Decision Making in Medicinal Chemistry: The Power of Our Intuition

DeLA-DrugSelf: Empowering multi-objective de novo design through SELFIES molecular representation

In this paper, we introduce DeLA-DrugSelf, an upgraded version of DeLA-Drug [J. Chem. Inf. Model. 62 (2022) 1411-1424], which incorporates essential advancements for automated multi-objective de novo design. Unlike its predecessor, which relies on SMILES notation for molecular representation, DeLA-DrugSelf employs a novel and robust molecular representation string named SELFIES (SELF-referencing Embedded String). The generation process in DeLA-DrugSelf not only involves substitutions to the initial string representing the starting query molecule but also incorporates insertions and deletions. This enhancement makes DeLA-DrugSelf significantly more adept at executing data-driven scaffold decoration and lead optimization strategies. Remarkably, DeLA-DrugSelf explicitly addresses the SELFIES-related collapse issue, considering only collapse-free compounds during generation. These compounds undergo a rigorous quality metrics evaluation, highlighting substantial advancements in terms of drug-likeness, uniqueness, and novelty compared to the molecules generated by the previous version of the algorithm. To evaluate the potential of DeLA-DrugSelf as a mutational operator within a genetic algorithm framework for multi-objective optimization, we employed a fitness function based on Pareto dominance. Our objectives focused on target-oriented properties aimed at optimizing known cannabinoid receptor 2 (CB2R) ligands. The results obtained indicate that DeLA-DrugSelf, available as a user-friendly web platform (https://www.ba.ic.cnr.it/softwareic/delaself/), can effectively contribute to the data-driven optimization of starting bioactive molecules based on user-defined parameters.

Molecule auto-correction to facilitate molecular design

Ensuring that computationally designed molecules are chemically reasonable is at best cumbersome. We present a molecule correction algorithm that morphs invalid molecular graphs into structurally related valid analogs. The algorithm is implemented as a tree search, guided by a set of policies to minimize its cost. We showcase how the algorithm can be applied to molecular design, either as a post-processing step or as an integral part of molecule generators.

Extracting medicinal chemistry intuition via preference machine learning

The lead optimization process in drug discovery campaigns is an arduous endeavour where the input of many medicinal chemists is weighed in order to reach a desired molecular property profile. Building the expertise to successfully drive such projects collaboratively is a very time-consuming process that typically spans many years within a chemist's career. In this work we aim to replicate this process by applying artificial intelligence learning-to-rank techniques on feedback that was obtained from 35 chemists at Novartis over the course of several months. We exemplify the usefulness of the learned proxies in routine tasks such as compound prioritization, motif rationalization, and biased de novo drug design. Annotated response data is provided, and developed models and code made available through a permissive open-source license.

MedChemLens: An Interactive Visual Tool to Support Direction Selection in Interdisciplinary Experimental Research of Medicinal Chemistry

Interdisciplinary experimental science (e.g., medicinal chemistry) refers to the disciplines that integrate knowledge from different scientific backgrounds and involve experiments in the research process. Deciding "in what direction to proceed" is critical for the success of the research in such disciplines, since the time, money, and resource costs of the subsequent research steps depend largely on this decision. However, such a direction identification task is challenging in that researchers need to integrate information from large-scale, heterogeneous materials from all associated disciplines and summarize the related publications of which the core contributions are often showcased in diverse formats. The task also requires researchers to estimate the feasibility and potential in future experiments in the selected directions. In this work, we selected medicinal chemistry as a case and presented an interactive visual tool, MedChemLens, to assist medicinal chemists in choosing their intended directions of research. This task is also known as drug target (i.e., disease-linked proteins) selection. Given a candidate target name, MedChemLens automatically extracts the molecular features of drug compounds from chemical papers and clinical trial records, organizes them based on the drug structures, and interactively visualizes factors concerning subsequent experiments. We evaluated MedChemLens through a within-subjects study (N=16). Compared with the control condition (i.e., unrestricted online search without using our tool), participants who only used MedChemLens reported faster search, better-informed selections, higher confidence in their selections, and lower cognitive load.

To Affinity and Beyond: A Personal Reflection on the Design and Discovery of Drugs

Faced with new and as yet unmet medical need, the stark underperformance of the pharmaceutical discovery process is well described if not perfectly understood. Driven primarily by profit rather than societal need, the search for new pharmaceutical products—small molecule drugs, biologicals, and vaccines—is neither properly funded nor sufficiently systematic. Many innovative approaches remain significantly underused and severely underappreciated, while dominant methodologies are replete with problems and limitations. Design is a component of drug discovery that is much discussed but seldom realised. In and of itself, technical innovation alone is unlikely to fulfil all the possibilities of drug discovery if the necessary underlying infrastructure remains unaltered. A fundamental revision in attitudes, with greater reliance on design powered by computational approaches, as well as a move away from the commercial imperative, is thus essential to capitalise fully on the potential of pharmaceutical intervention in healthcare.

On drug discovery against infectious diseases and academic medicinal chemistry contributions

This perspective is an attempt to document the problems that medicinal chemists are facing in drug discovery. It is also trying to identify relevant/possible, research areas in which academics can have an impact and should thus be the subject of grant calls. Accordingly, it describes how hit discovery happens, how compounds to be screened are selected from available chemicals and the possible reasons for the recurrent paucity of useful/exploitable results reported. This is followed by the successful hit to lead stories leading to recent and original antibacterials which are, or about to be, used in human medicine. Then, illustrated considerations and suggestions are made on the possible inputs of academic medicinal chemists. This starts with the observation that discovering a “good” hit in the course of a screening campaign still rely on a lot of luck – which is within the reach of academics –, that the hit to lead process requires a lot of chemistry and that if public–private partnerships can be important throughout these stages, they are absolute requirements for clinical trials. Concerning suggestions to improve the current hit success rate, one academic input in organic chemistry would be to identify new and pertinent chemical space, design synthetic accesses to reach these and prepare the corresponding chemical libraries. Concerning hit to lead programs on a given target, if no new hits are available, previously reported leads along with new structural data can be pertinent starting points to design, prepare and assay original analogues. In conclusion, this text is an actual plea illustrating that, in many countries, academic research in medicinal chemistry should be more funded, especially in the therapeutic area neglected by the industry. At the least, such funds would provide the intensive to secure series of hopefully relevant chemical entities which appears to often lack when considering the results of academic as well as industrial screening campaigns.

