Interrelationships of tubulin-GDP and tubulin-GTP in microtubule assembly

Collective effect of Vigna sp. (mung) tubulin GTP hydrolysis rate divergence on microtubule filament assembly

Microtubules (MTs) are dynamic cytoskeletal filaments with highly conserved sequences across evolution, polymerizing by the GTP-dependent assembly of tubulin subunits. Despite the sequence conservation, MT polymerization kinetics diverge quantitatively between vertebrate brain, the model plant Arabidopsis and the protozoan Plasmodium. Previously, tubulin purified from seedlings of the plant Vigna sp. (mung) by temperature cycling was found to have a very low critical concentration. However, the lengths of MTs were sub-micron, much shorter than brain tubulin filaments. This was explained in simulations to be the result of the collective effect of high nucleation and GTP hydrolysis rates. Here, we test the effect of GTPase rates of affinity-purified Vigna sp. tubulin on microtubule polymerization and elongation. Affinity-purified mung tubulin is active and has a critical concentration of .37 μM. The GTP-dependent polymerization kinetics are transient, consistent with previous results. Polymerization is stabilized in the presence of either GTP analog GMPPNP (non-hydrolyzable) or GMPCPP (slow-hydrolyzable). Using interference reflection microscopy (IRM) we find polymerization with the non-hydrolysable analog significantly increases filament numbers, while lengths are unaffected for both GTP analogs. However, prolonged incubation with slow-hydrolyzable GMPCPP results in long filaments, pointing to GTP hydrolysis as a key factor determining MT length. We find the average GTPase turnover number of mung tubulin is 22.8 min-1, compared to 2.04 min-1 for goat brain tubulin. Thus modulating GTPase rates affects both nucleation and elongation. This quantitative divergence in kinetics despite high sequence conservation in the GTPase domains of α- and β-tubulin could help better understand the roles of selective pressure and function in the diverse organisms.

A unified model for microtubule rescue

How microtubules transition from depolymerization to polymerization, known as rescue, is poorly understood. Here we examine two models for rescue: 1) an "end-driven" model in which the depolymerizing end stochastically switches to a stable state; and 2) a "lattice-driven" model in which rescue sites are integrated into the microtubule before depolymerization. We test these models using a combination of computational simulations and in vitro experiments with purified tubulin. Our findings support the "lattice-driven" model by identifying repeated rescue sites in microtubules. In addition, we discover an important role for divalent cations in determining the frequency and location of rescue sites. We use "wash-in" experiments to show that divalent cations inhibit rescue during depolymerization, but not during polymerization. We propose a unified model in which rescues are driven by embedded rescue sites in microtubules, but the activity of these sites is influenced by changes in the depolymerizing ends.

A conceptual view at microtubule plus end dynamics in neuronal axons

Axons are the cable-like protrusions of neurons which wire up the nervous system. Polar bundles of microtubules (MTs) constitute their structural backbones and are highways for life-sustaining transport between proximal cell bodies and distal synapses. Any morphogenetic changes of axons during development, plastic rearrangement, regeneration or degeneration depend on dynamic changes of these MT bundles. A key mechanism for implementing such changes is the coordinated polymerisation and depolymerisation at the plus ends of MTs within these bundles. To gain an understanding of how such regulation can be achieved at the cellular level, we provide here an integrated overview of the extensive knowledge we have about the molecular mechanisms regulating MT de/polymerisation. We first summarise insights gained from work in vitro, then describe the machinery which supplies the essential tubulin building blocks, the protein complexes associating with MT plus ends, and MT shaft-based mechanisms that influence plus end dynamics. We briefly summarise the contribution of MT plus end dynamics to important cellular functions in axons, and conclude by discussing the challenges and potential strategies of integrating the existing molecular knowledge into conceptual understanding at the level of axons.

New insights into microtubule elongation mechanisms

Microtubules are cytoskeletal structures in the cytoplasm of eukaryotic cells, and their highly dynamic properties are essential to perform a wide variety of vital functions in cells. Microtubule growth proceeds through the endwise addition of nucleotide-bound tubulin molecules. It has largely been assumed that only tubulin dimers can incorporate into microtubules, and that the chemical state of the nucleotide is crucial for the incorporation. Recent observations reveal that both tubulin dimers and oligomers can add to microtubule ends and that the chemical state of the nucleotide is not decisive for tubulin addition. Together with structural studies of tubulin, these results show tubulin assembly polymorphism, which could play a crucial role in microtubule-dependent cellular functions.

