Graphene Surface Acoustic Wave Sensor for Simultaneous Detection of Charge and Mass

Ion-sensitive field effect transistor biosensors for biomarker detection: current progress and challenges

The ion-sensitive field effect transistor (ISFET) has emerged as a crucial sensor device, owing to its numerous benefits such as label-free operation, miniaturization, high sensitivity, and rapid response time. Currently, ISFET technology excels in detecting ions, nucleic acids, proteins, and cellular components, with widespread applications in early disease screening, condition monitoring, and drug analysis. Recent advancements in sensing techniques, coupled with breakthroughs in nanomaterials and microelectronics, have significantly improved sensor performance. These developments are steering ISFETs toward a promising future characterized by enhanced sensitivity, seamless integration, and multifaceted detection capabilities. This review explores the structure and operational principles of ISFETs, highlighting recent research in ISFET biosensors for biomarker detection. It also examines the limitations of these sensors, proposes potential solutions, and anticipates their future trajectory. This review aims to provide a valuable reference for advancing ISFETs in the field of biomarker measurement.

Challenges for Field-Effect-Transistor-Based Graphene Biosensors

Owing to its outstanding physical properties, graphene has attracted attention as a promising biosensor material. Field-effect-transistor (FET)-based biosensors are particularly promising because of their high sensitivity that is achieved through the high carrier mobility of graphene. However, graphene-FET biosensors have not yet reached widespread practical applications owing to several problems. In this review, the authors focus on graphene-FET biosensors and discuss their advantages, the challenges to their development, and the solutions to the challenges. The problem of Debye screening, in which the surface charges of the detection target are shielded and undetectable, can be solved by using small-molecule receptors and their deformations and by using enzyme reaction products. To address the complexity of sample components and the detection mechanisms of graphene-FET biosensors, the authors outline measures against nonspecific adsorption and the remaining problems related to the detection mechanism itself. The authors also introduce a solution with which the molecular species that can reach the sensor surfaces are limited. Finally, the authors present multifaceted approaches to the sensor surfaces that provide much information to corroborate the results of electrical measurements. The measures and solutions introduced bring us closer to the practical realization of stable biosensors utilizing the superior characteristics of graphene.

A new strategy to minimize humidity influences on acoustic wave ultraviolet sensors using ZnO nanowires wrapped with hydrophobic silica nanoparticles

Surface acoustic wave (SAW) technology has been widely developed for ultraviolet (UV) detection due to its advantages of miniaturization, portability, potential to be integrated with microelectronics, and passive/wireless capabilities. To enhance UV sensitivity, nanowires (NWs), such as ZnO, are often applied to enhance SAW-based UV detection due to their highly porous and interconnected 3D network structures and good UV sensitivity. However, ZnO NWs are normally hydrophilic, and thus, changes in environmental parameters such as humidity will significantly influence the detection precision and sensitivity of SAW-based UV sensors. To solve this issue, in this work, we proposed a new strategy using ZnO NWs wrapped with hydrophobic silica nanoparticles as the effective sensing layer. Analysis of the distribution and chemical bonds of these hydrophobic silica nanoparticles showed that numerous C-F bonds (which are hydrophobic) were found on the surface of the sensitive layer, which effectively blocked the adsorption of water molecules onto the ZnO NWs. This new sensing layer design minimizes the influence of humidity on the ZnO NW-based UV sensor within the relative humidity range of 10-70%. The sensor showed a UV sensitivity of 9.53 ppm (mW/cm2)-1, with high linearity (R 2 value of 0.99904), small hysteresis (<1.65%) and good repeatability. This work solves the long-term dilemma of ZnO NW-based sensors, which are often sensitive to humidity changes.

Acoustically Induced Giant Synthetic Hall Voltages in Graphene

Any departure from graphene's flatness leads to the emergence of artificial gauge fields that act on the motion of the Dirac fermions through an associated pseudomagnetic field. Here, we demonstrate the tunability of strong gauge fields in nonlocal experiments using a large planar graphene sheet that conforms to the deformation of a piezoelectric layer by a surface acoustic wave. The acoustic wave induces a longitudinal and a giant synthetic Hall voltage in the absence of external magnetic fields. The superposition of a synthetic Hall potential and a conventional Hall voltage can annihilate the sample's transverse potential at large external magnetic fields. Surface acoustic waves thus provide a promising and facile avenue for the exploitation of gauge fields in large planar graphene systems.

