Generation and Stability of Bulk Nanobubbles

Hydroxide and Hydronium Ions Modulate the Dynamic Evolution of Nitrogen Nanobubbles in Water

It has been widely recognized that the pH environment influences the nanobubble dynamics and hydroxide ions adsorbed on the surface may be responsible for the long-term survival of the nanobubbles. However, understanding the distribution of hydronium and hydroxide ions in the vicinity of a bulk nanobubble surface at a microscopic scale and the consequent impact of these ions on the nanobubble behavior remains a challenging endeavor. In this study, we carried out deep potential molecular dynamics simulations to explore the behavior of a nitrogen nanobubble under neutral, acidic, and alkaline conditions and the inherent mechanism, and we also conducted a theoretical thermodynamic and dynamic analysis to address constraints related to simulation duration. Our simulations and theoretical analyses demonstrate a trend of nanobubble dissolution similar to that observed experimentally, emphasizing the limited dissolution of bulk nanobubbles in alkaline conditions, where hydroxide ions tend to reside slightly farther from the nanobubble surface than hydronium ions, forming more stable hydrogen bond networks that shield the nanobubble from dissolution. In acidic conditions, the hydronium ions preferentially accumulating at the nanobubble surface in an orderly manner drive nanobubble dissolution to increase the entropy of the system, and the dissolved nitrogen molecules further strengthen the hydrogen bond networks of systems by providing a hydrophobic environment for hydronium ions, suggesting both entropy and enthalpy effects contribute to the instability of nanobubbles under acidic conditions. These results offer fresh insights into the double-layer distribution of hydroxide and hydronium near the nitrogen-water interface that influences the dynamic behavior of bulk nanobubbles.

Advancing nanobubble technology for carbon-neutral water treatment and enhanced environmental sustainability

Gaseous nanobubbles (NBs) with dimensions ranging from 1 to 1000 nm in the liquid phase have garnered significant interest due to their unique physicochemical characteristics, including specific surface area, low internal gas pressure, long-term stability, efficient mass transfer, interface potential, and free radical production. These remarkable properties have sparked considerable attention in the scientific community and industries alike. These hold immense promise for environmental applications, especially for carbon-neutral water remediation. Their long-lasting stability in aqueous systems and efficient mass transfer properties make them highly suitable for delivering gases in the vicinity of pollutants. This potential has prompted research into the use of NBs for targeted delivery of gases in contaminated water bodies, facilitating the degradation of harmful substances and advancing sustainable remediation practices. However, despite significant progress in understanding NBs physicochemical properties and potential applications, several challenges and knowledge gaps persist. This review thereby aims to summarize the current state of research on NBs environmental applications and potential for remediation. By discussing the generation processes, mechanisms, principles, and characterization techniques, it sheds light on the promising future of NBs in advancing environmental sustainability. It explores their role in improving oxygenation, aeration, and pollutant degradation in water systems. Finally, the review addresses future research perspectives, emphasizing the need to bridge knowledge gaps and overcome challenges to unlock the full potential of this frontier technology for enhanced environmental sustainability.

Nanobubble transport in porous media: Towards agro- and environmental applications

Nanobubbles have been increasingly used in various applications involving porous media, such as groundwater remediation and irrigation. However, the fundamental scientific knowledge regarding the interactions between nanobubbles and the media is still limited. The interactions can be repulsive, attractive, or inert, and can involve reversible or irreversible attachment as well as destructive mechanisms. Specifically, the stability and mobility of nanobubbles in porous media is expected to be dependent on the dynamic conditions and the physicochemical properties of the porous media, solutions, and nanobubbles themselves. In this study, we investigated how changes in solution chemistry (pH, ionic strength, and valence) and media characteristics (size and wettability) affect the size and concentration of nanobubbles under dynamic conditions using column experiments. Quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring provided a deeper understanding of irreversible and elastic nanobubbles' interactions with silica-coated surfaces. Our findings suggest that nanobubbles are less mobile in solutions of higher ionic strength and valence, acidic pH and smaller porous media sizes, while the wettability of porous media has a negligible influence on the retention of nanobubbles. Overall, our findings provide insights into the underlying mechanisms of nanobubble interactions and suggest potential strategies to optimize their delivery in various applications.

Bulk Nanobubbles through Gas Supersaturation Originated by Hot and Cold Solvent Mixing

The nucleation mechanism of bulk nanobubbles remains unclear despite the considerable attention they have received in recent years. We propose two hypotheses: (i) The gas supersaturation in the bulk liquid is the primary factor for nanobubble nucleation, and (ii) the mixing of the same solvent at varying gas solubilities should produce nanobubbles, provided that the first hypothesis is correct. To test this hypothesis, we performed extensive experiments on nanobubble nucleation in both water and organic solvents. The temperature difference between hot and cold samples ranged from 10 to 80 °C in pure solvents such as water, methanol, ethanol, propanol, and butanol prepared and mixed in equal proportions. To the best of our knowledge, we report bulk nanobubble nucleation by mixing hot and cold solvents for the first time. The refractive index value calculations using Mie scattering theory confirmed the existence of nanobubbles. When surface tension dominates over surface charge, the critical work for nanobubble formation is ΔFc ∝ 1/ξ2, and when surface charge dominates over surface tension, the critical work is ΔFc ∝ ξ1/4. Our experimental results verify such dependency by measuring nanobubbles nucleated with varying degrees of gas supersaturation.

