Achieving Submicrosecond Thermally Activated Delayed Fluorescence Lifetime and Highly Efficient Electroluminescence by Fine-Tuning of the Phenoxazine-Pyrimidine Structure

The Golden Age of Thermally Activated Delayed Fluorescence Materials: Design and Exploitation

Since the seminal report by Adachi and co-workers in 2012, there has been a veritable explosion of interest in the design of thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF) compounds, particularly as emitters for organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs). With rapid advancements and innovation in materials design, the efficiencies of TADF OLEDs for each of the primary color points as well as for white devices now rival those of state-of-the-art phosphorescent emitters. Beyond electroluminescent devices, TADF compounds have also found increasing utility and applications in numerous related fields, from photocatalysis, to sensing, to imaging and beyond. Following from our previous review in 2017 ( Adv. Mater. 2017, 1605444), we here comprehensively document subsequent advances made in TADF materials design and their uses from 2017-2022. Correlations highlighted between structure and properties as well as detailed comparisons and analyses should assist future TADF materials development. The necessarily broadened breadth and scope of this review attests to the bustling activity in this field. We note that the rapidly expanding and accelerating research activity in TADF material development is indicative of a field that has reached adolescence, with an exciting maturity still yet to come.

Effects of donor substituents on the conformational heterogeneity, photophysical, mechanochromic and electroluminescent properties of the donor-substituted fluorine-containing triphenylpyrimidines

Three derivatives of fluorinated triphenylpyrimidine with the attached carbazole, phenothiazine, or acridan donor moieties are synthesized by Buchwald-Hartwig reactions. The impact of the donor units on emissive and other properties of the compounds is reported. The compounds exhibit excellent thermal stability, competitive photophysical phenomena such as room temperature phosphorescence (RTP) appearing when compounds are molecularly dispersed in the rigid polymer matrix and thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF). The compounds with carbazole and phenothiazine donor moieties show the manifestation of triplet-triplet annihilation in the electroluminescence when used as emitters in organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs). The phenothiazine-containing compound exhibit dual photoluminescence with the blue-shifted peak corresponding to the quasi-axial conformer and a red-shifted peak to the quasi-equatorial conformer. This derivative shows reversible shifts of emission spectra exceeding 100 nm due to the stable (at least 4 cycles) mechanochromic luminescence under the application of external stimuli. After grinding the emission intensity maximum is observed at 555 nm, after fuming at. ca 448 nm and after melting at 555 nm. The photoluminescence shifts and ON/OFF delayed fluorescence of the phenothiazine-based emitter occur due to the alteration between the crystalline and amorphous states. Optimization of the device structure allows to control the charge balance resulting in external quantum efficiency of up to 5.7 % observed for the OLED based on the phenothiazine-based emitter. This compound also shows the biggest response to the presence of oxygen acting as the quencher of triplet excited energy. The film of the compound doped in rigid Zeonex shows an 8.4-fold increase in emission intensity after evacuation. The optical sensor fabricated using the derivative of fluorinated triphenylpyrimidine and phenothiazine is characterized by the Stern-Volmer constant 1.37 × 10-4 ppm-1.

Regioisomerism vs Conformation: Impact of Molecular Design on the Emission Pathway in Organic Light-Emitting Device Emitters

Despite the design and proposal of several new structural motifs as thermally activated delayed fluorescent (TADF) emitters for organic light-emitting device (OLED) applications, the nature of their interaction with the host matrix in the emissive layer of the device and their influence on observed photophysical outputs remain unclear. To address this issue, we present, for the first time, the use of up to four regioisomers bearing a donor-acceptor-donor electronic structure based on the desymmetrized naphthalene benzimidazole scaffold, equipped with various electron-donating units and possessing distinguished conformational lability. Quantum chemical calculations allow us to identify the most favorable conformations adopted by the electron-rich groups across the entire pool of regioisomers. These conformations were then compared with conformational changes caused by the interaction of the emitter with the Zeonex and 4,4'-bis(N-carbazolyl)-1,1'-biphenyl (CBP) matrices, and the correlation with observed photophysics was monitored by UV-vis absorption and steady-state photoluminescence spectra, combined with time-resolved spectroscopic techniques. Importantly, a CBP matrix was found to have a significant impact on the conformational change of regioisomers, leading to unique TADF emission mechanisms that encompass dual emission and inversion of the singlet-triplet excited-state energies and result in the enhancement of TADF efficiency. As a proof of concept, regioisomers with optimal donor positions were utilized to fabricate an OLED, revealing, with the best-performing dye, an external quantum emission of 11.6%, accompanied by remarkable luminance (28,000 cd/m2). These observations lay the groundwork for a better understanding of the role of the host matrix. In the long term, this new knowledge can lead to predicting the influence of the host matrix and adopting the structure of the emitter in a way that allows the development of highly efficient and efficient OLEDs.