Field-Effect Transistor with a Plasmonic Fiber Optic Gate Electrode as a Multivariable Biosensor Device

A novel multivariable system, combining a transistor with fiber optic-based surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy with the gate electrode simultaneously acting as the fiber optic sensor surface, is reported. The dual-mode sensor allows for discrimination of mass and charge contributions for binding assays on the same sensor surface. Furthermore, we optimize the sensor geometry by investigating the influence of the fiber area to transistor channel area ratio and distance. We show that larger fiber optic tip diameters are favorable for electronic and optical signals and demonstrate the reversibility of plasmon resonance wavelength shifts after electric field application. As a proof of principle, a layer-by-layer assembly of polyelectrolytes is performed to benchmark the system against multivariable sensing platforms with planar surface plasmon resonance configurations. Furthermore, the biosensing performance is assessed using a thrombin binding assay with surface-immobilized aptamers as receptors, allowing for the detection of medically relevant thrombin concentrations.

A love-mode surface acoustic wave aptasensor with dummy fingers based on monolayer MoS2/Au NPs nanocomposites for alpha-fetoprotein detection

The detection of cancer markers still has shortages of low sensitivity, time-consuming operation, the use of unstable and expensive antibodies. In this work, a novel Love-mode surface acoustic wave (LSAW) aptasensor with dummy fingers based on the monolayer molybdenum disulfide/gold nanoparticles (monolayer MoS₂/Au NPs) was developed for the highly sensitive and rapid determination of alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) in serum. Interdigital electrodes (IDTs) with dummy fingers were designed and applied to improve the acoustic characteristic of the LSAW aptasensor. The less energy dissipation and wave-front distortion of the LSAW aptasensor were confirmed by COMSOL simulation and test results. The newly-developed sensing film monolayer MoS₂/Au NPs/Apt/6-mercaptohexanol (MCH) was applied for the specific detection of AFP and significantly improved the sensitivity of the LSAW aptasensor. The excellent performance of the LSAW aptasensor allowed the sensitive and rapid detection of AFP in serum in the range of 0.01 ⁓ 100 ng/mL with a low detection limit of 4.79 pg/mL. Additionally, the proposed LSAW aptasensor exhibited excellent selectivity, long-term stability, and reproducibility, and could be used to detect other cancer biomarkers.

Surface acoustic wave sensor based on Au/TiO2/PEDOT with dual response to carbon dioxide and humidity

A surface acoustic wave (SAW) gas sensor with an Au/TiO₂/poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene) (PEDOT, which is a conductive polymer with photoelectric conversion function) sensing film was constructed for the quantitative detection of water vapor and CO₂. The Au/TiO₂/PEDOT sensing film was assembled on the delayed region of the 204 MHz SAW delay line, which was used as the base device for the gas sensor. The center frequency of the sensor decreases with an increase in relative humidity (RH), and the center frequency increases with increasing CO₂ concentration, so that not only can the two gases be identified, but quantitative analysis can also be performed. The SAW sensor has a response range of 5%-90% for RH and a response range of 500-2000 ppm for CO₂ gas. The shifts in center frequency varied linearly with the concentrations, giving rise to the sensitivities of -0.0068 and -0.1880 kHz %^-1 for RH and ∼0.003 kHz ppm^-1 CO₂. The response/recovery time is 9 s/9.2 s for 700 ppm CO₂ and 15 s/14 s for 70% RH. The experimental results show that the SAW sensor offers excellent selectivity, wide response range, rapid response, and good stability and repeatability. The mechanism of humidity and CO₂ sensing is attributed to the hydrophilic porous structure of the Au/TiO₂/PEDOT sensing film, and also to the reversible variation of its viscoelasticity under illumination conditions. The sensor, combined with the communication function of its own SAW device, has several prospective applications in the monitoring of atmospheric conditions.

Electrical detection of ppb region NO2 using Mg-porphyrin-modified graphene field-effect transistors

