Recent Progress and Trends in X-ray-Induced Photodynamic Therapy with Low Radiation Doses

Harnessing External Irradiation for Precise Activation of Metal-Based Agents in Cancer Therapy

Cancer is a significant global health issue. Platinum-based chemotherapy drugs, including cisplatin, are crucial in clinical anti-cancer treatment. However, these drugs have limitations such as drug resistance, non-specific distribution, and irreversible toxic and side effects. In recent years, the development of metal-based agents has led to the discovery of other anti-cancer effects beyond chemotherapy. Precise spatiotemporal controlled external irradiation can activate metal-based agents at specific sites and play a different role from traditional chemotherapy. These strategies can not only enhance the anti-cancer efficiency, but also show fewer side effects and non-cross-drug resistance, which are ideal approaches to solve the problems caused by traditional platinum-based chemotherapy drugs. In this review, we focus on various metal-based agent-mediated cancer therapies that are activated by three types of external irradiation: near-infrared (NIR) light, ultrasound (US), and X-ray, and give some prospects. We hope that this review will promote the generation of new kinds of metal-based anti-cancer agents.

H2O2 promotes photodynamic efficacy of TMPyP4 against ovarian cancer in vitro by downregulating HIF-1α expression

Photodynamic therapy (PDT), employing photosensitizers to induce formation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) for tumor elimination, is emerging as a promising treatment modality in oncology due to its unique benefits. However, the PDT application in ovarian cancer, the most prevalent and lethal type of gynecological malignancy with a severe hypoxic microenvironment, remains unknown. This study revealed that photosensitizer TMPyP4 exhibited enhanced efficacy under H2O2 stimulation, with minimal change in cytotoxicity compared to TMPyP4 alone. The results showed that H2O2 increased ROS production induced by TMPyP4, leading to exacerbated mitochondrial dysfunction and DNA damage, ultimately inhibiting proliferation and inducing apoptosis in ovarian cancer cells. Mechanistically, H2O2 primarily enhanced the therapeutic efficacy of PDT with TMPyP4 against ovarian cancer cells by degrading HIF-1α, which subsequently modulated the HIF-1 signaling pathway, thereby alleviating the hypoxic environment in ovarian cancer cells. Our findings underscore the therapeutic potential of targeting HIF-1α within the hypoxic microenvironment for PDT in ovarian cancer and propose a novel integrated strategy for PDT treatment of this malignancy in vitro.

Axial O Atom-Modulated Fe(III)-N4 Sites for Enhanced Cascade Catalytic 1O2-Induced Tumor Therapy

The rational construction of efficient hypoxia-tolerant nanocatalysts capable of generating singlet oxygen (1O2) without external stimuli is of great importance for tumor therapy. Herein, uniformly dispersed and favorable biosafety profile graphitic carbon nitride quantum dots immobilized with Fe-N4 moieties modulated by axial O atom (denoted as O-Fe-N4) are developed for converting H2O2 into 1O2 via Russell reaction, without introducing external energy. Notably, O-Fe-N4 performs two interconnected catalytic properties: glutathione oxidase-mimic activity to provide substrate for subsequent 1O2 generation, avoiding the blunting anticancer efficacy by glutathione. The O-Fe-N4 catalyst demonstrates a specific activity of 79.58 U mg-1 at pH 6.2, outperforming the most reported Fe-N4 catalysts. Density functional theory calculations demonstrate that the axial O atom can effectively modulate the relative position and electron affinity between Fe and N, lowering the activation energy, strengthening the selectivity, and thus facilitating the Russell-type reaction. The gratifying enzymatic activity stemming from the well-defined Fe-N/O structure can inhibit tumor proliferation by efficiently downregulating glutathione peroxidase 4 activity and inducing lipid peroxidation. Altogether, the O-Fe-N4 catalyst not only represents an efficient platform for self-cascaded catalysis to address the limitations of 1O2-involved cancer treatment but also provides a paradigm to enhance the performance of the Fe-N4 catalyst.

