Insights into Excitonic Dynamics of Terpolymer-Based High-Efficiency Nonfullerene Polymer Solar Cells: Enhancing the Yield of Charge Separation States

The Double-Cross of Benzotriazole-Based Polymers as Donors and Acceptors in Non-Fullerene Organic Solar Cells

Organic solar cells (OSCs) are considered a very promising technology to convert solar energy to electricity and a feasible option for the energy market because of the advantages of light weight, flexibility, and roll-to-roll manufacturing. They are mainly characterized by a bulk heterojunction structure where a polymer donor is blended with an electron acceptor. Their performance is highly affected by the design of donor-acceptor conjugated polymers and the choice of suitable acceptor. In particular, benzotriazole, a typical electron-deficient penta-heterocycle, has been combined with various donors to provide wide bandgap donor polymers, which have received a great deal of attention with the development of non-fullerene acceptors (NFAs) because of their suitable matching to provide devices with relevant power conversion efficiency (PCE). Moreover, different benzotriazole-based polymers are gaining more and more interest because they are considered promising acceptors in OSCs. Since the development of a suitable method to choose generally a donor/acceptor material is a challenging issue, this review is meant to be useful especially for organic chemical scientists to understand all the progress achieved with benzotriazole-based polymers used as donors with NFAs and as acceptors with different donors in OSCs, in particular referring to the PCE.

Effect of fluorine on the photovoltaic properties of 2,1,3-benzothiadiazole-based alternating conjugated polymers by changing the position and number of fluorine atoms

Fluorination is one of the most effective ways to manipulate molecular packing, optical bandgap and molecular energy levels in organic semiconductor materials. In this work, different number of fluorine atoms was introduced into the acceptor moiety 2,2'-dithiophene linked 2,1,3-benzothiadiazole, utilizing the alkylthiophene modified dithieno[2,3-d:2',3'-d']benzo[1,2-b:4,5-b] (DTBDT) as the donor unit, three polymers: PDTBDT-0F-BTs, PDTBDT-2F-BTs and PDTBDT-6F-FBTs were synthesized. With the number of fluorine atoms in each repeat unit of polymers varying from 0 to 2 and then up to 6, PDTBDT-0F-BTs, PDTBDT-2F-BTs and PDTBDT-6F-FBTs exhibited gradually downshifted energy levels and improved dielectric constants (εr) from 3.4 to 4.3 to 5.8, further successively increased charge transport mobilities. As a result, the power conversion efficiency (PCE) of the bulk heterojunction organic photovoltaic devices (BHJ-OPV) from the blend films of aforementioned polymers paired with PC71BM were gradually increased from 1.69 for PDTBDT-0F-BTs to 1.89 for PDTBDT-2F-BTs and then to 5.28 for PDTBDT-6F-FBTs. The results show that the continuous insertion of fluorine atoms into the repeating units of the benzothiadiazole conjugated polymer leads to the deepening of HOMO energy level, the increase of εr and the increase of charge mobility, which improve the efficiency of charge transfer and electron collection, thus improving the photovoltaic performance of BHJ-OPV.

Designing Benzodithiophene-Based Small Molecule Donors for Organic Solar Cells by Regulation of Halogenation Effects

The donors are key components of organic solar cells (OSCs) and play crucial roles in their photovoltaic performance. Herein, we designed two new donors (BTR-γ-Cl and BTR-γ-F) by finely optimizing small molecule donors (BTR-Cl and BTR-F) with a high performance. The optoelectronic properties of the four donors and their interfacial properties with the well-known acceptor Y6 were studied by density functional theory and time-dependent density functional theory. Our calculations show that the studied four donors have large hole mobility and strong interactions with Y6, where the BTR-γ-Cl/Y6 has the largest binding energy. Importantly, the proportion of charge transfer (CT) states increases at the BTR-γ-Cl/Y6 (50%) and BTR-γ-F/Y6 (45%) interfaces. The newly designed donors are more likely to achieve CT states through intermolecular electric field (IEF) and hot exciton mechanisms than the parent molecules; meanwhile, donors containing Cl atoms are more inclined to produce CT states through the direct excitation mechanism than those containing F atoms. Our results not only provided two promising donors but also shed light on the halogenation effects on donors in OSCs, which might be important to design efficient photovoltaic materials.

