Influence of the SPR Experimental Conditions on the G-Quadruplex DNA Recognition by Porphyrin Derivatives

Effect of molecular crowders on ligand binding kinetics with G-quadruplex DNA probed by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

Guanine-rich single-stranded DNA folds into G-quadruplex DNA (GqDNA) structures, which play crucial roles in various biological processes. These structures are also promising targets for ligands, potentially inducing antitumor effects. While thermodynamic parameters of ligand/DNA interactions are well-studied, the kinetics of ligand interaction with GqDNA, particularly in cell-like crowded environments, remain less explored. In this study, we investigate the impact of molecular crowding agents (glucose, sucrose, and ficoll 70) at physiologically relevant concentrations (20% w/v) on the association and dissociation rates of the benzophenoxazine-core based ligand, cresyl violet (CV), with human telomeric antiparallel-GqDNA. We utilized fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) along with other techniques. Our findings reveal that crowding agents decrease the binding affinity of CV to GqDNA, with the most significant effect-a nearly three-fold decrease-observed with ficoll 70. FCS measurements indicate that this decrease is primarily due to a viscosity-induced slowdown of ligand association in the crowded environment. Interestingly, dissociation rates remain largely unaffected by smaller crowders, with only small effect observed in presence of ficoll 70 due to direct but weak interaction between the ligand and ficoll. These results along with previously reported data provide valuable insights into ligand/GqDNA interactions in cellular contexts, suggesting a conserved mechanism of saccharide crowder influence, regardless of variations in GqDNA structure and ligand binding mode. This underscores the importance of considering crowding effects in the design and development of GqDNA-targeted drugs for potential cancer treatment.

Systematic Evaluation of Benchmark G4 Probes and G4 Clinical Drugs using three Biophysical Methods: A Guideline to Evaluate Rapidly G4-Binding Affinity

G-quadruplex DNA structures (G4) are proven to interfere with most genetic and epigenetic processes. Small molecules binding these structures (G4 ligands) are invaluable tools to probe G4-biology and address G4-druggability in various diseases (cancer, viral infections). However, the large number of reported G4 ligands (>1000) could lead to confusion while selecting one for a given application. Herein we conducted a systematic affinity ranking of 11 popular G4 ligands vs 5 classical G4 sequences using FRET-melting, G4-FID assays and SPR. Interestingly SPR data globally align with the rankings obtained from the two semi-quantitative assays despite discrepancies due to limits and characteristics of each assay. In the whole, PhenDC3 emerges as the most potent binder irrespective of the G4 sequence. Immediately below PDS, PDC-360A, BRACO19, TMPyP4 and RHPS4 feature strong to medium binding again with poor G4 topology discrimination. More strikingly, the G4 drugs Quarfloxin, CX5461 and c-PDS exhibit weak affinity with all G4s studied. Finally, NMM and Cu-ttpy showed heterogeneous behaviors due, in part, to their physicochemical particularities poorly compatible with screening conditions. The remarkable properties of PhenDC3 led us to propose its use for benchmarking FRET-melting and G4-FID assays for rapid G4-affinity evaluation of newly developed ligands.

Investigating the NRAS 5' UTR as a target for small molecules

Neuroblastoma RAS (NRAS) is an oncogene that is deregulated and highly mutated in cancers including melanomas and acute myeloid leukemias. The 5' untranslated region (UTR) (5' UTR) of the NRAS mRNA contains a G-quadruplex (G4) that regulates translation. Here we report a novel class of small molecule that binds to the G4 structure located in the 5' UTR of the NRAS mRNA. We used a small molecule microarray screen to identify molecules that selectively bind to the NRAS-G4 with submicromolar affinity. One compound inhibits the translation of NRAS in vitro but showed only moderate effects on the NRAS levels in cellulo. Rapid Amplification of cDNA Ends and RT-PCR analysis revealed that the predominant NRAS transcript does not possess the G4 structure. Thus, although NRAS transcripts lack a G4 in many cell lines the concept of targeting folded regions within 5' UTRs to control translation remains a highly attractive strategy.

