Conformation change of tRNAGlu in the complex with glutamyl-tRNA synthetase is required for the specific binding of L-glutamate

How evolution shapes enzyme selectivity - lessons from aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases and other amino acid utilizing enzymes

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (AARSs) charge tRNA with their cognate amino acids. Many other enzymes use amino acids as substrates, yet discrimination against noncognate amino acids that threaten the accuracy of protein translation is a hallmark of AARSs. Comparing AARSs to these other enzymes allowed us to recognize patterns in molecular recognition and strategies used by evolution for exercising selectivity. Overall, AARSs are 2-3 orders of magnitude more selective than most other amino acid utilizing enzymes. AARSs also reveal the physicochemical limits of molecular discrimination. For example, amino acids smaller by a single methyl moiety present a discrimination ceiling of ~200, while larger ones can be discriminated by up to 10⁵ -fold. In contrast, substrates larger by a hydroxyl group challenge AARS selectivity, due to promiscuous H-bonding with polar active site groups. This 'hydroxyl paradox' is resolved by editing. Indeed, when the physicochemical discrimination limits are reached, post-transfer editing - hydrolysis of tRNAs charged with noncognate amino acids, evolved. The editing site often selectively recognizes the edited noncognate substrate using the very same feature that the synthetic site could not efficiently discriminate against. Finally, the comparison to other enzymes also reveals that the selectivity of AARSs is an explicitly evolved trait, showing some clear examples of how selection acted not only to optimize catalytic efficiency with the target substrate, but also to abolish activity with noncognate threat substrates ('negative selection').

tRNAGlu increases the affinity of glutamyl-tRNA synthetase for its inhibitor glutamyl-sulfamoyl-adenosine, an analogue of the aminoacylation reaction intermediate glutamyl-AMP: mechanistic and evolutionary implications

For tRNA-dependent protein biosynthesis, amino acids are first activated by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRSs) yielding the reaction intermediates aminoacyl-AMP (aa-AMP). Stable analogues of aa-AMP, such as aminoacyl-sulfamoyl-adenosines, inhibit their cognate aaRSs. Glutamyl-sulfamoyl-adenosine (Glu-AMS) is the best known inhibitor of Escherichia coli glutamyl-tRNA synthetase (GluRS). Thermodynamic parameters of the interactions between Glu-AMS and E. coli GluRS were measured in the presence and in the absence of tRNA by isothermal titration microcalorimetry. A significant entropic contribution for the interactions between Glu-AMS and GluRS in the absence of tRNA or in the presence of the cognate tRNA^Glu or of the non-cognate tRNA^Phe is indicated by the negative values of –TΔS_b, and by the negative value of ΔC_p. On the other hand, the large negative enthalpy is the dominant contribution to ΔG_b in the absence of tRNA. The affinity of GluRS for Glu-AMS is not altered in the presence of the non-cognate tRNA^Phe, but the dissociation constant K_d is decreased 50-fold in the presence of tRNA^Glu; this result is consistent with molecular dynamics results indicating the presence of an H-bond between Glu-AMS and the 3’-OH oxygen of the 3’-terminal ribose of tRNA^Glu in the Glu-AMS•GluRS•tRNA^Glu complex. Glu-AMS being a very close structural analogue of Glu-AMP, its weak binding to free GluRS suggests that the unstable Glu-AMP reaction intermediate binds weakly to GluRS; these results could explain why all the known GluRSs evolved to activate glutamate only in the presence of tRNA^Glu, the coupling of glutamate activation to its transfer to tRNA preventing unproductive cleavage of ATP.