Styrylpyrimidine chromophores with bulky electron-donating substituents: experimental and theoretical investigation

Styrylpyrimidines with bulky 9,9-dimethylacridan, phenoxazine and phenothiazine electron-donating fragments were designed. Thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF) properties were expected for these structures. These chromophores exhibit peculiar emission properties. For 9,9-dimethylacridan and phenoxazine derivatives, a single emission highly sensitive to the polarity is observed in solution whereas for phenothiazine derivative a dual emission is observed in solution and is attributed to the coexistence of quasi-axial (Qax) and quasi-equatorial (Qeq) conformers. This study intends to understand through theoretical and experimental works, why the studied chromophores do not exhibit TADF properties, contrary to what was expected. The absence of phosphorescence both at room temperature and 77 K tends to indicate the impossibility to harvest triplet states in these systems. Wave-function based calculations show that for both conformers of the three chromophores the S1-T1 splitting is significantly larger than 0.2 eV. The second triplet state T2 of Qeq conformers is found very close in energy to the singlet S1 state, but S1 and T2 states possess similar charge transfer characters. This prevents efficient spin-orbit coupling between the states, which is consistent with the absence of TADF.

Zero-Zero Energy-Dominated Degradation in Blue Organic Light-Emitting Diodes Employing Thermally Activated Delayed Fluorescence

Blue-emitting organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs) fall significantly behind other OLEDs in operational stability. To better understand the key factors governing the stability of blue OLEDs employing thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF), nine efficient sky-blue to green TADF emitters with different frontier orbital energy levels and different TADF lifetimes have been designed and synthesized on the basis of charge-transfer (CT) acridine/phenyltriazine derivatives. Among them, ToDMAC-TRZ, a molecule composed of a 9,9-dimethyl-2,7-di-o-tolyl-9,10-dihydroacridine donor and a 2,4,6-triphenyl-1,3,5-triazine acceptor, shows a quantum yield of nearly 1 and a TADF lifetime as short as 0.59 μs in thin film. However, the stability of OLEDs is independent of the frontier orbital energy levels and TADF lifetime of the emitter. In contrast, the device half-life is found to decrease by five-sixths as the 0-0 energy of the singlet excitons increases by about 0.06 eV, which can be well-explained by the Arrhenius equation employing a photoreaction model. Whether in photoluminescence or electroluminescence, the contribution of long-lifetime triplet excitons to degradation is much lower than expected, which can be accounted for by how the solid-state solvation effect reduces the energy of the ³CT state and how most molecules have a low-lying locally excited triplet state.

Substituent effect on TADF properties of 2-modified 4,6-bis(3,6-di-tert-butyl-9-carbazolyl)-5-methylpyrimidines

The interest in organic materials exhibiting thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF) significantly increased in recent years owing to their potential application as emitters in highly efficient organic light emitting diodes (OLEDs). Simple modification of the molecular structure of TADF compounds through the selection of different electron-donating or accepting fragments opens great possibilities to tune the emission properties and rates. Here we present the synthesis of a series of novel pyrimidine-carbazole emitters and their photophysical characterization in view of effects of substituents in the pyrimidine ring on their TADF properties. We demonstrate that electron-withdrawing substituents directly connected to the pyrimidine unit have greater impact on the lowering of the energy gap between singlet and triplet states (ΔE ST) for efficient TADF as compared to those attached through a phenylene bridge. A modification of the pyrimidine unit with CN, SCH3, and SO2CH3 functional groups at position 2 is shown to enhance the emission yield up to 0.5 with pronounced TADF activity.

