Site-directed mutagenesis of lysine 319 in the lactose permease of Escherichia coli

Function, Structure, and Evolution of the Major Facilitator Superfamily: The LacY Manifesto

The major facilitator superfamily (MFS) is a diverse group of secondary transporters with members found in all kingdoms of life. A paradigm for MFS is the lactose permease (LacY) of Escherichia coli, which couples the stoichiometric translocation of a galactopyranoside and an H+ across the cytoplasmic membrane. LacY has been the test bed for the development of many methods applied for the analysis of transport proteins. X-ray structures of an inward-facing conformation and the most recent structure of an almost occluded conformation confirm many conclusions from previous studies. Although structure models are critical, they are insufficient to explain the catalysis of transport. The clues to understanding transport are based on the principles of enzyme kinetics. Secondary transport is a dynamic process—static snapshots of X-ray crystallography describe it only partially. However, without structural information, the underlying chemistry is virtually impossible to conclude. A large body of biochemical/biophysical data derived from systematic studies of site-directed mutants in LacY suggests residues critically involved in the catalysis, and a working model for the symport mechanism that involves alternating access of the binding site is presented. The general concepts derived from the bacterial LacY are examined for their relevance to other MFS transporters.

Trp replacements for tightly interacting Gly-Gly pairs in LacY stabilize an outward-facing conformation

Trp replacements for conserved Gly-Gly pairs between the N- and C-terminal six-helix bundles on the periplasmic side of lactose permease (LacY) cause complete loss of transport activity with little or no effect on sugar binding. Moreover, the detergent-solubilized mutants exhibit much greater thermal stability than WT LacY. A Cys replacement for Asn245, which is inaccessible/unreactive in WT LacY, alkylates readily in the Gly→Trp mutants, indicating that the periplasmic cavity is patent. Stopped-flow kinetic measurements of sugar binding with the Gly→Trp mutants in detergent reveal linear dependence of binding rates on sugar concentration, as observed with WT or the C154G mutant of LacY, and are compatible with free access to the sugar-binding site in the middle of the molecule. Remarkably, after reconstitution of the Gly→Trp mutants into proteoliposomes, the concentration dependence of sugar-binding rates increases sharply with even faster rates than measured in detergent. Such behavior is strikingly different from that observed for reconstituted WT LacY, in which sugar-binding rates are independent of sugar concentration because opening of the periplasmic cavity is limiting for sugar binding. The observations clearly indicate that Gly→Trp replacements, which introduce bulky residues into tight Gly-Gly interdomain interactions on the periplasmic side of LacY, prevent closure of the periplasmic cavity and, as a result, shift the distribution of LacY toward an outward-open conformation.

Properties of a LacY efflux mutant

Crystal structures of lactose permease from Escherichia coli (LacY) exhibit two six-helix bundles with 2-fold pseudosymmetry separated by a large hydrophilic cavity. The cavity is open only on the cytoplasmic side and contains the side chains important for both sugar and H(+) binding at the apex in the middle of the protein; the periplasmic side is tightly closed. A plethora of biochemical and biophysical data strongly support an alternating access mechanism in which both the sugar- and H(+)-binding sites are exposed alternatively to either side of the membrane by reciprocal opening and closing of cytoplasmic and periplasmic cavities. Here we describe a unique mutation that results in an increase in sugar efflux. Asp240 (helix VII), which interacts with Lys319 (helix X), also comprises part of a salt-bridge/H-bond network that is critically involved in the mechanism of sugar/H(+) symport. The mutant, which contains Glu in place of Asp240, exhibits a marked decrease in active lactose transport and an enhanced rate of downhill lactose/H(+) efflux. Transport is increased to normal levels when the sugar concentration is increased 10-fold, consistent with the decrease in sugar affinity observed for this mutant. Taken as a whole, the results suggest that the primary defect induced by the mutation may involve a decrease in affinity for H(+).

