Surface Density Variation within Cyclic Polymer Brushes Reveals Topology Effects on Their Nanotribological and Biopassive Properties

The Structural Dispersity of Oligoethylene Glycol-Containing Polymer Brushes Determines Their Interfacial Properties

Ought to their bioinert properties and facile synthesis, poly[(oligoethylene glycol)methacrylate]s (POEGMAs) have been raised as attractive alternatives to poly(ethylene glycols) (PEGs) in an array of (bio)material applications, especially when they are applied as polymer brush coatings. However, commercially available OEG-methacrylate (macro)monomers feature a broad distribution of OEG lengths, thus generating structurally polydisperse POEGMAs when polymerized through reversible deactivation radical polymerization. Here, we demonstrate that the interfacial physicochemical properties of POEGMA brushes are significantly affected by their structural dispersity, i.e., the degree of heterogeneity in the length of side OEG segments. POEGMA brushes synthesized from discrete (macro)monomers obtained through chromatographic purification of commercial mixtures show increased hydration and reduced adhesion when compared to their structurally polydisperse analogues. The observed alteration of interfacial properties is directly linked to the presence of monodisperse OEG side chains, which hamper intramolecular and intermolecular hydrophobic interactions while simultaneously promoting the association of water molecules. These phenomena provide structurally homogeneous POEGMA brushes with a more lubricious and protein repellent character with respect to their heterogeneous counterparts. More generally, in contrast to what has been assumed until now, the properties of POEGMA brushes cannot be anticipated while ruling out the effect of dispersity by (macro)monomer feeds. Simultaneously, side chain dispersity of POEGMAs emerges as a critical parameter for determining the interfacial characteristics of brushes.

Design, preparation, and characterization of lubricating polymer brushes for biomedical applications

The lubrication modification of biomedical devices significantly enhances the functionality of implanted interventional medical devices, thereby providing additional benefits for patients. Polymer brush coating provides a convenient and efficient method for surface modification while ensuring the preservation of the substrate's original properties. The current research has focused on a "trial and error" method to finding polymer brushes with superior lubricity qualities, which is time-consuming and expensive, as obtaining effective and long-lasting lubricity properties for polymer brushes is difficult. This review summarizes recent research advances in the biomedical field in the design, material selection, preparation, and characterization of lubricating and antifouling polymer brushes, which follow the polymer brush development process. This review begins by examining various approaches to polymer brush design, including molecular dynamics simulation and machine learning, from the fundamentals of polymer brush lubrication. Recent advancements in polymer brush design are then synthesized and potential avenues for future research are explored. Emphasis is placed on the burgeoning field of zwitterionic polymer brushes, and highlighting the broad prospects of supramolecular polymer brushes based on host-guest interactions in the field of self-repairing polymer brush applications. The review culminates by providing a summary of methodologies for characterizing the structural and functional attributes of polymer brushes. It is believed that a development approach for polymer brushes based on "design-material selection-preparation-characterization" can be created, easing the challenge of creating polymer brushes with high-performance lubricating qualities and enabling the on-demand creation of coatings. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Biomedical devices have severe lubrication modification needs, and surface lubrication modification by polymer brush coating is currently the most promising means. However, the design and preparation of polymer brushes often involves "iterative testing" to find polymer brushes with excellent lubrication properties, which is both time-consuming and expensive. This review proposes a polymer brush development process based on the "design-material selection-preparation-characterization" strategy and summarizes recent research advances and trends in the design, material selection, preparation, and characterization of polymer brushes. This review will help polymer brush researchers by alleviating the challenges of creating polymer brushes with high-performance lubricity and promises to enable the on-demand construction of polymer brush lubrication coatings.