Decision Making in Structure-Based Drug Discovery: Visual Inspection of Docking Results

Molecular docking is a computational method widely used in drug discovery. Due to the inherent inaccuracies of molecular docking, visual inspection of binding modes is a crucial routine in the decision making process of computational medicinal chemists. Despite its apparent importance for medicinal chemistry projects, guidelines for the visual docking pose assessment have been hardly discussed in the literature. Here, we review the medicinal chemistry literature with the aim of identifying consistent principles for visual inspection, highlighting cases of its successful application, and discussing its limitations. In this context, we conducted a survey reaching experts in both academia and the pharmaceutical industry, which also included a challenge to distinguish native from incorrect poses. We were able to collect 93 expert opinions that offer valuable insights into visually supported decision-making processes. This perspective shall motivate discussions among experienced computational medicinal chemists and guide young scientists new to the field to stratify their compounds.

Improving the odds of success in antitumoral drug development using scoring approaches towards heterocyclic scaffolds

One of the most commonly discussed topics in the field of drug discovery is the continuous search for anticancer therapies, in which small-molecule development plays an important role. Although a number of techniques have been established over the past decades, one of the main methods for drug discovery and development is still represented by rational, ligand-based drug design. However, the success rate of this method could be higher if not affected by cognitive bias, which renders many potential druggable scaffolds and structures overlooked. The present study aimed to counter this bias by presenting an objective overview of the most important heterocyclic structures in the development of anti-proliferative drugs. As such, the present study analyzed data for 91,438 compounds extracted from the Developmental Therapeutics Program (DTP) database provided by the National Cancer Institute. Growth inhibition data from these compounds tested on a panel of 60 cancer cell lines representing various tissue types (NCI-60 panel) was statistically interpreted using 6 generated scores assessing activity, selectivity, growth inhibition efficacy and potency of different structural scaffolds, Bemis-Murcko skeletons, chemical features and structures common among the analyzed compounds. Of the most commonly used rings, the most prominent anti-proliferative effects were produced by quinoline, tetrahydropyran, benzimidazole and pyrazole, while overall, the optimal results were produced by complex ring structures that originate from natural compounds. These results highlight the impact of certain ring structures on the anti-proliferative effects in drug design. In addition, considering that medicinal chemists usually focus their research on simpler scaffolds the majority of the time with no significant pay-off, the present study indicates several unused complex scaffolds that could be exploited when designing anticancer therapies for optimal results in the fight against cancer.

Learning Molecular Representations for Medicinal Chemistry

The accurate modeling and prediction of small molecule properties and bioactivities depend on the critical choice of molecular representation. Decades of informatics-driven research have relied on expert-designed molecular descriptors to establish quantitative structure-activity and structure-property relationships for drug discovery. Now, advances in deep learning make it possible to efficiently and compactly learn molecular representations directly from data. In this review, we discuss how active research in molecular deep learning can address limitations of current descriptors and fingerprints while creating new opportunities in cheminformatics and virtual screening. We provide a concise overview of the role of representations in cheminformatics, key concepts in deep learning, and argue that learning representations provides a way forward to improve the predictive modeling of small molecule bioactivities and properties.

Positional Analogue Scanning: An Effective Strategy for Multiparameter Optimization in Drug Design

Minimizing the number and duration of design cycles needed to optimize hit or lead compounds into high-quality chemical probes or drug candidates is an ongoing challenge in biomedical research. Small structure modifications to hit or lead compounds can have meaningful impacts on pharmacological profiles due to significant effects on molecular and physicochemical properties and intra- and intermolecular interactions. Rapid pharmacological profiling of an efficiently prepared series of positional analogues stemming from the systematic exchange of methine groups with heteroatoms or other substituents in aromatic or heteroaromatic ring-containing hit or lead compounds is one approach toward minimizing design cycles (e.g., exchange of aromatic or heteroaromatic CH groups with N atoms or CF, CMe, or COH groups). In this Perspective, positional analogue scanning is shown to be an effective strategy for multiparameter optimization in drug design, whereby substantial improvements in a variety of pharmacological parameters can be achieved.

Chemical Intuition in Drug Design and Discovery

The medicinal chemist plays the most important role in drug design, discovery and development. The primary goal is to discover leads and optimize them to develop clinically useful drug candidates. This process requires the medicinal chemist to deal with large sets of data containing chemical descriptors, pharmacological data, pharmacokinetics parameters, and in silico predictions. The modern medicinal chemist has a large number of tools and technologies to aid him in creating strategies and supporting decision-making. Alongside with these tools, human cognition, experience and creativity are fundamental to drug research and are important for the chemical intuition of medicinal chemists. Therefore, fine-tuning of data processing and in-house experience are essential to reach clinical trials. In this article, we will provide an expert opinion on how chemical intuition contributes to the discovery of drugs, discuss where it is involved in the modern drug discovery process, and demonstrate how multidisciplinary teams can create the optimal environment for drug design, discovery, and development.