Building on Cram's legacy: stimulated gating in hemicarcerands

Picking the lock of coordination cage catalysis

The design principles of metallo-organic assembly reactions have facilitated access to hundreds of coordination cages of varying size and shape. Many of these assemblies possess a well-defined cavity capable of hosting a guest, pictorially mimicking the action of a substrate binding to the active site of an enzyme. While there are now a growing collection of coordination cages that show highly proficient catalysis, exhibiting both excellent activity and efficient turnover, this number is still small compared to the vast library of metal-organic structures that are known. In this review, we will attempt to unpick and discuss the key features that make an effective coordination cage catalyst, linking structure to activity (and selectivity) using lessons learnt from both experimental and computational analysis of the most notable exemplars. We will also provide an outlook for this area, reasoning why coordination cages have the potential to become the gold-standard in (synthetic) non-covalent catalysis.

Photochemistry in a capsule: controlling excited state dynamics via confinement

Exerting control on excited state processes has been a long-held goal in photochemistry. One approach to achieve control has been to mimic biological systems in Nature (e.g., photosynthesis) that has perfected it over millions of years by performing the reactions in highly organized assemblies such as membranes and proteins by restricting the freedom of reactants and directing them to pursue a select pathway. The duplication of this concept at a smaller scale in the laboratory involves the use of highly confined and organized assemblies as reaction containers. This article summarizes the studies in the author's laboratory using a synthetic, well-defined reaction container known as octa acid (OA). OA, unlike most commonly known cavitands, forms a capsule in water and remains closed during the lifetime of the excited states of included molecules. Thus, the described excited state chemistry occurs in a small space with hydrophobic characteristics. Examples where the photophysical and photochemical properties are dramatically altered, compared to that in organic solvents wherein the molecules are freely soluble, are presented to illustrate the value of a restricted environment in controlling the dynamics of molecules on an excited state surface. While the ground state complexation of the guest and host is controlled by well-known concepts of tight-fit, lock and key, complementarity, etc., free space around the guest is necessary for it to be able to undergo structural transformations in the excited state, where the time is short. This article highlights the role of free space during the dynamics of molecules within a confined, inflexible reaction cavity.

Picking on Carbonate: Kinetic Selectivity in the Encapsulation of Anions

Supramolecular hosts bind to inorganic anions at a fast rate and select them in proportion with thermodynamic stability of the corresponding [anion⊂host] complexes, forming in a reversible manner. In this study, we describe the action of hexapodal capsule 1 and its remarkable ability to select anions based on a large span of rates by which they enter this host. The thermodynamic affinity of 1 toward eighteen anions extends over eight orders of magnitude (0<K_a <10⁸  M^-1 ; ¹ H NMR spectroscopy). The capsule would retain CO₃ ^2- (K_a =10⁷  M^-1 ) for hours in the presence of eleven competing anions, including stronger binding SO₄ ^2- , HAsO₄ ^2- and HPO₄ ^2- (K_a =10⁷ -10⁸  M^-1 ). The observed selection resulted from 1 possessing narrow apertures (ca. 3×6 Å) comparable in size to anions (d=3.5-7.1 Å) slowing down the encapsulation to last from seconds to days. The unorthodox mode of action of 1 sets the stage for creating hosts that pick anions by their ability to access the host.

How neocarcerand Octacid4 self-assembles with guests into irreversible noncovalent complexes and what accelerates the assembly

Cram's supramolecular capsule Octacid4 can irreversibly and noncovalently self-assemble with small-molecule guests at room temperature, but how they self-assemble and what accelerates their assembly remain poorly understood. This article reports 81 distinct Octacid4•guest self-assembly pathways captured in unrestricted, unbiased molecular dynamics simulations. These pathways reveal that the self-assembly was initiated by the guest interaction with the cavity portal exterior of Octacid4 to increase the portal collisions that led to the portal expansion for guest ingress, and completed by the portal contraction caused by the guest docking inside the cavity to impede guest egress. The pathways also reveal that the self-assembly was accelerated by engaging populated host and guest conformations for the exterior interaction to increase the portal collision frequency. These revelations may help explain why the presence of an exterior binding site at the rim of the enzyme active site is a fundamental feature of fast enzymes such as acetylcholinesterase and why small molecules adopt local minimum conformations when binding to proteins. Further, these revelations suggest that irreversible noncovalent complexes with fast assembly rates could be developed-by engaging populated host and guest conformations for the exterior interactions-for materials technology, data storage and processing, molecular sensing and tagging, and drug therapy.

