Mechanism of ribonucleic acid chain initiation. 2. A real time analysis of initiation by the rapid kinetic technique

Mechanism of transcription initiation and promoter escape by E. coli RNA polymerase

To investigate roles of the discriminator and open complex (OC) lifetime in transcription initiation by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase (RNAP; α₂ββ'ωσ⁷⁰), we compare productive and abortive initiation rates, short RNA distributions, and OC lifetime for the λP_R and T7A1 promoters and variants with exchanged discriminators, all with the same transcribed region. The discriminator determines the OC lifetime of these promoters. Permanganate reactivity of thymines reveals that strand backbones in open regions of long-lived λP_R-discriminator OCs are much more tightly held than for shorter-lived T7A1-discriminator OCs. Initiation from these OCs exhibits two kinetic phases and at least two subpopulations of ternary complexes. Long RNA synthesis (constrained to be single round) occurs only in the initial phase (<10 s), at similar rates for all promoters. Less than half of OCs synthesize a full-length RNA; the majority stall after synthesizing a short RNA. Most abortive cycling occurs in the slower phase (>10 s), when stalled complexes release their short RNA and make another without escaping. In both kinetic phases, significant amounts of 8-nt and 10-nt transcripts are produced by longer-lived, λP_R-discriminator OCs, whereas no RNA longer than 7 nt is produced by shorter-lived T7A1-discriminator OCs. These observations and the lack of abortive RNA in initiation from short-lived ribosomal promoter OCs are well described by a quantitative model in which ∼1.0 kcal/mol of scrunching free energy is generated per translocation step of RNA synthesis to overcome OC stability and drive escape. The different length-distributions of abortive RNAs released from OCs with different lifetimes likely play regulatory roles.

The many conformational states of RNA polymerase elongation complexes and their roles in the regulation of transcription

Transcription is highly regulated both by protein factors and by specific RNA or DNA sequence elements. Central to this regulation is the ability of RNA polymerase (RNAP) to adopt multiple conformational states during elongation. This review focuses on the mechanism of transcription elongation and the role of different conformational states in the regulation of elongation and termination. The discussion centers primarily on data from structural and functional studies on Escherichia coli RNAP. To introduce the players, a brief introduction to the general mechanism of elongation, the regulatory proteins, and the conformational states is provided. The role of each of the conformational states in elongation is then discussed in detail. Finally, an integrated mechanism of elongation is presented, bringing together the panoply of experiments.

UTP allosterically regulates transcription by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase from the bacteriophage T7 A1 promoter

In the case of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase, UTP at elevated concentrations suppresses terminated transcript accumulation during multiple-round transcription from a DNA construct containing the T7 A1 promoter and T(e) terminator. The step that is affected by UTP at elevated concentrations is promoter clearance. In an attempt to understand better the mechanism by which UTP regulates this step, we analyzed the effect of UTP on the formation of pppApU in the presence of only UTP and ATP. At elevated concentrations, UTP is a non-competitive inhibitor with respect to ATP in the formation of pppApU. This indicates that the effect of UTP on the formation of pppApU is mediated through an allosteric site. Moreover, the magnitude of the inhibition of pppApU formation is sufficient to account for the decrease in terminated transcript accumulation at elevated UTP concentrations. Thus, it appears that UTP modulates terminated transcript accumulation during multiple-round transcription from this DNA construct by allosteric regulation of promoter clearance at the point of transcription initiation.