Two Compatible Acceptors as an Alloy Model with a Halogen-Free Solvent for Efficient Ternary Polymer Solar Cells

A ternary strategy of halogen-free solvent processing can open up a promising pathway for the preparation of polymer solar cells (PSCs) on a large scale and can effectively improve the power conversion efficiency with an appropriate third component. Herein, the green solvent o-xylene (o-XY) is used as the main solvent, and the non-fullerene acceptor Y6-DT-4F as the third component is introduced into the PBB-F:IT-4F binary system to broaden the spectral absorption and optimize the morphology to achieve efficient PSCs. The third component, Y6-DT-4F, is compatible with IT-4F and can form an "alloy acceptor", which can synergistically optimize the photon capture, carrier transport, and collection capabilities of the ternary device. Meanwhile, Y6-DT-4F has strong crystallinity, so when introduced into the binary system as the third component can enhance the crystallization, which is conducive to the charge transport. Consequently, the optimal ternary system based on PBB-F:IT-4F:Y6-DT-4F achieved an efficiency of 15.24%, which is higher than that of the binary device based on PBB-F:IT-4F (13.39%).

Ultrafast Kinetics of Chlorinated Polymer Donors: A Faster Excitonic Dissociation Path

Halogen-substituted donor/acceptor materials are widely regarded as a promising strategy toward improved power-conversion efficiencies (PCEs) in polymer solar cells (PSCs). A chlorinated polymer donor, PClBTA-PS, and its non-chlorinated analogue, PBTA-PS, are synthesized. The PClBTA-PS-based devices show significant enhancements in terms of open-circuit voltage (V_OC = 0.82 V) and fill factor (FF = 76.20%). In addition, a PCE of 13.20% is obtained, which is significantly higher than that for the PBTA-PS-based devices (PCE = 7.63%). Grazing incident wide-angle X-ray scattering shows that the chlorinated polymer enables better π-π stacking in both pure and blend films. DFT and TD-DFT calculations as well as ultrafast photophysics measurements indicate that chlorinated PClBTA-PS has a smaller bonding energy and a longer spontaneous-emission lifetime. The results also reveal that the charge-transfer-state excitons in PClBTA-PS:IT4Cl blend films split into the charge-separated (CS) state via a faster dissociation path, which produces a higher yield of the CS state. Overall, this study provides a deeper understanding of how a halogen-substituted polymer can improve PSCs in the future.

Rational Design and Characterization of Symmetry-Breaking Organic Semiconductors in Polymer Solar Cells: A Theory Insight of the Asymmetric Advantage

Asymmetric molecule strategy is considered an effective method to achieve high power conversion efficiency (PCE) of polymer solar cells (PSCs). In this paper, nine oligomers are designed by combining three new electron-deficient units (unitA)-n1, n2, and n3-and three electron-donating units (unitD)-D, E, and F-with their π-conjugation area extended. The relationships between symmetric/asymmetric molecule structure and the performance of the oligomers are investigated using the density functional theory (DFT) and time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) calculations. The results indicate that asymmetry molecule PEn2 has the minimum dihedral angle in the angle between two planes of unitD and unitA among all the molecules, which exhibited the advantages of asymmetric structures in molecular stacking. The relationship of the values of ionization potentials (IP) and electron affinities (EA) along with the unitD/unitA π-extend are revealed. The calculated reorganization energy results also demonstrate that the asymmetric molecules PDn2 and PEn2 could better charge the extraction of the PSCs than other molecules for their lower reorganization energy of 0.180 eV and 0.181 eV, respectively.

Significantly Boosting Efficiency of Polymer Solar Cells by Employing a Nontoxic Halogen-Free Additive

Traditional additives like 1,8-diiodooctane and 1-chloronaphthalene were successfully utilized morphology optimization of various polymer solar cells (PSCs) in an active layer, but their toxicity brought by halogen atoms limits their corresponding large-scale manufacturing. Herein, a new nontoxic halogen-free additive named benzyl benzoate (BB) was introduced into the classic PSCs (PTB7-Th:PC₇₁BM), and an optimal power conversion efficiency (PCE) of 9.43% was realized, while there was a poor PCE for additive free devices (4.83%). It was shown that BB additives could inhibit PC₇₁BM's overaggregation, which increased the interface contact area and formed a better penetration path of an active layer. In addition, BB additives could not only boost the distribution of a PTB7-Th donor at the surface, beneficial to suppressing exciton recombination in inverted devices but also boost the crystallinity of a blend layer, which is conducive to exciton dissociation and charge transport. Our work effectively improved a device performance by using a halogen-free additive, which can be referential for industrialization.

