Real-Time Profiling of Solid-State Nanopores During Solution-Phase Nanofabrication

Nanopore-based sensors for DNA sequencing: a review

Nanopore sensors, owing to their distinctive structural properties, can be used to detect biomolecular translocation events. These sensors operate by monitoring variations in electric current amplitude and duration, thereby enabling the calibration and distinction of various biomolecules. As a result, nanopores emerge as a potentially powerful tool in the field of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) sequencing. However, the interplay between testing bandwidth and noise often leads to the loss of part of the critical translocation signals, presenting a substantial challenge for the precise measurement of biomolecules. In this context, innovative detection mechanisms have been developed, including optical detection, tunneling current detection, and nanopore field-effect transistor (FET) detection. These novel detection methods are based on but beyond traditional nanopore techniques and each of them has unique advantages. Notably, nanopore FET sensors stand out for their high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and high bandwidth measurement capabilities, overcoming the limitations typically associated with traditional solid-state nanopore (SSN) technologies and thus paving the way for new avenues to biomolecule detection. This review begins by elucidating the fundamental detection principles, development history, applications, and fabrication methods for traditional SSNs. It then introduces three novel detection mechanisms, with a particular emphasis on nanopore FET detection. Finally, a comprehensive analysis of the advantages and challenges associated with both SSNs and nanopore FET sensors is performed, and then insights into the future development trajectories for nanopore FET sensors in DNA sequencing are provided. This review has two main purposes: firstly, to provide researchers with a preliminary understanding of advancements in the nanopore field, and secondly, to offer a comprehensive analysis of the fabrication techniques, transverse current detection principles, challenges, and future development trends in the field of nanopore FET sensors. This comprehensive analysis aims to help give researchers in-depth insights into cutting-edge advancements in the field of nanopore FET sensors.

Localized Nanopore Fabrication via Controlled Breakdown

Nanopore sensors provide a unique platform to detect individual nucleic acids, proteins, and other biomolecules without the need for fluorescent labeling or chemical modifications. Solid-state nanopores offer the potential to integrate nanopore sensing with other technologies such as field-effect transistors (FETs), optics, plasmonics, and microfluidics, thereby attracting attention to the development of commercial instruments for diagnostics and healthcare applications. Stable nanopores with ideal dimensions are particularly critical for nanopore sensors to be integrated into other sensing devices and provide a high signal-to-noise ratio. Nanopore fabrication, although having benefited largely from the development of sophisticated nanofabrication techniques, remains a challenge in terms of cost, time consumption and accessibility. One of the latest developed methods—controlled breakdown (CBD)—has made the nanopore technique broadly accessible, boosting the use of nanopore sensing in both fundamental research and biomedical applications. Many works have been developed to improve the efficiency and robustness of pore formation by CBD. However, nanopores formed by traditional CBD are randomly positioned in the membrane. To expand nanopore sensing to a wider biomedical application, controlling the localization of nanopores formed by CBD is essential. This article reviews the recent strategies to control the location of nanopores formed by CBD. We discuss the fundamental mechanism and the efforts of different approaches to confine the region of nanopore formation.

Assessment of 1/f noise associated with nanopores fabricated through chemically tuned controlled dielectric breakdown

Recently, we developed a fabrication method-chemically-tuned controlled dielectric breakdown (CT-CDB)-that produces nanopores (through thin silicon nitride membranes) surpassing legacy drawbacks associated with solid-state nanopores (SSNs). However, the noise characteristics of CT-CDB nanopores are largely unexplored. In this work, we investigated the 1/f noise of CT-CDB nanopores of varying solution pH, electrolyte type, electrolyte concentration, applied voltage, and pore diameter. Our findings indicate that the bulk Hooge parameter (α_b ) is about an order of magnitude greater than SSNs fabricated by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) while the surface Hooge parameter (α_s ) is ∼3 order magnitude greater. Theα_s of CT-CDB nanopores was ∼5 orders of magnitude greater than theirα_b , which suggests that the surface contribution plays a dominant role in 1/f noise. Experiments with DNA exhibited increasing capture rates with pH up to pH ∼8 followed by a drop at pH ∼9 perhaps due to the onset of electroosmotic force acting against the electrophoretic force. The1/f noise was also measured for several electrolytes and LiCl was found to outperform NaCl, KCl, RbCl, and CsCl. The 1/f noise was found to increase with the increasing electrolyte concentration and pore diameter. Taken together, the findings of this work suggest the pH approximate 7-8 range to be optimal for DNA sensing with CT-CDB nanopores.