Abortive intermediates in transcription by wheat-germ RNA polymerase II. Dynamic aspects of enzyme/template interactions in selection of the enzyme synthetic mode

At constant enzyme concentration and with the full set of nucleotide substrates dictated by template sequence, the chain-length distribution of polymeric product varies with template concentration in reactions catalysed by wheat-germ RNA polymerase II. Under the same conditions, but in the presence of a single ribonucleoside triphosphate, the rate of condensation of the triphosphate substrate to a dinucleotide primer also exhibits a complex dependence with the template concentration. This effect is observed using poly[d(A-T)] as a template. For both reactions there are two extreme types of behaviour in each of which transcription appears to involve a single enzyme synthetic mode, characterized by either a high (at low template concentration) or a low (at high template concentration) probability of releasing the transcripts. A strong correlation is found between these two pathways, such that conditions favouring the abortive release of trinucleotide products in the single-step addition reaction are associated with the synthesis of short-length RNA species in productive elongation, and reciprocally. A model previously developed by Papanicolaou, Lecomte & Ninio [(1986) J. Mol. Biol. 189, 435-448] to account for the kinetics of polymerization/excision ratios with Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I, and by Job, Soulié, Job & Shire [(1988) J. Theor. Biol. 134, 273-289] for kinetics of RNA-chain elongation by wheat-germ RNA polymerase II provides an explanation for the observed behaviour with the plant transcriptase. The basic requirement of this model is a slow equilibrium between two states of the polymerization complex with distinct probabilities of releasing the product. In the presence of Mn2+, and under conditions allowing the synthesis of poly[r(A-U)], one of these states is involved in the formation of oligonucleotides shorter than 15 bases, whereas the other catalyses the polymerization of chains longer than 40 bases.

Effect of Sarkosyl and heparin on single-step addition reactions catalysed by wheat-germ RNA polymerase II--poly[d(A-T)]transcription complexes

Incubation of purified wheat-germ RNA polymerase II with poly[d(A-T)] template, Mn2+, U-A dinucleoside monophosphate primer and UTP substrate resulted in catalytic formation of the trinucleoside diphosphate U-A-U, in accordance with the results of previous studies. Both Sarkosyl and heparin inhibited completely and immediately (within less than 1 min) U-A-U synthesis, if either of these compounds was added to the assays during the progress of the reaction. This behaviour is in marked contrast to that reported for single-step addition reactions catalysed by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase on the same template [Sylvester & Cashel (1980) Biochemistry 19, 1069-1074]. However, treatment of the transcription complexes with Sarkosyl or heparin for periods sufficient to abolish U-A-U formation completely did not suppress completely the ability of such complexes to elongate RNA chains. Hence, the effect of Sarkosyl or heparin on the rate of U-A-U synthesis was predominantly due to change in the rate (or in the mechanism) of trinucleotide product release by the transcription complexes. Furthermore, once U-A-U synthesis has begun on the poly[d(A-T)] template, the transcription complexes became resistant to the action of a competitor DNA such as poly[d(G-C)]. The results are consistent with a model where at least a sizeable fraction of the enzyme molecules remains associated with the DNA template upon formation of a single phosphodiester bond.

Potential memory and hysteretic effects in transcription

Kinetic results of RNA-chain elongation catalysed by wheat-germ RNA polymerase II are analysed according to the concept that DNA-dependent conformational transitions of the transcription complex intervene during transcription. A model is presented, involving participation of several forms of the transcription complex with different catalytic properties, generated by the sequence and/or conformation of the DNA template and/or the experimental conditions. The available experimental data suggest that these forms are interconvertible. Examples in which hysteretic transitions might occur are outlined, such as termination of transcription and transition from abortive to productive elongation in the first steps of RNA synthesis. The slow catalytic adaptation of the transcription complex to the template sequence might be a more general phenomenon for enzyme systems acting on polynucleotide templates, in view of the recent proposal that enzyme memory effects may also have some importance in DNA replication and messenger RNA (mRNA) translation.

A slow kinetic transient in RNA synthesis catalysed by wheat-germ RNA polymerase II

Progress curves of U-A-primed RNA synthesis catalysed by wheat-germ RNA polymerase II on a poly[d(A-T)] template exhibit a slow burst of activity. In contrast, the progress curves of single-step addition of UMP to U-A primer in the abortive elongation reaction do not exhibit the slow burst of activity. The correlation between the kinetic transient in the productive pathway of RNA synthesis and the rate of abortive elongation is suggestive of the occurrence of a slow conformational change of the transcription complex during the transition from abortive to productive elongation. The exceptional duration of the transient burst (in the region of 4 min) may suggest a transition of a hysteretic type.