Nanoshell Formation at the Electrically Charged Gas-Water Interface of Collapsing Microbubbles: Insights from Atomic Force Microscopy Imaging

AFM imaging has revealed intriguing features when bulk nanobubbles were deposited on a positively charged substrate. Numerous spherical objects, each less than 20 nm in diameter, were observed on the substrate. These objects were adorned with noticeable, tiny protrusions, each measuring a few nanometers. These findings suggest the presence of solid shells contributing to the stability of the gas bodies. Furthermore, electrically charged microbubbles appear to play a critical role in the formation of these solid shells. The collapse of microbubbles in an electrolyte aqueous solution containing iron ions leads to a condensing ionic cloud, creating conditions necessary for solid nucleation at the interface. At the end of the collapsing process, concurrent multinucleation may result in the deposition of solid material on the interface, forming solid shells with specific structures on the surfaces. This study illuminates the phenomenon of electrically charged gas-water interfaces during microbubble collapse and highlights the generation of stabilized nanoshells in aqueous solutions without the need for chemical stabilizers.

Two-dimensional water-molecule-cluster layers at nanobubble interfaces

HYPOTHESIS

Bulk nanobubbles (NBs) have high surface charge densities and long lifetimes. Despite several attempts to understand the lifetime of NBs, their interfacial layer structure remains unknown. It is hypothesized that a specific interfacial layer exists with a hydrogen bond network that stabilizes NBs.

EXPERIMENTS

In situ infrared reflectance-absorption spectroscopy and density functional theory were used to determine the interfacial layer structure of NBs. Furthermore, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy was used to examine the interfacial layer hardness of bubbles filled with N2, O2, and CO2, which was expected to depend on the encapsulated gas species.

FINDINGS

The interfacial layer was composed of three-, four-, and five-membered ring clusters of water molecules. An interface model was proposed in which a two-dimensional layer of clusters with large electric dipole moments is oriented toward the endohedral gas, and the hydrophobic surface is adjacent to the free water. The interfacial layer hardness was dependent on the interaction with the gas (N2 > O2 > CO2), which supports the proposed interface model. These findings can be generalized to the structure of water at gas-water interfaces.

Effect of chemical species and temperature on the stability of air nanobubbles

The colloidal stability of air nanobubbles (NBs) was studied at different temperatures (0-30 °C) and in the presence of sulfates, typically found in mining effluents, in a wide range of Na2SO4 concentrations (0.001 to 1 M), along with the effect of surfactants (sodium dodecyl sulfate), chloride salts (NaCl), and acid/base reagents at a pH range from 4 to 9. Using a nanobubble generator based on hydrodynamic cavitation, 1.2 × 108 bubbles/mL with a typical radius of 84.66 ± 7.88 nm were generated in deionized water. Multiple evidence is provided to prove their presence in suspension, including the Tyndall effect, dynamic light scattering, and nanoparticle size analysis. Zeta potential measurements revealed that NBs are negatively charged even after two months (from - 19.48 ± 1.89 to - 10.13 ± 1.71 mV), suggesting that their stability is due to the negative charge on their surface. NBs were found to be more stable in alkaline solutions compared to acidic ones. Further, low amounts of both chloride and sulfate dissolved salts led to a reduction of the size of NBs. However, when high amounts of dissolved salts are present, NBs are more likely to coalesce, and their size to be increased. Finally, the investigation of the stability of air NBs at low temperatures revealed a non-monotonic relationship between temperature and NBs upon considering water self-ionization and ion mobility. This research aims to open a new frontier towards the application of the highly innovative NBs technology on the treatment of mining, mineral, and metal processing effluents, which are challenging aqueous solutions containing chloride and sulfate species.

The Effect of Nanobubbles on Transdermal Applications

In the present work, a new method for dermal delivery using nanobubbles (NBs) is investigated. Oxygen NBs are generated in deionized water and used to produce cosmetic formulations with hyaluronic acid as an active ingredient. Nanobubbles result in the improvement of the effect and penetration of the active ingredient through Strat-M, a synthetic membrane that resembles human skin. Experiments conducted with the Franz Cell device confirm the greater penetration of the active ingredient into Strat-M due to NBs, compared to cosmetic formulations that do not contain NBs. The effect of NBs was further examined by measuring UV-Vis and FTIR spectra. A possible mechanism was outlined, too. It was also found that NBs do not change the pH or the FTIR spectrum of the cosmetic serum indicating non-toxicity.

An antioxidation strategy based on ultra-small nanobubbles without exogenous antioxidants

Antioxidation is in demand in living systems, as the excessive reactive oxygen species (ROS) in organisms lead to a variety of diseases. The conventional antioxidation strategies are mostly based on the introduction of exogenous antioxidants. However, antioxidants usually have shortcomings of poor stability, non-sustainability, and potential toxicity. Here, we proposed a novel antioxidation strategy based on ultra-small nanobubbles (NBs), in which the gas-liquid interface was employed to enrich and scavenge ROS. It was found that the ultra-small NBs (~ 10 nm) exhibited a strong inhibition on oxidization of extensive substrates by hydroxyl radicals, while the normal NBs (~ 100 nm) worked only for some substrates. Since the gas-water interface of the ultra-small NBs is non-expendable, its antioxidation would be sustainable and its effect be cumulative, which is different to that using reactive nanobubbles to eliminate free radicals as the gases are consumptive and the reaction is unsustainable. Therefore, our antioxidation strategy based on ultra-small NB would provide a new solution for antioxidation in bioscience as well as other fields such as materials, chemical industry, food industry, etc.

Oxygen-Rich Graphene/ZnO2-Ag nanoframeworks with pH-Switchable Catalase/Peroxidase activity as O2 Nanobubble-Self generator for bacterial inactivation

The oxygen-rich organic/inorganic (reduced graphene oxide (rGO)/ZnO₂-Ag) nanoframeworks as suppliers of O₂ nanobubbles (NBs) with dual pH-and-temperature-sensitive behavior were developed to suppress bacterial growth. It was demonstrated that not only the rate but also the final product of oxygen-rich ZnO₂ decomposition (to an intermediate product of H₂O₂) rate was dramatically controlled by pH adjustment. Furthermore, in the presence of Ag nanoparticles, ̇OH radical generation switched to O₂ NBs evolution by shifting the pH from acidic to basic/neutral conditions, demonstrating an adjustable nanozyme function-ability between catalase and peroxidase-like activity, respectively. Antibacterial properties of the in-situ generated O₂ NBs substantially enhanced against bacterial models including methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus in the presence of rGO. In fact, deflecting the electrons from their main respiratory chain to an oxygen-rich bypath through rGO significantly stimulated reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation, combating bacteria more efficiently. Moreover, NIR laser irradiation-induced temperature rise (due to the inherent photothermal properties of rGO) facilitated ZnO₂ decomposition and accelerated growth and collapse of NBs. The simultaneous microscale thermal and mechanical destructions induced stronger antibacterial behavior. These results hold great promises for designing simple organic/inorganic nanoframeworks as solid sources of NBs with tunable enzyme-like ability in response to environmental conditions suitable for forthcoming graphene-based bio-applications.