Professor Tatsuo Miyazawa: from molecular structure to biological function

The late Prof. Tatsuo Miyazawa was an outstanding physical chemist, who established a number of spectroscopic methods to analyse the structures of proteins, peptides and nucleotides, and used them to understand molecular functions. He developed an infrared spectroscopic method to quantitatively analyse the secondary structures, α-helices and β-strands, of proteins. He successfully utilized nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) methods to determine the conformations of peptides and proteins, particularly with respect to the interactions with their target molecules, which served as a solid basis for the wide range of applications of NMR spectroscopy to life science research. For example, he found that physiologically active peptides are randomly flexible in solution, but assume a particular effective conformation upon binding to their functional environments, such as membranes. He also used NMR spectroscopy to quantitatively analyse the conformer equilibrium of nucleotides, and related the dynamic properties of the modified nucleosides naturally-occurring in transfer ribonucleic acids (tRNAs) to their roles in correct codon recognition in protein synthesis. Furthermore, he studied the mechanisms of protein biosynthesis systems, including tRNA and aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. Inspired by the structural mechanism of amino acid recognition by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases, as revealed by NMR spectroscopy, he initiated a new research area in which non-natural amino acids are site-specifically incorporated into proteins to achieve novel protein functions (alloprotein technology).

The role of the catalytic domain of E. coli GluRS in tRNAGln discrimination

Discrimination of tRNA(Gln) is an integral function of several bacterial glutamyl-tRNA synthetases (GluRS). The origin of the discrimination is thought to arise from unfavorable interactions between tRNA(Gln) and the anticodon-binding domain of GluRS. From experiments on an anticodon-binding domain truncated Escherichia coli (E. coli) GluRS (catalytic domain) and a chimeric protein, constructed from the catalytic domain of E. coli GluRS and the anticodon-binding domain of E. coli glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase (GlnRS), we show that both proteins discriminate against E. coli tRNA(Gln). Our results demonstrate that in addition to the anticodon-binding domain, tRNA(Gln) discriminatory elements may be present in the catalytic domain in E. coli GluRS as well.

Crystal structure of glutamyl-queuosine tRNAAsp synthetase complexed with L-glutamate: structural elements mediating tRNA-independent activation of glutamate and glutamylation of tRNAAsp anticodon

Glutamyl-queuosine tRNA(Asp) synthetase (Glu-Q-RS) from Escherichia coli is a paralog of the catalytic core of glutamyl-tRNA synthetase (GluRS) that catalyzes glutamylation of queuosine in the wobble position of tRNA(Asp). Despite important structural similarities, Glu-Q-RS and GluRS diverge strongly by their functional properties. The only feature common to both enzymes consists in the activation of Glu to form Glu-AMP, the intermediate of transfer RNA (tRNA) aminoacylation. However, both enzymes differ by the mechanism of selection of the cognate amino acid and by the mechanism of its activation. Whereas GluRS selects l-Glu and activates it only in the presence of the cognate tRNA(Glu), Glu-Q-RS forms Glu-AMP in the absence of tRNA. Moreover, while GluRS transfers the activated Glu to the 3' accepting end of the cognate tRNA(Glu), Glu-Q-RS transfers the activated Glu to Q34 located in the anticodon loop of the noncognate tRNA(Asp). In order to gain insight into the structural elements leading to distinct mechanisms of amino acid activation, we solved the three-dimensional structure of Glu-Q-RS complexed to Glu and compared it to the structure of the GluRS.Glu complex. Comparison of the catalytic site of Glu-Q-RS with that of GluRS, combined with binding experiments of amino acids, shows that a restricted number of residues determine distinct catalytic properties of amino acid recognition and activation by the two enzymes. Furthermore, to explore the structural basis of the distinct aminoacylation properties of the two enzymes and to understand why Glu-Q-RS glutamylates only tRNA(Asp) among the tRNAs possessing queuosine in position 34, we performed a tRNA mutational analysis to search for the elements of tRNA(Asp) that determine recognition by Glu-Q-RS. The analyses made on tRNA(Asp) and tRNA(Asn) show that the presence of a C in position 38 is crucial for glutamylation of Q34. The results are discussed in the context of the evolution and adaptation of the tRNA glutamylation system.