Topological analysis of single-stranded DNA with an alpha-hederin nanopore

Nanopores have been emerged as a powerful tool for analyzing the structural information and interactional properties of a range of biomolecules. The spatial resolution of nanopore is determined by the diameter and effective thickness of its constriction region, but the presence of vestibule or stem structure in protein-based nanopore could negatively affect the sensitivity of the nanopore when applied for genome sequencing and topological analysis of DNA. Recently, alpha-hederin (Ah) has been reported to form a sub-nanometer scale pore structure in lipid membrane. With the simple structure and extremely small effective thickness, the Ah nanopore was shown to discriminate four different types of nucleotides. However, identification of a certain nucleotide in a strand of DNA, which is essential for genome sequencing, remains challenging. Here, we investigated the resolving capability of Ah nanopore to discriminate few nucleotides in a strand of single-stranded DNA, and the factors determining the sensitivity of Ah nanopore. The Ah nanopore was shown to be able to identify as few as three adenosine nucleotides in a strand of poly cytidine, in which the dwell time of the additional current blockade that represents the adenosine residue was in good agreement with their physical length. We also found that the lateral tension and chain pressure generated around the nanopore were influenced by pore's diameter and played as a dependent variables to determine the geometry of nanopore's constriction as well as the spatial resolution of the Ah nanopore.

Characterization of Flagellar Filaments and Flagellin through Optical Microscopy and Label-Free Nanopore Responsiveness

In this study, we investigated the translocation characteristics of flagellar filaments (Salmonella typhimurium) and flagellin subunits through silicon nitride nanopores in tandem with optical microscopy analysis. Even though untagged flagella are dark to the optical method, the label-free nature of the nanopore sensor allows it to characterize both tagged (Cy3) and pristine forms of flagella (including real-time developments). Flagella were depolymerized to flagellin subunits at ∼65 °C (most commonly reported temperature), ∼70 °C, ∼75 °C, and ∼80 °C to investigate the effect of temperature (T_depol) on depolymerization. The change in conductance (ΔG) profiles corresponding to T_depol ∼65 °C and ∼70 °C were bracketed within the flagellin monomer profile whereas those of ∼75 °C and ∼80 °C extended beyond this profile, suggesting a change to the native protein state. The molecular radius calculated from the excluded electrolyte volume of flagellin through nanopore-based ΔG characteristics for each T_depol of ∼65 °C, ∼70 °C, ∼75 °C, and ∼80 °C yielded ∼4.2 ± 0.2 nm, ∼4.3 ± 0.3 nm, ∼4.1 ± 0.2 nm, and ∼4.7 ± 0.5 nm, respectively. This, along with ΔG (plateaued values) and translocation time profiles, points to the possibility of flagellin misfolding at ∼80 °C.

Push-Button Method To Create Nanopores Using a Tesla-Coil Lighter

Controlled dielectric breakdown (CDB) of silicon nitride thin films immersed in electrolyte solution has been used to fabricate single nanofluidic channels with ∼10 nm and smaller diameters, nanopores, useful in single-molecule sensing and ionic circuit construction. A hand-held Tesla-coil lighter was used to form nanofluidic ionic conductors through a ∼10 nm thick silicon nitride membrane. Modifications to the conventional approach were required by the low-overhead Tesla-coil-assisted method (TCAM): increased circuit resistance by including water in place of electrolyte and discrete rather than continuous voltage applications. The resulting ionic conductance could be tuned with the number of voltage applications. TCAM and conventional CDB produced nanopores with different conductance versus pH curves, suggesting different surface chemistry. Nevertheless, sensing experiments using the canonical test molecule, λ-DNA, produced signals comparable to translocation results through solid-state nanopores fabricated by other methods. Thus, the TCAM method offers flexibility in fabrication and in the properties and function of the nanoscale ionic conductors that it can generate.

Formation of Single Nanopores with Diameters of 20-50 nm in Silicon Nitride Membranes Using Laser-Assisted Controlled Breakdown

Nanopores with diameters from 20 to 50 nm in silicon nitride (SiN _x) windows are useful for single-molecule studies of globular macromolecules. While controlled breakdown (CBD) is gaining popularity as a method for fabricating nanopores with reproducible size control and broad accessibility, attempts to fabricate large nanopores with diameters exceeding ∼20 nm via breakdown often result in undesirable formation of multiple nanopores in SiN _x membranes. To reduce the probability of producing multiple pores, we combined two strategies: laser-assisted breakdown and controlled pore enlargement by limiting the applied voltage. Based on laser power-dependent increases in nanopore conductance upon illumination and on the absence of an effect of ionic strength on the ratio between the nanopore conductance before and after laser illumination, we suggest that the increased rate of controlled breakdown results from laser-induced heating. Moreover, we demonstrate that conductance values before and after coating the nanopores with a fluid lipid bilayer can indicate fabrication of a single nanopore versus multiple nanopores. Complementary flux measurements of Ca²⁺ through the nanopore typically confirmed assessments of single or multiple nanopores that we obtained using the coating method. Finally, we show that thermal annealing of CBD pores significantly increased the success rate of coating and reduced the current noise before and after lipid coating. We characterize the geometry of these nanopores by analyzing individual resistive pulses produced by translocations of spherical proteins and demonstrate the usefulness of these nanopores for estimating the approximate molecular shape of IgG proteins.