Antifouling Surfaces Based on Polyzwitterion Loop Brushes

Antifouling surfaces have attracted increasing interest in recent years due to their potential application in various fields. In this work, we report a loop polyzwitterionic coating that exhibits excellent resistance to protein adsorption. Triblock and diblock copolymers of 2-[(2-hydroxyethyl)disulfanyl]ethyl methacrylate) (HSEMA) and 2-(dimethylamino)ethyl methacrylate) (DMAEMA) were synthesized by atom-transferred radical polymerization, followed by betainization of the DMAEMA block with 1,3-propane sultone and reduction of the disulfide bond in HSEMA to yield a triblock copolymer comprising a zwitterionic poly(sulfobetaine methacrylate) (PSBMA) midblock and poly(2-sulfanylethyl methacrylate) (PSEMA) terminal blocks as well as its diblock analogue that was of the same composition as the former and half the chain length. Both copolymers adsorbed to the gold substrate via the thiol groups in the terminal PSEMA block(s), creating loop and linear PSBMA brush coatings of comparable thickness, as revealed by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy and ellipsometry. Adsorption of bovine serum albumin and fibrinogen as model proteins from solution to these surfaces was investigated by a quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation and confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM), and platelet and bacterial adhesions were assessed by scanning electron microscopy and CLSM. The results demonstrate that both linear and loop polyzwitterion brushes are excellent in resisting the adsorption of the foulants, and the loop brushes are superior to the linear analogues.

Polymer brushes for friction control: Contributions of molecular simulations

When polymer chains are grafted to solid surfaces at sufficiently high density, they form brushes that can modify the surface properties. In particular, polymer brushes are increasingly being used to reduce friction in water-lubricated systems close to the very low levels found in natural systems, such as synovial joints. New types of polymer brush are continually being developed to improve with lower friction and adhesion, as well as higher load-bearing capacities. To complement experimental studies, molecular simulations are increasingly being used to help to understand how polymer brushes reduce friction. In this paper, we review how molecular simulations of polymer brush friction have progressed from very simple coarse-grained models toward more detailed models that can capture the effects of brush topology and chemistry as well as electrostatic interactions for polyelectrolyte brushes. We pay particular attention to studies that have attempted to match experimental friction data of polymer brush bilayers to results obtained using molecular simulations. We also critically look at the remaining challenges and key limitations to overcome and propose future modifications that could potentially improve agreement with experimental studies, thus enabling molecular simulations to be used predictively to modify the brush structure for optimal friction reduction.

Volume Overlap Variation within Hyperbranched Polymer Brushes Resolves Topology Effects against Protein Fouling

Hyperbranched polymer brushes with a three-dimensional dendritic structure are used in antifouling applications to obtain bioinert and compact dendritic structures. Though hyperbranched polyglycerol (HPG) is extensively utilized in the antifouling layer, there is still a lack of direct studies on the relationship between the interfacial properties and topology effect of hyperbranched polymer brushes. Here, we established the degree of chain volume overlap (D_v) to characterize the spatial shielding efficiency generated by HPG brushes and investigated the impact mechanism of the variable chain length on the interfacial physicochemical properties. The results revealed the D_v-relevant feature of performance that the most densely packed HPG brushes for a medium-length L_HPG3.07 enable the functional surface to display optimal antifouling performance toward protein adsorption by forming the most effective space barrier and hydrated layer in appropriate molecular weights and graft density. Moreover, we clarified the advance of hyperbranched polymer brushes exhibited in topology effects for imparting surface-enhanced resistance to biofouling relies on the generable higher steric hindrance as compared with linear analogs. This study established a D_v-relevant evaluation model for acquiring an optimized antifouling surface based on the appropriate choice of polymer structure, topology morphologies, and grafting parameters.

Conformation-dominated surface antifouling and aqueous lubrication

Antifouling and aqueous lubrication are important properties for biomaterials, especially for those with implantation purposes. In order to better understand the polymer conformation dependence of the surface antifouling and lubrication properties, poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) polymers with mono-functional and difunctional catechol anchors were designed and anchored on surface to adopt tail and loop conformations. Diblock and triblock copolymers with poly(dopamine methacrylamide) (PDMA) block as anchors and PEG block as the main body were synthesized and anchored on silicon surfaces by a "grafting to" strategy. The chemical composition, film thickness, and surface roughness of both coatings were controlled to be similar to give a direct comparison of looped brushes and tailed analogues. Then, the antifouling and surface friction behaviors were detected to verify the topological conformation effect of PEG polymer brushes. Results showed that PEG triblock copolymer modified surface exhibited an obviously better antifouling property and a lower friction coefficient of ∼0.011 than that of PEG diblock copolymer modified surface. Additionally, calculation and simulation results demonstrated that triblock copolymer had higher adsorption energy and anchored on surface with looped conformation. It is indicated that the strongly anchored PEG loops are effective for excellent antifouling and lubricating properties due to its strong hydration and steric hindrance. The conformation-dominated enhanced antifouling and reduced interfacial friction is an effective method for the development of excellent antifouling surfaces.

