Characterizing the Supported Lipid Membrane Formation from Cholesterol-Rich Bicelles

Elucidating Structural Configuration of Lipid Assemblies for mRNA Delivery Systems

The development of mRNA delivery systems utilizing lipid-based assemblies holds immense potential for precise control of gene expression and targeted therapeutic interventions. Despite advancements in lipid-based gene delivery systems, a critical knowledge gap remains in understanding how the biophysical characteristics of lipid assemblies and mRNA complexes influence these systems. Herein, we investigate the biophysical properties of cationic liposomes and their role in shaping mRNA lipoplexes by comparing various fabrication methods. Notably, an innovative fabrication technique called the liposome under cryo-assembly (LUCA) cycle, involving a precisely controlled freeze-thaw-vortex process, produces distinctive onion-like concentric multilamellar structures in cationic DOTAP/DOPE liposomes, in contrast to a conventional extrusion method that yields unilamellar liposomes. The inclusion of short-chain DHPC lipids further modulates the structure of cationic liposomes, transforming them from multilamellar to unilamellar structures during the LUCA cycle. Furthermore, the biophysical and biological evaluations of mRNA lipoplexes unveil that the optimal N/P charge ratio in the lipoplex can vary depending on the structure of initial cationic liposomes. Cryo-EM structural analysis demonstrates that multilamellar cationic liposomes induce two distinct interlamellar spacings in cationic lipoplexes, emphasizing the significant impact of the liposome structures on the final structure of mRNA lipoplexes. Taken together, our results provide an intriguing insight into the relationship between lipid assembly structures and the biophysical characteristics of the resulting lipoplexes. These relationships may open the door for advancing lipid-based mRNA delivery systems through more streamlined manufacturing processes.

Fabrication of High-Negatively Charged Bicelle-Mediated Supported Lipid Bilayer

Supported lipid bilayers (SLBs), two-dimensional lipid films formed on a solid-supporting substrate, serve as models for biomembranes and exhibit remarkable potential in chemistry, biology, and medicine. However, preparing SLBs with highly negatively charged contents on the negatively charged surface by overcoming electrostatic repulsion remains a challenge. Here, a creative bicelle-mediated and divalent cation-free SLB preparation method with the assistance of phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) solution was proposed, which can form the SLBs containing 50% DOPS or 30% CL on the silica surface monitored by a quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation (QCM-D). Results of molecular dynamics (MD) simulation indicate that electrostatic repulsion can be overcome by the increased number of hydrogen bonds caused by the adsorption of dihydrogen phosphate ions onto the headgroups of lipids. In addition, the negatively charged SLB formation was identified to be a three-step kinetic process, which differs from a two-step mechanism in the case of amphoteric SLB. The extra kinetic step can be attributed to the reduction in the number of intermolecular hydrogen bonds and the ordering of water molecules in the hydration layer. This investigation resolves the challenge of fabricating SLB over negatively charged surfaces and offers a fresh perspective on the SLB assembly methodology.

Morphological control and modern applications of bicelles

Bicellar systems have become popularized as their rich morphology can be applied in biochemistry, physical chemistry, and drug delivery technology. To the biochemical field, bicelles are powerful model membranes for the study of transmembrane protein behavior, membrane transport, and environmental interactions with the cell. Their morphological responses to environmental changes reveal a profound fundamental understanding of physical chemistry related to the principle of self-assembly. Recently, they have also drawn significant attention as theranostic nanocarriers in biopharmaceutical and diagnostic research due to their superior cellular uptake compared to liposomes. It is evident that applications are becoming broader, demanding to understand how the bicelle will form and behave in various environments. To consolidate current works on the bicelle's modern applications, this review will discuss various effects of composition and environmental conditions on the morphology, phase behavior, and stability. Furthermore, various applications such as payload entrapment and polymerization templating are presented to demonstrate their versatility and chemical nature.