Effects of Gas Type, Oil, Salts and Detergent on Formation and Stability of Air and Carbon Dioxide Bubbles Produced by Using a Nanobubble Generator

Recent developments in ultrafine bubble generation have opened up new possibilities for applications in various fields. Herein, we investigated how substances in water affect the size distribution and stability of microbubbles generated by a common nanobubble generator. By combining light scattering techniques with optical microscopy and high-speed imaging, we were able to track the evolution of microbubbles over time during and after bubble generation. Our results showed that air injection generated a higher number of microbubbles (<10 μm) than CO₂ injection. Increasing detergent concentration led to a rapid increase in the number of microbubbles generated by both air and CO₂ injection and the intensity signal detected by dynamic light scattering (DLS) slightly increased. This suggested that surface-active molecules may inhibit the growth and coalescence of bubbles. In contrast, we found that salts (NaCl and Na₂CO₃) in water did not significantly affect the number or size distribution of bubbles. Interestingly, the presence of oil in water increased the intensity signal and we observed that the bubbles were coated with an oil layer. This may contribute to the stability of bubbles. Overall, our study sheds light on the effects of common impurities on bubble generation and provides insights for analyzing dispersed bubbles in bulk.

Decrease in the Surface Tension of Nanobubble Dispersion in Water: Results of Surface Excess of Bulk Nanobubbles at Interfaces

The effect of nanobubbles (NBs) on the surface tension of liquid was investigated by three methods of different measuring principles, pendant drop (PD), Wilhelmy, and du Noüy methods, over a wide range of number concentration of bulk NBs (BNBs). In all of the three methods, the surface tension decreased in proportion to the number concentration of BNBs and the proportional constant was different among the three methods. Such behavior was inferred to be caused by the surface excess of BNBs at the gas-liquid or solid-liquid interface. In the PD method, the hydrophobic interaction between BNBs and air around a drop seems to cause the surface excess of BNBs along the surface of water drops. It brings about a subtle change in its profile, resulting in the decrease in surface tension, which takes a time of hundreds of seconds. Meanwhile, in the Wilhelmy and du Noüy methods, electrostatic attractive force between BNBs and a plate or ring is a likely cause of surface excess at the solid-liquid interface, resulting in the instantaneous decrease in surface tension. This study also provides a practical methodology of comparison for surface tension of NB dispersion: surface tension shall be compared among different samples with the same measurement method. Especially in the PD method, retention time of droplets before measurement shall be the same among samples.

Fast Formation of Hydrate Induced by Micro-Nano Bubbles: A Review of Current Status

Hydrate-based technologies have excellent application potential in gas separation, gas storage, transportation, and seawater desalination, etc. However, the long induction time and the slow formation rate are critical factors affecting the application of hydrate-based technologies. Micro-nano bubbles (MNBs) can dramatically increase the formation rate of hydrates owing to their advantages of providing more nucleation sites, enhancing mass transfer, and increasing the gas–liquid interface and gas solubility. Initially, the review examines key performance MNBs on hydrate formation and dissociation processes. Specifically, a qualitative and quantitative assembly of the formation and residence characteristics of MNBs during hydrate dissociation is conducted. A review of the MNB characterization techniques to identify bubble size, rising velocity, and bubble stability is also included. Moreover, the advantages of MNBs in reinforcing hydrate formation and their internal relationship with the memory effect are summarized. Finally, combining with the current MNBs to reinforce hydrate formation technology, a new technology of gas hydrate formation by MNBs combined with ultrasound is proposed. It is anticipated that the use of MNBs could be a promising sustainable and low-cost hydrate-based technology.

Clean production and characterization of nanobubbles using laser energy deposition

We have demonstrated the production of laser bulk nanobubbles (BNB) with ambient radii typically below 500 nm. The gaseous nature of the nanometric objects was confirmed by a focused acoustic pulse that expands the gas cavities to a size that can be visualized with optical microscopy. The BNBs were produced on demand by a collimated high-energy laser pulse in a "clean" way, meaning that no solid particles or drops were introduced in the sample by the generation method. This is a clear advantage relative to the other standard BNB production techniques. Accordingly, the role of nanometric particles in laser bubble production is discussed. The characteristics of the nanobubbles were evaluated with two alternative methods. The first one measures the response of the BNBs to acoustic pulses of increasing amplitude to estimate their rest radius through the calculation of the dynamics Blake threshold. The second one is based on the bubble dissolution dynamics and the correlation of the bubble's lifetime with its initial size. The high reproducibility of the present system in combination with automated data acquisition and analysis constitutes a sound tool for studying the effects of the liquid and gas properties on the stability of the BNBs solution.

Nanobubble technologies: Applications in therapy from molecular to cellular level

Nanobubbles are gaseous entities suspended in bulk liquids that have widespread beneficial usage in many industries. Nanobubbles are already proving to be versatile in furthering the effectiveness of disease treatment on cellular and molecular levels. They are functionalized with biocompatible and stealth surfaces to aid in the delivery of drugs. At the same time, nanobubbles serve as imaging agents due to the echogenic properties of the gas core, which can also be utilized for controlled and targeted delivery. This review provides an overview of the biomedical applications of nanobubbles, covering their preparation and characterization methods, discussing where the research is currently focused, and how they will help shape the future of biomedicine.