Residues in the H+ translocation site define the pKa for sugar binding to LacY

A remarkably high pKa of approximately 10.5 has been determined for sugar-binding affinity to the lactose permease of Escherichia coli (LacY), indicating that, under physiological conditions, substrate binds to fully protonated LacY. We have now systematically tested site-directed replacements for the residues involved in sugar binding, as well as H+ translocation and coupling, in order to determine which residues may be responsible for this alkaline pKa. Mutations in the sugar-binding site (Glu126, Trp151, Glu269) markedly decrease affinity for sugar but do not alter the pKa for binding. In contrast, replacements for residues involved in H+ translocation (Arg302, Tyr236, His322, Asp240, Glu325, Lys319) exhibit pKa values for sugar binding that are either shifted toward neutral pH or independent of pH. Values for the apparent dissociation constant for sugar binding (K(d)(app)) increase greatly for all mutants except neutral replacements for Glu325 or Lys319, which are characterized by remarkably high affinity sugar binding (i.e., low K(d)(app)) from pH 5.5 to pH 11. The pH dependence of the on- and off-rate constants for sugar binding measured directly by stopped-flow fluorometry implicates k(off) as a major factor for the affinity change at alkaline pH and confirms the effects of pH on K(d)(app) inferred from steady-state fluorometry. These results indicate that the high pKa for sugar binding by wild-type LacY cannot be ascribed to any single amino acid residue but appears to reside within a complex of residues involved in H+ translocation. There is structural evidence for water bound in this complex, and the water could be the site of protonation responsible for the pH dependence of sugar binding.

Roles of K+, H+, H2O, and DeltaPsi in solute transport mediated by major facilitator superfamily members ProP and LacY

H (+)-solute symporters ProP and LacY are members of the major facilitator superfamily. ProP mediates osmoprotectant (e.g., proline) accumulation, whereas LacY transports the nutrient lactose. The roles of K (+), H (+), H 2O, and DeltaPsi in H (+)-proline and H (+)-lactose symport were compared using right-side-out cytoplasmic membrane vesicles (MVs) from bacteria expressing both transporters and proteoliposomes (PRLs) reconstituted with pure ProP-His 6. ProP activity increased as LacY activity decreased when osmotic stress (increasing osmolality) was imposed on MVs. The activities of both transporters decreased to similar extents when Na (+) replaced K (+) in MV preparations. Thus, K (+) did not specifically control ProP activity. As with LacY, an increasing extravesicular pH stimulated ProP-mediated proline efflux much more than ProP-mediated proline exchange from de-energized MVs. In contrast to that of LacY, ProP-mediated exchange was only 2-fold faster than ProP-mediated efflux and was inhibited by respiration. In the absence of the protonmotive force (Deltamu H (+) ), efflux of lactose from MVs was much more sensitive to increasing osmolality than lactose exchange. Thus, H 2O may be directly involved in proton transport via LacY. In the absence of Deltamu H (+) , proline efflux and exchange from MVs were osmolality-independent. In PRLs with a DeltapH of 1 (lumen alkaline), ProP-His 6 was inactive when the membrane potential (DeltaPsi) was zero, was active but insensitive to osmolality when DeltaPsi was -100 mV, and became osmolality-sensitive as DeltaPsi increased further to -137 mV. ProP-His 6 had the same membrane orientation in PRLs as in cells and MVs. ProP switches among "off", "on", and "osmolality-sensitive" states as the membrane potential increases. Kinetic parameters determined in the absence of Deltamu H (+) represent a ProP population that is predominantly off.

A suppressor analysis of residues involved in cation transport in the lactose permease: identification of a coupling sensor

Four amino acids critical for lactose permease function were altered using site-directed mutagenesis. The resulting Quad mutant (E269Q/R302L/H322Q/E325Q) was expressed at 60% of wild-type levels but found to have negligible transport activity. The Quad mutant was used as a parental strain to isolate suppressors that regained the ability to ferment the alpha-galactoside melibiose. Six different suppressors were identified involving five discrete amino acid changes and one amino acid deletion (Q60L, V229G, Y236D, S306L, K319N and DeltaI298). All of the suppressors transported alpha-galactosides at substantial rates. In addition, the Q60L, DeltaI298 and K319N suppressors regained a small but detectable amount of lactose transport. Assays of sugar-driven cation transport showed that both the Q60L and K319N suppressors couple the influx of melibiose with cations (H(+) or H(3)O(+)). Taken together, the data show that the cation-binding domain in the lactose permease is not a fixed structure as proposed in previous models. Rather, the data are consistent with a model in which several ionizable residues form a dynamic coupling sensor that also may interact directly with the cation and lactose.