Macrocyclization efficiency for poly(2-oxazoline)s and poly(2-oxazine)s

Poly(2-oxazine)s show higher tendency to undergo macrocyclization compared to poly(2-alkyl-2-oxazoline)s, increasing scale-up potential and applicability of these cyclic polymers.

Counterpropagating Gradients of Antibacterial and Antifouling Polymer Brushes

We report on the formation of counterpropagating density gradients in poly([2-dimethylaminoethyl] methacrylate) (PDMAEMA) brushes featuring spatially varying quaternized and betainized units. Starting with PDMAEMA brushes with constant grafting density and degree of polymerization, we first generate a density gradient of quaternized units by directional vapor reaction involving methyl iodide. The unreacted DMAEMA units are then betainized through gaseous-phase betainization with 1,3-propanesultone. The gas reaction of PDMAEMA with 1,3-propanesultone eliminates the formation of byproducts present during the liquid-phase modification. We use the counterpropagating density gradients of quaternized and betainized PDMAEMA brushes in antibacterial and antifouling studies. Completely quaternized and betainized brushes exhibit antibacterial and antifouling behaviors. Samples containing 12% of quaternized and 85% of betainized units act simultaneously as antibacterial and antifouling surfaces.

Mussel-Inspired Multiloop Polyethers for Antifouling Surfaces

Despite the widespread use of polymers for antifouling coatings, the effect of the polymeric topology on the antifouling property has been largely underexplored. Unlike conventional brush polymers, a loop conformation often leads to strong steric stabilization of surfaces and antifouling and lubricating behavior owing to the large excluded volume and reduced chain ends. Herein, we present highly antifouling multiloop polyethers functionalized with a mussel-inspired catechol moiety with varying loop dimensions. Specifically, a series of polyethers with varying catechol contents were synthesized via anionic ring-opening polymerization by using triethylene glycol glycidyl ether (TEG) and catechol-acetonide glycidyl ether (CAG) to afford poly(TEG-co-CAG)_n. The versatile adsorption and antifouling effects of multiloop polyethers were evaluated using atomic force microscopy and a quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation. Furthermore, the crucial role of the loop dimension in the antifouling properties was analyzed via a surface force apparatus and a cell attachment assay. This study provides a new platform for the development of versatile antifouling polymers with varying topologies.

Gold nanoparticles endowed with low-temperature colloidal stability by cyclic polyethylene glycol in ethanol

The colloidal stability of metal nanoparticles is tremendously dependent on the thermal behavior of polymer brushes. Neat polyethylene glycol (PEG) presents an unconventional upper critical solution temperature in ethanol, where phase segregation and crystallization coexist. This thermal behavior translated to a PEG brush has serious consequences on the colloidal stability in ethanol of gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) modified with PEG brushes upon cooling. We observed that AuNPs (13 nm diameter) stabilized with conventional linear PEG brushes (M_n = 6 and 11 kg mol^-1) in ethanol suffer from reversible phase separation upon a temperature drop over the course of a few hours. However, the use of a polymer brush with cyclic topology as a stabilizer prevents sedimentation, ensuring the colloidal stability in ethanol at -25 °C for, at least, four months. We postulate that temperature-driven collapse of chain brushes promotes the interpenetration of linear chains, causing progressive AuNP sedimentation, a process that is unfavorable for cyclic polymer brushes whose topology prevents chain interpenetration. This study reinforces the notion about the importance of polymer topology on the colloidal stability of AuNPs.

Topology and Molecular Architecture of Polyelectrolytes Determine Their pH-Responsiveness When Assembled on Surfaces

Polymer composition and topology of surface-grafted polyacids determine the amplitude of their pH-induced swelling transition. The intrinsic steric constraints characterizing cyclic poly(2-carboxypropyl-2-oxazoline) (c-PCPOXA) and poly(2-carboxyethyl-2-oxazoline) (c-PCEOXA) forming brushes on Au surfaces induce an enhancement in repulsive interactions between charged polymer segments upon deprotonation, leading to an amplified expansion and a significant increment in swelling with respect to their linear analogues of similar molar mass. On the other hand, it is the composition of polyacid grafts that governs their hydration in both undissociated and ionized forms, determining the degree of swelling during their pH-induced transition.