Experimental Investigation of Cavitation Bulk Nanobubbles Characteristics: Effects of pH and Surface-Active Agents

Nanobubbles (NBs) have a widespread application in antimicrobial activity, wastewater treatment, and ecological restoration due to numerous peculiar characteristics, such as small diameter, long-term stability, and ability to produce hydroxyl radicals. Despite significant applications, only limited comprehensive investigations are available on the role of surfactants and pH in NBs characteristics. Therefore, this study examines the effects of different surfactants (i.e., anionic, cationic, and nonionic) and pH medium on bulk NB formation, diameter, concentration, bubble size distribution (BSD), ζ-potential, and stability. The effect of surfactant at concentrations above and below the critical micelle concentration was investigated. NBs were generated in deionized (DI) water using a piezoelectric transducer. The stability of NBs was assessed by tracking the variation in diameter and concentration over time. In a neutral medium, the diameter of NBs is smaller than in other surfactant or pH mediums. The diameter, concentration, BSD, and stability of NBs are strongly influenced by the ζ-potential rather than the solution medium. BSD curve shifts to a smaller bubble diameter when the magnitude of ζ-potential is high in any solution. In pure water, surfactant, and pH mediums, NBs have existed for a long time. NBs have a shorter life span in environments with a pH ≤ 3. Surfactant adsorption on the surface of NBs increases with increasing surfactant concentration up to a certain limit, beyond which it declines substantially. The Derjaguin-Landau-Verwey-Overbeek (DLVO) theory was used to interpret the NBs stability, resulting in a total potential energy barrier that is positive and greater than 45.55 k_BT for 6 ≤ pH ≤ 11, whereas for pH < 6, the potential energy barrier essentially vanishes. Moreover, an effort has also been made to explicate the plausible prospect of ion distribution and its alignment surrounding NBs in cationic and anionic surfactants. This study will extend the in-depth investigation of NBs for industrial applications involving NBs.

Generation and stabilization of CO2 nanobubbles using surfactants for extraction of polyphenols from Camellia oleifera shells

Camellia oleifera shells are abundant in polyphenolic compounds. Green extraction methods of polyphenolic compounds are essential to ensure product quality, efficiency, process cost, environment, and safety. This study investigated the effect of Tween 80 and Rhamnolipid surfactants on the production and utilization of stabilized carbon dioxide nanobubbles (CO₂ -NBs). The results confirmed the presence of the CO₂ -NBs in ultra-pure water with a concentration of 8.45 ± 1.05 × 10⁸  ml^-1 , among which the stable CO₂ -NBs possessed a mean size of 40-90 nm and a negative zeta potential (-41.6 ± 1.3 mV). Further, the efficiency of CO₂ -NBs combined with ultrasonication (CO₂ -NBs-Rh-UAE) was evaluated to extract polyphenols from Camellia oleifera shells (waste). The CO₂ -NBs treatment with ultrasonication showed the highest total phenolic content (TPC) and total flavonoid content (TFC) (36.75 ± 0.22 mg GAE/g DW and 24.06 ± 0.22 mg RE/g DW, respectively). Overall, this study demonstrated an innovative approach for producing, stabilizing, and utilizing biosurfactant stabilized CO₂ -NBs to extract polyphenolic compounds from the waste agricultural products. These findings highlighted the potential application of biosurfactant-stabilized CO₂ -NBs.

Proliferative effects of nanobubbles on fibroblasts

In recent years, the potential of nanobubbles (NBs) for biological activation has been actively investigated. In this study, we investigated the proliferative effects of nitrogen NBs (N-NBs) on fibroblast cells using cell assays with image analysis and flow cytometry. A high concentration of N-NBs (more than 4 × 10⁸ NBs/mL) was generated in Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’s medium (DMEM) using a gas–liquid mixing method. In image analysis, the cells were counted and compared, which showed an 11% increase in cell number in the culture medium with N-NBs. However, in two further cell cytometry analyses, the effect of nanobubbles on cell division was found to be insignificant (approximately 2%); as there is insufficient evidence that N-NB is involved in cell division mechanism, further studies are needed to determine whether NB affects other cellular mechanisms such as apoptosis. This study presents the first successful attempt of directly generating and quantifying N-NBs in a culture medium for cell culture. The findings suggest that the N-NBs in the culture medium can potentially facilitate cell proliferation.

Generation methods, stability, detection techniques, and applications of bulk nanobubbles in agro-food industries: a review and future perspective

Nanobubble (NB) technologies have received considerable attention for various applications due to their low cost, eco-friendliness, scale-up potential, process control, and unique physical characteristics. NB stands for nanoscopic gaseous cavities, typically <1 μm in diameter. NBs can exist on surfaces (surface or interfacial NBs) and be dispersed in a bulk liquid phase (bulk NBs). Compared to the microbubbles, NBs exhibit high specific surface area, negative surface charge, and better adsorption. Bulk NBs can be generated by hydrodynamic/acoustic cavitation, electrolysis, water-solvent mixing, nano-membrane filtration, and so on. NBs exhibit extraordinary longevity compared to microbubbles, prompting the interest of the scientific community aiming for potential applications including medicine, agriculture, food, wastewater treatment, surface cleaning, and so on. Based on the limited amount of research work available regarding the influence of NBs on food matrices, further research, however, needs to be done to provide more insights into its applications in food industries. This review provides an overview of the generation methods for NBs, techniques to evaluate them, and a discussion of their stability and several applications in various fields of science were discussed. However, recent studies have revealed that, despite the many benefits of NB technologies, several NB generating approaches are still limited in their application in specific agro-food industries. Further study should focus on process optimization, integrating various NB generation techniques/combining with other emerging technologies in order to achieve rapid technical progress and industrialization of NB-based technologies.HighlightsNanobubbles (NBs) are stable spherical entities of gas within liquid and are operationally defined as having diameters less than 1 µm.Currently, various reported theories still lack the ability to explain the evidence and stability of NBs in water, numerous NB applications have emerged due to the unique properties of NBs.NB technologies can be applied to various food and dairy products (e.g. yogurt and ice cream) and other potential applications, including agriculture (e.g. seed germination and plant growth), wastewater treatment, surface cleaning, and so on.