A computational study of competing conformational selection and induced fit in an abiotic system

Host-guest complexations can be described by two competing mechanisms, conformational selection (CS) and induced fit (IF). In this work, we used a combination of nudged elastic band (NEB), adaptive steered molecular dynamics (ASMD), and density functional theory (DFT, with a correction for dispersion) to study the dynamics of the pathways (IF/CS) by which two conformers of basket B(+) and B(-) interconvert and trap CX₄ guests (X = Cl and Br). While the results from NEB/DFT studies disclosed host-guest noncovalent contacts reducing the basket's conformational dynamics, ASMD methodology suggested an associative mechanism for the guest complexation. With theory in excellent agreement with experiments, NEB and ASMD emerge as the methods of choice for studying dynamics of supramolecular systems.

From Selection to Instruction and Back: Competing Conformational Selection and Induced Fit Pathways in Abiotic Hosts

Two limiting cases of molecular recognition, induced fit (IF) and conformational selection (CS), play a central role in allosteric regulation of natural systems. The IF paradigm states that a substrate "instructs" the host to change its shape after complexation, while CS asserts that a guest "selects" the optimal fit from an ensemble of preexisting host conformations. With no studies that quantitatively address the interplay of two limiting pathways in abiotic systems, we herein and for the first time describe the way by which twisted capsule M-1, encompassing two conformers M-1(+) and M-1(-), trap CX₄ (X=Cl, Br) to give CX₄ ⊂M-1(+) and CX₄ ⊂M-1(-), with all four states being in thermal equilibrium. With the assistance of 2D EXSY, we found that CBr₄ would, at its lower concentrations, bind M-1 via a M-1(+)→M-1(-)→CBr₄ ⊂M-1(-) pathway corresponding to conformational selection. For M-1 complexing CCl₄ though, data from 2D EXSY measurements and 1D NMR line-shape analysis suggested that lower CCl₄ concentrations would favor CS while the IF pathway prevailed at higher proportions of the guest. Since CS and IF are not mutually exclusive, we reason that our work sets the stage for characterizing the dynamics of a wide range of already existing hosts to broaden our fundamental understanding of their action. The objective is to master the way in which encapsulation takes place for designing novel and allosteric sequestering agents, catalysts and chemosensors akin to those found in nature.

How the water-soluble hemicarcerand incarcerates guests at room temperature decoded with modular simulations

Molecular dynamics simulations of hemicarcerands and related variants allow the study of constrictive binding and offer insight into the rules of molecular complexation, but are limited because three-dimensional models of hemicarcerands are tedious to build and their atomic charges are complicated to derive. There have been no molecular dynamics simulations of the reported water-soluble hemicarcerand (Octacid4) that explain how Octacid4 encapsulates guests at 298 K and keeps them encapsulated at 298 K in NMR experiments. Herein we report a modular approach to hemicarcerand simulations that simplifies the model building and charge derivation in a manner reminiscent of the approach to protein simulations with truncated amino acids as building blocks. We also report that in aqueous molecular dynamics simulations at 298 K apo Octacid4 adopts two clusters of conformations one of which has an equatorial portal open but the guest-bound Octacid4 adopts one cluster of conformations with all portals closed. These results explain how Octacid4 incarcerates guests at room temperature and suggest that the guest-induced host conformational change that impedes decomplexation is a previously unrecognized conformational characteristic that promotes strong molecular complexation.

