Deoxylysolecithin and a new biphenyl detergent as solubilizing agents for bovine rhodopsin. Functional test by formation of metarhodopsin II and binding of G-protein

Rhodopsin, light-sensor of vision

The light sensor of vertebrate scotopic (low-light) vision, rhodopsin, is a G-protein-coupled receptor comprising a polypeptide chain with bound chromophore, 11-cis-retinal, that exhibits remarkable physicochemical properties. This photopigment is extremely stable in the dark, yet its chromophore isomerises upon photon absorption with 70% efficiency, enabling the activation of its G-protein, transducin, with high efficiency. Rhodopsin's photochemical and biochemical activities occur over very different time-scales: the energy of retinaldehyde's excited state is stored in <1 ps in retinal-protein interactions, but it takes milliseconds for the catalytically active state to form, and many tens of minutes for the resting state to be restored. In this review, we describe the properties of rhodopsin and its role in rod phototransduction. We first introduce rhodopsin's gross structural features, its evolution, and the basic mechanisms of its activation. We then discuss light absorption and spectral sensitivity, photoreceptor electrical responses that result from the activity of individual rhodopsin molecules, and recovery of rhodopsin and the visual system from intense bleaching exposures. We then provide a detailed examination of rhodopsin's molecular structure and function, first in its dark state, and then in the active Meta states that govern its interactions with transducin, rhodopsin kinase and arrestin. While it is clear that rhodopsin's molecular properties are exquisitely honed for phototransduction, from starlight to dawn/dusk intensity levels, our understanding of how its molecular interactions determine the properties of scotopic vision remains incomplete. We describe potential future directions of research, and outline several major problems that remain to be solved.

Stereospecific modulation of dimeric rhodopsin

The classic concept that GPCRs function as monomers has been challenged by the emerging evidence of GPCR dimerization and oligomerization. Rhodopsin (Rh) is the only GPCR whose native oligomeric arrangement was revealed by atomic force microscopy demonstrating that Rh exists as a dimer. However, the role of Rh dimerization in retinal physiology is currently unknown. In this study, we identified econazole and sulconazole, two small molecules that disrupt Rh dimer contacts, by implementing a cell-based high-throughput screening assay. Racemic mixtures of identified lead compounds were separated and tested for their stereospecific binding to Rh using UV-visible spectroscopy and intrinsic fluorescence of tryptophan (Trp) 265 after illumination. By following the changes in UV-visible spectra and Trp265 fluorescence in vitro, we found that binding of R-econazole modulates the formation of Meta III and quenches the intrinsic fluorescence of Trp265. In addition, electrophysiological ex vivo recording revealed that R-econazole slows photoresponse kinetics, whereas S-econazole decreased the sensitivity of rods without effecting the kinetics. Thus, this study contributes new methodology to identify compounds that disrupt the dimerization of GPCRs in general and validates the first active compounds that disrupt the Rh dimer specifically.-Getter, T., Gulati, S., Zimmerman, R., Chen, Y., Vinberg, F., Palczewski, K. Stereospecific modulation of dimeric rhodopsin.

Opsin, a structural model for olfactory receptors?

Receptor-ligand interaction: Olfactory receptors (ORs) are G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs), which detect signaling molecules such as hormones and odorants. The structure of opsin, the GPCR employed in vision, with a detergent molecule bound deep in its orthosteric ligand-binding pocket provides a template for OR homology modeling, thus enabling investigation of the structural basis of the mechanism of odorant-receptor recognition.

A class of mild surfactants that keep integral membrane proteins water-soluble for functional studies and crystallization

Mixed protein-surfactant micelles are used for in vitro studies and 3D crystallization when solutions of pure, monodisperse integral membrane proteins are required. However, many membrane proteins undergo inactivation when transferred from the biomembrane into micelles of conventional surfactants with alkyl chains as hydrophobic moieties. Here we describe the development of surfactants with rigid, saturated or aromatic hydrocarbon groups as hydrophobic parts. Their stabilizing properties are demonstrated with three different integral membrane proteins. The temperature at which 50% of the binding sites for specific ligands are lost is used as a measure of stability and dodecyl-β-D-maltoside ('C12-b-M') as a reference for conventional surfactants. One surfactant increased the stability of two different G protein-coupled receptors and the human Patched protein receptor by approximately 10°C compared to C12-b-M. Another surfactant yielded the highest stabilization of the human Patched protein receptor compared to C12-b-M (13°C) but was inferior for the G protein-coupled receptors. In addition, one of the surfactants was successfully used to stabilize and crystallize the cytochrome b(6 )f complex from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. The structure was solved to the same resolution as previously reported in C12-b-M.

