Regulating the Coordination Environment of Single-Atom Catalysts Anchored on Thiophene Linked Porphyrin for an Efficient Nitrogen Reduction Reaction

Electrocatalytic Dinitrogen Reduction to Ammonia Using Easily Reducible N-Fused Cobalt Porphyrins

Single-site molecular electrocatalysts, especially those that perform catalytic conversion of N2 to NH3 under mild conditions, are highly desirable to derive fundamental structure-activity relations and as potential alternatives to the current energy-consuming Haber-Bosch ammonia production process. Combining theoretical calculations with experimental evidence, it has been shown that easily reducible cobalt porphyrins catalyze the six-electron, six-proton reduction of dinitrogen to NH3 at neutral pH and under ambient conditions. Two easily reducible N-fused cobalt porphyrins - CoNHF and CoNHF(Br)2 - reveal NRR activity with Faradic efficiencies between 6-7.5 % with ammonia yield rates of 300-340 μmol g-1 h-1. Contrary to this, much harder-to-reduce N-fused porphyrins - CoNHF(Ph)2 and CoNHF(PE)2 - reveal no NRR activity. The present study highlights the significance of tuning the redox and structural properties of single-site NRR electrocatalysts for improved NRR activity under mild conditions.

Designing C9N10 Anchored Single Mo Atom as an Efficient Electrocatalyst for Nitrogen Fixation

Electrochemical nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) is a promising route for realizing green and sustainable ammonia synthesis under ambient conditions. However, one of the major challenges of currently available Single-atom catalysts (SACs) is poor catalytic activity and low catalytic selectivity, which is far away from the requirements of industrial applications. Herein, first-principle calculations within the density functional theory were performed to evaluate the feasibility of a single Mo atom anchored on a g-C9N10 monolayer (Mo@g-C9N10) as NRR electrocatalysts. The results demonstrated that the gas phase N2 molecule can be sufficiently activated on Mo@g-C9N10, and N2 reduction dominantly occurs on the active Mo atom via the preferred enzymatic mechanism, with a low limiting potential of -0.48 V. In addition, Mo@g-C9N10 possesses a good prohibition ability for the competitive hydrogen evolution reaction. More impressively, good electronic conductivity and high electron transport efficiency endow Mo SACs with excellent activity for electrocatalytic N2 reduction. This theoretical research not only accelerates the development of NRR electrocatalysts but also increases our insights into optimizing the catalytic performance of SACs.

Rational design of bimetallic MBene for efficient electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction

Electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) is one of the most promising approaches to achieving green and efficient NH3 production. However, the designs of efficient NRR catalysts with high activity and selectivity still are severely hampered by inherent linear scaling relations among the adsorption energies of NRR intermediates. Herein, the properties of ten M3B4 type MBenes have been initially investigated for efficient N2 activation and reduction to NH3via first-principles calculations. We highlight that Cr3B4 MBene possesses remarkable NRR activity with a record-low limiting potential (-0.13 V). Then, this work proposes descriptor-based design principles that can effectively evaluate the catalytic activity of MBenes, which have been further employed to design bimetallic M2M'B4 MBenes. As a result, 5 promising candidates including Ti2YB4, V2YB4, V2MoB4, Nb2YB4, and Nb2CrB4 with excellent NRR performance have been extracted from 20 bimetallic MBenes. Further analysis illuminates that constructing bimetallic MBenes can selectively tune the adsorption strength of NHNH2** and NH2NH2**, and break the linear scaling relations between their adsorption energies, rendering them ideal for NRR. This work not only pioneers the application of MBenes as efficient NRR catalysts but also proposes rational design principles for boosting their catalytic performance.

Computational screening of pyrazine-based graphene-supported transition metals as single-atom catalysts for the nitrogen reduction reaction

Electrochemical synthesis of NH3 from N2 utilizing single-atom catalysts (SACs) is a promising strategy for industrial nitrogen fixation and chemical raw material production. In this work, single transition metals (TMs) anchored on pyrazine-based graphene (TM@py-GY) are systematically studied to screen potential electrocatalysts for the nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) using first-principles calculations. Particularly, the descriptor φ related to electronegativity and valence electron number is selected to clarify the trend of NRR activity, realizing a fast-scan/estimation among various candidates. After a four-step screening process, WI@py-GY and MoII@py-GY SACs are screened with good structural stability, high selectivity, and high activity. Meanwhile, the thermodynamic stability of WI@py-GY and MoII@py-GY SACs is demonstrated to ensure their feasibility in real experimental conditions. Furthermore, electronic properties are also examined in detail to analyze activity origin. This work not only provides an effective and reliable method for screening electrochemical NRR catalysts with excellent performance but also provides guidance for the rational design of SACs.

