Protein Translocation Activity in Surface-Supported Lipid Bilayers

Atomic force microscope kymograph analysis: A case study of two membrane proteins

Kymograph analysis is employed across the biological atomic force microscopy (AFM) community to boost temporal resolution. The method is well suited for revealing protein dynamics at the single molecule level in near-native conditions. Yet, kymograph analysis comes with limitations that depend on several factors including protein geometry and instrumental drift. This work focuses on conformational dynamics of difficult-to-study sparse distributions of membrane proteins. We compare and contrast AFM kymograph analysis for two proteins, one of which (SecDF) exhibits conformational dynamics primarily in the vertical direction (normal to the membrane surface) and the other (Pgp) exhibits a combination of lateral dynamics and vertical motion. Common experimental issues are analyzed including translational and rotational drift. Conformational transition detection is evaluated via kymograph simulations followed by state detection algorithms. We find that kymograph analysis is largely robust to lateral drift. Displacement of the AFM line scan trajectory away from the protein center of mass by a few nanometers, roughly half of the molecule diameter, does not significantly affect transition detection nor generate undue dwell time errors. On the other hand, for proteins like Pgp that exhibit significant azimuthal maximum height dependence, rotational drift can potentially produce artifactual transitions. Measuring the height of a membrane protein protrusion is generally superior to measurement of width, confirming intuition based on vertical resolution superiority. In low signal-to-noise scenarios, common state detection algorithms struggle with transition detection as opposed to infinite hidden Markov models. AFM kymography represents a valuable addition to the membrane biophysics toolkit; continued hardware and software improvements are poised to expand the method's impact in the field.

Advantages and potential limitations of applying AFM kymograph analysis to pharmaceutically relevant membrane proteins in lipid bilayers

Membrane proteins play critical roles in disease and in the disposition of many pharmaceuticals. A prime example is P-glycoprotein (Pgp) which moves a diverse range of drugs across membranes and out of the cell before a therapeutic payload can be delivered. Conventional structural biology methods have provided a valuable framework for comprehending the complex conformational changes underlying Pgp function, which also includes ATPase activity, but the lack of real-time information hinders understanding. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) is a single-molecule technique that is well-suited for studying active membrane proteins in bilayers and is poised to advance the field beyond static snapshots. After verifying Pgp activity in surface-support bilayers, we used kymograph analysis in conjunction with AFM imaging and simulations to study structural transitions at the 100 ms timescale. Though kymographs are frequently employed to boost temporal resolution, the limitations of the method have not been well characterized, especially for sparse non-crystalline distributions of pharmaceutically relevant membrane proteins like Pgp. Common experimental challenges are analyzed, including protein orientation, instrument noise, and drift. Surprisingly, a lateral drift of 75% of the protein dimension leads to only a 12% probability of erroneous state transition detection; average dwell time error achieves a maximum value of 6%. Rotational drift of proteins like Pgp, with azimuthally-dependent maximum heights, can lead to artifactual transitions. Torsional constraints can alleviate this potential pitfall. Confidence in detected transitions can be increased by adding conformation-altering ligands such as non-hydrolysable analogs. Overall, the data indicate that AFM kymographs are a viable method to access conformational dynamics for Pgp, but generalizations of the method should be made with caution.

Atomic Force Microscopy Reveals Complexity Underlying General Secretory System Activity

The translocation of specific polypeptide chains across membranes is an essential activity for all life forms. The main components of the general secretory (Sec) system of E. coli include integral membrane translocon SecYEG, peripheral ATPase SecA, and SecDF, an ancillary complex that enhances polypeptide secretion by coupling translocation to proton motive force. Atomic force microscopy (AFM), a single-molecule imaging technique, is well suited to unmask complex, asynchronous molecular activities of membrane-associated proteins including those comprising the Sec apparatus. Using AFM, the dynamic structure of membrane-external protein topography of Sec system components can be directly visualized with high spatial-temporal precision. This mini-review is focused on AFM imaging of the Sec system in near-native fluid conditions where activity can be maintained and biochemically verified. Angstrom-scale conformational changes of SecYEG are reported on 100 ms timescales in fluid lipid bilayers. The association of SecA with SecYEG, forming membrane-bound SecYEG/SecA translocases, is directly visualized. Recent work showing topographical aspects of the translocation process that vary with precursor species is also discussed. The data suggests that the Sec system does not employ a single translocation mechanism. We posit that differences in the spatial frequency distribution of hydrophobic content within precursor sequences may be a determining factor in mechanism selection. Precise AFM investigations of active translocases are poised to advance our currently vague understanding of the complicated macromolecular movements underlying protein export across membranes.

Looking into a crystal ball: printing and patterning self-assembled peptide nanostructures

The solution processability of organic semiconductors and conjugated polymers along with the advent of nanomaterials as conducting inks have revolutionized next-generation flexible consumer electronics. Another equally important class of nanomaterials, self-assembled peptides, heralded as next-generation materials for bioelectronics, have a lot of potential in printed technology. In this minireview, we address the self-assembly process in dipeptides, their application in electronics, and recent progress in three-dimensional printing. The prospect of a generalizable path for nanopatterning self-assembled peptides using ice lithography and its challenges are further discussed.