Surveying silicon nitride nanopores for glycomics and heparin quality assurance

Polysaccharides have key biological functions and can be harnessed for therapeutic roles, such as the anticoagulant heparin. Their complexity—e.g., >100 monosaccharides with variety in linkage and branching structure—significantly complicates analysis compared to other biopolymers such as DNA and proteins. More, and improved, analysis tools have been called for, and here we demonstrate that solid-state silicon nitride nanopore sensors and tuned sensing conditions can be used to reliably detect native polysaccharides and enzymatic digestion products, differentiate between different polysaccharides in straightforward assays, provide new experimental insights into nanopore electrokinetics, and uncover polysaccharide properties. We show that nanopore sensing allows us to easily differentiate between a clinical heparin sample and one spiked with the contaminant that caused deaths in 2008 when its presence went undetected by conventional assays. The work reported here lays a foundation to further explore polysaccharide characterization and develop assays using thin-film solid-state nanopore sensors.

The complexity of polysaccharides significantly complicates their analysis in comparison to other biopolymers. Here, the authors demonstrate that solid-state silicon nitride nanopore sensors can be used to reliably detect native polysaccharides and to perform a simple quality assurance assay on a polysaccharide therapeutic, heparin.

Physical Model for Rapid and Accurate Determination of Nanopore Size via Conductance Measurement

Nanopores have been explored for various biochemical and nanoparticle analyses, primarily via characterizing the ionic current through the pores. At present, however, size determination for solid-state nanopores is experimentally tedious and theoretically unaccountable. Here, we establish a physical model by introducing an effective transport length, L_eff, that measures, for a symmetric nanopore, twice the distance from the center of the nanopore where the electric field is the highest to the point along the nanopore axis where the electric field falls to e^-1 of this maximum. By [Formula: see text], a simple expression S₀ = f (G, σ, h, β) is derived to algebraically correlate minimum nanopore cross-section area S₀ to nanopore conductance G, electrolyte conductivity σ, and membrane thickness h with β to denote pore shape that is determined by the pore fabrication technique. The model agrees excellently with experimental results for nanopores in graphene, single-layer MoS₂, and ultrathin SiN_x films. The generality of the model is verified by applying it to micrometer-size pores.

Through a Window, Brightly: A Review of Selected Nanofabricated Thin-Film Platforms for Spectroscopy, Imaging, and Detection

We present a review of the use of selected nanofabricated thin films to deliver a host of capabilities and insights spanning bioanalytical and biophysical chemistry, materials science, and fundamental molecular-level research. We discuss approaches where thin films have been vital, enabling experimental studies using a variety of optical spectroscopies across the visible and infrared spectral range, electron microscopies, and related techniques such as electron energy loss spectroscopy, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, and single molecule sensing. We anchor this broad discussion by highlighting two particularly exciting exemplars: a thin-walled nanofluidic sample cell concept that has advanced the discovery horizons of ultrafast spectroscopy and of electron microscopy investigations of in-liquid samples; and a unique class of thin-film-based nanofluidic devices, designed around a nanopore, with expansive prospects for single molecule sensing. Free-standing, low-stress silicon nitride membranes are a canonical structural element for these applications, and we elucidate the fabrication and resulting features-including mechanical stability, optical properties, X-ray and electron scattering properties, and chemical nature-of this material in this format. We also outline design and performance principles and include a discussion of underlying material preparations and properties suitable for understanding the use of alternative thin-film materials such as graphene.

Microfluidic and Nanofluidic Resistive Pulse Sensing: A Review

The resistive pulse sensing (RPS) method based on the Coulter principle is a powerful method for particle counting and sizing in electrolyte solutions. With the advancement of micro- and nano-fabrication technologies, microfluidic and nanofluidic resistive pulse sensing technologies and devices have been developed. Due to the unique advantages of microfluidics and nanofluidics, RPS sensors are enabled with more functions with greatly improved sensitivity and throughput and thus have wide applications in fields of biomedical research, clinical diagnosis, and so on. Firstly, this paper reviews some basic theories of particle sizing and counting. Emphasis is then given to the latest development of microfuidic and nanofluidic RPS technologies within the last 6 years, ranging from some new phenomena, methods of improving the sensitivity and throughput, and their applications, to some popular nanopore or nanochannel fabrication techniques. The future research directions and challenges on microfluidic and nanofluidic RPS are also outlined.