The trace detection of NO₂ through small sensors is essential for air quality measurement and the health field; however, small sensors based on electrical devices cannot detect NO₂ with the desired selectivity and quantitativity in the parts per billion (ppb) concentration region. In this study, we fabricated metalloporphyrin-modified graphene field-effect transistors (FETs). Mg-, Ni-, Cu-, and Co-porphyrins were deposited on the graphene FETs, and the transfer characteristics were measured. With the introduction of NO₂ in the ppb concentration region, the FETs of pristine graphene and Ni-, Cu-, and Co-porphyrin-modified graphene showed an insufficient response, whereas the Mg-porphyrin-modified graphene exhibited large voltage shifts in the transport characteristics. This indicates that Mg-porphyrin acts as an adsorption site for NO₂ molecules. An analysis of the Dirac-point voltage shifts with the introduction of NO₂ indicates that the shifts were well-fitted with the Langmuir adsorption isotherm model, and the limit of detection for NO₂ was found to be 0.3 ppb in N₂. The relationship between the mobility and the Dirac-point voltage shift with the NO₂ concentration shows that the complex of NO₂ and Mg-porphyrin behaves as a point-like charge impurity. Moreover, the Mg-porphyrin-modified graphene FETs show less response to other gases (O₂, H₂, acetic acid, trimethylamine, methanol, and hexane), thus indicating high sensitivity for NO₂ detection. Furthermore, we successfully demonstrated the quantitative detection of NO₂ in air, which is near the environmental standards. In conclusion, the results of the Mg-porphyrin-modified graphene FETs enable a rapid, easy, and selective detectability.

Acoustic streaming of microparticles using graphene-based interdigital transducers

Surface acoustic wave (SAW) devices offer many benefits in chemistry and biomedicine, enabling precise manipulation of micro-droplets, mixing of liquids by acoustic streaming and pumping of liquids in enclosed channels, while presenting a cost-effective and easy fabrication and integration with electronic devices. In this work, we present microfluidic devices which use graphene-based interdigital transducers (IDTs) to generate SAWs with a frequency of 100 MHz and an amplitude of up to 200 pm, which allow us to manipulate microparticle solutions by acoustic streaming. Due to the negligible mass loading of the piezoelectric surface by graphene, the SAWs generated by these devices have no frequency shift, typically observed when metal IDTs are used.

Sensitive Materials and Coating Technologies for Surface Acoustic Wave Sensors

Since their development, surface acoustic wave (SAW) devices have attracted much research attention due to their unique functional characteristics, which make them appropriate for the detection of chemical species. The scientific community has directed its efforts toward the development and integration of new materials as sensing elements in SAW sensor technology with a large area of applications, such as for example the detection of volatile organic compounds, warfare chemicals, or food spoilage, just to name a few. Thin films play an important role and are essential as recognition elements in sensor structures due to their wide range of capabilities. In addition, other requisites are the development and application of new thin film deposition techniques as well as the possibility to tune the size and properties of the materials. This review article surveys the latest progress in engineered complex materials, i.e., polymers or functionalized carbonaceous materials, for applications as recognizing elements in miniaturized SAW sensors. It starts with an overview of chemoselective polymers and the synthesis of functionalized carbon nanotubes and graphene, which is followed by surveys of various coating technologies and routes for SAW sensors. Different coating techniques for SAW sensors are highlighted, which provides new approaches and perspective to meet the challenges of sensitive and selective gas sensing.

Multifunctional and Sensitivity Enhancement of Hybrid Acoustoplasmonic Sensors Fabricated on 36XY-LiTaO3 with Gold Nanoparticles for the Detection of Permittivity, Conductivity, and the Refractive Index

Integration of high-sensitivity sensors with multiple sensing performance for the environmental detection of permittivity (ε_r), conductivity (σ), and the refractive index (n) is required to support Societies 5.0. However, there are still many sensors with low sensitivity that stand alone. A shear-horizontal surface acoustic wave (SH-SAW) sensor is usually used because of its high-sensitivity performance in detecting electrical properties. Moreover, localized surface plasmon resonance (LSPR) sensors show remarkable optical side capability. Here, we have successfully combined these advantages with an additional benefit of sensitivity enhancement. We propose a hybrid acoustoplasmonic sensor generated by integrating SH-SAW and LSPR devices to simultaneously detect ε_r, σ, and n. The SH-SAW sensor was fabricated on a 36XY-LiTaO₃ substrate using a developed interdigital transducer. Then, the LSPR sensor was implemented by the deposition of gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) on the propagation surfaces of the SH-SAW sensor. Fascinatingly, the AuNPs not only generate the LSPR effect but also enhance the SH-SAW sensor sensitivity. Comprehensive investigations were performed with atomic force microscopy imaging, CST software used for plasmonic E-field simulation, and hybrid sensing evaluation. Moreover, the SH-SAW sensitivity enhancement achieved using AuNPs was verified by frequency-domain and time-domain measurements. Thus, the SH-SAW sensor with AuNPs has a wide ε_r detection range (25-85), sensing capabilities for ultrasmall σ (0.00528-0.02504 S/m), and high sensitivity for n detection (45.5-201.9 nm/RIU). The cross-sectional effects were also evaluated. The effect of the LSPR device on the SH-SAW device was examined by turning the light OFF or ON (hereafter OFF/ON). The impact of the SH-SAW device on the LSPR device was investigated by turning the sine signal OFF/ON. We found that the SH-SAW sensor was not impacted by light. Interestingly, the presence of the SH-SAW sensor affects the positions of the AuNPs, which consistently generates a small blueshift in the LSPR effect. However, insignificant variation was noted in independent performances. In general, the SH-SAW sensor with AuNPs shows multifunctional independent characteristics and high-sensitivity performance, making it suitable for a chemical environment, with the possibility of integration with a wireless network.

