RNA polymerase: correlation between transcript length, abortive product synthesis, and formation of a stable ternary complex

Transcription initiation in a single-subunit RNA polymerase proceeds through DNA scrunching and rotation of the N-terminal subdomains

Elucidating the mechanism of transcription initiation by RNA polymerases (RNAP) is essential for understanding gene transcription and regulation. Although several models, such as DNA scrunching, RNAP translation, and RNAP rotation, have been proposed, the mechanism of initiation by T7 RNAP has remained unclear. Using ensemble and single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) studies, we provide evidence for concerted DNA scrunching and rotation during initiation by T7 RNAP. A constant spatial distance between the upstream and downstream edges of initiation complexes making 4-7 nt RNA supports the DNA scrunching model, but not the RNAP translation or the pure rotation model. DNA scrunching is accompanied by moderate hinging motion (18 degrees +/- 4 degrees ) of the promoter toward the downstream DNA. The observed stepwise conformational changes provide a basis to understand abortive RNA synthesis during early stages of initiation and promoter escape during the later stages that allows transition to processive elongation.

Structural basis of transcription: an RNA polymerase II elongation complex at 3.3 A resolution

The crystal structure of RNA polymerase II in the act of transcription was determined at 3.3 A resolution. Duplex DNA is seen entering the main cleft of the enzyme and unwinding before the active site. Nine base pairs of DNA-RNA hybrid extend from the active center at nearly right angles to the entering DNA, with the 3' end of the RNA in the nucleotide addition site. The 3' end is positioned above a pore, through which nucleotides may enter and through which RNA may be extruded during back-tracking. The 5'-most residue of the RNA is close to the point of entry to an exit groove. Changes in protein structure between the transcribing complex and free enzyme include closure of a clamp over the DNA and RNA and ordering of a series of "switches" at the base of the clamp to create a binding site complementary to the DNA-RNA hybrid. Protein-nucleic acid contacts help explain DNA and RNA strand separation, the specificity of RNA synthesis, "abortive cycling" during transcription initiation, and RNA and DNA translocation during transcription elongation.

Requirement for the beta,gamma-pyrophosphate bond of ATP in a stage between transcription initiation and elongation by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase

A linear fragment of DNA was fixed to acrylamide or agarose beads by its ends. When a fragment containing the lambda PR promoter is immobilized and transcribed, the RNA products are unchanged from those obtained on the unfixed DNA. Transcription from the immobilized fragment can be interrupted by diluting the reaction mixture into a large volume of the same buffer. Brief centrifugation allows isolation of the transcription complex with the immobilized DNA. If interruption occurs during elongation, the elongation can be resumed upon a second addition of substrates. If ATP is replaced by a beta, gamma-unhydrolyzable analogue in the second addition, the elongated products are similar to those obtained when the substrate contain ATP. When ATP is replaced by the analogue at the initiation step, however, the yield of elongated products is decreased to less than one-sixth and that of short abortive products is increased. Thus the ATP analogues are good substrates once elongation has been established in the presence of ATP, but not good enough to get past a stage just after initiation in the absence of ATP. We conclude that the beta, gamma-pyrophosphate bond of ATP is important for preparation of efficient elongation.

RNA chain initiation by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase. Structural transitions of the enzyme in early ternary complexes