The magnesium-GTP interaction in microtubule assembly

Microtubule-associated-protein-dependent assembly of tubulin with GDP in the exchangeable site (tubulin-GDP) can occur with minimal free Mg2+ (< 3 microM). This reaction is totally inhibited by EDTA and by GTP concentrations over 2 mM and stimulated by MgCl2. Quantitative aspects of this stimulation are affected by both the Mg2+ and GTP concentrations but no relationship exists between reaction rates and relative amounts of different magnesium and GTP species. GTP binding to tubulin-GDP, while maximally stimulated 2-3-fold by exogenous MgCl2, was inhibited less than 50% by EDTA, and the amount of GTP bound increased as its concentration rose to levels that inhibited polymerization. Studies on the binding of Mg2+ to tubulin-GDP in the presence and absence of GTP showed that the increase in the amount of tubulin-associated Mg2+ was substoichiometric to the amount of GTP bound (maximum stoichiometry of additional Mg2+ to GTP bound, 0.7). Upon polymerization the increased Mg2+ content of tubulin was reduced, indicating its loss during GTP hydrolysis. Mg2+ thus plays a critical role in assembly distinct from its enhancement of GTP binding to the exchangeable site. If magnesium is present in trace amounts, this role must either be catalytic during polymerization or limited to nucleation.

A model of microtubule oscillations

Simulations of microtubule oscillations have been obtained by a kinetic model including nucleation of microtubules, elongation by addition of GTP-loaded tubulin dimers, disassembly into oligomers, and dissolution of oligomers followed by nucleotide exchange at the free dimers. Dynamic instability is described by the on and off rates for dimer association in the growth phase, the rate of rapid shortening, and the transition rates for catastrophe and rescue. The latter are assumed to be completely determined by the current state of the system ("short cap hypothesis"). Microtubule oscillations and normal polymerizations measured by time-resolved X-ray scattering were used to test the model. The model is able to produce oscillations without further assumptions. However, in order to obtain good fits to the experimental data one requires an additional mechanism which prevents rapid desynchronization of the microtubules. One of several possible mechanisms that will be discussed is the destabilization of microtubules by the products of disassembly.

X-ray solution scattering studies on vinblastine-induced polymers of microtubule protein: structural characterisation and effects of temperature

We report here on X-ray solution scattering and electron microscopy studies of microtubule protein in the presence of the antimitotic drug, vinblastine. In buffer conditions used for microtubule assembly, vinblastine caused the formation of coil-like structures. The coils appeared to be made up of two protofilaments. Details of the structure and behaviour of coils in solution were obtained from interpretation of their solution scattering patterns. Upon increasing temperature from 4 to 37 degrees C the pitch of the coils increased from 25.92 to 26.96 nm. However, little change was observed in their mean diameters (38.46 and 38.45 nm, respectively). Increasing the temperature also favoured increased formation and/or elongation of the coils. The effect of temperature on the pitch was fully reversible. Vinblastine-induced assembly of pure tubulin also showed the formation of coils. However, these coils appeared to consist of only one protofilament. Their mean diameters (38.35 nm) were similar to those of the coils formed from microtubule protein.

Modulation of tubulin-nucleotide interactions by metal ions: comparison of beryllium with magnesium and initial studies with other cations

With microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs) BeSO4 and MgSO4 stimulated tubulin polymerization as compared to a reaction mixture without exogenously added metal ion, while beryllium fluoride had no effect (E. Hamel et al., 1991, Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 286, 57-69). Effects of both cations were most dramatic at GTP concentrations in the same molar range as the tubulin concentration. We have now compared effects of beryllium and magnesium on tubulin-nucleotide interactions in both unpolymerized tubulin and in polymer. Polymer formed with magnesium had properties similar to those of polymer formed without exogenous cation, except for a 20% lower stoichiometry of exogenous GTP incorporated into the latter. In both polymers the incorporated GTP was hydrolyzed to GDP. Stoichiometry of GTP incorporation into polymers formed with beryllium or magnesium was identical, but much of the GTP in the beryllium polymer was not hydrolyzed. The beryllium polymer was more stable than the magnesium polymer. Beryllium also differed from magnesium in only weakly enhancing the binding of GTP in the exchangeable site of unpolymerized tubulin, while neither cation affected GDP exchange at the site. If both cations were present in a reaction mixture, polymer stability was little changed from that of the beryllium polymer, but most of the GTP incorporated into polymer was hydrolyzed. Six additional metal salts (AlCl3, CdCl2, CoCl2, MnCl2, SnCl2, and ZnCl2) also stimulated MAP-dependent tubulin polymerization, but enhanced polymer stability did not correlate with polymer GTP content. We postulate that enhanced polymer stability is a consequence of cation binding directly to tubulin and/or polymer while deficient GTP hydrolysis in the presence of beryllium, as well as aluminum and tin, is a consequence of tight binding of cation to GTP in the exchangeable site.

Natural products which interact with tubulin in the vinca domain: maytansine, rhizoxin, phomopsin A, dolastatins 10 and 15 and halichondrin B

This paper summarizes published data on the interactions of tubulin with antimitotic compounds that inhibit the binding of vinca alkaloids to the protein. These are all relatively complex natural products isolated from higher plants, fungi and marine invertebrate animals. These agents are maytansine, rhizoxin, phomopsin A, dolastatins 10 and 15 and halichondrin B and their congeners. Effects on tubulin polymerization, ligand binding interactions and structure-activity relationships are emphasized.