DNA G-quadruplex-stabilizing metal complexes as anticancer drugs

Guanine quadruplexes (G4s) are important targets for cancer treatments as their stabilization has been associated with a reduction of telomere ends or a lower oncogene expression. Although less abundant than purely organic ligands, metal complexes have shown remarkable abilities to stabilize G4s, and a wide variety of techniques have been used to characterize the interaction between ligands and G4s. However, improper alignment between the large variety of experimental techniques and biological activities can lead to improper identification of top candidates, which hampers progress of this important class of G4 stabilizers. To address this, we first review the different techniques for their strengths and weaknesses to determine the interaction of the complexes with G4s, and provide a checklist to guide future developments towards comparable data. Then, we surveyed 74 metal-based ligands for G4s that have been characterized to the in vitro level. Of these complexes, we assessed which methods were used to characterize their G4-stabilizing capacity, their selectivity for G4s over double-stranded DNA (dsDNA), and how this correlated to bioactivity data. For the biological activity data, we compared activities of the G4-stabilizing metal complexes with that of cisplatin. Lastly, we formulated guidelines for future studies on G4-stabilizing metal complexes to further enable maturation of this field.

G-Tetrad-Selective Ligand Binding Kinetics in G-Quadruplex DNA Probed with Fluorescence Correlation Spectroscopy

Probing the kinetics of ligand binding to biomolecules is of paramount interest in biology and pharmacology. Measurements of such kinetic processes provide information on the rate-determining steps that control the binding affinity of ligands to biomolecules, thereby predicting the mechanism of the molecular interaction. In this context, ligand binding to G-quadruplex DNA (GqDNA) structures has attracted tremendous attention primarily because of their use in possible anticancer therapy. Although a large number of G-quadruplex-specific ligands have been proposed, probing the kinetics of G-tetrad-selective binding of (multiple) ligands within a G-quadruplex DNA (GqDNA) structure remains challenging. Most of the earlier studies focused on the thermodynamics of ligand binding; however, the kinetics of ligand association and dissociation with GqDNA, particularly binding of multiple ligands within a GqDNA structure, have not been explored. Here, we propose a simple fluorescence correlation spectroscopy-based method that measures the G-tetrad-selective association and dissociation rates of ligands within a GqDNA structure by correlating the fluorescence fluctuations of a site-specific (5' or 3' end-labeled) fluorophore (Cy3) in GqDNA due to quenching of Cy3 fluorescence, induced by the ligand binding to the G-tetrads. We show that well-known GqDNA ligands, BRACO19, TMPyP4, Hoechst 33258, and Hoechst 33342, have G-tetrad-selective association and dissociation rates, which suggest site-dependent variation of free energy barriers for binding/unbinding of the ligands with GqDNA. We also show that the measured kinetic rates depend not only on the G-tetrad site (5' vs 3' end) but also on the ligand and GqDNA structures.

Combining Electrospray Mass Spectrometry (ESI-MS) and Computational Techniques in the Assessment of G-Quadruplex Ligands: A Hybrid Approach to Optimize Hit Discovery

Guanine-rich sequences forming G-quadruplexes (GQs) are present in several genomes, ranging from viral to human. Given their peculiar localization, the induction of GQ formation or GQ stabilization with small molecules represents a strategy for interfering with crucial biological functions. Investigating the recognition event at the molecular level, with the aim of fully understanding the triggered pharmacological effects, is challenging. Native electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) is being optimized to study these noncovalent assemblies. Quantitative parameters retrieved from ESI-MS studies, such as binding affinity, the equilibrium binding constant, and sequence selectivity, will be overviewed. Computational experiments supporting the ESI-MS investigation and boosting its efficiency in the search for GQ ligands will also be discussed with practical examples. The combination of ESI-MS and in silico techniques in a hybrid high-throughput-screening workflow represents a valuable tool for the medicinal chemist, providing data on the quantitative and structural aspects of ligand–GQ interactions.