Hydrogels Generated from Cyclic Poly(2-Oxazoline)s Display Unique Swelling and Mechanical Properties

Cyclic macromolecules do not feature chain ends and are characterized by a higher effective intramolecular repulsion between polymer segments, leading to a higher excluded-volume effect and greater hydration with respect to their linear counterparts. As a result of these unique properties, hydrogels composed of cross-linked cyclic polymers feature enhanced mechanical strength while simultaneously incorporating more solvent with respect to networks formed from their linear analogues with identical molar mass and chemical composition. The translation of topology effects by cyclic polymers into the properties of polymer networks provides hydrogels that ideally do not include defects, such as dangling chain ends, and display unprecedented physicochemical characteristics.

Cyclic Polyethylene Glycol as Nanoparticle Surface Ligand

Cyclic polymers behave different than linear polymers due to the lack of end groups and smaller coil dimensions. Herein, we demonstrate that cyclic polyethylene glycol (PEG) can be used as an alternative of classical linear PEG ligands for gold nanoparticle (AuNP) stabilization. We observed that the brush height of cyclic PEG on AuNPs of diameter 4.4 and 13.2 nm increases identically as that of linear brushes with (Nσ^1/2)^0.7 (N, number of monomers in a chain and σ, grafting density) and that cyclic brushes are more stretched than their linear analogues when compared to their unperturbed dimensions. Such structural effect and the reduced footprint diameter in cyclic brushes with the entire chain in a concentrated polymer brush regime explains the distinct response of NPs to ionic strength and temperature, respectively, compared to linear analogues. These experiments are an important step in understanding the effect of polymer brush topology on colloidal properties.

Functional Nanoassemblies of Cyclic Polymers Show Amplified Responsiveness and Enhanced Protein-Binding Ability

The physicochemical properties of cyclic polymer adsorbates are significantly influenced by the steric and conformational constraints introduced during their cyclization. These translate into a marked difference in interfacial properties between cyclic polymers and their linear counterparts when they are grafted onto surfaces yielding nanoassemblies or polymer brushes. This difference is particularly clear in the case of cyclic polymer brushes that are designed to chemically interact with the surrounding environment, for instance, by associating with biological components present in the medium, or, alternatively, through a response to a chemical stimulus by a significant change in their properties. The intrinsic architecture characterizing cyclic poly(2-oxazoline)-based polyacid brushes leads to a broad variation in swelling and nanomechanical properties in response to pH change, in comparison with their linear analogues of identical composition and molecular weight. In addition, cyclic glycopolymer brushes derived from polyacids reveal an enhanced exposure of galactose units at the surface, due to their expanded topology, and thus display an increased lectin-binding ability with respect to their linear counterparts. This combination of amplified responsiveness and augmented protein-binding capacity renders cyclic brushes invaluable building blocks for the design of "smart" materials and functional biointerfaces.

Topological Polymer Chemistry Enters Materials Science: Expanding the Applicability of Cyclic Polymers

Polymer-topology effects can alter technologically relevant properties when cyclic macromolecules are applied within diverse materials formulations. These include coatings, polymer networks, or nanostructures for delivering therapeutics. While substituting linear building blocks with cyclic analogues in commonly studied materials is itself of fundamental interest, an even more fascinating observation has been that the introduction of physical or chemical boundaries (e.g., a grafting surface or cross-links) can amplify the topology-related effects observed when employing cyclic polymer-based precursors for assembling multidimensional objects. Hence, the application of cyclic polymers has enabled the fabrication of coatings with enhanced biorepellency and superior lubricity, broadened the tuning potential for mechanical properties of polymer networks, increased the thermodynamic stability, and altered the capability of loading and releasing drugs within polymeric micelles.

Unraveling the nanomechanical properties of surface-grafted conjugated polymer brushes with ladder-like architecture

Surface-grafted polymer brushes with ladder-like architecture enforce extended conformation of the chains affecting their mechanical and tribological properties.

