Photochemical CO2-to-Formate/CO Conversion Catalyzed by Half-Metallocene Ir(III) Catalyst and Its Mechanistic Investigation

Photocatalytic Conversion of CO2 to Formate/CO by an (η6-para-Cymene)Ru(II) Half-Metallocene Catalyst: Influence of Additives and TiO2 Immobilization on the Catalytic Mechanism and Product Selectivity

The catalytic efficacy of the monobipyridyl (η6-para-Cymene)Ru(II) half-metallocene, [(p-Cym)Ru(bpy)Cl]+ was evaluated in both mixed homogeneous (dye + catalyst) and heterogeneous hybrid systems (dye/TiO2/Catalyst) for photochemical CO2 reduction. A series of homogeneous photolysis experiments revealed that the (p-Cym)Ru(II) catalyst engages in two competitive routes for CO2 reduction (CO2 to formate conversion via RuII-hydride vs CO2 to CO conversion through a RuII-COOH intermediate). The conversion activity and product selectivity were notably impacted by the pKa value and the concentration of the proton source added. When a more acidic TEOA additive was introduced, the half-metallocene Ru(II) catalyst leaned toward producing formate through the RuII-H mechanism, with a formate selectivity of 86%. On the other hand, in homogeneous catalysis with TFE additive, the CO2-to-formate conversion through RuII-H was less effective, yielding a more efficient CO2-to-CO conversion with a selectivity of >80% (TONformate of 140 and TONCO of 626 over 48 h). The preference between the two pathways was elucidated through an electrochemical mechanistic study, monitoring the fate of the metal-hydride intermediate. Compared to the homogeneous system, the TiO2-heterogenized (p-Cym)Ru(II) catalyst demonstrated enhanced and enduring performance, attaining TONs of 1000 for CO2-to-CO and 665 for CO2-to-formate.

Inorganometallic Photocatalyst for CO2 Reduction

ConspectusDuring the last few decades, the design of catalytic systems for CO₂ reduction has been extensively researched and generally involves (1) traditional approaches using molecular organic/organometallic materials and heterogeneous inorganic semiconductors and (2) combinatory approaches wherein these materials are combined as needed. Recently, we have devised a number of new TiO₂-mediated multicomponent hybrid systems that synergistically integrate the intrinsic merits of various materials, namely, molecular photosensitizers/catalysts and n-type TiO₂ semiconductors, and lower the energetic and kinetic barriers between components. We have termed such multicomponent hybrid systems assembled from the hybridization of various organic/inorganic/organometallic units in a single platform inorganometallic photocatalysts. The multicomponent inorganometallic (MIOM) hybrid system onto which the photosensitizer and catalyst are coadsorbed efficiently eliminates the need for bulk-phase diffusion of the components and avoids the accumulation of radical intermediates that invokes a degradation pathway, in contrast to the homogeneous system, in which the free reactive species are concentrated in a confined reaction space. In particular, in energetic terms, we discovered that in nonaqueous media, the conduction band (CB) levels of reduced TiO₂ (TiO₂(e^-)) are positioned at a higher level (in the range -1.5 to -1.9 V vs SCE). This energetic benefit of reduced TiO₂ allows smooth electron transfer (ET) from injected electrons (TiO₂(e^-)) to the coadsorbed CO₂ reduction catalyst, which requires relatively high reducing power (at least more than -1.1 V vs SCE). On the other hand, the existence of various shallow surface trapping sites and surface bands, which are 0.3-1.0 eV below the CB of TiO₂, efficiently facilitates electron injection from any photosensitizer (including dyes having low excited energy levels) to TiO₂ without energetic limitation. This is contrasted with most photocatalytic systems, wherein successive absorption of single high-energy photons is required to produce excited states with enough energy to fulfill photocatalytic reaction, which may allow unwanted side reactions during photocatalysis. In this Account, we present our recent research efforts toward advancing these MIOM hybrid systems for photochemical CO₂ reduction and discuss their working mechanisms in detail. Basic ET processes within the MIOM system, including intervalence ET in organic/organometallic redox systems, metal-to-ligand charge transfer of organometallic complexes, and interfacial/outer-sphere charge transfer between components, were investigated by conducting serial photophysical and electrochemical analyses. Because such ET events occur primarily at the interface between the components, the efficiency of interfacial ET between the molecular components (organic/organometallic photosensitizers and molecular reduction catalysts) and the bulk inorganic solid (mainly n-type TiO₂ semiconductors) has a significant influence on the overall photochemical reaction kinetics and mechanism. In some TiO₂-mediated MIOM hybrids, the chemical attachment of organic or organometallic photosensitizing units onto TiO₂ semiconductors efficiently eliminates the step of diffusion/collision-controlled ET between components and prevents the accumulation of reactive species (oxidatively quenched cations or reductively quenched anions) in the reaction solution, ensuring steady photosensitization over an extended reaction period. The site isolation of a single-site organometallic catalyst employing TiO₂ immobilization promotes the monomeric catalytic pathway during the CO₂ reduction process, resulting in enhanced product selectivity and catalytic performance, including lifetime extension. In addition, as an alternative inorganic solid scaffold, the introduction of a host porphyrin matrix (interlinked in a metal-organic framework (MOF) material) led to efficient and durable photocatalytic CO₂ conversion by the new MOF-Re(I) hybrid as a result of efficient light harvesting/exciton migration in the porphyrinic MOF and rapid quenching of the photogenerated electrons by the doped Re(I) catalytic sites. Overall, the case studies presented herein provide valuable insights for the rational design of advanced multicomponent hybrid systems for artificial photosynthesis involving CO₂ reduction.