Recent Developments in Generation, Detection and Application of Nanobubbles in Flotation

This paper reviews recent developments in the fundamental understating of ultrafine (nano) bubbles (NBs) and presents technological advances and reagent types used for their generation in flotation. The generation of NBs using various approaches including ultrasonication, solvent exchange, temperature change, hydrodynamic cavitation, and electrolysis was assessed. Most importantly, restrictions and opportunities with respect to the detection of NBs were comprehensively reviewed, focusing on various characterization techniques such as the laser particle size analyzer (LPSA), nanoparticle tracking (NTA), dynamic light scattering (DLS), zeta-phase light scattering (ZPALS), and zeta sizer. As a key feature, types and possible mechanisms of surfactants applied to stabilize NBs were also explored. Furthermore, flotation-assisted nano-bubbles was reported as an efficient method for recovering minerals, with a special focus on flotation kinetics. It was found that most researchers reported the existence and formation of NBs by different techniques, but there is not enough information on an accurate measurement of their size distribution and their commonly used reagents. It was also recognized that a suitable method for generating NBs, at a high rate and with a low cost, remains a technical challenge in flotation. The application of hydrodynamic cavitation based on a venturi tube and using the LPSA and NTA in laboratory scales were identified as the most predominant approaches for the generation and detection of NBs, respectively. In this regard, neither pilot- nor industrial-scale case studies were found in the literature; they were only highlighted as future works. Although the NB-stabilizing effects of electrolytes have been well-explored, the mechanisms related to surfactants remain the issue of further investigation. The effectiveness of the NB-assisted flotation processes has been mostly addressed for single minerals, and only a few works have been reported for bulk materials. Finally, we believe that the current review paves the way for an appropriate selection of generating and detecting ultrafine bubbles and shines the light on a profound understanding of its effectiveness.

Development of quantitative and concise measurement method of oxygen in fine bubble dispersion

Fine bubbles (FBs) have attracted significant attention in several research fields. Although some reports have argued that FB dispersion is useful as an oxygen (gas) carrier, only a few reports have examined its properties as an oxygen carrier using experimental data. As one of the reasons for this, there are no standard methods for measuring the oxygen content in FB dispersions. Conventional oxygen measurement methods have certain drawbacks in accuracy or speed; thus, it is difficult to use oxygen content as the primary outcome. In this study, we introduce a Clark-type polarographic oxygen electrode device (OXYG1-PLUS) for oxygen measurement, allowing the dilution of FB dispersion without the influence of ambient air and the adhesion of FBs on the electrode surface due to its special shape. First, the accuracy of our dilution method was evaluated using pure water as a sample, and it was confirmed that our method could measure with an accuracy of ±0.5 mg/L from the results with conventional dissolved oxygen meters. Second, the oxygen content in FB dispersion was evaluated with our method and a chemical titration method (Winkler’s method), and it was found that our method could measure the oxygen content in FB dispersions quantitively. This method satisfies the easiness (4 steps) and quickness (within 8 min) for a wide range of oxygen contents (0 to 332 mg/L, theoretical range) with low coefficient variation (< 4.7%) and requires a small sample volume (50–500 μL); thus, it is a useful method for measuring the oxygen in FB dispersions.

Ion adsorption stabilizes bulk nanobubbles

The mechanism leading to the extraordinary stability of bulk nanobubbles in aqueous solutions remains an outstanding problem in soft matter, modern surface science, and physical chemistry science. In this work, the stability of bulk nanobubbles in electrolyte solutions under different pH levels and ionic strengths is studied. Nanobubbles are generated via the technique of ultrasonic cavitation, and characterized for size, number concentration and zeta potential under ambient conditions. Experimental results show that nanobubbles can survive in both acidic and basic solutions with pH values far away from the isoelectric point. We attribute the enhanced stability with increasing acidity or alkalinity of the aqueous solutions to the effective accumulation of net charges, regardless of their sign. The kinetic stability of the nanobubbles in various aqueous solutions is evaluated within the classic DLVO framework. Further, by combining a modified Poisson-Boltzmann equation with a modified Langmuir adsorption model, we describe a simple model that captures the influence of ion species and bulk concentration and reproduce the dependence of the nanobubble's surface potential on pH. We also discuss the apparent contradiction between quantitative calculation by ion stabilization model and experimental results. This essentially requires insight into the structure and dynamics of interfacial water on the atomic-scale.

Molecular simulations on the stability and dynamics of bulk nanobubbles in aqueous environments

Nanobubbles have attracted significant attention due to their unexpectedly long lifetimes and stabilities in liquid solutions. However, explanations for the unique properties of nanobubbles at the molecular scale are somewhat controversial. Of special interest is the validity of the Young-Laplace equation in predicting the inner pressure of such bubbles. In this work, large-scale molecular dynamics simulations were performed to study the stability and diffusion of nanobubbles of methane in water. Two types of force field, atomistic and coarse-grained, were used to compare the calculated results. In accordance with predictions from the Young-Laplace equation, it was found that the inner pressure of the nanobubbles increased with decreasing nanobubble size. Consequently, a large pressure difference between the nanobubble and its surroundings resulted in the high solubility of methane molecules in water. The solubility was considered to enable nanobubble stability at exceptionally high pressures. Smaller bubbles were observed to be more mobile via Brownian motion. The calculated diffusion coefficient also showed a strong dependence on the nanobubble size. However, this active mobility of small nanobubbles also triggered a mutable nanobubble shape over time. Nanobubbles were also found to coalesce when they were sufficiently close. A critical distance between two nanobubbles was thus identified to avoid coalescence. These results provide insight into the behavior of nanobubbles in solution and the mechanism of their unique stability while withstanding high inner pressures.

