Understanding the Reactivity and Decomposition of a Highly Active Iron Pincer Catalyst for Hydrogenation and Dehydrogenation Reactions

Transition metal pincer catalysts for formic acid dehydrogenation: a mechanistic perspective

The storage and transportation of hydrogen gas, a non-polluting alternative to carbon-based fuels, have always been challenging due to its extreme flammability. In this regard, formic acid (FA) is a promising liquid organic hydrogen carrier (LOHC), and over the past decades, significant progress has been made in dehydrogenating FA through transition metal catalysis. In this review, our goal is to provide a detailed insight into the existing processes to expose various mechanistic challenges associated with FA dehydrogenation (FAD). Specifically, methodologies catalyzed by pincer-ligated metal complexes were chosen. Pincer ligands are preferred as they provide structural rigidity to the complexes, making the isolation and analysis of reaction intermediates less challenging and consequently providing a better mechanistic understanding. In this perspective, the catalytic activity of the reported pincer complexes in FAD was overviewed, and more importantly, the catalytic cycles were examined in detail. Further attention was given to the structural modifications, role of additives, reaction medium, and their crucial effects on the outcome.

On the Demise of PPP-Ligated Iron Catalysts in the Formic Acid Dehydrogenation Reaction

The PPP-ligated iron complexes, cis-(iPrPPRP)FeH2(CO) [iPrPPRP = (o-iPr2PC6H4)2PR (R = H or Me)], catalyze the dehydrogenation of formic acid to carbon dioxide but lose their catalytic activity over time. This study focuses on the analysis of the species formed from the degradation of cis-(iPrPPMeP)FeH2(CO) over its course of catalyzing the dehydrogenation reaction. These degradation products include species both soluble and insoluble in the reaction medium. The soluble component of the decomposed catalyst is a mixture of cis-[(iPrPPMeP)FeH(CO)2][(HCO2)(HCO2H)x], protonated iPrPPMeP, and oxidation products resulting from adventitious O2. The precipitate is solvated Fe(OCHO)2. Further mechanistic investigation suggests that cis-[(iPrPPMeP)FeH(CO)2][(HCO2)(HCO2H)x] displays diminished but measurable catalytic activity, likely through the displacement of a CO ligand by the formate ion. The formation of Fe(OCHO)2 along with the dissociation of iPrPPMeP is responsible for the eventual loss of catalytic activity.

Carbon neutral hydrogen storage and release cycles based on dual-functional roles of formamides

The development of alternative clean energy carriers is a key challenge for our society. Carbon-based hydrogen storage materials are well-suited to undergo reversible (de)hydrogenation reactions and the development of catalysts for the individual process steps is crucial. In the current state, noble metal-based catalysts still dominate this field. Here, a system for partially reversible and carbon-neutral hydrogen storage and release is reported. It is based on the dual-functional roles of formamides and uses a small molecule Fe-pincer complex as the catalyst, showing good stability and reusability with high productivity. Starting from formamides, quantitative production of CO-free hydrogen is achieved at high selectivity ( > 99.9%). This system works at modest temperatures of 90 °C, which can be easily supplied by the waste heat from e.g., proton-exchange membrane fuel cells. Employing such system, we achieve >70% H₂ evolution efficiency and >99% H₂ selectivity in 10 charge-discharge cycles, avoiding undesired carbon emission between cycles.

Structure and Thermodynamic Hydricity in Cobalt(triphosphine)(monophosphine) Hydrides

The mononuclear cobalt hydride complex [HCo(triphos)(PMe3)], in which triphos = PhP(CH2CH2PPh2)2, was synthesized and characterized by X-ray crystallography and by 1H and 31P NMR spectroscopy. The geometry of the compound is a distorted trigonal bipyramid in which the axial positions are occupied by the hydride and the central phosphorus atom of the triphos ligand, while the PMe3 and terminal triphos donor atoms occupy the equatorial positions. Protonation of [HCo(triphos)(PMe3)] generates H2 and the Co(I) cation, [Co(triphos)(PMe3)]+, and this reaction is reversible under an atmosphere of H2 when the proton source is weakly acidic. The thermodynamic hydricity of HCo(triphos)(PMe3) was determined to be 40.3 kcal/mol in MeCN from measurements of these equilibria. The reactivity of the hydride is, therefore, well suited to CO2 hydrogenation catalysis. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations were performed to evaluate the structures and hydricities of a series of analogous cobalt(triphosphine)(monophosphine) hydrides where the phosphine substituents are systematically changed from Ph to Me. The calculated hydricities range from 38.5 to 47.7 kcal/mol. Surprisingly, the hydricities of the complexes are generally insensitive to substitution at the triphosphine ligand, as a result of competing structural and electronic trends. The DFT-calculated geometries of the [Co(triphos)(PMe3)]+ cations are more square planar when the triphosphine ligand possesses bulkier phenyl groups and more tetrahedrally distorted when the triphosphine ligand has smaller methyl substituents, reversing the trend observed for [M(diphosphine)2]+ cations. More distorted structures are associated with an increase in ΔGH-°, and this structural trend counteracts the electronic effect in which methyl substitution at the triphosphine is expected to yield smaller ΔGH-° values. However, the steric influence of the monophosphine follows the normal trend that phenyl substituents give more distorted structures and increased ΔGH-° values.