Guest Recognition Control Accompanied by Stepwise Gate Closing and Opening of a Macrocyclic Metallohost

Host-guest binding behavior of macrocyclic hosts is significantly influenced by the shapes and sizes of the hosts. In particular, closing/opening the apertures of the hosts controls the guest uptake/release. A post-metalation modification method was used to achieve the open/close conversions. The starting open complex, [LCo₂ (pip)₄ ](OTf)₂ , was efficiently converted to the closed complex, [LCo₂ (hda)₂ ](OTf)₂ , which has a doubly bridged structure. The conversion of this closed complex to the open complex [LCo₂ (hda)₂ (OAc)]⁺ was too slow to be completed, but this gate-opening was dramatically accelerated by the addition of Na⁺ . The Na⁺ binding was also significantly enhanced by the gate-opening, that is, conversion of [LCo₂ (hda)₂ ]²⁺ to [LCo₂ (hda)₂ (OAc)]⁺ .

Computational NMR Spectra of o-Benzyne and Stable Guests and Their Hemicarceplexes

The incarceration of o-benzyne and 27 other guest molecules within hemicarcerand 1, as reported experimentally by Warmuth, and Cram and co-workers, has been studied by density functional theory (DFT). The ¹ H NMR chemical shifts, rotational mobility, and conformational preference of the guests within the supramolecular cage were determined, which showed intriguing correlations of the chemical shifts with structural parameters of the host-guest system. Furthermore, based on the computed chemical shifts reassignments of some NMR signals are proposed. This affects, in particular, the putative characterization of the volatile benzyne molecule inside a hemicarcerand, for which our CCSD(T) and KT2 results indicate that the experimentally observed signals are most likely not resulting from an isolated o-benzyne within the supramolecular host. Instead, it is shown that the guest reacted with an aromatic ring of the host, and this adduct is responsible for the experimentally observed signals.

De novo endo-functionalized organic cages as cooperative multi-hydrogen-bond-donating catalysts

Two endo-functionalized organic cages as oxyanion hole mimics were achieved via dynamic covalent chemistry, which exhibit good size selectivity, catalytic activity and broad substrate scopes for Friedel-Crafts reactions. The modular character of the synthesis provides an easy way to modify the size, shape and inner function of the molecular cavity.

Light-responsive molecular containers

This review highlights relevant studies of light-controlled molecular containers able to catch and release small molecules.

Tailored oxido-vanadium(V) cage complexes for selective sulfoxidation in confined spaces

Five sets of oxido-vanadium(V) complexes, which include both cages and open structures, were prepared and tested in the catalytic oxidation of sulfides. It was found that the hemicryptophane complexes, which are simultaneously comprised of cyclotriveratrylene (CTV), binaphthol and oxido-vanadium(V) moieties, are the most efficient supramolecular catalysts. The specific shape of the confined hydrophobic space above the metal center leads to a strong improvement in the yield, selectivity and rate of the reaction, compared to the other catalysts investigated herein. A remarkable turnover number (TON) of 10 000 was obtained, which can be attributed to both the high reactivity and stability of the catalyst. Similarly to enzymes, the kinetic analysis shows that the mechanism of oxidation with the supramolecular catalysts obeys the Michaelis-Menten model, in which initial rate saturation occurs upon an increase in substrate concentration. This enzyme-like behavior is also supported by the competitive inhibition and substrate size-selectivity observed, which underline the crucial role played by the cavity.

Multicavity macrocyclic hosts

Multicavity macrocyclic hosts are host molecules comprising more than one macrocyclic guest binding components connected through multipoint linkages.

Gated molecular baskets

In this review, we describe the construction of gated molecular baskets, discuss their mechanism of action in regulating the exchange of guests and illustrate the potential of these concave hosts to act as catalysts for controlling chemical reactions. Importantly, a number of computational and experimental studies have suggested that gated baskets ought to unfold their gates at the rim for permitting the passage of guests to/from their inner space. These dynamic hosts are therefore offered as useful models for investigating the process of gating in artificial systems. Furthermore, gated baskets should permit examining the benefit of controlling the rate by which reactants access a gated catalyst for promoting chemical reactions occurring in its confined space.

Self-assembled capsules based on tetrafunctionalized calix[4]resorcinarene cavitands

The hemispherical structures of calix[4]resorcinarene cavitands are suitable for forming capsular assemblies with guest encapsulations through various intermolecular interactions.