Aeration and dissolution behavior of oxygen nanobubbles in water

HYPOTHESIS

Nanobubbles (NBs) in water elicit unique physicochemical and colloidal properties (e.g., high stability and longevity). Aeration kinetics and dissolution behavior of oxygen (O₂) NBs are assumed to be bubble size dependent.

EXPERIMENTS

As an indicator for aeration efficiency, volumetric mass transfer coefficient (K_L·a) was assessed by measuring the dissolved oxygen (DO) levels during aeration using O₂ NBs with different sizes. Mass transfer coefficient (K_L) was estimated by correlation analysis. Moreover, a modified Epstein-Plesset (EP) model was developed to predict the dissolution behavior by monitoring the DO and size changes during the dissolution of O₂ NBs in water.

FINDINGS

A higher rate of DO increase and a higher equilibrium DO level were both observed after aeration with NBs that present higher surface areas for the mass transfer of O₂ and a higher vapor pressure of O₂ to drive the partitioning equilibrium. Dissolution kinetics of O₂ NBs were highly dependent on the initial bubble size as indicated by the changes of bubble size and DO. Smaller NBs raised up DO faster, whereas larger NBs could lead to higher equilibrium DO levels. Moreover, the rate of DO decline and the quasi-steady DO levels both decreased when the dilution ratio increased, confirming that O₂ NBs dictates the DO level in water. Finally, the dissolving NBs may either swell or shrink according to the model prediction.

Generation of Bulk Nanobubbles by Self-Developed Venturi-Type Circulation Hydrodynamic Cavitation Device

Bulk nanobubbles (BNBs) have attracted substantial interest from academia and industry owing to their peculiar properties and extensive potential applications. However, a scalable engineering method needs to be developed. Herein, we developed a nanobubble generator based on venturi-type recirculating hydrodynamic cavitation. The existence of nanobubbles produced by our generator was confirmed using physicochemical test methods, including the Tyndall effect, multiple freeze-thaw degassing experiments, and trace metal analysis. Subsequently, the effects of different operating parameters (circulation time and operating pressure) on bulk nanobubble production and properties, as well as their stability, were investigated. The results suggest that the characteristics of BNBs varied with the circulation time (5-20 min) and operating pressure (2-5 bar). However, all the particle size distribution of BNBs had a bimodal distribution with a mean diameter of 180-210 nm for the different circulation time and operating pressures. For example, by increasing the circulation time from 5 to 20 min, the peak value of size distribution decreased from 333/122 nm to 218/52 nm, and the average sample scattering signal count rate (Avg. Count Rate) increased from 133 to 303 Kcps. The evaluation of the stability of the BNBs formed for the circulation time of 15 min and the operating pressure of 3 bar showed that they could continue existence and stability in the suspension for 72 h. The study results might provide a valuable method for further investigation of industrial applications of venturi-type nanobubble generators.

Biomedical nanobubbles and opportunities for microfluidics

The use of bulk nanobubbles in biomedicine is increasing in recent years, which is attributable to the array of therapeutic and diagnostic tools promised by developing bulk nanobubble technologies. From cancer drug delivery and ultrasound contrast enhancement to malaria detection and the diagnosis of acute donor tissue rejection, the potential applications of bulk nanobubbles are broad and diverse. Developing these technologies to the point of clinical use may significantly impact the quality of patient care. This review compiles and summarizes a representative collection of the current applications, fabrication techniques, and characterization methods of bulk nanobubbles in biomedicine. Current state-of-the-art generation methods are not designed to create nanobubbles of high concentration and low polydispersity, both characteristics of which are important for several bulk nanobubble applications. To date, microfluidics has not been widely considered as a tool for generating nanobubbles, even though the small-scale precision and real-time control offered by microfluidics may overcome the challenges mentioned above. We suggest possible uses of microfluidics for improving the quality of bulk nanobubble populations and propose ways of leveraging existing microfluidic technologies, such as organ-on-a-chip platforms, to expand the experimental toolbox of researchers working to develop biomedical nanobubbles.

The use of bulk nanobubbles in biomedicine is increasing in recent years. This translates into new opportunities for microfluidics, which may enable the generation of higher quality nanobubbles that lead to advances in diagnostics and therapeutics.

From Bubbles to Nanobubbles

Nanobubbles are classified into surface and bulk. The main difference between them is that the former is immobile, whereas the latter is mobile. The existence of sNBs has already been proven by atomic force microscopy, but the existence of bNBs is still open to discussion; there are strong indications, however, of its existence. The longevity of NBs is a long-standing problem. Theories as to the stability of sNBs reside on their immobile nature, whereas for bNBs, the landscape is not clear at the moment. In this preliminary communication, we explore the possibility of stabilizing a bNB by Brownian motion. It is shown that a fractal walk under specific conditions may leave the size of the bubble invariant.