Human tryptophanyl-tRNA synthetase is switched to a tRNA-dependent mode for tryptophan activation by mutations at V85 and I311

For most aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRS), their cognate tRNA is not obligatory to catalyze amino acid activation, with the exception of four class I (aaRS): arginyl-tRNA synthetase, glutamyl-tRNA synthetase, glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase and class I lysyl-tRNA synthetase. Furthermore, for arginyl-, glutamyl- and glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase, the integrated 3' end of the tRNA is necessary to activate the ATP-PPi exchange reaction. Tryptophanyl-tRNA synthetase is a class I aaRS that catalyzes tryptophan activation in the absence of its cognate tRNA. Here we describe mutations located at the appended β1–β2 hairpin and the AIDQ sequence of human tryptophanyl-tRNA synthetase that switch this enzyme to a tRNA-dependent mode in the tryptophan activation step. For some mutant enzymes, ATP-PPi exchange activity was completely lacking in the absence of tRNA^Trp, which could be partially rescued by adding tRNA^Trp, even if it had been oxidized by sodium periodate. Therefore, these mutant enzymes have strong similarity to arginyl-tRNA synthetase, glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase and glutamyl-tRNA synthetase in their mode of amino acid activation. The results suggest that an aaRS that does not normally require tRNA for amino acid activation can be switched to a tRNA-dependent mode.

Structural bases of transfer RNA-dependent amino acid recognition and activation by glutamyl-tRNA synthetase

Glutamyl-tRNA synthetase (GluRS) is one of the aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases that require the cognate tRNA for specific amino acid recognition and activation. We analyzed the role of tRNA in amino acid recognition by crystallography. In the GluRS*tRNA(Glu)*Glu structure, GluRS and tRNA(Glu) collaborate to form a highly complementary L-glutamate-binding site. This collaborative site is functional, as it is formed in the same manner in pretransition-state mimic, GluRS*tRNA(Glu)*ATP*Eol (a glutamate analog), and posttransition-state mimic, GluRS*tRNA(Glu)*ESA (a glutamyl-adenylate analog) structures. In contrast, in the GluRS*Glu structure, only GluRS forms the amino acid-binding site, which is defective and accounts for the binding of incorrect amino acids, such as D-glutamate and L-glutamine. Therefore, tRNA(Glu) is essential for formation of the completely functional binding site for L-glutamate. These structures, together with our previously described structures, reveal that tRNA plays a crucial role in accurate positioning of both L-glutamate and ATP, thus driving the amino acid activation.

ATP binding by glutamyl-tRNA synthetase is switched to the productive mode by tRNA binding

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases catalyze the formation of an aminoacyl-AMP from an amino acid and ATP, prior to the aminoacyl transfer to tRNA. A subset of aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases, including glutamyl-tRNA synthetase (GluRS), have a regulation mechanism to avoid aminoacyl-AMP formation in the absence of tRNA. In this study, we determined the crystal structure of the 'non-productive' complex of Thermus thermophilus GluRS, ATP and L-glutamate, together with those of the GluRS.ATP, GluRS.tRNA.ATP and GluRS.tRNA.GoA (a glutamyl-AMP analog) complexes. In the absence of tRNA(Glu), ATP is accommodated in a 'non-productive' subsite within the ATP-binding site, so that the ATP alpha-phosphate and the glutamate alpha-carboxyl groups in GluRS. ATP.Glu are too far from each other (6.2 A) to react. In contrast, the ATP-binding mode in GluRS.tRNA. ATP is dramatically different from those in GluRS.ATP.Glu and GluRS.ATP, but corresponds to the AMP moiety binding mode in GluRS.tRNA.GoA (the 'productive' subsite). Therefore, tRNA binding to GluRS switches the ATP-binding mode. The interactions of the three tRNA(Glu) regions with GluRS cause conformational changes around the ATP-binding site, and allow ATP to bind to the 'productive' subsite.