Reexamination of the role of nonhydrolyzable guanosine 5'-triphosphate analogues in tubulin polymerization: reaction conditions are a critical factor for effective interactions at the exchangeable nucleotide site

Recently it was proposed [O'Brien, E. T., & Erickson, H. P. (1989) Biochemistry 28, 1413-1422] that tubulin polymerization supported by guanosine 5'-(beta,gamma-imidotriphosphate) [p(NH)ppG], guanosine 5'-(beta,gamma-methylenetriphosphate) [p(CH2)ppG], and ATP might be due to residual GTP in reaction mixtures and that these nucleotides would probably support only one cycle of assembly. Since we had observed polymerization with these three compounds, we decided to study these reactions in greater detail in two systems. The first contained purified tubulin and a high concentration of glycerol, the second tubulin and microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs). In both systems, reactions supported by nucleotides other than GTP were most vigorous at lower pH values. In the glycerol system, repeated cycles of polymerization were observed with ATP and p(CH2)ppG, but not with p(NH)ppG. With p(NH)ppG, a single cycle of polymerization was observed, and this was caused by contaminating GTP. In the MAPs system, repeated cycles of polymerization were observed with both nonhydrolyzable GTP analogues, even without contaminating GTP, but ATP was not active at all in this system. Binding to tubulin of p(NH)ppG, p(CH2)ppG, and, to a lesser extent, ATP was demonstrated indirectly, since high concentrations of the three nucleotides displaced radiolabeled GDP originally bound in the exchangeable site, with p(NH)ppG the most active of the three compounds in this displacement assay. The failure of GTP-free p(NH)ppG to support tubulin polymerization in our glycerol system even though it displaced GDP from the exchangeable site was further investigated by examining the effects of p(NH)ppG on polymerization and polymer-bound nucleotide with low concentrations of GTP. The two nucleotides appeared to act synergistically in supporting polymerization, so that a reaction occurred with a subthreshold GTP concentration if p(NH)ppG was also in the reaction mixture. Analysis of radiolabeled exchangeable-site nucleotide in polymers formed in reaction mixtures containing both GTP and p(NH)ppG demonstrated that p(NH)ppG which entered polymer did so primarily at the expense of GDP originally bound in the exchangeable site rather than at the expense of GTP. It appears that in the glycerol reaction condition, tubulin-p(NH)ppG cannot initiate tubulin polymerization but that it can participate in polymer elongation. ATP and p(CH2)ppG also entered the exchangeable site during polymerization without GTP in glycerol, as demonstrated by displacement of radiolabeled GDP from polymer when these alternate nucleotides were used.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Influence of the guanine nucleotide phosphorylation state and of Mg2+ ions on the interaction of vinzolidine/tubulin 6 S: a fluorescence quenching study

The binding of the new vincaalkaloid vinzolidine to tubulin 6 S was investigated by using fluorescence quenching methods. The value of the apparent equilibrium binding constant was found to depend on the phosphorylation state of the guanine nucleotide bound to the tubulin exchangeable site (E-site), with Ka values of 4.9 X 10(4) and 8.19 X 10(4) M-1 for GTP- and GDP-tubulin, respectively. The effect of Mg2+ ions on this binding was more important on GTP-tubulin than on GDP-tubulin, and might be related to the existence of Mg2+ site(s) independent of the nucleotide.

Spindle microtubule dynamics: modulation by metabolic inhibitors

Recent experiments have shown that spindle microtubules are exceedingly dynamic. Measurements of fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP), in cells previously microinjected with fluorescent tubulin, provide quantitative information concerning the rate of turnover, or exchange, of tubulin subunits with the population of microtubules in living cells at steady state. In an effort to elucidate the pathways and factors that regulate tubulin exchange with microtubules in living cells, we have investigated the energy requirements for tubulin turnover as measured by FRAP. Spindle morphology was not detectably altered in cells incubated with 5 mM sodium azide and 1 mM 2-deoxyglucose (Az/DOG) for 5 minutes, as assayed by polarized light microscopy and antitubulin immunofluorescence. In FRAP experiments on these ATP-depleted cells, the average rate of recovery and the average percent of bleached fluorescence recovered were reduced to 37% and 30% of controls, respectively. When the inhibitors were removed, cells continued through mitosis, and rapid FRAP was restored. In the presence of azide and glucose, the rate of recovery and percent of fluorescence recovered were only slightly reduced, demonstrating that energy production via glycolysis can support microtubule turnover. Longer incubations with Az/DOG altered the microtubule organization in mitotic cells: astral microtubules lengthened and spindle fibers shortened. Furthermore, both astral and spindle microtubules became resistant to nocodazole-induced disassembly under these conditions. Together these observations indicate that microtubule dynamics require ATP and suggest a relationship between microtubule organization and turnover.