Advancing electrochemical nitrogen reduction: Efficacy of two-dimensional SiP layered structures with single-atom transition metal catalysts

Researchers are interested in single-atom catalysts with atomically scattered metals relishing the enhanced electrocatalytic activity for nitrogen reduction and 100 % metal atom utilization. In this paper, we investigated 18 transition metals (TM) spanning 3d to 5d series as efficient nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) catalysts on defective 2D SiPV layered structures through first-principles calculation. A systematic screening identified Mo@SiPV, Nb@SiPV, Ta@SiPV and W@SiPV as superior, demonstrating enhanced ammonia synthesis with significantly lower limiting potentials (-0.25, -0.45, -0.49 and -0.15 V, respectively), compared to the benchmark -0.87 eV for the defective SiP. In addition, the descriptor ΔG*N was introduced to establish the relationship between the different NRR intermediates, and the volcano plot of the limiting potentials were determined for their potential-determining steps (PDS). Remarkably, the limiting voltage of the NRR possesses a good linear relationship with the active center TM atom Ɛd, which is a reliable descriptor for predicting the limiting voltage. Furthermore, we verified the stability (using Ab Initio Molecular Dynamics - AIMD) and high selectivity (UL(NRR)-UL(HER) > -0.5 V) of these four catalysts in vacuum and solvent environments. This study systematically demonstrates the strong catalytic potential of 2D TM@SiPV(TM = Mo, Nb, Ta, W) single-atom catalysts for nitrogen reduction electrocatalysis.

Electrocatalysts for Urea Synthesis from CO2 and Nitrogenous Species: From CO2 and N2/NOx Reduction to urea synthesis

The traditional industrial synthesis of urea relies on the energy-intensive and polluting process, namely the Haber-Bosch method for ammonia production, followed by the Bosch-Meiser process for urea synthesis. In contrast, electrocatalytic C-N coupling from carbon dioxide (CO2) and nitrogenous species presents a promising alternative for direct urea synthesis under ambient conditions, bypassing the need for ammonia production. This review provides an overview of recent progress in the electrocatalytic coupling of CO2 and nitrogen sources for urea synthesis. It focuses on the role of intermediate species and active site structures in promoting urea synthesis, drawing from insights into reactants' adsorption behavior and interactions with catalysts tailored for CO2 reduction, nitrogen reduction, and nitrate reduction. Advanced electrocatalyst design strategies for urea synthesis from CO2 and nitrogenous species under ambient conditions are explored, providing insights for efficient catalyst design. Key challenges and prospective directions are presented in the conclusion. Mechanistic studies elucidating the C-N coupling reaction and future development directions are discussed. The review aims to inspire further research and development in electrocatalysts for electrochemical urea synthesis.

Designing N, P-doped graphene surface-supported Mo single-atom catalysts for efficient conversion of nitrogen into ammonia: a computational guideline

Tuning the surroundings of single-atom catalysts (SACs) has been recognized as a successful approach to enhance their electrocatalytic efficiency. In this study, we utilized density functional theory (DFT) computations to systematically investigate how the coordination environment influences the catalytic performance of individual molybdenum atoms for the nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) to NH3. Upon comparing an extensive array of coordination combinations, Mo-based SACs were found to feature a distinctive N, P-dual coordination. Specifically, MoN3P1G demonstrates superior performance in the conversion of nitrogen into ammonia with an exceptionally low limiting potential (-0.64 V). This MoN3P1G catalyst preferably follows the distal pathway, with the initial hydrogenation step (*N2 → *NNH) being the rate-determining step. Additionally, MoN3P1G exhibits the ability to suppress competing H2 production, showcases high thermodynamic stability, and holds significant promise for experimental preparation. These findings not only contribute to diversifying the SAC family through localized coordination control but also present cost-effective strategies for enhancing sustainable NH3 production.

Designing asymmetrical TMN4 sites via phosphorus or sulfur dual coordination as high-performance electrocatalysts for oxygen evolution reaction

The development ofhighly efficient oxygen evolution reaction (OER) catalysts based on more cost-effective and earth-abundant elements is of great significance and still faces a huge challenge. In this work, a series of transition metal (TM)embedding a newly-defined monolayer carbon nitride phase is theoretically profiled and constructed as a catalytic platform for OER studies. Typically, a four-step screening strategy was proposed to rapidly identified high performance candidates and the coordination structure and catalytic performance relationship was thoroughly analyzed. Moreover, the eliminating criterion was established to condenses valid range based on the Gibbs free energy of OH*. Our results reveal that the as-constructed 2FeCN/P exhibits superior activity toward OER with an ultralow overpotential of 0.25 V, at the same time, the established 3FeCN/S configuration performed well as abifunctional OER/ORR electrocatalysis with extremely low overpotential ηOER/ηORR of 0.26/0.48 V. Overall, this work provides an effective framework for screening advanced OER catalysts, which can also be extended to other complex multistep catalytic reactions.

