Radiation inactivation analysis of influenza virus reveals different target sizes for fusion, leakage, and neuraminidase activities

Stochastic fusion simulations and experiments suggest passive and active roles of hemagglutinin during membrane fusion

Influenza enters the host cell cytoplasm by fusing the viral and host membrane together. Fusion is mediated by hemagglutinin (HA) trimers that undergo conformational change when acidified in the endosome. It is currently debated how many HA trimers, w, and how many conformationally changed HA trimers, q, are minimally required for fusion. Conclusions vary because there are three common approaches for determining w and q from fusion data. One approach correlates the fusion rate with the fraction of fusogenic HA trimers and leads to the conclusion that one HA trimer is required for fusion. A second approach correlates the fusion rate with the total concentration of fusogenic HA trimers and indicates that more than one HA trimer is required. A third approach applies statistical models to fusion rate data obtained at a single HA density to establish w or q and suggests that more than one HA trimer is required. In this work, all three approaches are investigated through stochastic fusion simulations and experiments to elucidate the roles of HA and its ability to bend the target membrane during fusion. We find that the apparent discrepancies among the results from the various approaches may be resolved if nonfusogenic HA participates in fusion through interactions with a fusogenic HA. Our results, based on H3 and H1 serotypes, suggest that three adjacent HA trimers and one conformationally changed HA trimer are minimally required to induce membrane fusion (w = 3 and q = 1).

Fusion of alphaviruses with liposomes is a non-leaky process

It has been reported that low-pH-induced fusion of influenza virus with liposomes results in rapid and extensive release of both low- and high-molecular-weight substances from the liposomes [Günther-Ausborn et al., J. Biol. Chem. 270 (1995) 29279-29285; Shangguan et al., Biochemistry 35 (1996) 4956-4965]. Here, we demonstrate retention of encapsulated water-soluble compounds during fusion of Semliki Forest virus (SFV) or Sindbis virus with liposomes at low pH. Under conditions allowing complete fusion of the liposomes, a limited fluorescence dequenching of liposome-encapsulated calcein was observed, particularly for SFV. Also, radioactively labeled inulin or sucrose were largely retained. Freezing and thawing of the viruses in the absence of sucrose resulted in an enhanced leakiness of fusion. These results support the notion that the alphavirus fusion event per se is non-leaky and may well involve a discrete hemifusion intermediate.

Comparison of gamma and neutron radiation inactivation of influenza A virus

Radiation inactivation of viral pathogens has potential application in sterilization and in the manufacture of biological reagents, including the production of non-infectious viral antigens. Viral inactivation by gamma radiation has been extensively investigated, but few direct comparisons to other qualities of radiation have been explored. Experiments were designed to examine direct radiation damage by both gamma photons (gamma) and neutrons (n) while minimizing methodological differences. Frozen samples of influenza A X31/H3N2 and PR8/H1N1 were exposed to gamma and n at doses between 0 and 15.6 kGy. Other experimental parameters, including dose-rate, were not varied. Virus titers were determined by tissue culture infectious dose (TCID(50)) and plaque forming unit (PFU) assays. D(10) values, kGy per log reduction, were calculated from these assays. PR8 D(10) values based on PFU assays were approximately 2 and 5 kGy for gamma and n exposures, respectively, and those based on TCID(50) were approximately 6 and 14 kGy. Similar results were obtained for the A/X31 strain. The data demonstrate that gamma was 2-3-fold more effective than n, with a relative biological effectiveness (RBE) range of 0.43-0.65. These neutron results are likely the first reported for a medically relevant virus. PAGE analysis of viral proteins and RNAs failed to show macromolecular damage. D(10) values were found to be similar to a broad summary of previously reported gamma inactivation values for other virus types. The dependence of the magnitudes of D(10) on titer assay in this study suggests that more than one titer method should be used to determine if complete inactivation has occurred.

Membrane fusion mediated by baculovirus gp64 involves assembly of stable gp64 trimers into multiprotein aggregates

The baculovirus fusogenic activity depends on the low pH conformation of virally-encoded trimeric glycoprotein, gp64. We used two experimental approaches to investigate whether monomers, trimers, and/or higher order oligomers are functionally involved in gp64 fusion machine. First, dithiothreitol (DTT)- based reduction of intersubunit disulfides was found to reversibly inhibit fusion, as assayed by fluorescent probe redistribution between gp64-expressing and target cells (i.e., erythrocytes or Sf9 cells). This inhibition correlates with disappearance of gp64 trimers and appearance of dimers and monomers in SDS-PAGE. Thus, stable (i.e., with intact intersubunit disulfides) gp64 trimers, rather than independent monomers, drive fusion. Second, we established that merger of membranes is preceded by formation of large (greater than 2 MDa), short-lived gp64 complexes. These complexes were stabilized by cell-surface cross-linking and characterized by glycerol density gradient ultracentrifugation. The basic structural unit of the complexes is stable gp64 trimer. Although DTT-destabilized trimers were still capable of assuming the low pH conformation, they failed to form multimeric complexes. The fact that formation of these complexes correlated with fusion in timing, and was dependent on (a) low pH application, (b) stable gp64 trimers, and (c) cell-cell contacts, suggests that such multimeric complexes represent a fusion machine.