Bioinert and Lubricious Surfaces by Macromolecular Design

The modification of a variety of biomaterials and medical devices often encompasses the generation of biopassive and lubricious layers on their exposed surfaces. This is valid when the synthetic supports are required to integrate within physiological media without altering their interfacial composition and when the minimization of shear stress prevents or reduces damage to the surrounding environment. In many of these cases, hydrophilic polymer brushes assembled from surface-interacting polymer adsorbates or directly grown by surface-initiated polymerizations (SIP) are chosen. Although growing efforts by polymer chemists have been focusing on varying the composition of polymer brushes in order to attain increasingly bioinert and lubricious surfaces, the precise modulation of polymer architecture has simultaneously enabled us to substantially broaden the tuning potential for the above-mentioned properties. This feature article concentrates on reviewing this latter strategy, comparatively analyzing how polymer brush parameters such as molecular weight and grafting density, the application of block copolymers, the introduction of branching and cross-links, or the variation of polymer topology beyond the simple, linear chains determine highly technologically relevant properties, such as biopassivity and lubrication.

Dynamics of lubricious, concentrated PMMA brush layers studied by surface forces and resonance shear measurements

We employed surface forces and resonance shear measurement (RSM) for studying the structure and properties of typical concentrated polymer brushes (CPBs) of poly(methylmethacrylate) (PMMA) in toluene, which are known to show very low friction. The surface forces measured between the silica surfaces bearing PMMA brush layers showed a steric repulsive force at distances between the silica surfaces of less than ca. 1050 nm (Donset). Upon retraction after compression of the PMMA brush layers, no adhesive force was observed. This indicated that the interpenetration of the polymer chain was not induced by the normal load. Based on the resonance shear measurement, the elastic (k2) and damping (viscous) (b2) parameters, which represent the dynamic properties, of the PMMA brush layers were obtained by analyzing the resonance curves. At distances below the Donset, the b2 value significantly increased and slightly decreased at the higher normal loads, and the k2 value monotonically increased with increasing load. These k2 and b2 values were greater than those obtained for a PMMA brush layer and a bare silica surface (PMMA-silica). This indicated that the mobility of the polymer chains for the PMMA-PMMA brush layers was more suppressed compared to that for the PMMA-silica, due to the interpenetration of the polymer chains. The interpenetration of the polymer chains, commonly not observed for CPBs, could be most probably induced by the application of both the normal load and oscillating shear motion. With increasing shear amplitude on the compressed PMMA-PMMA brushes (at L = 0.84, 1.34 and 4.28 mN), the b2 value first increased then decreased whilst the k2 value monotonically decreased. These tendencies can be explained by the change from the sticking condition due to interpenetration (high k2), small sliding under interpenetration (increase in b2, decrease in k2), and then smooth sliding by pulling out of interpenetrated polymer chains (decrease in b2 and k2). The obtained results indicated that the operating conditions are quite important for using polymer brush layers as tribological materials because they can exhibit both a high and low friction depending on the conditions such as the load and shear amplitude.

Quantifying Solvent Effects on Polymer Surface Grafting

When grafting polymers onto surfaces, the reaction conditions critically influence the resulting interface properties, including the grafting density and molar mass distribution (MMD) on the surface. Herein, we show theoretically and experimentally that the application of poor solvents is beneficial for the "grafting-to" approach. We demonstrate the effect by grafting poly(methyl methacrylate) chains on silica nanoparticles in different solvents and compare the MMD of the polymer in solution before and after grafting via size exclusion chromatography (SEC). The shorter polymer chains are preferentially grafted onto the surface, leading to a distortion effect between the MMD in solution and on surfaces. The molecular weight distortion effect is significantly higher for ethyl acetate (good solvent quality, difference in M_w surface to solution 14%) than for N,N-dimethylacetamide (poor solvent quality, 6%). The difference in MMD on the surface to the solution significantly affects both the surface properties (e.g. the grafting densities) and their determination.

Synthesis of macrocyclic poly(ethylene oxide)s containing a protected thiol group: a strategy for decorating gold surfaces with ring polymers

Macrocyclic poly(ethylene oxide)s containing a protected thiol group are able to attach to gold substrates without thiol deprotection enabling surface modification.