Sparsely tethered bilayer lipid membranes formed by self-assembly of bicelles: Spectroelectrochemical characterization and incorporation of transmembrane protein

Many biochemical processes related to proper homeostasis take place in cell membranes. The key molecules involved in these processes are proteins, including transmembrane proteins. These macromolecules still challenge the understanding of their function within the membrane. Biomimetic models that mimic the properties of the cell membrane can help understand their functionality. Unfortunately, preserving the native protein structure in such systems is problematic. A possible solution to this problem involves the use of bicelles. Their unique properties make integrating bicelles with transmembrane proteins manageable while preserving their native structure. Hitherto, bicelles have not been used as precursors for protein-hosting lipid membranes deposited on solid substrates like pre-modified gold. Here, we demonstrated that bicelles can be self-assembled to form sparsely tethered bilayer lipid membranes and the properties of the resulting membrane satisfy the conditions suitable for transmembrane protein insertion. We showed that the incorporation of α-hemolysin toxin in the lipid membrane leads to a decrease in membrane resistance due to pore formation. Simultaneously, the insertion of the protein causes a drop in the capacitance of the membrane-modified electrode, which can be explained by the dehydration of the polar region of the lipid bilayer and the loss of water from the submembrane region.

Membrane Models and Experiments Suitable for Studies of the Cholesterol Bilayer Domains

Cholesterol (Chol) is an essential component of animal cell membranes and is most abundant in plasma membranes (PMs) where its concentration typically ranges from 10 to 30 mol%. However, in red blood cells and Schwann cells, PMs Chol content is as high as 50 mol%, and in the PMs of the eye lens fiber cells, it can reach up to 66 mol%. Being amphiphilic, Chol molecules are easily incorporated into the lipid bilayer where they affect the membrane lateral organization and transmembrane physical properties. In the aqueous phase, Chol cannot form free bilayers by itself. However, pure Chol bilayer domains (CBDs) can form in lipid bilayer membranes with the Chol content exceeding 50 mol%. The range of Chol concentrations surpassing 50 mol% is less frequent in biological membranes and is consequently less investigated. Nevertheless, it is significant for the normal functioning of the eye lens and understanding how Chol plaques form in atherosclerosis. The most commonly used membrane models are unilamellar and multilamellar vesicles (MLVs) and supported lipid bilayers (SLBs). CBDs have been observed directly using confocal microscopy, X-ray reflectometry and saturation recovery electron paramagnetic resonance (SR EPR). Indirect evidence of CBDs has also been reported by using atomic force microscopy (AFM) and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) experiments. The overall goal of this review is to demonstrate the advantages and limitations of the various membrane models and experimental techniques suitable for the detection and investigation of the lateral organization, function and physical properties of CBDs.

Tethered Bilayer Lipid Membrane Platform for Screening Triton X-100 Detergent Replacements by Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy

In light of regulatory considerations, there are ongoing efforts to identify Triton X-100 (TX-100) detergent alternatives for use in the biological manufacturing industry to mitigate membrane-enveloped pathogen contamination. Until now, the efficacy of antimicrobial detergent candidates to replace TX-100 has been tested regarding pathogen inhibition in endpoint biological assays or probing lipid membrane disruption in real-time biophysical testing platforms. The latter approach has proven especially useful to test compound potency and mechanism of action, however, existing analytical approaches have been limited to studying indirect effects of lipid membrane disruption such as membrane morphological changes. A direct readout of lipid membrane disruption by TX-100 detergent alternatives would be more practical to obtain biologically relevant information to guide compound discovery and optimization. Herein, we report the use of electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) to investigate how TX-100 and selected replacement candidates-Simulsol SL 11W (Simulsol) and cetyltrimethyl ammonium bromide (CTAB)-affect the ionic permeability of tethered bilayer lipid membrane (tBLM) platforms. The EIS results revealed that all three detergents exhibited dose-dependent effects mainly above their respective critical micelle concentration (CMC) values while displaying distinct membrane-disruptive behaviors. TX-100 caused irreversible membrane disruption leading to complete solubilization, whereas Simulsol caused reversible membrane disruption and CTAB induced irreversible, partial membrane defect formation. These findings establish that the EIS technique is useful for screening the membrane-disruptive behaviors of TX-100 detergent alternatives with multiplex formatting possibilities, rapid response, and quantitative readouts relevant to antimicrobial functions.