CO2 electroreduction on single atom catalysts: the role of the DFT functional

One key process involving single atom catalysts (SACs) is the electroreduction of CO2 to fuels. The chemistry of SACs differs largely from that of extended catalytic surfaces, presenting an opportunity to improve the ability to activate very stable molecules, such as CO2. In this work, we performed a density functional theory (DFT) study of CO2 activation on a series of SACs, focusing on the role played by the adopted functional in activity predictions. The role of the exchange-correlation functional has been widely investigated in heterogenous catalysts, but it is less explored in SACs. We tested the widely used PBE and the PBE+U corrected functionals against the more robust hybrid PBE0 functional. The results show that PBE is reliable if one is interested in qualitative predictions, but it leads to some inaccuracies in other cases. A possible way to attenuate this effect is by adopting the PBE+U framework, as it gives results that are very similar to PBE0 at an acceptable computational cost. The results of this study further underline the importance of the computational framework adopted in predicting the activity of SACs. The work suggests that one needs to go beyond PBE for quantitative estimates, an important consideration when performing screening and high-throughput calculations.

Design of Single-Atom Catalysts for E lectrocatalytic Nitrogen Fixation

The Electrochemical nitrogen reduction reaction (ENRR) can be used to solve environmental problems as well as energy shortage. However, ENRR still faces the problems of low NH3 yield and low selectivity. The NH3 yield and selectivity in ENRR are affected by multiple factors such as electrolytic cells, electrolytes, and catalysts, etc. Among these catalysts are at the core of ENRR research. Single-atom catalysts (SACs) with intrinsic activity have become an emerging technology for numerous energy regeneration, including ENRR. In particular, regulating the microenvironment of SACs (hydrogen evolution reaction inhibition, carrier engineering, metal-carrier interaction, etc.) can break through the limitation of intrinsic activity of SACs. Therefore, this Review first introduces the basic principles of NRR and outlines the key factors affecting ENRR. Then a comprehensive summary is given of the progress of SACs (precious metals, non-precious metals, non-metallic) and diatomic catalysts (DACs) in ENRR. The impact of SACs microenvironmental regulation on ENRR is highlighted. Finally, further research directions for SACs in ENRR are discussed.

Establishing an orbital-level understanding of active origins of heteroatom-coordinated single-atom catalysts: The case of N2 reduction

Heteroatom-coordinated single-atom catalysts (SACs) supported by porous graphene exhibit high activity in electrochemical reduction reactions. However, the underlying active origins are complex and puzzling, hindering the development of efficient catalysts. Herein, we investigate the active origins of heteroatom-coordinated Fe-XmYn SACs (X, Y = B, C, N, O, m + n = 4) toward nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) as a model reaction, through comprehensive analysis of structural, energetic, and electronic parameters. Specifically, the number and arrangement of heteroatoms are found to significantly affect the degree of d-orbital splitting and magnetic moment of the Fe center. Moreover, d-orbital splitting energy (dSE), rather than the conventional d-band theory, explains the adsorption behavior of intermediates in multi-step electron-proton coupling (EPC) reactions. In addition, both s- and d-orbitals of Fe are found to be important for Fe-N bonding, which promotes charge transfer (CT) and N2 activation. Importantly, CT is thought to influence the Pauli repulsion and orbital interaction. Correspondingly, relationships are unveiled between limiting potential (Ulimit) and adsorption energy ΔE(*NNH), dSE, CT, Fe-N bond. In all, this work provides orbital-level insights into the active origins of Fe-XmYn SACs, contributing to the understanding of intrinsic mechanism and the design of electrocatalysts for multi-step EPC reactions.

Modeling Single-Atom Catalysis

Electronic structure calculations represent an essential complement of experiments to characterize single-atom catalysts (SACs), consisting of isolated metal atoms stabilized on a support, but also to predict new catalysts. However, simulating SACs with quantum chemistry approaches is not as simple as often assumed. In this work, the essential factors that characterize a reliable simulation of SACs activity are examined. The Perspective focuses on the importance of precise atomistic characterization of the active site, since even small changes in the metal atom's surroundings can result in large changes in reactivity. The dynamical behavior and stability of SACs under working conditions, as well as the importance of adopting appropriate methods to solve the Schrödinger equation for a quantitative evaluation of reaction energies are addressed. The Perspective also focuses on the relevance of the model adopted. For electrocatalysis this must include the effects of the solvent, the presence of electrolytes, the pH, and the external potential. Finally, it is discussed how the similarities between SACs and coordination compounds may result in reaction intermediates that usually are not observed on metal electrodes. When these aspects are not adequately considered, the predictive power of electronic structure calculations is quite limited.