Protein control of the redox potential of the primary quinone acceptor in reactioncCenters from Rhodobacter sphaeroides

Influence of Polar Mutations on the Electronic and Structural Properties of QA-· in Bacterial Reaction Centers

Reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides with residue M265 mutated from isoleucine to threonine, serine, and asparagine (M265IT, M265IS, and M265IN, respectively) in the Q_A^-· state are studied by high-resolution electron spin echo envelope modulation (ESEEM) and electron nuclear double resonance spectroscopy methods to investigate the structural characteristics of these mutants influencing the redox properties of the Q_A site. All three mutants decrease the redox midpoint potential (E_m) of Q_A by ∼0.1 V, yet the mechanism for this drop in E_m is unclear. In this work, we examine (i) the hydrogen bonding interactions between Q_A^-· and residues histidine M219 and alanine M260, (ii) the electron spin density distribution of the semiquinone, and (iii) the orientations of the ubiquinone methoxy substituents. ¹³C measurements show no significant contribution of methoxy dihedral angles to the observed decrease in E_m for the Q_A mutants. Instead, ¹⁴N three-pulse ESEEM data suggest that electrostatic or hydrogen bond formation between the mutated M265 side chain and His-M219 N_δ may be involved in the observed lowering of the Q_A midpoint potential. For mutant M265IN, analysis of the proton hyperfine couplings reveals a weakened hydrogen bond network, resulting in an altered Q_A^-· spin density distribution. The magnetic resonance study presented here is most consistent with an electrostatic or structural perturbation of the His-M219 N_δ hydrogen bond in these mutants as a mechanism for the ∼0.1 V decrease in Q_A E_m.

Introduction of the Menaquinone Biosynthetic Pathway into Rhodobacter sphaeroides and de Novo Synthesis of Menaquinone for Incorporation into Heterologously Expressed Integral Membrane Proteins

Quinones are redox-active molecules that transport electrons and protons in organelles and cell membranes during respiration and photosynthesis. In addition to the fundamental importance of these processes in supporting life, there has been considerable interest in exploiting their mechanisms for diverse applications ranging from medical advances to innovative biotechnologies. Such applications include novel treatments to target pathogenic bacterial infections and fabricating biohybrid solar cells as an alternative renewable energy source. Ubiquinone (UQ) is the predominant charge-transfer mediator in both respiration and photosynthesis. Other quinones, such as menaquinone (MK), are additional or alternative redox mediators, for example in bacterial photosynthesis of species such as Thermochromatium tepidum and Chloroflexus aurantiacus. Rhodobacter sphaeroides has been used extensively to study electron transfer processes, and recently as a platform to produce integral membrane proteins from other species. To expand the diversity of redox mediators in R. sphaeroides, nine Escherichia coli genes encoding the synthesis of MK from chorismate and polyprenyl diphosphate were assembled into a synthetic operon in a newly designed expression plasmid. We show that the menFDHBCE, menI, menA, and ubiE genes are sufficient for MK synthesis when expressed in R. sphaeroides cells, on the basis of high performance liquid chromatography and mass spectrometry. The T. tepidum and C. aurantiacus photosynthetic reaction centers produced in R. sphaeroides were found to contain MK. We also measured in vitro charge recombination kinetics of the T. tepidum reaction center to demonstrate that the MK is redox-active and incorporated into the Q_A pocket of this heterologously expressed reaction center.

Systematic High-Accuracy Prediction of Electron Affinities for Biological Quinones

Quinones play vital roles as electron carriers in fundamental biological processes; therefore, the ability to accurately predict their electron affinities is crucial for understanding their properties and function. The increasing availability of cost-effective implementations of correlated wave function methods for both closed-shell and open-shell systems offers an alternative to density functional theory approaches that have traditionally dominated the field despite their shortcomings. Here, we define a benchmark set of quinones with experimentally available electron affinities and evaluate a range of electronic structure methods, setting a target accuracy of 0.1 eV. Among wave function methods, we test various implementations of coupled cluster (CC) theory, including local pair natural orbital (LPNO) approaches to canonical and parameterized CCSD, the domain-based DLPNO approximation, and the equations-of-motion approach for electron affinities, EA-EOM-CCSD. In addition, several variants of canonical, spin-component-scaled, orbital-optimized, and explicitly correlated (F12) Møller-Plesset perturbation theory are benchmarked. Achieving systematically the target level of accuracy is challenging and a composite scheme that combines canonical CCSD(T) with large basis set LPNO-based extrapolation of correlation energy proves to be the most accurate approach. Methods that offer comparable performance are the parameterized LPNO-pCCSD, the DLPNO-CCSD(T₀ ), and the orbital optimized OO-SCS-MP2. Among DFT methods, viable practical alternatives are only the M06 and the double hybrids, but the latter should be employed with caution because of significant basis set sensitivity. A highly accurate yet cost-effective DLPNO-based coupled cluster approach is used to investigate the methoxy conformation effect on the electron affinities of ubiquinones found in photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers. © 2018 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Protonated rhodosemiquinone at the Q(B) binding site of the M265IT mutant reaction center of photosynthetic bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides

The second electron transfer from primary ubiquinone Q(A) to secondary ubiquinone Q(B) in the reaction center (RC) from Rhodobacter sphaeroides involves a protonated Q(B)(-) intermediate state whose low pK(a) makes direct observation impossible. Here, we replaced the native ubiquinone with low-potential rhodoquinone at the Q(B) binding site of the M265IT mutant RC. Because the in situ midpoint redox potential of Q(A) of this mutant was lowered approximately the same extent (≈100 mV) as that of Q(B) upon exchange of ubiquinone with low-potential rhodoquinone, the inter-quinone (Q(A) → Q(B)) electron transfer became energetically favorable. After subsequent saturating flash excitations, a period of two damped oscillations of the protonated rhodosemiquinone was observed. The Q(B)H(•) was identified by (1) the characteristic band at 420 nm of the absorption spectrum after the second flash and (2) weaker damping of the oscillation at 420 nm (due to the neutral form) than at 460 nm (attributed to the anionic form). The appearance of the neutral semiquinone was restricted to the acidic pH range, indicating a functional pK(a) of <5.5, slightly higher than that of the native ubisemiquinone (pK(a) < 4.5) at pH 7. The analysis of the pH and temperature dependencies of the rates of the second electron transfer supports the concept of the pH-dependent pK(a) of the semiquinone at the Q(B) binding site. The local electrostatic potential is severely modified by the strongly interacting neighboring acidic cluster, and the pK(a) of the semiquinone is in the middle of the pH range of the complex titration. The kinetic and thermodynamic data are discussed according to the proton-activated electron transfer mechanism combined with the pH-dependent functional pK(a) of the semiquinone at the Q(B) site of the RC.

The 2-Methoxy Group Orientation Regulates the Redox Potential Difference between the Primary (QA) and Secondary (QB) Quinones of Type II Bacterial Photosynthetic Reaction Centers

Recent studies have shown that only quinones with a 2-methoxy group can act simultaneously as the primary (Q_A) and secondary (Q_B) electron acceptors in photosynthetic reaction centers from purple bacteria such as Rb. sphaeroides. ¹³C HYSCORE measurements of the 2-methoxy group in the semiquinone states, SQ_A and SQ_B, were compared with DFT calculations of the ¹³C hyperfine couplings as a function of the 2-methoxy dihedral angle. X-ray structure comparisons support 2-methoxy dihedral angle assignments corresponding to a redox potential gap (ΔE_m) between Q_A and Q_B of 175-193 mV. A model having a methyl group substituted for the 2-methoxy group exhibits no electron affinity difference. This is consistent with the failure of a 2-methyl ubiquinone analogue to function as Q_B in mutant reaction centers with a ΔE_m of ∼160-195 mV. The conclusion reached is that the 2-methoxy group is the principal determinant of electron transfer from Q_A to Q_B in type II photosynthetic reaction centers with ubiquinone serving as both acceptor quinones.

Tuning cofactor redox potentials: the 2-methoxy dihedral angle generates a redox potential difference of >160 mV between the primary (Q(A)) and secondary (Q(B)) quinones of the bacterial photosynthetic reaction center

Only quinones with a 2-methoxy group can act simultaneously as the primary (QA) and secondary (QB) electron acceptors in photosynthetic reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. (13)C hyperfine sublevel correlation measurements of the 2-methoxy in the semiquinone states, SQA and SQB, were compared with quantum mechanics calculations of the (13)C couplings as a function of the dihedral angle. X-ray structures support dihedral angle assignments corresponding to a redox potential gap (ΔEm) between QA and QB of ~180 mV. This is consistent with the failure of a ubiquinone analogue lacking the 2-methoxy to function as QB in mutant reaction centers with a ΔEm of ≈160-195 mV.