Understanding the Stabilization of a Bulk Nanobubble: A Molecular Dynamics Analysis

Bulk nanobubbles (NBs) have received considerable attention because of their extensive potential applications, such as in ultrasound imaging and water management. Although multiple types of experimental evidence have supported the existence and stabilization of bulk NBs, the underlying mechanism remains unclear. This study numerically investigates the bulk NB stabilization with molecular dynamics (MD) methods: the all-atom (AA) MD simulation is used for NBs of several nanometers diameter; the coarse-grained (CG) MD simulation is for the NBs of about 100 nm. The NB properties are statistically obtained and analyzed, including the inner density, inner pressure, surface charge, interfacial hydrogen bond (HB), and gaseous diffusion. The results show that the gas inside an NB has ultrahigh density (tens of kilograms per cubic meter). A double-layer surface charge exists on the NB. The inner/outer layer is positively/negatively charged, and the electrostatic stress can counteract part of the surface tension. In addition, the interfacial HB is weakened by the interaction between gas and water molecules, causing less surface tension. The above features are beneficial to NB stabilization. The NB equilibrium radii solved by the interfacial mechanical equilibrium equation agree with the MD results, indicating that this equation can describe the force balance of an NB as small as several nanometers. Besides, supersaturation appears to be necessary for the NB thermodynamic equilibrium. Based on Henry's law and the ideal gas law, the theoretical analysis suggests that the stability of the NB thermodynamic equilibrium is conditional: the number of gas molecules in NBs should be more than half that dissolved in liquid. This study unravels a stabilized bulk NB's properties and discusses the NB equilibrium and stabilization mechanism, which will advance the understanding and application of bulk NBs.

Coarsening behavior of bulk nanobubbles in water

In recent years, minuscule gas bubbles called bulk nanobubbles (BNBs) have drawn increasing attention due to their unique properties and broad applicability in various technological fields, such as biomedical engineering, water treatment, and nanomaterials. However, questions remain regarding the stability and behavior of BNBs. In the present work, BNBs were generated in water using a gas-liquid mixing method. NB analysis was performed using a nanoparticle tracking analysis (NTA) method to investigate the coarsening behavior of BNBs in water over time. The diameters of the BNBs increased, and their cubic radii increased linearly (r³ ~ t) over time. While the concentration of BNBs decreased, the total volume of BNBs remained the same. The size distribution of the BNBs broadened, and the concentration of larger BNBs increased over time. These results indicate that relatively small BNBs disappeared due to dissolution and larger BNBs grew through mass transfer between BNBs instead of coalescence. In other words, BNBs underwent Ostwald ripening: gas molecules from smaller BNBs diffused through the continuous phase to be absorbed into larger BNBs.

Elucidating CO2 nanobubble interfacial reactivity and impacts on water chemistry

HYPOTHESIS

Carbon dioxide nanobubbles can increase effective gas-transfer to solution and enhance buffering capacity given the stable suspension in water of CO₂ gas within nanobubbles and the existence of larger gas/water interface.

EXPERIMENTS

The physico-chemical properties and responses of CO₂ nanobubbles were recorded at different generation times (10, 30, 50, and 70 min) and benchmarked against traditional macrobubbles of CO₂ for the same amount of delivered gas. Effective concentration of CO₂ was evaluated by measuring the buffer capacity (β). The size distribution of nanobubbles during the experiments was measured by Nanoparticle Track Analysis.

FINDINGS

The mass transfer coefficient (K_La) showed a dramatically increase by 11-fold for the same volume of gas delivered when using nanobubbles. The β values obtained for nanobubbles were 7 times higher than that of traditional bubbles which can lead to significant source of CO₂ availability by using the nanobubble method. Nanobubbles, consequently, undergo mass loss at higher pH corresponding to mass transfer process due to concentration gradient at the surrounding nanobubbles. This is the first report of CO₂ nanobubbles buffer capacity evaluation.

Micellization Transformations of Sodium Oleate Induced by Gas Nucleation

The interfacial properties of surfactant solutions are closely related to the micellization of surfactants. Temperature, salt type and concentration, pH, and other parameters affecting the micellization of surfactants have all been extensively investigated previously. However, the effect of dissolved gas on surfactant micellization and associated interfacial properties' transformations is not completely understood yet. In this study, sodium oleate (NaOl) was chosen as the research object, and the role of gas/gas nucleation in NaOl micellization was systematically investigated. The results indicated that the solution changed to be more turbid and the dissolved oxygen content increased after NaOl solutions were subjected to compression-decompression treatments. Meanwhile, the surface tension of the NaOl solution was altered, which was more pronounced when the concentration of NaOl was close to the critical micelle concentration. Given that the surface tension was a good indicator of the assembly and distribution state of the soluble monomers and insoluble micelles of NaOl, interactions between nucleated bubbles originating from the gas nucleation and NaOl molecules were unveiled through the analysis of the size distribution and zeta potential of sub-micro- and nanoscale particles in bulk solutions. Finally, possible micellization models of NaOl molecules, fully considering the role of gas/gas nucleation, were proposed under varying NaOl concentration conditions.

Stimuli-responsive nanobubbles for biomedical applications

Stimuli-responsive nanobubbles have received increased attention for their application in spatial and temporal resolution of diagnostic techniques and therapies, particularly in multiple imaging methods, and they thus have significant potential for applications in the field of biomedicine. This review presents an overview of the recent advances in the development of stimuli-responsive nanobubbles and their novel applications. Properties of both internal- and external-stimuli responsive nanobubbles are highlighted and discussed considering the potential features required for biomedical applications. Furthermore, the methods used for synthesis and characterization of nanobubbles are outlined. Finally, novel biomedical applications are proposed alongside the advantages and shortcomings inherent to stimuli-responsive nanobubbles.

On-Demand Bulk Nanobubble Generation through Pulsed Laser Illumination

We demonstrate the temporally and spatially controlled nucleation of bulk nanobubbles in water through pulsed laser irradiation with a collimated beam. Transient bubbles appear within the light exposed region once a tension wave passes through. The correlation between illumination and cavitation nucleation provides evidence that gaseous nanobubbles are nucleated in the liquid by a laser pulse with an intensity above 58  MW/cm^{2}. We estimate the radius of the nanobubbles through microscopic high-speed imaging and by solving the diffusion equation to be below 420 nm for ∼80% of the bubble population. This technique may provide a novel approach to test theories on existence of stable bulk nanobubbles.