Recent Advances in Photosensitizer Materials for Light-Mediated Tumor Therapy

Photodynamic therapy (PDT) as an emerging therapeutic method has drawn much attention in the treatment field for cancer. Photosensitizer, which can convert photon energy into cytotoxic species under light irradiation, is the core component in PDT. The design of photosensitizers still faces problems of light absorption, targeting, penetration and oxygen dependence. With the rapid progress of material science, various photosensitizers have been developed to produce cytotoxic species for treatment of tumor with high selectivity, safety, and noninvasiveness. Besides, the applications of photosensitizers have been expanded to diverse cancer treatments such as drug release, optogenetics and immune checkpoint blockade. In this review, we summarize the recent advances of photosensitizers in various therapeutic methods for cancer. Prevailing challenges and further prospects associated with photosensitizers are also discussed.

Oxygen-Independent Radiodynamic Therapy: Radiation-Boosted Chemodynamics for Reprogramming the Tumor Immune Environment and Enhancing Antitumor Immune Response

Radiodynamic therapy (RDT) has emerged as a promising modality for cancer treatment, offering notable advantages such as deep tissue penetration and radiocatalytic generation of oxygen free radicals. However, the oxygen-dependent nature of RDT imposes limitations on its efficacy in hypoxic conditions, particularly in modulating and eliminating radioresistant immune suppression cells. A novel approach involving the creation of a "super" tetrahedron polyoxometalate (POM) cluster, Fe12-POM, has been developed for radiation boosted chemodynamic catalysis to enable oxygen-independent RDT in hypoxic conditions. This nanoscale cluster comprises four P2W15 units functioning as energy antennas, while the Fe3 core serves as an electron receptor and catalytic center. Under X-ray radiation, a metal-to-metal charge transfer phenomenon occurs between P2W15 and the Fe3 core, resulting in the valence transition of Fe3+ to Fe2+ and a remarkable 139-fold increase in hydroxyl radical generation compared to Fe12-POM alone. The rapid generation of hydroxyl radicals, in combination with PD-1 therapy, induces a reprogramming of the immune environment within tumors. This reprogramming is characterized by upregulation of CD80/86, downregulation of CD163 and FAP, as well as the release of interferon-γ and tumor necrosis factor-α. Consequently, the occurrence of abscopal effects is facilitated, leading to significant regression of both local and distant tumors in mice. The development of oxygen-independent RDT represents a promising approach to address cancer recurrence and improve treatment outcomes.

Toward "super-scintillation" with nanomaterials and nanophotonics

Following the discovery of X-rays, scintillators are commonly used as high-energy radiation sensors in diagnostic medical imaging, high-energy physics, astrophysics, environmental radiation monitoring, and security inspections. Conventional scintillators face intrinsic limitations including a low extraction efficiency of scintillated light and a low emission rate, leading to efficiencies that are less than 10 % for commercial scintillators. Overcoming these limitations will require new materials including scintillating nanomaterials ("nanoscintillators"), as well as new photonic approaches that increase the efficiency of the scintillation process, increase the emission rate of materials, and control the directivity of the scintillated light. In this perspective, we describe emerging nanoscintillating materials and three nanophotonic platforms: (i) plasmonic nanoresonators, (ii) photonic crystals, and (iii) high-Q metasurfaces that could enable high performance scintillators. We further discuss how a combination of nanoscintillators and photonic structures can yield a "super scintillator" enabling ultimate spatio-temporal resolution while enabling a significant boost in the extracted scintillation emission.