Proton movement and photointermediate kinetics in rhodopsin mutants

The role of ionizable amino acid side chains in the bovine rhodopsin activation mechanism was studied in mutants E134Q, E134R/R135E, H211F, and E122Q. All mutants exhibited bathorhodopsin stability on the 30 ns to 1 micros time scale similar to that of the wild type. Lumirhodopsin decay was also similar to that of the wild type except for the H211F mutant where early decay (20 micros) to a second form of lumirhodopsin was seen, followed by formation of an extremely long-lived Meta I(480) product (34 ms), an intermediate which forms to a much reduced extent, if at all, in dodecyl maltoside suspensions of wild-type rhodopsin. A smaller amount of a similar long-lived Meta I(480) product was seen after photolysis of E122Q, but E134Q and E134R/R135Q displayed kinetics much more similar to those of the wild type under these conditions (i.e., no Meta I(480) product). These results support the idea that specific interaction of His211 and Glu122 plays a significant role in deprotonation of the retinylidene Schiff base and receptor activation. Proton uptake measurements using bromcresol purple showed that E122Q was qualitatively similar to wild-type rhodopsin, with at least one proton being released during lumirhodopsin decay per Meta I(380) intermediate formed, followed by uptake of at least two protons per rhodopsin bleached on a time scale of tens of milliseconds. Different results were obtained for H211F, E134Q, and E134R/R135E, which all released approximately two protons per rhodopsin bleached. These results show that several ionizable groups besides the Schiff base imine are affected by the structural changes involved in rhodopsin activation. At least two proton uptake groups and probably at least one proton release group in addition to the Schiff base are present in rhodopsin.

Rhodopsin photointermediates in two-dimensional crystals at physiological temperatures

Bovine rhodopsin photointermediates formed in two-dimensional (2D) rhodopsin crystal suspensions were studied by measuring the time-dependent absorbance changes produced after excitation with 7 ns laser pulses at 15, 25, and 35 degrees C. The crystalline environment favored the Meta I(480) photointermediate, with its formation from Lumi beginning faster than it does in rhodopsin membrane suspensions at 35 degrees C and its decay to a 380 nm absorbing species being less complete than it is in the native membrane at all temperatures. Measurements performed at pH 5.5 in 2D crystals showed that the 380 nm absorbing product of Meta I(480) decay did not display the anomalous pH dependence characteristic of classical Meta II in the native disk membrane. Crystal suspensions bleached at 35 degrees C and quenched to 19 degrees C showed that a rapid equilibrium existed on the approximately 1 s time scale, which suggests that the unprotonated predecessor of Meta II in the native membrane environment (sometimes called MII(a)) forms in 2D rhodopsin crystals but that the non-Schiff base proton uptake completing classical Meta II formation is blocked there. Thus, the 380 nm absorbance arises from an on-pathway intermediate in GPCR activation and does not result from early Schiff base hydrolysis. Kinetic modeling of the time-resolved absorbance data of the 2D crystals was generally consistent with such a mechanism, but details of kinetic spectral changes and the fact that the residuals of exponential fits were not as good as are obtained for rhodopsin in the native membrane suggested the photoexcited samples were heterogeneous. Variable fractional bleach due to the random orientation of linearly dichroic crystals relative to the linearly polarized laser was explored as a cause of heterogeneity but was found unlikely to fully account for it. The fact that the 380 nm product of photoexcitation of rhodopsin 2D crystals is on the physiological pathway of receptor activation suggests that determination of its structure would be of interest.

Rhodopsin activation affects the environment of specific neighboring phospholipids: an FTIR spectroscopic study

Rhodopsin is a member of a superfamily of G-protein-coupled receptors that transduce signals across membranes. We used Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) difference spectroscopy to study the interaction between rhodopsin and lipid bilayer upon receptor activation. A difference band at 1744 cm(-1) (+)/1727 cm(-1) (-) was identified in the FTIR-difference spectrum of rhodopsin mutant D83N/E122Q in which spectral difference bands arising from the carbonyl stretching frequencies of protonated carboxylic acid groups were removed by mutation. As the band was abolished by detergent delipidation, we suggested that it arose from carbonyl groups of phospholipid fatty acid esters. Rhodopsin and the D83N/E122Q mutant were reconstituted into various (13)C-labeled 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine vesicles and probed. The 1744-cm(-1) (+)/1727 cm(-1) (-) band could be unequivocally assigned to a change in the lipid ester carbonyl stretch upon receptor activation, with roughly equal contribution from both lipid esters. The band intensity scaled with the amount of rhodopsin but not with the amount of lipid, excluding the possibility that it was due to the bulk lipid phase. We also excluded the possibility that the lipid band represents a change in the number of boundary lipids or a general alteration in the boundary lipid environment upon formation of metarhodopsin II. Instead, the data suggest that the lipid band represents the change of a specific lipid-receptor interaction that is coupled to protein conformational changes.