Performance of homogeneous catalysts viewed in dynamics

Effective assessment of catalytic performance is the foundation for the rational design and development of new catalysts with superior performance. The ubiquitous screening/optimization studies use reaction yields as the sole performance metric in an approach that often neglects the complexity of the catalytic system and intrinsic reactivities of the catalysts. Using an example of hydrogenation catalysis, we examine the transient behavior of catalysts that are often encountered in activation, deactivation and catalytic turnover processes. Each of these processes and the reaction environment in which they take place are gradually shown to determine the real-time catalyst speciation and the resulting kinetics of the overall catalytic reaction. As a result, the catalyst performance becomes a complex and time-dependent metric defined by multiple descriptors apart from the reaction yield. This behaviour is not limited to hydrogenation catalysis and affects various catalytic transformations. In this feature article, we discuss these catalytically relevant descriptors in an attempt to arrive at a comprehensive depiction of catalytic performance.

Methyl Effects on the Stereochemistry and Reactivity of PPP-Ligated Iron Hydride Complexes

Iron dihydride complexes are key intermediates in many iron-catalyzed reactions. Previous efforts to study molecules of this type have led to the discovery of a remarkably stable cis-FeH₂ complex, which is supported by bis[2-(diisopropylphosphino)phenyl]phosphine (^iPrPP^HP) along with CO. In this work, the hydrogen on the central phosphorus has been replaced with a methyl group, and the corresponding iron carbonyl dichloride, hydrido chloride, and dihydride complexes have been synthesized. The addition of the methyl group favors the anti configuration for the Me-P-Fe-H moiety and the trans geometry for the H-Fe-CO motif, which is distinctively different from the ^iPrPP^HP system. Furthermore, it increases the thermal stability of the dihydride complex, cis-(^iPrPP^MeP)Fe(CO)H₂ (^iPrPP^MeP = bis[2-(diisopropylphosphino)phenyl]methylphosphine). The variations in stereochemistry and compound stability contribute greatly to the differences between the two PPP systems in reactions with PhCHO, CS₂, and HCO₂H.

Large changes in hydricity as a function of charge and not metal in (PNP)M–H (de)hydrogenation catalysts that undergo metal–ligand cooperativity

Ligand pKa and metal hydricity scale with one another in (de)hydrogenation catalysts that undergo metal–ligand cooperativity, irrespective of metal or ligand identity. Anionic hydrides are significantly more hydridic than their neutral counterparts.

Electronic insights into aminoquinoline-based PNHN ligands: protonation state dictates geometry while coordination environment dictates N-H acidity and bond strength

A variety of transition metal complexes bearing aminoquinoline PN^HH'-R ligands R = Ph (L1H), Cy (L2H) and their amido analogues are reported for rhodium(I) ([Rh(L1H)(PPh₃)]⁺1 and Rh(L1)(PPh₃) 2), cobalt(II) (Co(L2)(Cl) 3), and iron(II) ([Fe(L1H)₂]²⁺5, Fe(L1)₂6, and [Fe(C₅Me₅)(L1H)]PF₆7). The acid-base and redox properties of the amido complexes 2, 6, and their protio parent complexes 1, and 5 permit the determination of the pK_a and bond dissociation free energy (BDFE) of their N-H bonds while the ligand scaffold is coordinated to metal centres of square planar and octahedral geometry, respectively. From relative concentrations obtained by the use of ³¹P{¹H} NMR spectroscopy, a pK_a^THF value of 14 is calculated for rhodium complex 1, 6.4 for iron complex 5, and 24 for iron complex 7. These data, when combined with elecrochemical potentials obtained via cyclic voltammetry, allow the calculations of BDFE values for the N-H bond of 69 kcal mol^-1 for 1, and of 55 kcal mol^-1 for 5.

Control of Catalyst Isomers Using an N-Phenyl-Substituted RN(CH2CH2PiPr2)2 Pincer Ligand in CO2 Hydrogenation and Formic Acid Dehydrogenation

A novel pincer ligand, ^iPrPN^PhP [PhN(CH₂CH₂PⁱPr₂)₂], which is an analogue of the versatile MACHO ligand, ^iPrPN^HP [HN(CH₂CH₂PⁱPr₂)₂], was synthesized and characterized. The ligand was coordinated to ruthenium, and a series of hydride-containing complexes were isolated and characterized by NMR and IR spectroscopies, as well as X-ray diffraction. Comparisons to previously published analogues ligated by ^iPrPN^HP and ^iPrPN^MeP [CH₃N(CH₂CH₂PⁱPr₂)₂] illustrate that there are large changes in the coordination chemistry that occur when the nitrogen substituent of the pincer ligand is altered. For example, ruthenium hydrides supported by the ^iPrPN^PhP ligand always form the syn isomer (where syn/anti refer to the relative orientation of the group on nitrogen and the hydride ligand on ruthenium), whereas complexes supported by ^iPrPN^HP form the anti isomer and complexes supported by ^iPrPN^MeP form a mixture of syn and anti isomers. We evaluated the impact of the nitrogen substituent of the pincer ligand in catalysis by comparing a series of ^iPrPN^RP (R = H, Me, Ph)-ligated ruthenium hydride complexes as catalysts for formic acid dehydrogenation and carbon dioxide (CO₂) hydrogenation to formate. The ^iPrPN^PhP-ligated species is the most active for formic acid dehydrogenation, and mechanistic studies suggest that this is likely because there are kinetic advantages for catalysts that operate via the syn isomer. In CO₂ hydrogenation, the ^iPrPN^PhP-ligated species is again the most active under our optimal conditions, and we report some of the highest turnover frequencies for homogeneous catalysts. Experimental and theoretical insights into the turnover-limiting step of catalysis provide a basis for the observed trends in catalytic activity. Additionally, the stability of our complexes enabled us to detect a previously unobserved autocatalytic effect involving the base that is added to drive the reaction. Overall, by modifying the nitrogen substituent on the MACHO ligand, we have developed highly active catalysts for formic acid dehydrogenation and CO₂ hydrogenation and also provided a framework for future catalyst development.