An example of non-conservation of oligomeric structure in prokaryotic aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. Biochemical and structural properties of glycyl-tRNA synthetase from Thermus thermophilus

Glycyl-tRNA synthetase (Gly-tRNA synthetase) from Thermus thermophilus was purified to homogeneity and with high yield using a five-step purification procedure in amounts sufficient to solve its crystallographic structure [Logan, D.T., Mazauric, M.-H., Kern, D. & Moras, D. (1995) EMBO J. 14, 4156-4167]. Molecular-mass determinations of the native and denatured protein indicate an oligomeric structure of the alpha 2 type consistent with that found for eukaryotic Gly-tRNA synthetases (yeast and Bombyx mori), but different from that of Gly-tRNA synthetases from mesophilic prokaryotes (Escherichia coli and Bacillus brevis) which are alpha 2 beta 2 tetramers. N-terminal sequencing of the polypeptide chain reveals significant identity, reaching 50% with those of the eukaryotic enzymes (B. mori, Homo sapiens, yeast and Caenorhabditis elegans) but no significant identity was found with both alpha and beta chains of the prokaryotic enzymes (E. coli, Haemophilus influenzae and Coxiella burnetii) albeit the enzyme is deprived of the N-terminal extension characterizing eukaryotic synthetases. Thus, the thermophilic Gly-tRNA synthetase combines strong structural homologies of eukaryotic Gly-tRNA synthetases with a feature of prokaryotic synthetases. Heat-stability measurements show that this synthetase keeps its ATP-PPi exchange and aminoacylation activities up to 70 degrees C. Glycyladenylate strongly protects the enzyme against thermal inactivation at higher temperatures. Unexpectedly, tRNA(Gly) does not induce protection. Cross-aminoacylations reveal that the thermophilic Gly-tRNA synthetase charges heterologous E. coli tRNA(gly(GCC)) and tRNA(Gly(GCC)) and yeast tRNA(Gly(GCC)) as efficiently as T. thermophilus tRNA(Gly). All these aminoacylation reactions are characterized by similar activation energies as deduced from Arrhenius plots. Therefore, contrary to the E. coli and H. sapiens Gly-tRNA synthetases, the prokaryotic thermophilic enzyme does not possess a strict species specificity. The results are discussed in the context of the three-dimensional structure of the synthetase and in the view of the particular evolution of the glycinylation systems.

Glutamyl-tRNA synthetase from Thermus thermophilus HB8. Molecular cloning of the gltX gene and crystallization of the overproduced protein

The gene for the Glu-tRNA synthetase from an extreme thermophile, Thermus thermophilus HB8, was isolated using a synthetic oligonucleotide probe coding for the N-terminal amino acid sequence of Glu-tRNA synthetase. Nucleotide-sequence analysis revealed an open reading frame coding for a protein composed of 468 amino acid residues (Mr 53,901). Codon usage in the T. thermophilus Glu-tRNA synthetase gene was in fact similar to the characteristic usages in the genes for proteins from bacteria of genus Thermus: the G + C content in the third position of the codons was as high as 94%. In contrast, the amino acid sequence of T. thermophilus Glu-tRNA synthetase showed high similarity with bacterial Glu-tRNA synthetases (35-45% identity); the sequences of the binding sites for ATP and for the 3' terminus of tRNA(Glu) are highly conserved. The Glu-tRNA synthetase gene was efficiently expressed in Escherichia coli under the control of the tac promoter. The recombinant T. thermophilus Glu-tRNA synthetase was extremely thermostable and was purified to homogeneity by heat treatment and three-step column chromatography. Single crystals of T. thermophilus Glu-tRNA synthetase were obtained from poly(ethylene glycol) 6000 solution by a vapor-diffusion technique. The crystals diffract X-rays beyond 0.35 nm. The crystal belongs to the orthorhombic space group P2(1)2(1)2(1), with unit-cell parameters of a = 8.64 nm, b = 8.86 nm and c = 8.49 nm.

Mutant enzymes and tRNAs as probes of the glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase: tRNA(Gln) interaction

This paper focuses on several aspects of the specificity of mutants of Escherichia coli glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase (GlnRS) and tRNA(Gln). Temperature-sensitive mutants located in glnS, the gene for GlnRS, have been described previously. The mutations responsible for the temperature-sensitive phenotype were analyzed, and pseudorevertants of these mutants isolated and characterized. The nature of these mutations is discussed in terms of their location in the three-dimensional structure of the tRNA(Gln).GlnRS complex. In order to characterize the specificity of the aminoacylation reaction, mutant tRNA(Gln) species were synthesized with either a 2'-deoxy AMP or 3'-deoxy AMP as their 3'-terminal nucleotide. Subsequent assays for aminoacylation and ATP/PPi exchange activity established the esterification of glutamine to the 2'-hydroxyl of the terminal adenosine; there is no glutaminylation of the 3'-OH group. This correlates with the classification of GlnRS as a class I aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase. Mutations in tRNA(Gln) are discussed which affect the recognition of GlnRS and the current concept of glutamine identity in E coli is reviewed.