Temporal Dynamics of Solid-State Thermally Activated Delayed Fluorescence: Disorder or Ultraslow Solvation?

Time-resolved emission spectra of thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF) compounds in solid hosts demonstrate significant temporal shifts. To explain the shifts, two possible mechanisms were suggested, namely, slow solid-state solvation and conformational disorder. Here we employ solid hosts with controllable polarity for analysis of the temporal dynamics of TADF. We show that temporal fluorescence shifts are independent of the dielectric constant of the solid film; however, these shifts evidently depend on the structural parameters of both the host and the TADF dopant. A ≤50% smaller emission peak shift was observed in more rigid polymer host polystyrene than in poly(methyl methacrylate). The obtained results imply that both the host and the dopant should be as rigid as possible to minimize fluorescence instability.

Synthesis, Characterization, and Thin-Film Transistor Response of Benzo[i]pentahelicene-3,6-dione

Organic semiconductors hold the promise of simple, large area solution deposition, low thermal budgets as well as compatibility with flexible substrates, thus emerging as viable alternatives for cost-effective (opto)-electronic devices. In this study, we report the optimized synthesis and characterization of a helically shaped polycyclic aromatic compound, namely benzo[i]pentahelicene-3,6-dione, and explored its use in the fabrication of organic field effect transistors. In addition, we investigated its thermal, optical absorption, and electrochemical properties. Finally, the single crystal X-ray characterization is reported.

V-Shaped Methylpyrimidinium Chromophores for Nonlinear Optics

A series of four V-shaped methylpyrimidinium salts bearing diphenylamino-electron-donating groups appended at various pyrimidine positions were designed. These chromophores were obtained by regioselective N(1) monomethylation by methyl methanesulfonate of the pyrimidine core. Linear optical properties were studied experimentally and electronic properties were further completed by (TD)-DFT calculations. The second-order nonlinear optical (NLO) properties were also studied using electric field induced second harmonic generation (EFISH) method in chloroform, and all pyrimidinium salts exhibited μβ₀ >1000×10^-48  esu. The 2,4-disubstituted pyrimidinium core is preferred over 4,6-disubstitution as it enhances the NLO response and increases the dipole moment. (E,E)-2,4-Bis[4-(diphenylamino)styryl]-1-methylpyrimidin-1-ium methanesulfonate appears to be the best NLO-phore in chloroform in the series (μβ₀ =2500×10^-48  esu) and a figure of merit μβ₀ /MW=3.4 10^-48  esu mol g^-1 .

Vibrational Damping Reveals Vibronic Coupling in Thermally Activated Delayed Fluorescence Materials

We investigate a series of D-A molecules consisting of spiro[acridan-9,9'-fluorene] as the donor and 2-phenylenepyrimidine as the acceptor. In two of the materials, a spiro center effectively electronically isolates the D unit from (consequently) optically innocent yet structurally influential adamantyl side groups. In a third material, adamantyl groups attached directly to the acceptor strongly influence the electronic properties. Steady-state and time-resolved photophysical studies in solution, Zeonex polymer matrix, and neat films reveal that the substituents impact the efficiency of vibronic coupling between singlet and triplet states relevant to reverse intersystem crossing (rISC) and thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF), without significantly changing the singlet-triplet gap in the materials. The adamantyl groups serve to raise the segmental mass and inertia, thereby damping intramolecular motions (both vibrational and rotational). This substitution pattern reveals the role of large-amplitude (primarily D-A dihedral angle rocking) motions on reverse intersystem crossing (rISC), as well as smaller contributions from low-amplitude or dampened vibrations in solid state. We demonstrate that rISC still occurs when the high-amplitude motions are suppressed in Zeonex and discuss various vibronic coupling scenarios that point to an underappreciated role of intersegmental motions that persist in rigid solids. Our results underline the complexity of vibronic couplings in the mediation of rISC and provide a synthetic tool to enable future investigations of vibronic coupling through selective mechanical dampening with no impact on electronic systems.