The conformations and basal conformational dynamics of translocation factor SecDF vary with translocon SecYEG interaction

The general secretory, or Sec, system is a primary protein export pathway from the cytosol of Escherichia coli and all eubacteria. Integral membrane protein complex SecDF is a translocation factor that enhances polypeptide secretion, which is driven by the Sec translocase, consisting of translocon SecYEG and ATPase SecA. SecDF is thought to utilize a proton gradient to effectively pull precursor proteins from the cytoplasm into the periplasm. Working models have been developed to describe the structure and function of SecDF, but important mechanistic questions remain unanswered. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) is a powerful technique for studying the dynamics of single-molecule systems including membrane proteins in near-native conditions. The sharp tip of the AFM provides direct access to membrane-external protein conformations. Here, we acquired AFM images and kymographs (∼100 ms resolution) to visualize SecDF protrusions in near-native supported lipid bilayers and compared the experimental data to simulated AFM images based on static structures. When studied in isolation, SecDF exhibited a stable and compact conformation close to the lipid bilayer surface, indicative of a resting state. Interestingly, upon SecYEG introduction, we observed changes in both SecDF conformation and conformational dynamics. The population of periplasmic protrusions corresponding to an intermediate form of SecDF, which is thought to be active in precursor protein handling, increased >9-fold. In conjunction, our dynamics measurements revealed an enhancement in the transition rate between distinct SecDF conformations when the translocon was present. Together, this work provides a novel vista of basal-level SecDF conformational dynamics in near-native conditions.

Atomic force microscopy for quantitative understanding of peptide-induced lipid bilayer remodeling

A number of peptides are known to bind lipid bilayer membranes and cause these natural barriers to leak in an uncontrolled manner. Though membrane permeabilizing peptides play critical roles in cellular activity and may have promising future applications in the therapeutic arena, significant questions remain about their mechanisms of action. The atomic force microscope (AFM) is a single molecule imaging tool capable of addressing lipid bilayers in near-native fluid conditions. The apparatus complements traditional assays by providing local topographic maps of bilayer remodeling induced by membrane permeabilizing peptides. The information garnered from the AFM includes direct visualization and statistical analyses of distinct bilayer remodeling modes such as highly localized pore-like voids in the bilayer and dispersed thinned membrane regions. Colocalization of distinct remodeling modes can be studied. Here we examine recent work in the field and outline methods used to achieve precise AFM image data. Experimental challenges and common pitfalls are discussed as well as techniques for unbiased analysis including the Hessian blob detection algorithm, bootstrapping, and the Bayesian information criterion. When coupled with robust statistical analyses, high precision AFM data is poised to advance understanding of an important family of peptides that cause poration of membrane bilayers.

Methodologies for Measuring Protein Trafficking across Cellular Membranes

Nearly all proteins are synthesized in the cytosol. The majority of this proteome must be trafficked elsewhere, such as to membranes, to subcellular compartments, or outside of the cell. Proper trafficking of nascent protein is necessary for protein folding, maturation, quality control and cellular and organismal health. To better understand cellular biology, molecular and chemical technologies to properly characterize protein trafficking (and mistrafficking) have been developed and applied. Herein, we take a biochemical perspective to review technologies that enable spatial and temporal measurement of protein distribution, focusing on both the most widely adopted methodologies and exciting emerging approaches.

Atomic Force Microscopy Reveals Membrane Protein Activity at the Single Molecule Level

Atomic force microscopy has emerged as a valuable complementary technique in membrane structural biology. The apparatus is capable of probing individual membrane proteins in fluid lipid bilayers at room temperature with spatial resolution at the molecular length scale. Protein conformational dynamics are accessible over a range of biologically relevant timescales. This chapter presents methodology our group uses to achieve robust AFM image data of the General Secretory system, the primary pathway of protein export from the cytoplasm to the periplasm of E. coli. Emphasis is given to measuring and maintaining biochemical activity and to objective AFM image processing methods. For example, the biochemical assays can be used to determine chemomechanical coupling efficiency of surface adsorbed translocases. The Hessian blob algorithm and its extension to nonlocalized linear features, the line detection algorithm, provide automated feature delineations. Many of the methods discussed here can be applied to other membrane protein systems of interest.

Comparison of Single and Multiple Turnovers of SecYEG in Escherichia coli

Precursor proteins are translocated across the cytoplasmic membrane in Escherichia coli by the general secretory, or Sec, pathway. The main components of the pathway are the integral membrane heterotrimeric SecYEG complex and the peripheral membrane ATPase, SecA. In this study, we have applied an in vitro assay using inverted cytoplasmic membrane vesicles to investigate the complex cycle that leads to translocation. We compared the apparent rate constants for nine precursors under two experimental conditions, single turnover and multiple turnovers. For each precursor, the rate constant for a single turnover was higher than for multiple turnovers, indicating that a different step limits the rate under the two conditions. We conclude that the rate-limiting step for a single turnover is an early step in the initial phase of transit through the channel, whereas the rate of multiple turnovers is limited by the resetting of the translocon. The presence of the chaperone SecB during multiple turnovers increased the maximal amplitude translocated for the three precursor species tested, pGBP, pPhoA, and proOmpA, and also increased the apparent rate constants for both pGBP and pPhoA. The rate constant for proOmpA was decreased by the presence of SecB.IMPORTANCE Vastly different experimental techniques and conditions have been used to study export in E. coli We demonstrated that altering experimental conditions can change the step that is observed during study. Investigators should consider specific experimental conditions when comparing data from different laboratories, as well as when comparing data from different experiments within a laboratory. We have shown that each precursor species has inherent properties that determine the translocation rate; thus generalizations from studies of a single species must be made with caution. A summary of advantages and disadvantages in use of nine precursors is presented.