Carbon dots as a novel photosensitizer for photodynamic therapy of cancer and bacterial infectious diseases: recent advances

Carbon dots (CDs) are novel carbon-based nanomaterials that have been used as photosensitizer-mediated photodynamic therapy (PDT) in recent years due to their good photosensitizing activity. Photosensitizers (PSs) are main components of PDT that can produce large amounts of reactive oxygen species (ROS) when stimulated by light source, which have the advantages of low drug resistance and high therapeutic efficiency. CDs can generate ROS efficiently under irradiation and therefore have been extensively studied in disease local phototherapy. In tumor therapy, CDs can be used as PSs or PS carriers to participate in PDT and play an extremely important role. In bacterial infectious diseases, CDs exhibit high bactericidal activity as CDs are effective in disrupting bacterial cell membranes leading to bacterial death upon photoactivation. We focus on recent advances in the therapy of cancer and bacteria with CDs, and also briefly summarize the mechanisms and requirements for PSs in PDT of cancer, bacteria and other diseases. We also discuss the role CDs play in combination therapy and the potential for future applications against other pathogens.

Assembling Au8 clusters on surfaces of bifunctional nanoimmunomodulators for synergistically enhanced low dose radiotherapy of metastatic tumor

BACKGROUND

Radiotherapy is one of the mainstays of cancer therapy and has been used for treating 65-75% of patients with solid tumors. However, radiotherapy of tumors has two limitations: high-dose X-rays damage adjacent normal tissue and tumor metastases cannot be prevented.

RESULTS

Therefore, to overcome the two limitations of radiotherapy, a multifunctional core-shell R837/BMS@Au8 nanoparticles as a novel radiosensitizer were fabricated by assembling Au8NCs on the surface of a bifunctional nanoimmunomodulator R837/BMS nanocore using nanoprecipitation followed by electrostatic assembly. Formed R837/BMS@Au8 NP composed of R837, BMS-1, and Au8 clusters. Au8NC can enhance X-ray absorption at the tumor site to reduce X-ray dose and releases a large number of tumor-associated antigens under X-ray irradiation. With the help of immune adjuvant R837, dendritic cells can effectively process and present tumor-associated antigens to activate effector T cells, meanwhile, a small-molecule PD-L1 inhibitor BMS-1 can block PD-1/PD-L1 pathway to reactivate cytotoxic T lymphocyte, resulting in a strong systemic antitumor immune response that is beneficial for limiting tumor metastasis. According to in vivo and in vitro experiments, radioimmunotherapy based on R837/BMS@Au8 nanoparticles can increase calreticulin expression on of cancer cells, reactive oxygen species generation, and DNA breakage and decrease colony formation. The results revealed that distant tumors were 78.2% inhibited depending on radioimmunotherapy of primary tumors. Therefore, the use of a novel radiosensitizer R837/BMS@Au8 NPs realizes low-dose radiotherapy combined with immunotherapy against advanced cancer.

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, the multifunctional core-shell R837/BMS@Au8 nanoparticles as a novel radiosensitizer effectively limiting tumor metastasis and decrease X-ray dose to 1 Gy, providing an efective strategy for the construction of nanosystems with radiosensitizing function.

Hafnium (Hf)-Chelating Porphyrin-Decorated Gold Nanosensitizers for Enhanced Radio-Radiodynamic Therapy of Colon Carcinoma

X-ray-induced radiodynamic therapy (RDT) that can significantly reduce radiation dose with an improved anticancer effect has emerged as an attractive and promising therapeutic modality for tumors. However, it is highly significant to develop safe and efficient radiosensitizing agents for tumor radiation therapy. Herein, we present a smart nanotheranostic system FA-Au-CH that consists of gold nanoradiosensitizers, photosensitizer chlorin e6 (Ce6), and folic acid (FA) as a folate-receptor-targeting ligand for improved tumor specificity. FA-Au-CH nanoparticles have been demonstrated to be able to simultaneously serve as radiosensitizers and RDT agents for enhanced computed tomography (CT) imaging-guided radiotherapy (RT) of colon carcinoma, owing to the strong X-ray attenuation capability of high-Z elements Au and Hf, as well as the characteristics of Hf that can transfer radiation energy to Ce6 to generate ROS from Ce6 under X-ray irradiation. The integration of RT and RDT in this study demonstrates great efficacy and offers a promising therapeutic modality for the treatment of malignant tumors.