Mechanical Strength and Hydration Characteristics of Cement Mixture with Highly Concentrated Hydrogen Nanobubble Water

In this study, highly concentrated hydrogen nanobubble water was utilized as the blending water for cement mortar to improve its compressive and flexural strengths. Highly concentrated nanobubbles can be obtained through osmosis. This concentration was maintained by sustaining the osmotic time. The mortar specimens were cured for 28 days, in which the nanobubble concentration was increased. This improved their flexural strength by 2.25–13.48% and compressive strength by 6.41–11.22%, as compared to those afforded by plain water. The nanobubbles were densified at high concentrations, which caused a decrease in their diameter. This increased the probability of collisions with the cement particles and accelerated the hydration and pozzolanic reactions, which facilitated an increase in the strength of cement. Thermogravimetric analysis and scanning electron microscopy were used to confirm the development of calcium silicate hydrate (C-S-H) and hydration products with an increase in the nanobubble concentration. Quantitative analysis of the hydration products and the degree of hydration were calculated by mineralogical analysis.

Stretch-Induced Cavitation: How Critical Cavity Radius and Barrier Energy, Radius, and Energy of a Stable Cavity Depend on the Stretching Factor

Characteristics of tension-induced cavitation, such as free energy at the barrier for cavitation, the size of the critical (barrier) cavity, the stable cavity size, and the free energy of the stable cavity, depend on the amount of tension (stretch) and the initial size of the sample. In this work, we study how the characteristics of the cavitation mentioned above scale with the amount of applied tension. We consider two models characterizing the properties of cavitating liquid: (a) a simple model with a linear tension-strain relation and neglect of curvature dependence of cavity surface tension and (b) a more realistic model with a nonlinear tension-strain relation and curvature-dependent surface tension. For both models, we find the relevant scaling relations when we stretch the initial volume of the liquid sample in the interval between 1% and 20% of the initial volume. Specific numerical tests are performed for the case of liquid water when the initial volume of the sample is a sphere with a radius of 100 nm.

Free-Radical Generation from Bulk Nanobubbles in Aqueous Electrolyte Solutions: ESR Spin-Trap Observation of Microbubble-Treated Water

Microbubbles are very fine bubbles that shrink and collapse underwater within several minutes, leading to the generation of free radicals. Electron spin resonance spectroscopy (ESR) confirmed the generation of hydroxyl radicals under strongly acidic conditions. The drastic environmental change caused by the collapse of the microbubbles may trigger radical generation via the dispersion of the elevated chemical potential that had accumulated around the gas-water interface. The present study also confirmed the generation of ESR signals from the microbubble-treated waters even after several months had elapsed following the dispersion of the microbubbles. Bulk nanobubbles were expected to be the source of the spin-adducts of hydroxyl radicals. Such microbubble stabilization and conversion might be caused by the formation of solid microbubble shells generated by iron ions in the condensed ionic cloud around the microbubble. Therefore, the addition of a strong acid might cause drastic changes in the environment and destroy the stabilized condition. This would restart the collapsing process, leading to hydroxyl radical generation.

Effect of Gas Type and Its Pressure on Nanobubble Generation

The dependence of the volume number density of ion-stabilized gas nanobubbles (bubstons) on the type of gas and the pressure created by this gas in deionized water and saline solution has been investigated. The range of external pressures from the saturated water vapor (17 Torr) to 5 atm was studied. It turned out that the growth rate of the volume number density of bubstons is controlled by the magnitude of the molecular polarizability of dissolved gases. The highest densities of bubstons were obtained for gases whose molecules have a dipole moment. At fixed external pressure and the polarizability of gas molecules, the addition of external ions leads to a sharp increase in the content of bubstons.

Probing Internal Pressures and Long-Term Stability of Nanobubbles in Water

Nanobubbles (NBs) in liquid exhibit many intriguing properties such as low buoyancy and high mass transfer efficiency and reactivity as compared to large bulk bubbles. However, it remains elusive why or how bulk NBs are stabilized in water, and particularly, the states of internal pressures of NBs are difficult to measure due to the lack of proper methodologies or instruments. This study employed the injection of high-pressure gases through a hydrophobized ceramic membrane to produce different gaseous NBs (e.g., N₂, O₂, H₂, and CO₂) in water, which is different from cavitation bubbles with potential internal low pressure and noncondensed gases. The results indicate that increasing the injection gas pressure (60-80 psi) and solution temperatures (6-40 °C) both reduced bubble sizes from approximately 400 to 200 nm, which are validated by two independent models developed from the Young-Laplace equation and contact mechanics. Particularly, the colloidal force model can explain the effects of surface tension and surface charge repulsion on bubble sizes and internal pressures. The contact mechanics model incorporates the measurement of the tip-bubble interaction forces by atomic force microscopy to determine the internal pressures and the hardness of NBs (e.g., Young's modulus). Both the colloidal force balance model and our contact mechanics model yielded consistent predictions of the internal pressures of various NBs (120-240 psi). The developed methods and model framework will be useful to unravel properties of NBs and support engineering applications of NBs (e.g., aeration or ozonation). Finally, the bulk NBs under sealed storage could be stable for around a week and progressively reduce in concentrations over the next 30-60 days.

Generating Bulk Nanobubbles in Alcohol Systems

Bulk nanobubbles (NBs) have attracted wide attention due to their peculiar physicochemical properties and great potential in applications in various fields. However, so far there are no reports on bulk NBs generated in pure organic systems, which we think is very important as NBs would largely improve the efficiency of gas-liquid mass transfer and facilitate chemical reactions to take place. In this paper, we verified that air and N₂ NBs could be generated in a series of alcohol solutions by using various methods including acoustical cavitation, pressurization-depressurization, and vibration. The experiments proved that NBs existed in alcohol solutions, with a highest density of 5.8 × 10⁷ bubble/mL in propanol. Our results also indicated that bulk NBs could stably exist for at least hours in alcohol systems. The parameters in generating NBs in alcohols were optimized. Our findings open up an opportunity for improving gas-liquid mass transfer efficiency in the field of the chemical industry.