On the Promotion of Catalytic Reactions by Surface Acoustic Waves

Surface acoustic waves (SAW) allow to manipulate surfaces with potential applications in catalysis, sensor and nanotechnology. SAWs were shown to cause a strong increase in catalytic activity and selectivity in many oxidation and decomposition reactions on metallic and oxidic catalysts. However, the promotion mechanism has not been unambiguously identified. Using stroboscopic X-ray photoelectron spectro-microscopy, we were able to evidence a sub-nanosecond work function change during propagation of 500 MHz SAWs on a 9 nm thick platinum film. We quantify the work function change to 455 μeV. Such a small variation rules out that electronic effects due to elastic deformation (strain) play a major role in the SAW-induced promotion of catalysis. In a second set of experiments, SAW-induced intermixing of a five monolayers thick Rh film on top of polycrystalline platinum was demonstrated to be due to enhanced thermal diffusion caused by an increase of the surface temperature by about 75 K when SAWs were excited. Reversible surface structural changes are suggested to be a major cause for catalytic promotion.

Dual Monitoring of Surface Reactions in Real Time by Combined Surface-Plasmon Resonance and Field-Effect Transistor Interrogation

By combining surface plasmon resonance (SPR) and electrolyte gated field-effect transistor (EG-FET) methods in a single analytical device we introduce a novel tool for surface investigations, enabling simultaneous measurements of the surface mass and charge density changes in real time. This is realized using a gold sensor surface that simultaneously serves as a gate electrode of the EG-FET and as the SPR active interface. This novel platform has the potential to provide new insights into (bio)adsorption processes on planar solid surfaces by directly relating complementary measurement principles based on (i) detuning of SPR as a result of the modification of the interfacial refractive index profile by surface adsorption processes and (ii) change of output current as a result of the emanating effective gate voltage modulations. Furthermore, combination of the two complementary sensing concepts allows for the comparison and respective validation of both analytical techniques. A theoretical model is derived describing the mass uptake and evolution of surface charge density during polyelectrolyte multilayer formation. We demonstrate the potential of this combined platform through the observation of layer-by-layer assembly of PDADMAC and PSS. These simultaneous label-free and real-time measurements allow new insights into complex processes at the solid-liquid interface (like non-Fickian ion diffusion), which are beyond the scope of each individual tool.

Selective Detection of Cu2+ Ions by Immobilizing Thiacalix[4]arene on Graphene Field-Effect Transistors

Highly accurate quantitative detection of heavy metals is essential for environmental pollution monitoring and health safety. Here, for selective detection of Cu2+ ions with high sensitivity, thiacalix[4]arene (TCA) immobilized on graphene field-effect transistors (G-FETs) are developed. Our proposed TCA-immobilized G-FETs are successfully used to detect Cu2+ ions at concentrations ranging from 1 μM to 1 mM via changes in their transfer characteristics. Moreover, the measured transfer characteristics clearly shift only when Cu2+ ions are introduced in the buffer solution despite it containing other metal ions, including those of Na+, Mg2+, Ni2+, and Cd2+; this selective detection of Cu2+ ions is attributed to the planar arrangement of TCA on graphene. Therefore, TCA-immobilized G-FETs selectively detect Cu2+ with high sensitivity.

Microfluidic opportunities in printed electrolyte-gated transistor biosensors

Printed electrolyte-gated transistors (EGTs) are an emerging biosensor platform that leverage the facile fabrication engendered by printed electronics with the low voltage operation enabled by ion gel dielectrics. The resulting label-free, nonoptical sensors have high gain and provide sensing operations that can be challenging for conventional chemical field effect transistor architectures. After providing an overview of EGT device fabrication and operation, we highlight opportunities for microfluidic enhancement of EGT sensor performance via multiplexing, sample preconcentration, and improved transport to the sensor surface.