Optimized strategies of ROS-based nanodynamic therapies for tumor theranostics

Reactive oxygen species (ROS) play a crucial role in regulating the metabolism of tumor growth, metastasis, death and other biological processes. ROS-based nanodynamic therapies (NDTs) are becoming attractive due to non-invasive, low side effects and tumor-specific advantages. NDTs have rapidly developed into numerous branches, such as photodynamic therapy, chemodynamic therapy, sonodynamic therapy and so on. However, the complexity of the tumor microenvironment and the limitations of existing sensitizers have greatly restricted the therapeutic effects of NDTs, which heavily rely on ROS levels. To address the limitations of NDTs, various strategies have been developed to increase ROS yield, which is an urgent aspect for the positive development of NDTs. In this review, the nanodynamic potentiation strategies in terms of unique properties and universalities of NDTs are comprehensively outlined. We mainly summarize the current dilemmas faced by each NDT and the respective solutions. Meanwhile, the NDTs universalities-based potentiation strategies and NDTs-based combined treatments are elaborated. Finally, we conclude with a discussion of the key issues and challenges faced in the development and clinical transformation of NDTs.

Application of singlet oxygen-activatable nanocarriers to boost X-ray-induced photodynamic therapy and cascaded ferroptosis for breast cancer treatment

Ferroptosis has appealing antitumor potential that is mainly based on the accumulation of lipid peroxide to a lethal level. The cytotoxic singlet oxygen (1O2) generated from nanoscale X-ray-induced photodynamic therapy (X-PDT) may facilitate glutathione (GSH) depletion and further activate ferroptosis. To realize combined X-PDT and ferroptosis, a nanocarrier (D-NPVR) was engineered with a hyperbranched copolymer with 1O2-sensitive linkers, where both the photosensitizer (verteporfin) and ferroptosis inducer RAS-selective lethal small molecule 3 (RSL3) were encapsulated. Upon X-ray radiation, D-NPVR could produce a large amount of 1O2 for apoptosis. Subsequently, 1O2 triggered D-NP dissociation by cleavage of 1,2-bis(2-hydroxyethylthio)ethylene bonds to boost payload release and decrease levels of intracellular GSH via thiol oxidation. Liberated RSL3 is a covalent inhibitor for glutathione peroxide 4 (GPX4), which is responsible for detoxifying lipid peroxides to lipid alcohols with GSH assistance, and both 1O2-induced GSH depletion and GPX4 inactivation thereby produced ferroptotic cell death. Tumor growth inhibition in murine 4T1 tumor-bearing mice demonstrated that D-NPVR produced pronounced therapeutic efficiency where ferroptosis induction was supported by the GPX4 content and expression. This study highlights the contribution of 1O2-sensitive nanocarriers for promoting the potency of combined X-PDT and ferroptosis.

The use of nanomaterials in advancing photodynamic therapy (PDT) for deep-seated tumors and synergy with radiotherapy

Photodynamic therapy (PDT) has been under development for at least 40 years. Multiple studies have demonstrated significant anti-tumor efficacy with limited toxicity concerns. PDT was expected to become a major new therapeutic option in treating localized cancer. However, despite a shifting focus in oncology to aggressive local therapies, PDT has not to date gained widespread acceptance as a standard-of-care option. A major factor is the technical challenge of treating deep-seated and large tumors, due to the limited penetration and variability of the activating light in tissue. Poor tumor selectivity of PDT sensitizers has been problematic for many applications. Attempts to mitigate these limitations with the use of multiple interstitial fiberoptic catheters to deliver the light, new generations of photosensitizer with longer-wavelength activation, oxygen independence and better tumor specificity, as well as improved dosimetry and treatment planning are starting to show encouraging results. Nanomaterials used either as photosensitizers per se or to improve delivery of molecular photosensitizers is an emerging area of research. PDT can also benefit radiotherapy patients due to its complementary and potentially synergistic mechanisms-of-action, ability to treat radioresistant tumors and upregulation of anti-tumoral immune effects. Furthermore, recent advances may allow ionizing radiation energy, including high-energy X-rays, to replace external light sources, opening a novel therapeutic strategy (radioPDT), which is facilitated by novel nanomaterials. This may provide the best of both worlds by combining the precise targeting and treatment depth/volume capabilities of radiation therapy with the high therapeutic index and biological advantages of PDT, without increasing toxicities. Achieving this, however, will require novel agents, primarily developed with nanomaterials. This is under active investigation by many research groups using different approaches.