We have studied the properties and structures of a series of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase ternary complexes formed during the initial steps of RNA chain initiation and elongation. Five different templates were used that contained the bacteriophage T7 A1 promoter or the E. coli Tac or the lac UV5 promoter, as well as variant templates with alterations in the initial transcribed regions. The majority of ternary complexes bearing short transcripts (from two to nine nucleotides) are highly unstable and cannot be easily studied. This includes transcripts from the phage T7 A1 promoter, for which the stability of complexes bearing transcripts as short as four nucleotides has previously been postulated. However, with one Tac promoter template, RNA polymerase forms ternary complexes with transcripts as short as five nucleotides that are stable enough for biochemical study. We describe several approaches to identifying and isolating such stable complexes and show that stringent criteria are needed in carrying out such experiments if the results are to be meaningful. Deoxyribonuclease I (DNase I) footprinting has been used to probe the general structure of the stable ternary complexes formed as the polymerase begins transcription and moves away from the start site. The enzyme undergoes a sequence of structural changes during initiation and transition to an elongating complex. Complexes with five to eight nucleotide transcripts, designated initial transcribing complexes (ITC), have identical footprints; they all retain the sigma factor and have a slightly extended DNase I footprint (-57 to +24) as compared to the open promoter complex (-57 to +20). ITC complexes all show a region of marked DNase I hypersensitivity in the -25 region that may reflect bending or distortion of the DNA template. Complexes with 10 or 11 nucleotide transcripts, designated initial elongating complexes (IEC), have lost the sigma factor and have a slightly reduced and shifted DNase I footprint (-32 to +30). However, these IEC have not yet achieved the much smaller footprint (approximately 30 bp) reported as characteristic of elongating ternary complexes bearing longer RNA chains. During the initial phase of transcription, the RNA polymerase does not move monotonically along the DNA template as RNA chains are extended, but instead, the upstream and downstream contacts remain more or less fixed as the nascent transcript is elongated up to about eight nucleotides in length. Only after incorporation of 10 nucleotides is there significant movement of the enzyme away from the promoter region and a commitment to elongation.

Formation and characterization of precise eucaryotic transcription complexes using a semisynthetic DNA template and specific oligoribonucleotide primers

An artificial template of defined sequence which supports specific in vitro initiation and elongation by yeast RNA polymerase II has been constructed. This template is a pBR322 derivative which contains a synthetic oligonucleotide inserted into the BamHI cloning site. The sequence of this oligonucleotide is such that when the plasmid is restricted with SacI the two ends obtained are identical. The addition of an oligodeoxycytidylate chain to the 3' hydroxy termini produces a DNA template, (poly dC-p+22), with the sequence: 3'(C)nTCGA-GAGTCTCCTA. . . . The underlined position denotes the beginning of the duplex region. When initiation is primed with the diribonucleotide GpC the predicted sequence of the transcript obtained is: 5'GCUCUCAGAGGAU. . . . Kinetic and product analyses indicate that a ternary complex containing a precise length of transcript can be produced which is subsequently resistant to heparin inactivation. Initiation can also be directed to a specific position dictated by a tri or tetraribonucleotide primer.

Isolation and properties of transcribing ternary complexes of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase positioned at a single template base

We have studied the conditions needed for the formation of stable ternary complexes by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase using a procedure in which elongation by the majority of active enzyme molecules is halted at a specific template base. Stable complexes of this sort, containing RNA chains as short as 15 nucleotides, have been formed from three different promoter sites (T7 A1, lambda PL, and E. coli rrnB P1) using di- and trinucleotides as primers in reactions limited by the presence of only three of the nucleoside triphosphate substrates. The resulting ternary complexes can be stored for at least five days without loss in activity, and provide useful reagents and substrates for studies of the properties of RNA polymerases engaged in chain elongation and termination. At all three promoter sites abortive initiation, leading to synthesis and release of oligomers up to ten nucleotides, competes with productive initiation, leading to the formation of stable elongating complexes. Thus the relative instability of ternary RNA polymerase complexes bearing transcripts shorter than ten nucleotides may be a general feature of the transcription initiation reaction.

Specific binding of monomeric bacteriophage T3 and T7 RNA polymerases to their respective cognate promoters requires the initiating ribonucleoside triphosphate (GTP)

Bacteriophage T3 and T7 RNA polymerases are monomeric proteins of Mr of about 100,000. Each polymerase has stringent specificity for its own promoters that is present only on the homologous phage DNA template. Neither enzyme recognizes the heterologous phage promoters or Escherichia coli RNA polymerase promoters. In the present study, the interaction of T3 and T7 RNA polymerases with their respective cognate promoters was studied by DNase I footprinting techniques. These studies revealed an absolute requirement for the initiating nucleotide (GTP) for each phage RNA polymerase to bind specifically to and protect its cognate promoter from DNase I digestion. In the absence of the initiating nucleotide, both enzymes randomly bind DNA with lower affinity. No other nucleotide can substitute for GTP; however, the addition of GTP + ATP, which causes the synthesis of a hexamer RNA (pppGpGpGpApGpA), makes the DNA-RNA-protein complex highly stable. Nitrocellulose filter binding studies confirmed these observations. On the basis of these results we propose that the binding of the initiating nucleotide (in this case, GTP) drives the phage RNA polymerase into an "initiation conformation" in which the random DNA-binding property of the enzyme is converted to a promoter-specific recognition, and the polymerase is primed to initiate transcription.