Evidence for the specific interaction of a lipid molecule with rhodopsin which is altered in the transition to the active state metarhodopsin II

Comparing the FTIR difference spectra of the rhodopsin --> metarhodopsin II transition in membranes and in dodecylmaltoside detergent, characteristic variations are observed between 1715 and 1750 cm(-1). By repeating the measurements with the rhodopsin mutant D83N/E122Q, the spectral variation between the samples in membranes versus detergent could be assigned to a difference band at 1743(+)/1724(-) cm(-1), which does not exhibit a deuteration-induced downshift. We provide evidence that this band is probably caused by the C=O stretch of only one ester group of one lipid molecule. This group interacts with the dark state of rhodopsin, whereas in metarhodopsin II, the lipid molecule behaves as if it were in the bulk lipid phase.

Molecular and crystal structure of an amphiphile: 4'-propoxybiphenyl-4-methyl-N,N-dimethylamineoxide dihydrate

A novel amphiphile, 4'-propoxybiphenyl-4-methyl-N,N-dimethylamineoxide, has been synthesized, crystallized (P2(1)/a, a = 9.084 A, b = 8.911 A, c = 22.460 A, beta = 96.224 degrees) and its crystal structure was determined. The amphiphile forms a bilayer in which the amineoxide oxygen of each molecule binds two water molecules. In the hydrophobic part of the bilayer the biphenyls form edge-to-face contacts, in the polar layer there is a hydrogen bonding network. The potential use of the compound as a detergent for membrane proteins has been demonstrated and the relevance of the amineoxide hydrate for other detergents discussed.

Depalmitoylation of rhodopsin with hydroxylamine

Intrinsic membrane proteins that to date have been investigated with respect to the function of palmitoylation are the beta-adrenergic receptor, rhodopsin, the alpha 2A-adrenergic receptor, and the influenza virus spike glycoprotein. As described above, the studies have led to differing conclusions with respect to the influence of palmitoylation on physiological activity. The basis of the differences remains unclear, but it may relate at least in part to the membrane environment of the protein during these studies, that is, the presence of a native membrane, the membrane composition of the expression cell line (in the case of mutant proteins), or the absence of membrane (in the case of detergent-purified proteins). For example, in the case of rhodopsin, the composition of the ROS disk membrane differs from that of the rod plasma membrane, and presumably also from the plasma membranes of cell lines in which mutant rhodopsins are expressed. Variation in membrane composition is known to have marked effects on the ability of rhodopsin to mediate the photic activation of PDE. Thus, although Karnik et al. clearly demonstrated the absence of an absolute requirement for palmitate in activating transducin, the influence of detergent on tertiary protein structure may have masked the full effect of the elimination of palmitate on the transducin-activating property of rhodopsin. Alternatively, the differing results obtained in the studies of rhodopsin could be a consequence of differences in amino acid sequences of the proteins studied. The precise functional role of the palmitate groups of rhodopsin remains an important question for further research. It was suggested by Ovchinnikov et al. that the hydrolysis of covalently bound palmitate might occur during the process of rhodopsin bleaching, but more recent data argue against this hypothesis. Experiments using synthetic peptides (representing cytoplasmic loop regions of rhodopsin) to identify the sites of interaction of R* and transducin provide support for an alternative possibility, namely, that palmitoylation and the resulting cytoplasmic loop play a role in the coupling of rhodopsin with transducin. The finding that the binding of transducin to R* occurs independently of the presence of palmitate argues against an essential requirement of palmitoylation on the binding step itself. However, available data indicate an enhancement, by depalmitoylation, of light-dependent GTPase activity in ROS preparations, although not in assays of unpalmitoylated, purified mutant rhodopsins (see above).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

2D crystallization: from art to science

The techniques as well as the principles of the 2D crystallization of membrane and water-soluble proteins for electron crystallography are reviewed. First, the biophysics of the interactions between proteins, lipids and detergents is surveyed. Second, crystallization of membrane proteins in situ and by reconstitution methods is discussed, and the various factors involved are addressed. Third, we elaborate on the 2D crystallization of water-soluble proteins, both in solution and at interfaces, such as lipid monolayers, mica, carbon film or mercury surfaces. Finally, techniques and instrumentations that are required for 2D crystallization are described.