G-Quadruplexes and Their Ligands: Biophysical Methods to Unravel G-Quadruplex/Ligand Interactions

Progress in the design of G-quadruplex (G4) binding ligands relies on the availability of approaches that assess the binding mode and nature of the interactions between G4 forming sequences and their putative ligands. The experimental approaches used to characterize G4/ligand interactions can be categorized into structure-based methods (circular dichroism (CD), nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy and X-ray crystallography), affinity and apparent affinity-based methods (surface plasmon resonance (SPR), isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) and mass spectrometry (MS)), and high-throughput methods (fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET)-melting, G4-fluorescent intercalator displacement assay (G4-FID), affinity chromatography and microarrays. Each method has unique advantages and drawbacks, which makes it essential to select the ideal strategies for the biological question being addressed. The structural- and affinity and apparent affinity-based methods are in several cases complex and/or time-consuming and can be combined with fast and cheap high-throughput approaches to improve the design and development of new potential G4 ligands. In recent years, the joint use of these techniques permitted the discovery of a huge number of G4 ligands investigated for diagnostic and therapeutic purposes. Overall, this review article highlights in detail the most commonly used approaches to characterize the G4/ligand interactions, as well as the applications and types of information that can be obtained from the use of each technique.

Surface plasmon resonance study of the interaction of N-methyl mesoporphyrin IX with G-quadruplex DNA

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) was used to investigate the interaction between N-methyl mesoporphyrin IX (NMM) and different G-quadruplex (G4) topologies. The study was associated with circular dichroism analysis (CD) to assess the topology of the G4s when they interacted with NMM. We demonstrate the high selectivity of NMM for the parallel G4 structure with a dissociation constant at least ten times lower than those of other G4 topologies. We also confirm the ability of NMM to shift the G4 conformation from both the hybrid and antiparallel topologies toward the parallel structure.

Evaluation of an Analogue of the Marine ε-PLL Peptide as a Ligand of G-quadruplex DNA Structures

ε-poly-l-Lysine (ε-PLL) peptide is a product of the marine bacterium Bacillus subtilis with antibacterial and anticancer activity largely used worldwide as a food preservative. ε-PLL and its synthetic analogue α,ε-poly-l-lysine (α,ε-PLL) are also employed in the biomedical field as enhancers of anticancer drugs and for drug and gene delivery applications. Recently, several studies reported the interaction between these non-canonical peptides and DNA targets. Among the most important DNA targets are the DNA secondary structures known as G-quadruplexes (G4s) which play relevant roles in many biological processes and disease-related mechanisms. The search for novel ligands capable of interfering with G4-driven biological processes elicits growing attention in the screening of new classes of G4 binders. In this context, we have here investigated the potential of α,ε-PLL as a G4 ligand. In particular, the effects of the incubation of two different models of G4 DNA, i.e., the parallel G4 formed by the Pu22 (d[TGAGGGTGGGTAGGGTGGGTAA]) sequence, a mutated and shorter analogue of the G4-forming sequence known as Pu27 located in the promoter of the c-myc oncogene, and the hybrid parallel/antiparallel G4 formed by the human Tel22 (d[AGGGTTAGGGTTAGGGTTAGGG]) telomeric sequence, with α,ε-PLL are discussed in the light of circular dichroism (CD), UV, fluorescence, size exclusion chromatography (SEC), and surface plasmon resonance (SPR) evidence. Even though the SPR results indicated that α,ε-PLL is capable of binding with µM affinity to both the G4 models, spectroscopic and SEC investigations disclosed significant differences in the structural properties of the resulting α,ε-PLL/G4 complexes which support the use of α,ε-PLL as a G4 ligand capable of discriminating among different G4 topologies.

Scaffold stabilization of a G-triplex and study of its interactions with G-quadruplex targeting ligands

G-triplex nucleic acid structures (G3) have been conjectured to form in vivo but little is known about their physiological functions. The identification of ligands capable of specific binding to G3 structures is therefore highly appealing but remains elusive. Here we report on the assembly of a DNA conjugate which folds into a stable G3 structure. The structural mimic was used to probe the interactions between a G3 ligand and first-in-class G4 ligands, revealing signification binding promiscuity.