TADF Parameters in the Solid State: An Easy Way to Draw Wrong Conclusions

The successful development of thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF) OLEDs relies on advances in molecular design. To guide the molecular design toward compounds with preferable properties, special care should be taken while estimating the parameters of prompt and delayed fluorescence. Mistakes made in the initial steps of analysis may lead to completely misleading conclusions. Here we show that inaccuracies usually are introduced in the very first steps while estimating the solid-state prompt and delayed fluorescence quantum yields, resulting in an overestimation of prompt fluorescence (PF) parameters and a subsequent underestimation of the delayed emission (DF) yield and rates. As a solution to the problem, a working example of a more sophisticated analysis is provided, stressing the importance of in-depth research of emission properties in both oxygen-saturated and oxygen-free surroundings.

TD-DFT and Experimental Methods for Unraveling the Energy Distribution of Charge-Transfer Triplet/Singlet States of a TADF Molecule in a Frozen Matrix

Reverse intersystem crossing (RISC) rate of a thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF) molecule is sensitive to the energy alignment of the singlet charge-transfer state (¹CT), triplet charge-transfer state (³CT), and locally excited triplet state (³LE). However, the energy distribution of the charge-transfer states originating from the conformational distribution of TADF molecules in a solid matrix inevitably generated during the preparation of a solid sample due to the rotatable donor-acceptor linkage is rarely considered. Moreover, the investigation of the energy distribution of the ³CT state is both theoretically and experimentally difficult due to the triplet instabilities of time-dependent density functional (TD-DFT) calculations and difficulties in phosphorescence measurements, respectively. As a result, the relationships between conformational distribution, configurations of excited state transition orbitals, and excited state energies/dynamics have not been clearly explained. In this work, we determined the energy distribution of CT states of the TADF emitter TPSA in frozen toluene at 77 K by the measurement of time-resolved spectra in the full time range (1 ns to 30 s) of emission including prompt fluorescence, TADF, ³CT phosphorescence, and ³LE phosphorescence. We obtained the energy band of CT states where ¹CT and ³CT states are distributed in the range of 2.85-3.00 and 2.64-2.96 eV, respectively. We tested various global hybrid and long-range corrected functionals for the TD-DFT calculation of ³CT energy of TPSA and found that only the M11 functional shows consistent results without triplet instability. We performed TD-DFT with the M11* functional optimized for a robust dihedral angle scan of ³CT states without triplet instability and reproduced the energy band structure obtained from the experiment. Through TD-DFT and experimental investigations, it is estimated that the dihedral angles of donor-acceptor (θ_D-A) and acceptor-linker (θ_A) of TPSA in frozen toluene lie within the range 70° ≤ θ_D-A ≤ 90° and 0° ≤ θ_A ≤ 30° respectively. Our results show that the dihedral angle distribution must be considered for further investigation of the photophysics of TADF molecules and the development of stable and efficient TADF emitters.

Photophysics of 9,9-Dimethylacridan-Substituted Phenylstyrylpyrimidines Exhibiting Long-Lived Intramolecular Charge-Transfer Fluorescence and Aggregation-Induced Emission Characteristics

Six pyrimidine-based push-pull systems substituted at positions C2 and C4/6 with phenylacridan and styryl moieties, employing methoxy or N,N-diphenylamino donors, have been designed and synthesized through cross-coupling and Knoevenagel reactions. X-ray analysis confirmed that the molecular structure featured the acridan moiety arranged perpendicularly to the residual π system. Photophysical studies revealed significant differences between the methoxy and N,N-diphenylamino chromophores. Solvatochromic studies revealed that the methoxy derivatives showed dual emission in polar solvents. Time-resolved spectroscopy revealed that the higher energy band involved very fast (<80 ps) fluorescence, whereas the lower energy one included long components (≈30 ns) due to long-lived intramolecular charge-transfer fluorescence. In contrast to N,N-diphenylamino chromophores, the methoxy derivatives also showed aggregation-induced emission in mixtures of THF/water, as well as dual emission in thin films, covering almost the whole visible spectrum with corresponding chromaticity coordinates not far from that of pure white light. These properties render the methoxy derivatives as very promising organic materials for white organic light-emitting diodes.