Silica-Based Platform Decorated with Conjugated Polymer Dots and Prussian Blue for Improved Photodynamic Cancer Therapy

To advance cancer treatment, we have developed a novel composite material consisting of conjugated polymer dots (CPDs) and Prussian blue (PB) particles, which were immobilized on, and encapsulated within, silica particles, respectively. The CPDs functioned as both a photosensitizer and a photodynamic agent, and the PB acted as a photothermal agent. The silica platform provided a biocompatible matrix that brought the two components into close proximity. Under laser irradiation, the fluorescence from the CPDs in the composite material enabled cell imaging and was subsequently converted to thermal energy by PB. This efficient energy transfer was accomplished because of the spectral overlap between the emission of donor CPDs and the absorbance of acceptor PB. The increase in local temperature in the cells resulted in a significant increase in the amount of reactive oxygen species (ROS) generated by CPDs, in which their independent use did not produce sufficient ROS for cancer cell treatment. To assess the impact of the enhanced ROS generation by the composite material, we conducted experiments using cancer cells under 532 nm laser irradiation. The results showed that with the increase in local temperature, the generated ROS increased by 30% compared with the control, which did not contain PB. When the silica-based composite material was positioned at the periphery of the tumor for 120 h, it led to a much slower tumor growth than other materials tested. By using a CPD-based photodynamic therapy platform, a new simplified approach to designing and preparing cancer treatments could be achieved, which included photothermal PB-assisted enhanced ROS generation using a single laser. This advancement opens up an exciting new opportunity for effective cancer treatment.

Pure Organic AIE Nanoscintillator for X-ray Mediated Type I and Type II Photodynamic Therapy

X-ray induced photodynamic therapy (X-PDT) circumvents the poor penetration depth of conventional PDT with minimal radio-resistance generation. However, conventional X-PDT typically requires inorganic scintillators as energy transducers to excite neighboring photosensitizers (PSs) to generate reactive oxygen species (ROS). Herein, a pure organic aggregation-induced emission (AIE) nanoscintillator (TBDCR NPs) that can massively generate both type I and type II ROS under direct X-ray irradiation is reported for hypoxia-tolerant X-PDT. Heteroatoms are introduced to enhance X-ray harvesting and ROS generation ability, and AIE-active TBDCR exhibits aggregation-enhanced ROS especially less oxygen-dependent hydroxyl radical (HO•- , type I) generation ability. TBDCR NPs with a distinctive PEG crystalline shell to provide a rigid intraparticle microenvironment show further enhanced ROS generation. Intriguingly, TBDCR NPs show bright near-infrared fluorescence and massive singlet oxygen and HO•- generation under direct X-ray irradiation, which demonstrate excellent antitumor X-PDT performance both in vitro and in vivo. To the best of knowledge, this is the first pure organic PS capable of generating both 1 O2 and radicals (HO•- ) in response to direct X-ray irradiation, which shall provide new insights for designing organic scintillators with excellent X-ray harvesting and predominant free radical generation for efficient X-PDT.

