes in the solid-liquid interfacial free energy. In this work, the asymmetry of the solid-liquid interfacial free energy is shown to originate from differences in structural organization of the ions at the interface, with positively polarized surfaces inducing a more favorable electrostatic arrangement of the ions. Analysis of the liquid structure in the vicinity of the three phase contact line, however, shows that the ion size asymmetry, together with differences in orientational ordering of the cations on oppositely polarized surfaces, instead leads to enhanced spreading on the negatively polarized surfaces, resulting in a corresponding contact angle asymmetry.