An architecture for the fusion site of influenza hemagglutinin

The recent finding that more than one Influenza hemagglutinin (HA) is required at the fusion site for HA-expressing fibroblasts, together with the crystal structure of HA at neutral pH, provide the basic elements of a plausible model for this fusion site. Within an aggregate of HA trimers at low pH, we propose fusion intermediates which are based upon a minimal alteration to the known neutral pH structure of HA and which should have reasonable activation energies. This is the first model of a glycoprotein-mediated fusion site which explicitly accounts for the disposition of the lipids within these intermediates. While the fusion site created by HA will not be the same as that of eukaryotic fusion complexes, general characteristics could be shared.

Phosphatidylserine vesicle lysis by Sendai virus at low pH is not due to virus-vesicle fusion

As a model of the fusion of Sendai virus with red cells, the interaction of the virus with phosphatidylserine (PS) vesicles at pH 5 was quantitated by the release of a trapped marker from target vesicles and by mixing of lipids of the virus and the vesicles. Release of the marker was measured as dequenching of calcein trapped at a self-quenched concentration and lipid mixing was measured as a decrease in energy transfer between fluorescent phospholipid analogs in the target membrane. At comparable virus:vesicle ratios both calcein release and lipid mixing were maximal at pH 5 and significantly reduced after trypsin, but not chymotrypsin, treatment. In contrast, these two effects differed in their PS dependence, time course, and temperature dependence, indicating that calcein release is not a consequence of the fusion of a permeable virus membrane with an impermeable target membrane. Vesicles composed of 25 to 100% PS released similar amounts of calcein, whereas fusion increased linearly as a function of PS content of the target vesicles. The half-time was 15 s for calcein release but 1.5 min for fusion. The temperature coefficient of fusion was at least three times greater than that of calcein release. These results indicate that calcein release at pH 5 may signify an interaction of the virus with PS target membranes which precedes but does not necessarily culminate in fusion, given too low a temperature or an inappropriate target membrane composition.

Radiation inactivation analysis of fusion and hemolysis by vesicular stomatitis virus

Radiation inactivation analysis was used to determine the size of the functional unit responsible for fusion of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) with cardiolipin or phosphatidylcholine-phosphatidylethanolamine (1:1) liposomes, and for VSV-induced hemolysis. When radiation-insensitive background values were subtracted, the calculated functional units for all three activities were similar, ranging from 866 to 957 kDa, equivalent to about 15 G protein molecules. This is in striking contrast to results of similar studies with influenza and Sendai viruses, in which the functional unit corresponded in size to a single fusion protein monomer, and suggests that VSV fusion may occur by a different mechanism.

Fusion of a Sendai mutant deficient in HN protein (ts271) with cardiolipin liposomes

Sendai mutant ts271 contains less than 5% of the amount of HN glycoprotein found in wild-type Sendai. Fusion of this mutant with cardiolipin liposomes revealed no differences from the wild-type virus with regard to specific activity, pH dependence, or radiation inactivation. Target sizes of both mutant and wild-type viral proteins were determined by the radiation-induced disappearance of each band from an SDS-polyacrylamide gel and no differences were found. Of the viral proteins, only F had a target size corresponding to the monomer molecular weight, ca. 60 kDa, identical to the minimum unit previously determined by functional assay for Sendai virus-erythrocyte membrane fusion (K. Bundo-Morita, S. Gibson, and J. Lenard, Biochemistry 26, 6223-6227 (1987)). This provides additional evidence that F alone is the active protein mediating Sendai-erythrocyte fusion. It is concluded that the HN protein is unlikely to mediate any fusion reactions of the intact virions, either with biological membranes or with cardiolipin liposomes.

Posttranslational oligomerization and cooperative acid activation of mixed influenza hemagglutinin trimers

The influenza virus hemagglutinin (HA) is a well-characterized integral membrane glycoprotein composed of three identical subunits. We have analyzed the formation of mixed trimers in cells expressing two different HA gene products. The results show efficient and essentially random assembly of functional hybrid trimers provided that the HAs are from the same HA subtype. Trimerization is thus a posttranslational event, and subunits are recruited randomly from a common pool of monomers in the endoplasmic reticulum. Mixed trimers were not observed between HAs derived from different subtypes, indicating that the trimerization event is sequence specific. Mixed trimers containing mutant subunits were, moreover, used to establish that the acid-induced conformational change involved in the membrane fusion activity of HA is a highly cooperative event.