Ultrafast channel I and channel II charge generation processes at a nonfullerene donor-acceptor PTB7:PDI interface is crucial for its excellent photovoltaic performance

Nonfullerene organic solar cells have received much attention in recent years due to their low cost, high absorption coefficient and excellent synthetic flexibility. However, the microscopic photoinduced dynamics at corresponding donor-acceptor interfaces remains unclear. In this work, we have firstly employed state-of-the-art TDDFT-based nonadiabatic dynamics simulations in combination with static electronic structure calculations to explore the ultrafast photoinduced dynamics at a typical nonfullerene donor-acceptor PTB7:PDI interface using a minimal model system (172 atoms). Upon excitation with specific wavelength of light, both PTB7 and PDI can be locally excited to generate |PTB7* and |PDI* excitons due to their high absorption ability and significant overlap in absorption spectrum. After that, these localized excitons gradually convert to charge transfer exciton |PTB7+PDI-, while another |PTB7-PDI+ charge transfer exciton is not involved in the whole process. Along with the exciton conversion, electron transfer from PTB7 to PDI (channel I charge generation) and the hole transfer from PDI to PTB7 (channel II charge generation) occurs simultaneously with time constants of 643 fs and 549 fs respectively. In the same time, D index that measures the centroid distance of electron and hole increases from 1.0 Å to 4.0 Å, which clearly reflects a charge transfer process at the interface. Our present work provides solid evidence that both channel I and channel II charge generation processes play important roles at PTB7:PDI interface, which could be helpful for the design of novel nonfullerene solar cells with better photovoltaic performance.

A sequential ROMP strategy to donor–acceptor di-, tri- and tetra arylenevinylene block copolymers

Sequential ROMP of electron rich and electron deficient paracyclophanediene monomers gives donor–acceptor di-, tri- and even tetrablock phenylenevinylene coploymers.

Effects of Fluorination on Fused Ring Electron Acceptor for Active Layer Morphology, Exciton Dissociation, and Charge Recombination in Organic Solar Cells

Fluorination is one of the effective approaches to alter the organic semiconductor properties that impact the performance of the organic solar cells (OSCs). Positive effects of fluorination are also revealed in the application of fused ring electron acceptors (FREAs). However, in comparison with the efforts allocated to the material designs and power conversion efficiency enhancement, understanding on the excitons and charge carriers' behaviors in high-performing OSCs containing FREAs is limited. Herein, the impact of fluorine substituents on the active layer morphology, and therefore exciton dissociation, charge separation, and charge carriers' recombination processes are examined by fabricating OSCs with PTO2 as the donor and two FREAs, O-IDTT-IC and its fluorinated analogue O-IDTT-4FIC, as the acceptors. With the presence of O-IDTT-4FIC in the devices, it is found that the excitons dissociate more efficiently, and the activation energy required to split the excitons to free charge carriers is much lower; the charge carriers live longer and suffer less extent of trap-assisted recombination; the trap density is 1 order of magnitude lower than that of the nonfluorinated counterpart. Overall, these findings provide information about the complex impacts of FREA fluorination on efficiently performed OSCs.

Appropriate Molecular Interaction Enabling Perfect Balance Between Induced Crystallinity and Phase Separation for Efficient Photovoltaic Blends

Fluorination is a promising modification method to adjust the photophysical profiles of organic semiconductors. Notably, the fluorine modification on donor or acceptor materials could impact the molecular interaction, which is strongly related to the morphology of bulk heterojunction (BHJ) blends and the resultant device performance. Therefore, it is essential to investigate how the molecular interaction affects the morphology of BHJ films. In this study, a new fluorinated polymer PBDB-PSF is synthesized to investigate the molecular interaction in both nonfluorinated (ITIC) and fluorinated (IT-4F) systems. The results reveal that the F-F interaction in the PBDB-PSF:IT-4F system could effectively induce the crystallization of IT-4F while retaining the ideal phase separation scale, resulting in outstanding charge transport. On the contrary, poor morphology can be observed in the PBDB-PSF:ITIC system because of the unbalanced molecular interaction. As a consequence, the PBDB-PSF:IT-4F device delivers an excellent power conversion efficiency of 13.63%, which greatly exceeds that of the PBDB-PSF:ITIC device (9.84%). These results highlight manipulating the micromorphology with regard to molecular interaction.

Optimized Molecular Packing and Nonradiative Energy Loss Based on Terpolymer Methodology Combining Two Asymmetric Segments for High-Performance Polymer Solar Cells

In this work, a random terpolymer methodology combining two electron-rich units, asymmetric thienobenzodithiophene (TBD) and thieno[2,3-f]benzofuran segments, is systematically investigated. The synergetic effect is embodied on the molecular packing and nanophase when copolymerized with 1,3-bis(2-ethylhexyl)benzo[1,2-c:4,5-c']dithiophene-4,8-dione, producing an impressive power conversion efficiency (PCE) of 14.2% in IT-4F-based NF-PSCs, which outperformed the corresponding D-A copolymers. The balanced aggregation and better interpenetrating network of the TBD50:IT-4F blend film can lead to mixing region exciton splitting and suppress carrier recombination, along with high yields of long-lived carriers. Moreover, the broad applicability of terpolymer methodology is successfully validated in most electron-deficient systems. Especially, the TBD50/Y6-based device exhibits a high PCE of 15.0% with a small energy loss (0.52 eV) enabled by the low nonradiative energy loss (0.22 eV), which are among the best values reported for polymers without using benzodithiophene unit to date. These results demonstrate an outstanding terpolymer approach with backbone engineering to raise the hope of achieving even higher PCEs and to enrich organic photovoltaic materials reservoir.