Mutational control of bioenergetics of bacterial reaction center probed by delayed fluorescence

The free energy gap between the metastable charge separated state P(+)QA(-) and the excited bacteriochlorophyll dimer P* was measured by delayed fluorescence of the dimer in mutant reaction center proteins of the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides. The mutations were engineered both at the donor (L131L, M160L, M197F and M202H) and acceptor (M265I and M234E) sides. While the donor side mutations changed systematically the number of H-bonds to P, the acceptor side mutations modified the energetics of QA by altering the van-der-Waals and electronic interactions (M265IT) and H-bond network to the acidic cluster around QB (M234EH, M234EL, M234EA and M234ER). All mutants decreased the free energy gap of the wild type RC (~890meV), i.e. destabilized the P(+)QA(-) charge pair by 60-110meV at pH8. Multiple modifications in the hydrogen bonding pattern to P resulted in systematic changes of the free energy gap. The destabilization showed no pH-dependence (M234 mutants) or slight increase (WT, donor-side mutants and M265IT above pH8) with average slope of 10-15meV/pH unit over the 6-10.5pH range. In wild type and donor-side mutants, the free energy change of the charge separation consisted of mainly enthalpic term but the acceptor side mutants showed increased entropic (even above that of enthalpic) contributions. This could include softening the structure of the iron ligand (M234EH) and the QA binding pocket (M265IT) and/or increase of the multiplicity of the electron transfer of charge separation in the acceptor side upon mutation.

The measured and calculated affinity of methyl- and methoxy-substituted benzoquinones for the Q(A) site of bacterial reaction centers

Quinones play important roles in mitochondrial and photosynthetic energy conversion acting as intramembrane, mobile electron, and proton carriers between catalytic sites in various electron transfer proteins. They display different affinity, selectivity, functionality, and exchange dynamics in different binding sites. The computational analysis of quinone binding sheds light on the requirements for quinone affinity and specificity. The affinities of 10 oxidized, neutral benzoquinones were measured for the high affinity Q(A) site in the detergent-solubilized Rhodobacter sphaeroides bacterial photosynthetic reaction center. Multiconformation Continuum Electrostatics was then used to calculate their relative binding free energies by grand canonical Monte Carlo sampling with a rigid protein backbone, flexible ligand, and side chain positions and protonation states. Van der Waals and torsion energies, Poisson-Boltzmann continuum electrostatics, and accessible surface area-dependent ligand-solvent interactions are considered. An initial, single cycle of GROMACS backbone optimization improves the match with experiment as do coupled-ligand and side-chain motions. The calculations match experiment with an root mean square deviation (RMSD) of 2.29 and a slope of 1.28. The affinities are dominated by favorable protein-ligand van der Waals rather than electrostatic interactions. Each quinone appears in a closely clustered set of positions. Methyl and methoxy groups move into the same positions as found for the native quinone. Difficulties putting methyls into methoxy sites are observed. Calculations using a solvent-accessible surface area-dependent implicit van der Waals interaction smoothed out small clashes, providing a better match to experiment with a RMSD of 0.77 and a slope of 0.97.

The correlation of cathodic peak potentials of vitamin K(3) derivatives and their calculated electron affinities. The role of hydrogen bonding and conformational changes

2-methyl-1,4-naphtoquinone 1 (vitamin K(3), menadione) derivatives with different substituents at the 3-position were synthesized to tune their electrochemical properties. The thermodynamic midpoint potential (E(1/2)) of the naphthoquinone derivatives yielding a semi radical naphthoquinone anion were measured by cyclic voltammetry in the aprotic solvent dimethoxyethane (DME). Using quantum chemical methods, a clear correlation was found between the thermodynamic midpoint potentials and the calculated electron affinities (E(A)). Comparison of calculated and experimental values allowed delineation of additional factors such as the conformational dependence of quinone substituents and hydrogen bonding which can influence the electron affinities (E(A)) of the quinone. This information can be used as a model to gain insight into enzyme-cofactor interactions, particularly for enzyme quinone binding modes and the electrochemical adjustment of the quinone motif.

Reversible proton coupled electron transfer in a peptide-incorporated naphthoquinone amino acid

The synthesis of a naphthoquinone amino acid and its electrochemical characterization in a peptide is presented.