Reaction rate and collisional efficiency of the rhodopsin-transducin system in intact retinal rods

A model of transducin activation is constructed from its partial reactions (formation of metarhodopsin II, association, and dissociation of the rhodopsin-transducin complex). The kinetic equations of the model are solved both numerically and, for small photoactivation, analytically. From data on the partial reactions in vitro, rate and activation energy profile of amplified transducin turnover are modeled and compared with measured light-scattering signals of transducin activation in intact retinal rods. The data leave one free parameter, the rate of association between transducin and rhodopsin. Best fit is achieved for an activation energy of 35 kJ/mol, indicating lateral membrane diffusion of the proteins as its main determinant. The absolute value of the association rate is discussed in terms of the success of collisions to form the catalytic complex. It is greater than 30% for the intact retina and 10 times lower after permeabilization with staphylococcus aureus alpha-toxin. Dissociation rates for micromolar guanosinetriphosphale (GTP) (Kohl, B., and K. P. Hofmann, 1987. Biophys. J. 52:271-277) must be extrapolated linearly up to the millimolar range to explain the rapid transducin turnover in situ. This is interpreted by an unstable rhodopsin-transducin-GTP transient state. At the time of maximal turnover after a flash, the rate of activation is determined as 30, 120, 800, 2,500, and 4,000 activated transducins per photoactivated rhodopsin and second at 5, 10, 20, 30, 37 degrees C, respectively.

Rhodopsin mutants that bind but fail to activate transducin

Rhodopsin is a member of a family of receptors that contain seven transmembrane helices and are coupled to G proteins. The nature of the interactions between rhodopsin mutants and the G protein, transduction (Gt), was investigated by flash photolysis in order to monitor directly Gt binding and dissociation. Three mutant opsins with alterations in their cytoplasmic loops bound 11-cis-retinal to yield pigments with native rhodopsin absorption spectra, but they failed to stimulate the guanosine triphosphatase activity of Gt. The opsin mutations included reversal of a charged pair conserved in all G protein-coupled receptors at the cytoplasmic border of the third transmembrane helix (mutant CD1), replacement of 13 amino acids in the second cytoplasmic loop (mutant CD2), and deletion of 13 amino acids from the third cytoplasmic loop (mutant EF1). Whereas mutant CD1 failed to bind Gt, mutants CD2 and EF1 showed normal Gt binding but failed to release Gt in the presence of guanosine triphosphate. Therefore, it appears that at least the second and third cytoplasmic loops of rhodopsin are required for activation of bound Gt.

Photoactivation of rhodopsin and interaction with transducin in detergent micelles. Effect of 'doping' with steroid molecules

On detergent-solubilised bovine rhodopsin, we have studied the formation of the active photoproduct, metarhodopsin II (MII), and its interaction with the rod G-protein, transducin (G1). The measured rate of flash-induced MII formation decreases by a factor of 300 from n-dodecyl-beta-D-maltoside (k = 4 x 10(3) at 18 degrees C, pH 6.5), over (3-(lauroyloxy)propyl)-phosphorylcholine (deoxylysolecithin), n-octyl-beta-D-glucopyranoside, sodium cholate to Chapso. For the two last agents, MII formation is similarly slow as in the native disc membrane; however, the micellar system does not display the very large decrease of the rate with lowering temperature, as is characteristic for the membrane. This points to entropic factors determining the rate in the micellar systems. An admixture of rigid steroid molecules (11-deoxycorticosterone) to lysolecithin micelles ('doped micelles') slows MII formation and shifts the MI/MII equilibrium to values typical for detergents of rigid structure. The observation gives further support to the surface free energy concept of MII formation outlined in previous studies. The free adjustment of the MI/MII equilibrium in these doped micelles allows Gt-induced formation of extra-MII to be measured, providing a convenient monitor of rhodopsin-Gt interaction in solution.

Crystallization of porin using short chain phospholipids

A protein from outer membranes of Escherichia coli K-12, porin OmpF was crystallized either with short acyl chain phospolipids or with various detergents as amphiphiles. In dihexanoyl phosphatidylcholine, crystals greater than 0.3 mm in all dimensions were obtained that diffract X-rays beyond 3.5 A. Crystal morphology and unit cell dimensions were indistinguishable from those of detergent-grown crystals, indicating that the role of the phospholipids used is similar to those of many conventional detergents.

Three-dimensional crystallization of membrane proteins

As recently as 10 years ago, the prospect of solving the structure of any membrane protein by X-ray crystallography seemed remote. Since then, the threedimensional (3-D) structures of two membrane protein complexes, the bacterial photosynthetic reaction centres ofRhodopseudomonas viridis(Deisenhoferet al.1984, 1985) and ofRhodobacter sphaeroides(Allenet al.1986, 1987a, 6; Changet al.1986) have been determined at high resolution. This astonishing progress would not have been possible without the pioneering work of Michel and Garavito who first succeeded in growing 3-D crystals of the membrane proteins bacteriorhodopsin (Michel & Oesterhelt, 1980) and matrix porin (Garavito & Rosenbusch, 1980). X-ray crystallography is still the only routine method for determining the 3-D structures of biological macromolecules at high resolution and well-ordered 3-D crystals of sufficient size are the essential prerequisite.