Evidence for two types of complexes formed by yeast tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase with cognate and non-cognate tRNA. Effect of ribonucleoside triphosphates

Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis at pH 8.3 was used to detect and quantitate the formation of the yeast tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (an alpha 2-type enzyme) complex with its cognate tRNA. Electrophoretic mobility of the complex is intermediate between the free enzyme and free tRNA; picomolar quantities can be readily detected by silver staining and quantitated by densitometry of autoradiograms when [32P]tRNA is used. Two kinds of complexes of Tyr-tRNA synthetase with yeast tRNA(Tyr) were detected. A slower-moving complex is formed at ratios of tRNA(Tyr)/enzyme less than or equal to 0.5; it is assigned the composition tRNA.(alpha 2)2. At higher ratios, a faster-moving complex is formed, approaching saturation at tRNA(Tyr)/enzyme = 1; any excess of tRNA(Tyr) remains unbound. This complex is assigned the composition tRNA.alpha 2. The slower, i.e. tRNA.(alpha 2)2 complex, but not the faster complex, can be formed even with non-cognate tRNAs. Competition experiments show that the affinity of the enzyme towards tRNA(Tyr) is at least 10-fold higher than that for the non-cognate tRNAs. ATP and GTP affect the electrophoretic mobility of the enzyme and prevent the formation of tRNA.(alpha 2)2 complexes both with cognate and non-cognate tRNAs, while neither tyrosine, as the third substrate of Tyr tRNA synthetase, nor AMP, AMP/PPi, or spermidine, have such effects. Hence, the ATP-mediated formation of the alpha 2 structure parallels the increase in specificity of the enzyme towards its cognate tRNA.

Conformational changes of aminoacyl-tRNA and uncharged tRNA upon complex formation with polypeptide chain elongation factor Tu

The conformation change of Thermus thermophilus tRNA(1Ile) upon complex formation with T. thermophilus elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) was studied by analysis of the circular dichroism (CD) bands at 315 nm (due to the 2-thioribothymidine residue in the T-loop) and at 295 nm (due to the core structure of tRNA). Formation of the ternary complex of isoleucyl-tRNA(1Ile) and EF-Tu.GTP increased the intensities of these CD bands, indicating stabilization of the association between the T-loop and the D-loop and also a significant conformation change of the core region. Upon complex formation of EF-Tu.GTP and uncharged tRNA, however, the conformation of the core region is not changed, while the association of the two loops is still stabilized. On the other hand, the binding with EF-Tu.GDP does not appreciably affect the conformation of isoleucyl-tRNA or uncharged tRNA. These indicate the importance of the gamma-phosphate group of GTP and the aminoacyl group in the formation of the active complex of aminoacyl-tRNA and EF-Tu.GTP.

Interactions of Escherichia coli SO-187 tRNA(IVal) with Bacillus stearothermophilus valine-tRNA synthetase studied by 13C-NMR

Uracil isotopically labelled with 13C at C4 and C5 has been incorporated into nucleic acids of the Escherichia coli uracil auxotroph, SO-187. [4,5-13C]uracil-labeled tRNA(IVal) was isolated and purified. 13C longitudinal relaxation times measured at 67.8 MHz demonstrated that the C5 dipole caused a 20-50% increase in the C4 relaxation. Interactions of this tRNA with valine-tRNA synthetase (VTS) purified from Bacillus stearothermophilus were established by 13C-NMR. Specific spectral changes were seen at 4-thiouridine, ribothymidine and pseudouridine of the 'bend' in the three-dimensional structure, and particularly at the uridine-5-oxyacetic acid in the wobble position of the anticodon. Thus, the protein seems to be in contact along the entire tRNA molecule, including the anticodon loop.