Interactions of Bacterial Quorum Sensing Signals with Model Lipid Membranes: Influence of Membrane Composition on Membrane Remodeling

We report the influence of membrane composition on the multiscale remodeling of multicomponent lipid bilayers initiated by contact with the amphiphilic bacterial quorum sensing signal N-(3-oxo)-dodecanoyl-l-homoserine lactone (3-oxo-C12-AHL) and its anionic headgroup hydrolysis product, 3-oxo-C12-HS. We used fluorescence microscopy and quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation (QCM-D) to characterize membrane reformation that occurs when these amphiphiles are placed in contact with supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) composed of (i) 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DOPC) containing varying amounts of cholesterol or (ii) mixtures of DOPC and either 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine (DOPE, a conical zwitterionic lipid) or 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phospho-l-serine (DOPS, a model anionic lipid). In general, we observe these mixed-lipid membranes to undergo remodeling events, including the formation and subsequent collapse of long tubules and the formation of hemispherical caps, upon introduction to biologically relevant concentrations of 3-oxo-C12-AHL and 3-oxo-C12-HS in ways that differ substantially from those observed in single-component DOPC membranes. These differences in bilayer reformation and their associated dynamics can be understood in terms of the influence of membrane composition on the time scales of molecular flip-flop, lipid packing defects, and lipid phase segregation in these materials. The lipid components investigated here are representative of classes of lipids that comprise both naturally occurring cell membranes and many useful synthetic soft materials. These studies thus represent a first step toward understanding the ways in which membrane composition can impact interactions with this important class of bacterial signaling molecules.

Unraveling How Cholesterol Affects Multivalency-Induced Membrane Deformation of Sub-100 nm Lipid Vesicles

Cholesterol plays a critical role in modulating the lipid membrane properties of biological and biomimetic systems and recent attention has focused on its role in the functions of sub-100 nm lipid vesicles and lipid nanoparticles. These functions often rely on multivalent ligand-receptor interactions involving membrane attachment and dynamic shape transformations while the extent to which cholesterol can influence such interaction processes is largely unknown. To address this question, herein, we investigated the attachment of sub-100 nm lipid vesicles containing varying cholesterol fractions (0-45 mol %) to membrane-mimicking supported lipid bilayer (SLB) platforms. Biotinylated lipids and streptavidin proteins were used as model ligands and receptors, respectively, while the localized surface plasmon resonance sensing technique was employed to track vesicle attachment kinetics in combination with analytical modeling of vesicle shape changes. Across various conditions mimicking low and high multivalency, our findings revealed that cholesterol-containing vesicles could bind to receptor-functionalized membranes but underwent appreciably less multivalency-induced shape deformation than vesicles without cholesterol, which can be explained by a cholesterol-mediated increase in membrane bending rigidity. Interestingly, the extent of vesicle deformation that occurred in response to increasingly strong multivalent interactions was less pronounced for vesicles with greater cholesterol fraction. The latter trend was rationalized by taking into account the strong dependence of the membrane bending energy on the area of the vesicle-SLB contact region and such insights can aid the engineering of membrane-enveloped nanoparticles with tailored biophysical properties.

Lipid bilayer composition as a determinant of cancer cell sensitivity to tumoricidal protein-lipid complexes

Complexes formed by the alpha1 N-terminal peptide of alpha-lactalbumin and oleic acid (alpha1-oleate) interact with lipid bilayers. Plasma membrane perturbations trigger tumor cell death but normal differentiated cells are more resistant, and their plasma membranes are less strongly affected. This study examined membrane lipid composition as a determinant of tumor cell reactivity. Bladder cancer tissue showed a higher abundance of unsaturated lipids enriched in phosphatidylcholine, PC (36:4) and PC (38:4), and sphingomyelin, SM (36:1) than healthy bladder tissue, where saturated lipids predominated and the lipid extracts from bladder cancer tissue inhibited the tumoricidal effect of the complex more effectively than healthy tissue extracts. Furthermore, unsaturated PC in solution inhibited tumor cell death, and the complex interacted with giant unilamellar vesicles formed by PC, confirming the affinity of alpha1-oleate for fluid membranes enriched in PC. Quartz Crystal Microbalance with dissipation monitoring (QCM-D) detected a preference of the complex for the liquid-disordered phase, suggesting that the insertion into PC-based membranes and the resulting membrane perturbations are influenced by membrane lipid saturation. The results suggest that the membrane lipid composition is functionally important and that specific unsaturated membrane lipids may serve as "recognition motifs" for broad-spectrum tumoricidal molecules such as alpha1-oleate.