Photosensing System Using Photosystem I and Gold Nanoparticle on Graphene Field-Effect Transistor

In this study, a light sensor is fabricated based on photosystem I (PSI) and a graphene field-effect transistor (FET) that detects light at a high quantum yield under ambient conditions. We immobilized PSI on a micrometer-sized graphene FET using Au nanoparticles (AuNPs) and measured the I-V characteristics of the modified graphene FET before and after light irradiation. The source-drain current (I_sd) increased upon illumination, exhibiting a photoresponsivity of 4.8 × 10² A W^-1, and the charge neutrality point of graphene shifted by -12 mV. This system represents the first successful photosensing system based on proteins and a solution-gated graphene FET. The probable mechanism of this negative shift can be explained by the increase in negative charge carriers in graphene induced by a hole trap in the AuNP resulting from electron transfer from the AuNP to PSI. Photoresponses were only observed in the presence of two surface-active agents, n-hexyltrimethylammonium bromide and sodium dodecylbenzenesulfonate, because they caused the formation of a hydrophobic environment on the surface of the graphene. The lipid layer of these agents caused dissociation of ascorbate ions from the graphene sheet, thereby expanding the Debye screening length of the electrolyte solution. The hydrophobic environment above graphene also enhanced hole storage in the AuNP through electron transfer from the AuNP to PSI.

Two-Dimensional Graphene Family Material: Assembly, Biocompatibility and Sensors Applications

Graphene and its chemically exfoliated derivatives—GO and rGO—are the key members of graphene family materials (GFM). The atomically thick crystal structure and the large continuous π conjugate of graphene imparts it with unique electrical, mechanical, optical, thermal, and chemical properties. Although those properties of GO and rGO are compromised, they have better scalability and chemical tunability. All GFMs can be subject to noncovalent modification due to the large basal plane. Besides, they have satisfying biocompatibility. Thus, GFMs are promising materials for biological, chemical and mechanical sensors. The present review summarizes how to incorporate GFMs into different sensing system including fluorescence aptamer-based sensors, field-effect transistors (FET), and electrochemical sensors, as well as, how to covalently and/or non-covalently modify GFMs to achieve various detection purpose. Sensing mechanisms and fabrication strategies that will influence the sensitivity of different sensing system are also reviewed.

Employing graphene acoustoelectric switch by dual surface acoustic wave transducers

We implement a logic switch by using a graphene acoustoelectric transducer at room temperature. We operate two pairs of inter-digital transducers (IDTs) to launch surface acoustic waves (SAWs) on a LiNbO3 substrate and utilize graphene as a channel material to sustain acoustoelectric current Iae induced by SAWs. By cooperatively tuning the input power on the IDTs, we can manipulate the propagation direction of Iae such that the measured Iae can be deliberately controlled to be positive, negative, or even zero. We define the zero-crossing Iae as [Formula: see text], and then demonstrate that Iae can be switched with a ratio [Formula: see text] at a rate up to few tens kHz. Our device with an accessible operation scheme provides a means to convert incoming acoustic waves modulated by digitized data sequence onto electric signals with frequency band suitable for digital audio modulation. Consequently, it could potentially open a route for developing graphene-based logic devices in large-scale integration electronics.

Direct growth of few-layer graphene on AlN-based resonators for high-sensitivity gravimetric biosensors

We present the successful growth of few-layer graphene on top of AlN-based solidly mounted resonators (SMR) using a low-temperature chemical vapour deposition (CVD) process assisted by Ni catalysts, and its effective bio-functionalization with antibodies. The SMRs are manufactured on top of fully insulating AlN/SiO2 acoustic mirrors able to withstand the temperatures reached during the CVD growth of graphene (up to 650 °C). The active AlN films, purposely grown with the c-axis tilted, effectively excite shear modes displaying excellent in-liquid performance, with electromechanical coupling and quality factors of around 3% and 150, respectively, which barely vary after graphene integration. Raman spectra reveal that the as-grown graphene is composed of less than five weakly coupled layers with a low density of defects. Two functionalization protocols of the graphene are proposed. The first one, based on a covalent binding approach, starts with a low-damage O2 plasma treatment that introduces a controlled density of defects in graphene, including carboxylic groups. After that, 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)carbodiimide hydrochloride/N-hydroxysuccinimide (EDC/NHS) chemistry is used to covalently bind streptavidin molecules to the surface of the sensors. The second functionalization protocol is based on the non-covalent bonding of streptavidin on hydrophobic graphene surfaces. The two protocols end with the effective bonding of biotinylated anti-IgG antibodies to the streptavidin, which leaves the surface of the devices ready for possible IgG detection.