De Novo Design, Synthesis, and Characterization of Quinoproteins

Quinones and quinoproteins are essential redox components and enzymes in biological systems. Here, we report the de novo design, synthesis, and properties of model four-alpha-helix bundle quinoproteins. The proteins were designed and constructed from three different helices with 21 or 22 amino acid residues by chemoselective ligation to a cyclic decapeptide template. A free cysteine unit is placed at the hydrophobic core of the protein for binding of ubiquinone-0 and menaquinone-0 through a thioether bond. The quinoproteins with molecular weights of 11-12 kDa were characterized by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry, UV/Vis spectroscopy, size-exclusion chromatography, circular dichroism measurements, (1)H NMR spectroscopy, cyclic voltammetry, and redox-induced FTIR difference spectroscopy. The midpoint redox potentials at pH 8 in aqueous solution E(m,8) of thioether conjugates with N-acetyl cysteine methyl ester were 89 mV and -63 mV and with a synthetic protein 229 mV and 249 mV versus standard hydrogen electrode (SHE) for ubiquinone-0 and menaquinone-0, respectively. Detailed redox-induced FTIR difference spectroscopic studies of the model compounds and quinoproteins show the special resonance features for C=O bands at 1656-1660 and 1655-1665 cm(-1) due to the sulfur substitution to ubiquinone-0 and menaquinone-0, respectively. The construction of model quinoproteins represents a significant step toward more complex artificial redox systems.

Modeling binding kinetics at the Q(A) site in bacterial reaction centers

Bacterial reaction centers (RCs) catalyze a series of electron-transfer reactions reducing a neutral quinone to a bound, anionic semiquinone. The dissociation constants and association rates of 13 tailless neutral and anionic benzo- and naphthoquinones for the Q(A) site were measured and compared. The K(d) values for these quinones range from 0.08 to 90 microM. For the eight neutral quinones, including duroquinone (DQ) and 2,3-dimethoxy-5-methyl-1,4-benzoquinone (UQ(0)), the quinone concentration and solvent viscosity dependence of the association rate indicate a second-order rate-determining step. The association rate constants (k(on)) range from 10(5) to 10(7) M(-)(1) s(-)(1). Association and dissociation rate constants were determined at pH values above the hydroxyl pK(a) for five hydroxyl naphthoquinones. These negatively charged compounds are competitive inhibitors for the Q(A) site. While the neutral quinones reach equilibrium in milliseconds, anionic hydroxyl quinones with similar K(d) values take minutes to bind or dissociate. These slow rates are independent of ionic strength, solvent viscosity, and quinone concentration, indicating a first-order rate-limiting step. The anionic semiquinone, formed by forward electron transfer at the Q(A) site, also dissociates slowly. It is not possible to measure the association rate of the unstable semiquinone. However, as the protein creates kinetic barriers for binding and releasing anionic hydroxyl quinones without greatly increasing the affinity relative to neutral quinones, it is suggested that the Q(A) site may do the same for anionic semiquinone. Thus, the slow semiquinone dissociation may not indicate significant thermodynamic stabilization of the reduced species in the Q(A) site.

PsbS genotype in relation to coordinated function of PS II and PS I in Arabidopsis leaves

Application of multiple probes to systems that carry specific mutations provides a powerful means for studying how known regulators of light utilization interact in vivo. Two lines of Arabidopsis thaliana were studied, each carrying a unique lesion in the nuclear psbS gene encoding a 22-kDa pigment-binding protein (PS II-S) essential for full expression of photoprotective, rapid-phase, nonphotochemical quenching of chlorophyll fluorescence (NPQ). The PS II-S protein is absent in line npq4-1 due to deletion of psbS. Line npq4-9 expresses normal levels of PS II-S but carries a single amino acid substitution that lowers NPQ capacity by about 50%. A prior report [Peterson RB and Havir EA (2001) Planta 214: 142-152] described an altered pattern of redox states of the acceptor side of Photosystem II (PS II) and donor side of Photosystem I (PS I) for npq4-9 suggesting that interphotosystem electron transport may be restricted by a higher transthylakoid DeltapH in this line. In vivo steady state fluorescence and absorbance measurements (820 nm) confirmed these earlier observations for line npq4-9 but not for npq4-1. Thus, the prior results cannot be correlated simply to a loss of NPQ capacity. Likewise, the kinetics of the 820-nm absorbance change did not indicate a substantial effect of psbS genotype on electron flow from plastoquinol to PS I. A simple model is proposed to relate linear electron transport rate (measured gasometrically) to a parameter (based on fluorescence) that provides a relative measure of the density of excitation available for photochemistry in PS II. Surprisingly, analyses using this model suggested that the in vivo midpoint potential of the primary quinone acceptor in PS II (Q(A)) is lowered in both psbS mutant lines. This heretofore-unsuspected role for PS II-S is discussed with regard to: (1) numerous prior reports indicating plasticity of the redox potential of Q(A) and (2) the basis for the contrasting regulation of quantum yields of PS I and II in npq4-1 and npq4-9.