Local Drug Delivery Techniques for Triggering Immunogenic Cell Death

Immunogenic cell death (ICD), a dying state of the cells, encompasses the changes in the conformations of cell surface and the release of damage-associated molecular patterns, which could initiate an adaptive immune response by stimulating the dendritic cells to present antigens to T cells. Advancements in biomaterials, nanomedicine, and micro- and nano-technologies have facilitated the development of effective ICD inducers, but the potential toxicity of these vesicles encountered in drug delivery via intravenous administration hampers their further application. As alternatives, the local drug delivery systems have gained emerging attention due to their ability to prolong the retention of high payloads at the lesions, sequester drugs from harsh environments, overcome biological barriers to exert optimal efficacy, and minimize potential side effects to guarantee bio-safety. Herein, a brief overview of the local drug delivery techniques used for ICD inducers is provided, explaining how these techniques broaden, alter, and enhance the therapeutic capability while circumventing systemic toxicity at the same time. The historical context and prominent examples of the local administration of ICD inducers are introduced. The complexities, potential pitfalls, and opportunities for local drug delivery techniques in cancer immunotherapy are also discussed.

Red, green, and blue radio-luminescent polymer dots doped with heteroleptic tris-cyclometalated iridium complexes

In this study, we synthesized radioexcitable luminescent polymer dots (P-dots) doped with heteroleptic tris-cyclometalated iridium complexes that emit red, green, and blue light. We investigated the luminescence properties of these P-dots under X-ray and electron beam irradiation, revealing their potential as new organic scintillators.

Energy Partitioning in Multicomponent Nanoscintillators for Enhanced Localized Radiotherapy

Multicomponent nanomaterials consisting of dense scintillating particles functionalized by or embedding optically active conjugated photosensitizers (PSs) for cytotoxic reactive oxygen species (ROS) have been proposed in the last decade as coadjuvant agents for radiotherapy of cancer. They have been designed to make scintillation-activated sensitizers for ROS production in an aqueous environment under exposure to ionizing radiations. However, a detailed understanding of the global energy partitioning process occurring during the scintillation is still missing, in particular regarding the role of the non-radiative energy transfer between the nanoscintillator and the conjugated moieties which is usually considered crucial for the activation of PSs and therefore pivotal to enhance the therapeutic effect. We investigate this mechanism in a series of PS-functionalized scintillating nanotubes where the non-radiative energy transfer yield has been tuned by control of the intermolecular distance between the nanotube and the conjugated system. The obtained results indicate that non-radiative energy transfer has a negligible effect on the ROS sensitization efficiency, thus opening the way to the development of different architectures for breakthrough radiotherapy coadjutants to be tested in clinics.

Enhancement of Light and X-ray Charging in Persistent Luminescence Nanoparticle Scintillators Zn2SiO4:Mn2+, Yb3+, Li. ACS APPLIED MATERIALS & INTERFACES 2023;15:21228-21238. [PMID: 37078901 DOI: 10.1021/acsami.3c00664]

Persistent luminescence nanoparticle scintillators (PLNS) have been attempted for X-ray-induced photodynamic therapy (X-PDT) because persistent luminescence after ceasing radiation can make PLNS use less cumulative irradiation time and dose to generate the same amount of reactive oxygen species (ROS) compared with conventional scintillators to combat cancer cells. However, excessive surface defects in PLNS reduce the luminescence efficiency and quench the persistent luminescence, which is fatal to the efficacy of X-PDT. Herein, the PLNS of SiO₂@Zn₂SiO₄:Mn²⁺, Yb³⁺, Li⁺ was designed by the energy trap engineering and synthesized by a simple template method, which has excellent X-ray and UV-excited persistent luminescence and continuously tunable emission spectra from 520 to 550 nm. Its luminescence intensity and afterglow time are more than 7 times that of the reported Zn₂SiO₄:Mn²⁺ used for X-PDT. By loading a Rose Bengal (RB) photosensitizer, an effective persistent energy transfer from the PLNS to photosensitizer is observed even after the removal of X-ray irradiation. The X-ray dose of nanoplatform SiO₂@Zn₂SiO₄:Mn²⁺, Yb³⁺, Li⁺@RB in X-PDT of HeLa cancer cells was reduced to 0.18 Gy compared to the X-ray dose of 1.0 Gy for Zn₂SiO₄:Mn for X-PDT. This indicates that the Zn₂SiO₄:Mn²⁺, Yb³⁺, Li⁺ PLNS have great potential for X-PDT applications.