Nanoarchitectured air-stable supported lipid bilayer incorporating sucrose-bicelle complex system

Cell-membrane-mimicking supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) provide an ultrathin, self-assembled layer that forms on solid supports and can exhibit antifouling, signaling, and transport properties among various possible functions. While recent material innovations have increased the number of practically useful SLB fabrication methods, typical SLB platforms only work in aqueous environments and are prone to fluidity loss and lipid-bilayer collapse upon air exposure, which limits industrial applicability. To address this issue, herein, we developed sucrose-bicelle complex system to fabricate air-stable SLBs that were laterally mobile upon rehydration. SLBs were fabricated from bicelles in the presence of up to 40 wt% sucrose, which was verified by quartz crystal microbalance-dissipation (QCM-D) and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) experiments. The sucrose fraction in the system was an important factor; while 40 wt% sucrose induced lipid aggregation and defects on SLBs after the dehydration-rehydration process, 20 wt% sucrose yielded SLBs that exhibited fully recovered lateral mobility after these processes. Taken together, these findings demonstrate that sucrose-bicelle complex system can facilitate one-step fabrication of air-stable SLBs that can be useful for a wide range of biointerfacial science applications.

Monitoring the formation of a colloidal lipid gel at the nanoscale: vesicle aggregation driven by a temperature-induced mechanism

Colloidal gels made of lipid vesicles at highly diluted conditions have been recently described. The structure and composition of this type of material could be especially relevant for studies that combine model lipid membranes with proteins, peptides, or enzymes to replicate biological conditions. Details about the nanoscale events that occur during the formation of such gels would motivate their future application. Thus, in this work we investigate the gelation mechanism, which consists of a lipid dispersion of vesicles going through a process that involves freezing and heating. The appropriate combination of techniques (transmission electron microscopy, differential scanning calorimetry and synchrotron small angle X-ray scattering) allowed in-depth analysis of the different events that give rise to the formation of the gel. Results showed how freezing damaged the lipid dispersion, causing a polydisperse suspension of membrane fragments and vesicles upon melting. Heating above the lipids' main phase transition temperature promoted the formation of elongated tubular structures. After cooling, these lipid tubes broke down into vesicles that formed branched aggregates across the aqueous phase, obtaining a material with gel characteristics. These mechanistic insights may also allow finding new ways to interact with lipid vesicles to form structured materials. Future works might complement the presented results with molecular dynamics or nuclear magnetic resonance experiments.

Mechanistic Aspects of the Evolution of 3D Cholesterol Crystallites in a Supported Lipid Membrane via a Quartz Crystal Microbalance with Dissipation Monitoring

The irreversible formation of cholesterol monohydrate crystals within biological membranes is the leading cause of various diseases, including atherosclerosis. Understanding the process of cholesterol crystallization is fundamentally important and could also lead to the development of improved therapeutic strategies. This has driven several studies investigating the effect of the environmental parameters on the induction of cholesterol crystallite growth and the structure of the cholesterol crystallites, while the kinetics and mechanistic aspects of the crystallite formation process within lipid membranes remain poorly understood. Herein, we fabricated cholesterol crystallites within a supported lipid bilayer (SLB) by adsorbing a cholesterol-rich bicellar mixture onto a glass and silica surface and investigated the real-time kinetics of cholesterol crystallite nucleation and growth using epifluorescence microscopy and quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation (QCM-D) monitoring. Microscopic imaging showed the evolution of the morphology of cholesterol crystallites from nanorod- and plate-shaped habits during the initial stage to mostly large, micron-sized three-dimensional (3D) plate-shaped crystallites in the end, which was likened to Ostwald ripening. QCM-D kinetics revealed unique signal responses during the later stage of the growth process, characterized by simultaneous positive frequency shifts, nonmonotonous energy dissipation shifts, and significant overtone dependence. Based on the optically observed changes in crystallite morphology, we discussed the physical background of these unique QCM-D signal responses and the mechanistic aspects of Ostwald ripening in this system. Together, our findings revealed mechanistic details of the cholesterol crystallite growth kinetics, which may be useful in biointerfacial sensing and bioanalytical applications.