Modulation of the free energy of the primary quinone acceptor (QA) in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: contributions from the protein and protein-lipid(cardiolipin) interactions

The redox midpoint potential (E(m)) of Q(A), the primary quinone of bacterial reaction centers, is substantially modulated by the protein environment. Quite subtle mutations in the Q(A) binding site, e.g., at residues M218, M252 and M265, cause significant increases in the equilibrium constant for electron transfer to Q(B), which indicate relative lowering of the E(m) of Q(A). However, reports of functional linkage between the Q(A) and Q(B) sites make it difficult to partition such effects between Q(A) and Q(B) from purely relative changes. We report here measurements on the yield of delayed fluorescence emission from the primary donor (P) accompanying the thermally activated charge recombination of P(+)Q(A)(-) to form the excited singlet state of the primary donor, P*. The results show that for mutations of the Q(A) site residues, Met(M218) and Ile(M265), essentially all the substantial thermodynamic effect is localized at Q(A), with no evidence for a significant effect of these residues on the properties of Q(B) or the mutual influence (linkage) of Q(A) and Q(B). We also report a significant lowering of the E(m) of Q(A) by the native lipid, cardiolipin, which brings the E(m) in isolated reaction centers more in line with that seen in native membrane vesicles (chromatophores). Possible origins of this effect are discussed in the context of the Q(A) binding site structure.

Acquisition of photosynthetic capacity by a reaction centre that lacks the QA ubiquinone; possible insights into the evolution of reaction centres?

A photosynthetically impaired strain of Rhodobacter sphaeroides containing reaction centres with an alanine to tryptophan mutation at residue 260 of the M-polypeptide (AM260W) was incubated under photosynthetic growth conditions. This incubation produced photosynthetically competent strains containing suppressor mutations that changed residue M260 to glycine or cysteine. Spectroscopic analysis demonstrated that the loss of the Q(A) ubiquinone seen in the original AM260W mutant was reversed in the suppressor mutants. In the mutant where Trp M260 was replaced by Cys, the rate of reduction of the Q(A) ubiquinone by the adjacent (H(A)) bacteriopheophytin was reduced by three-fold. The findings of the experiment are discussed in light of the X-ray crystal structures of the wild-type and AM260W reaction centres, and the possible implications for the evolution of reaction centres as bioenergetic complexes are considered.

Does different orientation of the methoxy groups of ubiquinone-10 in the reaction centre of Rhodobacter sphaeroides cause different binding at QA and QB?

The different roles of ubiquinone-10 (UQ10) at the primary and secondary quinone (QA and QB) binding sites of Rhodobacter sphaeroides R26 reaction centres are governed by the protein microenvironment. The 4C=O carbonyl group of QA is unusually strongly hydrogen-bonded, in contrast to QB. This asymmetric binding seems to determine their different functions. The asymmetric hydrogen-bonding at QA can be caused intrinsically by distortion of the methoxy groups or extrinsically by binding to specific amino-acid side groups. Different X-ray-based structural models show contradictory orientations of the methoxy groups and do not provide a clear picture. To elucidate if distortion of the methoxy groups induces this hydrogen-bonding, their (ring-)C-O vibrations were assigned by use of site-specifically labelled [5-13C]UQ10 and [6-13C]UQ10 reconstituted at either the QA or the QB binding site. Two infrared bands at 1288 cm(-1) and 1264 cm(-1) were assigned to the methoxy vibrations. They did not shift in frequency at either the QA or QB binding sites, as compared with unbound UQ10. As the frequencies of these vibrations and their coupling are sensitive to the conformations of the methoxy groups, different conformations of the C(5) and C(6) methoxy groups at the QA and QB binding sites can now be excluded. Both methoxy groups are oriented out of plane at QA and QB. Therefore, hydrogen-bonding to His M219 combined with electrostatic interactions with the Fe2+ ion seems to determine the strong asymmetric binding of QA.

Tuning of the redox potential of the primary electron donor in reaction centres of purple bacteria: effects of amino acid polarity and position

Mutation of residues His L168 and Phe M197 in the reaction centre from Rhodobacter sphaeroides has an unusually strong effect on the mid-point redox potential (E(m)) of the pair of bacteriochlorophylls that form the primary donor of electrons, tuning E(m) over a range of nearly 250 mV. This effect is correlated to the accompanying change in the permanent dipole of the L168 or M197 residue, suggesting it is mediated by changes in charge-dipole interactions. Comparisons with mutations made at a variety of other positions show that this correlation is particular to this residue pair, perhaps reflecting their proximity to the ring I regions of the dimer bacteriochlorophylls that form the overlap region between these molecules.