Rediscovering the Monodispersity of Sulfonatocalix[4]arene-Based Micelles

Unravel-engineer-design: a three-pronged approach to advance ionomer performance at interfaces in proton exchange membrane fuel cells

Proton exchange membrane fuel cells (PEMFCs), which use hydrogen as fuel, present an eco-friendly alternative to internal combustion engines (ICEs) for powering low-to-heavy-duty vehicles and various devices. Despite their promise, PEMFCs must meet strict cost, performance, and durability standards to reach their full potential. A key challenge lies in optimizing the electrode, where a thin ionomer layer is responsible for proton conduction and binding catalyst particles to the electrode. Enhancing ion transport within these sub-μm thick films is critical to improving the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) at the cathodes of PEMFCs. For the past 15 years, our research has targeted this limitation through a comprehensive "Unravel - Engineer - Design" approach. We first unraveled the behavior of ionomers, gaining deeper insights into both the average and distributed proton conduction properties within sub-μm thick films and at interfaces that mimic catalyst binder layers. Next, we engineered ionomer-substrate interfaces to gain control over interfacial makeup and boost proton conductivity, essential for PEMFC efficiency. Finally, we designed novel nature-derived or nature-inspired, fluorine-free ionomers to tackle the ion transport limitations seen in state-of-the-art ionomers under thin-film confinement. Some of these ionomers even pave the way to address cost and sustainability challenges in PEMFC materials. This feature article highlights our contributions and their importance in advancing PEMFCs and other sustainable energy conversion and storage technologies.

Is Structural Precision of Platonic Micelles Controlled Solely by Close-Packed Head Groups or Also by Hydrophobic Tail Packing? A DFT Exploration

Platonic micelles have been defined as structurally precise amphiphilic aggregates with discrete aggregation numbers corresponding to the close packing of spherical caps (representing head groups) on a sphere (representing hydrophobic core), analogous to the Tammes problem in geometry. Here, we use DFT to explore how an actual molecule behaves compared to the idealized picture based on the Tammes problem by also considering the packing of the tails. We modeled micelles of aggregation numbers 4 to 8 generated from the calix[4]arene amphiphile, PACaL3, with the tails forming a close-packed configuration while the headgroups are arranged as in Platonic solids. The DFT calculations reveal that tail packing overwhelmingly influences the equilibrium aggregation number. While the DFT prediction of a PACaL3 micelle of aggregation number 6 agrees with the scattering experiments of the Sakurai group, DFT calculations also suggest small concentrations of micelles of aggregation number 7. More interestingly, DFT calculations reveal that PACaL3 micelle formation occurs even though less than 20% of the hydrophobic tail surface is removed from contact with water, in contrast to the roughly 80% removal observed for classical surfactant micelles. While the close-packed head groups model predicts higher coverage of the hydrophobic surface for aggregation numbers 4 and 6 compared to 5 and 7, the DFT calculations also accounting for tail packing show that the surface coverage for aggregation numbers 5 and 7 is practically no different than that for aggregation number 4. Finally, although both the close-packed head groups model and the DFT calculations agree that the exposed hydrophobic surface area controls the equilibrium micelle aggregation number, the DFT calculations demonstrate how this exposed hydrophobic area is overwhelmingly determined by the tail group packing and not just by the close packing of head groups.

Non-dependence of dodecamer structures on alkyl chain length in Platonic micelles

When the micellar aggregation number (Nagg) is sufficiently small (Nagg < 30), the micelle shows an abnormal aggregation behavior: monodispersity without any distribution in Nagg, whose values coincide with the vertex number of a regular polyhedral structure, i.e., they are termed Platonic solids. Micelles with these characteristics are named "Platonic micelles". In this study, we investigated the aggregation behavior of calixarene-based micelles bearing primary amines-the first example of Platonic micelles-with increasing alkyl chain length by small-angle X-ray scattering, asymmetrical flow field flow fractionation coupled with multiangle light scattering, and analytical ultracentrifugation measurements. Morphological transition of the micelles from spherical to cylindrical was observed when the alkyl chain length was increased in this calixarene-based micellar system, which is similar to the case of conventional systems and is acceptable in terms of the packing parameter principle. However, although the micellar Nagg normally increases with an increase in the alkyl chain length, the structure of calixarene-based Platonic micelles bearing butyl (C4), heptyl (C5), and hexyl (C6) chains remains at 12-mer. This is presumably due to the relationship between the thermodynamic stability of the Platonic micelles and the coverage ratio defined by the Tammes problem.

Discrete and Discontinuous Increase in the Micellar Aggregation Number: Effects of the Alkyl Chain Length on Platonic Micelles

Micelles with perfect monodispersity in terms of the aggregation number ( N_agg) have recently been discovered, whose values of N_agg interestingly always coincide with the vertex or face number of regular polyhedral structures (i.e., Platonic solids). Owing to the monodispersity of the micelles, named Platonic micelles, we could expect them to exhibit unprecedented aggregation behavior. In this study, the effects of alkyl chain length on micellar aggregation behavior were characterized using small-angle scattering techniques such as small-angle X-ray scattering and asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation coupled with multi-angle light scattering, as well as analytical ultracentrifugation measurements. The N_agg of Platonic micelles discretely and discontinuously increased when increasing the alkyl chain length, which differs markedly from the findings for conventional micelles. This aggregation behavior could be reasonably explained by the relationship between the thermodynamic stability of the micelles and the coverage density defined by one of the unsolved mathematical problems: the Tammes problem.

Morphological Transition of Oppositely Charged Calix[4]arene Surfactant Mixture

When a negatively charged sulfonic or a positively charged amine group is attached to calix[4]arene surfactants, denoted as SCal7 and QACal7, respectively, each system forms monodispersed spherical micelles with a defined aggregation number. We postulated that these defined monodisperse aggregations can be adjusted in terms of the coverage, that is, how efficiently can a spherical surface (, hydrophobic domain) be covered with identical caps (hydrophilic headgroup). We carried out small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), as well as titration calorimetry and dynamic light scattering (DLS), to observe the morphologies of the mixtures of these two components. The calorimetry showed a 1:1 stoichiometric exothermic reaction with a rather large binding constant. This means that, once the twin is formed from QACal7 and SCal7, these components hardly separate. SAXS showed that the spherical micelles changed to cylindrical ones and then to vesicle shapes as the composition reached a ratio of 1:1. At some intermediate compositions, mixtures of cylinders and plates (or spheres) were observed, which were confirmed by dynamic light scattering. We assume that the twin has a larger packing parameter than the individuals because of the cancellation of the charges between the sulfonic and the amine groups, and thus, the increase of the twin composition induces the entire morphology change, as expected from the packing parameter principle. In the present case, the coverage may be a secondary factor determining the morphology.