Interaction of graphene oxide with artificial cell membranes: Role of anionic phospholipid and cholesterol in nanoparticle attachment and membrane disruption

A mechanistic understanding of the interaction of graphene oxide (GO) with cell membranes is critical for predicting the biological effects of GO following accidental exposure and biomedical applications. We herein used a quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring (QCM-D) to probe the interaction of GO with model cell membranes modified with anionic lipids or cholesterol under biologically relevant conditions. The attachment efficiency of GO on supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) decreased with increasing anionic lipid content and was unchanged with varying cholesterol content. In addition, the incorporation of anionic lipids to the SLBs rendered the attachment of GO partially reversible upon a decrease in solution ionic strength. These results demonstrate the critical role of lipid bilayer surface charge in controlling GO attachment and release. We also employed the fluorescent dye leakage technique to quantify the role of anionic lipids and cholesterol in vesicle disruption caused by GO. Notably, we observed a linear correlation between the amount of dye leakage from the vesicles and the attachment efficiencies of GO on the SLBs, confirming that membrane disruption is preceded by GO attachment. This study highlights the non-negligible role of lipid bilayer composition in controlling the physicochemical interactions between cell membranes and GO.

Structure, Formation, and Biological Interactions of Supported Lipid Bilayers (SLB) Incorporating Lipopolysaccharide

Biomimetic membrane systems play a crucial role in the field of biosensor engineering. Over the years, significant progress has been achieved creating artificial membranes by various strategies from vesicle fusion to Langmuir transfer approaches to meet an ever-growing demand for supported lipid bilayers on various substrates such as glass, mica, gold, polymer cushions, and many more. This paper reviews the diversity seen in the preparation of biologically relevant model lipid membranes which includes monolayers and bilayers of phospholipid and other crucial components such as proteins, characterization techniques, changes in the physical properties of the membranes during molecular interactions and the dynamics of the lipid membrane with biologically active molecules with special emphasis on lipopolysaccharides (LPS).

Versatile formation of supported lipid bilayers from bicellar mixtures of phospholipids and capric acid

Originally developed for the structural biology field, lipid bicelle nanostructures composed of long- and short-chain phospholipid molecules have emerged as a useful interfacial science tool to fabricate two-dimensional supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) on hydrophilic surfaces due to ease of sample preparation, scalability, and versatility. To improve SLB fabrication prospects, there has been recent interest in replacing the synthetic, short-chain phospholipid component of bicellar mixtures with naturally abundant fatty acids and monoglycerides, i.e., lauric acid and monocaprin. Such options have proven successful under specific conditions, however, there is room for devising more versatile fabrication options, especially in terms of overcoming lipid concentration-dependent SLB formation limitations. Herein, we investigated SLB fabrication by using bicellar mixtures consisting of long-chain phospholipid and capric acid, the latter of which has similar headgroup and chain length properties to lauric acid and monocaprin, respectively. Quartz crystal microbalance-dissipation, epifluorescence microscopy, and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching experiments were conducted to characterize lipid concentration-dependent bicelle adsorption onto silicon dioxide surfaces. We identified that uniform-phase SLB formation occurred independently of total lipid concentration when the ratio of long-chain phospholipid to capric acid molecules ("q-ratio") was 0.25 or 2.5, which is superior to past results with lauric acid- and monocaprin-containing bicelles in which cases lipid concentration-dependent behavior was observed. Together, these findings demonstrate that capric acid-containing bicelles are versatile tools for SLB fabrication and highlight how the molecular structure of bicelle components can be rationally finetuned to modulate self-assembly processes at solid-liquid interfaces.