"Double-Acceptor-Type" Random Conjugated Terpolymer Donors for Additive-Free Non-Fullerene Organic Solar Cells

Random conjugated terpolymers (RCTs) not only promote great comprehension and realization for the state-of-the-art highly effective non-fullerene organic solar cells (OSCs) but also offer a simple and practical synthetic strategy. However, the photovoltaic properties of RCTs yet lagged behind that of the donor-acceptor (D-A) alternating copolymer, especially in additive-free devices. Hence, we developed two feasible "double-acceptor-type" random conjugated terpolymers, PBDB-TAZ20 and PBDB-TAZ40. The additive-free OSCs based on PBDB-TAZ20:ITIC and PBDB-TAZ40:ITIC exhibit decent efficiencies of 12.34 and 11.27%, respectively, which both surpass the PBDB-T:ITIC-based device. For RCTs, the reasonably weakened crystallinity and the reduced phase separation degree are demonstrated to help in improving charge transport, reducing bimolecular recombination, and thus enhancing the photovoltaic performance of additive-free OSCs. The results imply that adding a third moiety into the D-A polymer donors provides a simple but efficient synthetic approach for high-performance OSCs.

Size Effect of Two-Dimensional Conjugated Space in Photovoltaic Polymers' Side Chain: Balancing Phase Separation and Charge Transport

Various two-dimensional (2D) side-chain-substituted benzo(1,2-b:4,5-b')dithiophene (BDT) blocks have been used to construct donor polymers, whereas the size effect of the side chains on the photovoltaic performance was overlooked in the past few years. In this work, three size-varied conjugated spaces (benzene, naphthalene, and biphenyl) were introduced into the corresponding polymers PBDB-Ph, PBDB-Na, and PBDB-BPh. This space engineering has a significant impact on the extent of phase separation in the active layer which blended with the polymer and the acceptor ITCPTC and preserved the desired morphology. The varied space size in the side chains lead to distinct balance mobility ratios of holes to electrons (benzene, 0.21; naphthalene, 0.75; and biphenyl, 0.57). Finally, PBDB-Na-based polymer solar cells (PSCs) delivered the highest power conversion efficiency of 12.52% when compared to the PSC performances of PBDB-Ph (8.48%) and PBDB-BPh (11.35%). The method in tailoring the side chain structures could fabricate a balance between phase separation and charge transport, providing an enlightenment for the development of photovoltaic devices.

Fluorination Effect for Highly Conjugated Alternating Copolymers Involving Thienylenevinylene-Thiophene-Flanked Benzodithiophene and Benzothiadiazole Subunits in Photovoltaic Application

Two two-dimensional (2D) donor-acceptor (D-A) type conjugated polymers (CPs), namely, PBDT-TVT-BT and PBDT-TVT-FBT, in which two ((E)-(4,5-didecylthien-2-yl)vinyl)- 5-thien-2-yl (TVT) side chains were introduced into 4,8-position of benzo[1,2-b:4,5-b']dithiophene (BDT) to synthesize the highly conjugated electron-donating building block BDT-TVT, and benzothiadiazole (BT) and/or 5,6-difluoro-BT as electron-accepting unit, were designed to systematically ascertain the impact of fluorination on thermal stability, optoelectronic property, and photovoltaic performance. Both resultant copolymers exhibited the lower bandgap (1.60 ~ 1.69 eV) and deeper highest occupied molecular orbital energy level (EHOMO, -5.17 ~ -5.37 eV). It was found that the narrowed absorption, deepened EHOMO and weakened aggregation in solid film but had insignificant influence on thermal stability after fluorination in PBDT-TVT-FBT. Accordingly, a PBDT-TVT-FBT-based device yielded 16% increased power conversion efficiency (PCE) from 4.50% to 5.22%, benefited from synergistically elevated VOC, JSC, and FF, which was mainly originated from deepened EHOMO, increased μh, μe, and more balanced μh/μe ratio, higher exciton dissociation probability and improved microstructural morphology of the photoactive layer as a result of incorporating fluorine into the polymer backbone.