Control of H+/Lactose Coupling by Ionic Interactions in the Lactose Permease ofEscherichia coli

A combinatorial approach was used to study putative interactions among six ionizable residues (Asp-240, Glu-269, Arg-302, Lys-319, His-322, and Glu-325) in the lactose permease. Neutral mutations were made involving five ion pairs that had not been previously studied. Double mutants, R302L/E325Q and D240N/H322Q, had moderate levels of downhill [(14)C]-lactose transport. Mutants in which only one of these six residues was left unchanged (pentuple mutants) were also made. A Pent269(-) mutant (in which only Glu-269 remains) catalyzed a moderate level of downhill lactose transport. Pent240(-) and Pent 322(+) also showed low levels of downhill lactose transport. Additionally, a Pent240(-) mutant exhibited proton transport upon addition of melibiose, but not lactose. This striking result demonstrates that neutralization of up to five residues of the lactose permease does not abolish proton transport. A mutant with neutral replacements at six ionic residues (hextuple mutant) had low levels of downhill lactose transport, but no uphill accumulation or proton transport. Since none of the mutants in this study catalyzes active accumulation of lactose, this is consistent with other reports that have shown that each residue is essential for proper coupling. Nevertheless, none of the six ionizable residues is individually required for substrate-induced proton cotransport. These results suggest that the H(+) binding domain may be elsewhere in the permease or that cation binding may involve a flexible network of charged residues.

Role of glutamate-269 in the lactose permease of Escherichia coli

Glu-269, which is located on the hydrophilic face of putative helix VIII in the lactose permease of Escherichia coli, has been replaced with Asp, Gln or Cys by oligonucleotide-directed, site specific mutagenesis. Cells expressing Asp-269 permease exhibit no lactose accumulation or lactose-induced H+ translocation, but retain some ability to mediate lactose influx down a concentration gradient at high substrate concentrations. Furthermore, right-side-out membrane vesicles containing Asp-269 permease do not catalyse active lactose transport, facilitated lactose efflux or equilibrium exchange. Remarkably, however, Asp-269 permease accumulates beta, D-galactopyranosyl 1-thio-beta,D-galactopyranoside in a partially uncoupled fashion, whereas no transport of methyl-beta,D-thiogalactopyranoside, sucrose or maltose is detectable. Mutant permeases containing neutral replacements (Gln or Cys) or Glu-269 are completely devoid of activity, although the proteins are present in the membrane at concentrations comparable with wild-type or Asp-269 permease. The observations demonstrate that a carboxylate at position 269 is essential for transport activity, and Glu-269 is important for substrate binding and/or recognition.

Cysteine scanning mutagenesis of putative transmembrane helices IX and X in the lactose permease of Escherichia coli

Using a functional lactose permease mutant devoid of Cys residues (C-less permease), each amino-acid residue in putative transmembrane helices IX and X and the short intervening loop was systematically replaced with Cys (from Asn-290 to Lys-335). Thirty-four of 46 mutants accumulate lactose to high levels (70-100% or more of C-less), and an additional 7 mutants exhibit lower but highly significant lactose accumulation. As expected (see Kaback, H.R., 1992, Int. Rev. Cytol. 137A, 97-125), Cys substitution for Arg-302, His-322, or Glu-325 results in inactive permease molecules. Although Cys replacement for Lys-319 or Phe-334 also inactivates lactose accumulation, Lys-319 is not essential for active lactose transport (Sahin-Tóth, M., Dunten, R.L., Gonzalez, A., & Kaback, H.R., 1992, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 89, 10547-10551), and replacement of Phe-334 with leucine yields permease with considerable activity. All single-Cys mutants except Gly-296 --> Cys are present in the membrane in amounts comparable to C-less permease, as judged by immunological techniques. In contrast, mutant Gly-296 --> Cys is hardly detectable when expressed at a relatively low rate from the lac promoter/operator but present in the membrane in stable form when expressed at a high rate from T7 promoter. Finally, studies with N-ethylmaleimide (NEM) show that only a few mutants are inactivated significantly. Remarkably, the rate of inactivation of Val-315 --> Cys permease is enhanced at least 10-fold in the presence of beta-galactopyranosyl 1-thio-beta-D-galactopyranoside (TDG) or an H+ electrochemical gradient (delta mu-H+). The results demonstrate that only three residues in this region of the permease -Arg-302, His-322, and Glu-325-are essential for active lactose transport. Furthermore, the enhanced reactivity of the Val-315 --> Cys mutant toward NEM in the presence of TDG or delta mu-H+ probably reflects a conformational alteration induced by either substrate binding or delta mu-H+.