Biologically interfaced nanoplasmonic sensors

Understanding biointerfacial processes is crucial in various fields across fundamental and applied biology, but performing quantitative studies via conventional characterization techniques remains challenging due to instrumentation as well as analytical complexities and limitations. In order to accelerate translational research and address current challenges in healthcare and medicine, there is an outstanding need to develop surface-sensitive technologies with advanced measurement capabilities. Along this line, nanoplasmonic sensing has emerged as a powerful tool to quantitatively study biointerfacial processes owing to its high spatial resolution at the nanoscale. Consequently, the development of robust biological interfacing strategies becomes imperative to maximize its characterization potential. This review will highlight and discuss the critical role of biological interfacing within the context of constructing nanoplasmonic sensing platforms for biointerfacial science applications. Apart from paving the way for the development of highly surface-sensitive characterization tools that will spur fundamental biological interaction studies and improve the overall understanding of biological processes, the basic principles behind biointerfacing strategies presented in this review are also applicable to other fields that involve an interface between an inorganic material and a biological system.

Supported Lipid Bilayer Formation from Phospholipid-Fatty Acid Bicellar Mixtures

Supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) are versatile cell membrane-mimicking biointerfaces for various applications such as biosensors and drug delivery systems, and there is broad interest in developing simple, cost-effective methods to achieve SLB fabrication. One promising approach involves the deposition of quasi-two-dimensional bicelle nanostructures that are composed of long-chain phospholipids and either short-chain phospholipids or detergent molecules. While a variety of long-chain phospholipids have been used to prepare bicelles for SLB fabrication applications, only two short-chain phospholipids, 1,2-dihexanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine and 1,2-diheptanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (collectively referred to as DHPC), have been investigated. There remains an outstanding need to identify natural alternatives to DHPC, especially ones that are more affordable, to improve fabrication prospects and application opportunities. Herein, we explored the potential to fabricate SLBs from bicellar mixtures composed of long-chain phospholipids and lauric acid (LA), which is a low-cost, naturally abundant fatty acid that is widely used in soapmaking and various industrial applications. Quartz crystal microbalance-dissipation (QCM-D) experiments were conducted to track bicelle adsorption onto silica surfaces as a function of bicelle composition and lipid concentration, along with time-lapse fluorescence microscopy imaging and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) experiments to further characterize lipid adlayer properties. The results identified optimal conditions where it is possible to efficiently form SLBs from LA-containing bicelles at low lipid concentrations while also unraveling mechanistic insights into the bicelle-mediated SLB formation process and verifying that LA-containing bicelles are biocompatible with human cells for surface coating applications.

Supported Lipid Bilayer Formation: Beyond Vesicle Fusion

Supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) are cell-membrane-mimicking platforms that can be formed on solid surfaces and integrated with a wide range of surface-sensitive measurement techniques. SLBs are useful for unravelling details of fundamental membrane biology and biophysics as well as for various medical, biotechnology, and environmental science applications. Thus, there is high interest in developing simple and robust methods to fabricate SLBs. Currently, vesicle fusion is a popular method to form SLBs and involves the adsorption and spontaneous rupture of lipid vesicles on a solid surface. However, successful vesicle fusion depends on high-quality vesicle preparation, and it typically works with a narrow range of material supports and lipid compositions. In this Feature Article, we summarize current progress in developing two new SLB fabrication techniques termed the solvent-assisted lipid bilayer (SALB) and bicelle methods, which have compelling advantages such as simple sample preparation and compatibility with a wide range of material supports and lipid compositions. The molecular self-assembly principles underpinning the two strategies and important experimental parameters are critically discussed, and recent application examples are presented. Looking forward, we envision that these emerging SLB fabrication strategies can be widely adopted by specialists and nonspecialists alike, paving the way to enriching our understanding of lipid membrane properties and realizing new application possibilities.