Verification of a new model of the time course of RNA synthesis. Measurement of the rates of initiation and elongation

The time course of RNA synthesis in vitro commonly starts with a lag followed by a linear phase. Differing from the earlier interpretation we have previously proposed that, under conditions where the initiation rate is low, the lag represents the time taken for the first RNA polymerase molecule to reach a termination site. During the linear phase, initiation is balanced by termination (Mahon, G.A.T., McWilliam, P., Gordon, R.L. and McConnell, D.J. (1980) J. Theor. Biol. 87, 483-515). We report the use of rifampicin as a further test of this new model. We show that it does apply under conditions of high ionic strength (0.3 M KCl), and under these conditions time courses may be analyzed to yield unbiased estimates of the initiation (Vi) and chain elongation (Vp) rates. We illustrate the application of the method of time course analysis and confirm some of its features by examining the effect of variation in the concentrations of RNA polymerase and nucleoside triphosphate on the estimates of Vi and Vp. The alternative interpretation of the time course applies under conditions of low ionic strength, where the initiation rate is high. (Chamberlin, M.J., Nierman, W.C., Wiggs, J. and Neff, N. (1979) J. Biol. Chem. 254, 10061-10069.) The advantages of each model in measuring Vi and Vp (the major parameters of the transcription reaction) are discussed.

Purification and characterization of ternary complexes containing accurately initiated RNA polymerase II and less than 20 nucleotides of RNA

We have previously demonstrated that transcription of the adenovirus type 2 (Ad2) late promoter in vitro under UTP-limiting conditions results in pauses by the elongating RNA polymerase II between positions +6 and +17. We report here the purification of complexes between the paused RNA polymerase and a 260 base-pair Ad2 promoter-bearing DNA fragment. The procedure involves sedimentation through sucrose gradients, electrophoresis in agarose gels, and electroelution from the gels; the final complex pool is completely active in chain elongation. We observe a sharp discontinuity in complex stability during purification as a function of the number of bases added to the growing chains: complexes in which the polymerase has added more than ten bases are stable and are active in chain elongation even after the electroelution step, whereas complexes containing seven or fewer bases dissociate very easily. When purified complexes are extensively digested with proteinase K their electrophoretic mobility is increased considerably, yet they remain fully active in chain elongation. If purified complexes are digested with DNase I their electrophoretic mobility does not change. When the nuclease-treated complexes are allowed to continue chain elongation, they are able to add approximately 20 more bases to the nascent chains.

Non-processive transcription of poly[d(A-T)] by wheat germ RNA polymerase II

RNA product distribution obtained during the transcription of poly[d(A-T)] by wheat germ RNA polymerase IIA under various experimental conditions was analyzed by high resolution polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Poly[r(A-U)] synthesis proceeded as if wheat germ RNA polymerase II was a non-processive enzyme: a ladder of RNA products of increasing lengths was obtained, which apparently, terminated at every other nucleotide. RNA release was not dependent upon nucleoside triphosphate substrate concentrations. A likely explanation would be that ternary complexes enzyme: DNA: RNA were very much unstable; moreover, oligonucleotides released were not re-used for further elongation by the enzyme.

RNA polymerase: linear competitive inhibition by bis-(3' to 5')-cyclic dinucleotides,NpNp

We have investigated the possible role of the bis-(3' to 5')-cyclic dinucleotides UpUp and ApUp as kinetic inhibitors of the DNA dependent RNA polymerase enzyme of E. coli, using T7 delta D111 deletion mutant DNA and several synthetic DNA polymers as templates. We have established that UpUp is a linear competitive inhibitor of the initiation phase of the polymerization (Ki = 28 microM using T7 delta D111 DNA as a template), but that it has no effect when added during the elongation phase. The compound ApUp is an inhibitor of the reaction only when poly(dA-T).poly(dA-T) is used as a template, and UpUp is an inhibitor of the reaction when poly(dA).poly(dT) was employed as the DNA template.