Kinetic co-operativity of wheat-germ RNA polymerase II with adenosine 5'-[beta gamma-imido]triphosphate as substrate

A kinetic study of productive RNA chain elongation indicates that adenosine 5'-[beta gamma-imido]triphosphate can serve as substrate in reactions catalysed by purified wheat-germ RNA polymerase II on a poly[d(A-T)] template. However, in contrast with the results obtained with the natural substrate ATP, the double-reciprocal plots, 1/velocity versus 1/[nucleotide], are not linear but characteristic of apparent negative co-operativity. The extent of the kinetic co-operativity is modified when the reactions are conducted in the additional presence of fixed amounts of an alternative substrate such as ATP or inhibitors such as dATP or cordycepin triphosphate. Analogous results are obtained whether the reactions are carried out in the presence of Mg2+ or Mn2+ as the metal ion cofactor. However, the data show that with Mn2+ the RNA polymerase is less specific in substrate recognition than with Mg2+. Tentative kinetic models are proposed to account for the rate measurements.

Effect of low nucleotide concentrations on abortive elongation catalysed by wheat-germ RNA polymerase II

A kinetic study of the effect of elongating nucleotide concentration on the reactions of abortive elongation catalysed by wheat-germ RNA polymerase II on a poly[d(A-T)] template suggests that the shift from abortive to productive elongation may involve the participation of at least two nucleotides, according to a mechanism very similar to that reported for Escherichia coli RNA polymerase. Experiments performed with non-complementary nucleotides with respect to the DNA template, and with substrate derivatives, allow an analysis of the substrate specificity during these reactions. Similar experiments performed with poly[d(A-A-T)].poly[d(T-T-A)] as template provide a starting point for a better understanding of the effect of DNA sequence on the rates of abortive and productive elongation catalysed by the plant enzyme.

Poly(dAT) dependent trinucleotide synthesis catalysed by wheat germ RNA polymerase II. Effects of nucleotide substrates and cordycepin triphosphate

Kinetics of condensation of ribonucleotides to dinucleotides, leading to trinucleotide products formation, have been studied using wheat germ RNA polymerase II and poly(dAT). Assay conditions can be selected under which both ApUpA and UpApU are formed in catalytic amounts. The kinetic parameters associated with these reactions indicate that the rate of trinucleotide formation might be affected by DNA sequence, as reported for E.coli RNA polymerase. Kinetics of disappearance of ApUpA and UpApU were studied under experimental conditions allowing poly(rAU) synthesis. The results can be interpreted as if after formation of a phosphodiester bond, a slow isomerisation step of the ternary transcription complex could occur. During this step, transcription complexes could dissociate with a finite probability, releasing trinucleotides in an abortive pathway. The above results are discussed in the view that, under these experimental conditions, wheat germ RNA polymerase II catalyses poly(rAU) synthesis, as if it is a non-processive enzyme. Cordycepin triphosphate can be condensed to a dinucleotide primer, yielding ApUpA. However the ATP analogue cannot be incorporated into longer products than a trinucleotide. On the other hand 3'-dATP behaves as a very potent inhibitor of translocation, with an inhibition constant of 0.15 microM, a value which is two orders of magnitude smaller than the Km value corresponding to ATP utilization in poly(rAU) synthesis. Simple models are proposed which allow a comparison with E.coli RNA polymerase, for which the results are well documented.

Enzymatic properties of plant RNA polymerases : An approach to the study of transcription in plants

Results obtained in the past few years in the study of the reaction mechanism of plant RNA polymerases are reviewed and discussed. They suggest that valuable information can be obtained using a highly simplified transcription system composed of purified plant enzymes and cloned genes. This type of approach may provide a starting point for the development of an in vitro transcription system. The detailed study of the fundamental enzymatic properties of the plant RNA polymerases allows a comparison with the well documented corresponding bacterial enzyme.

Complex RNA chain elongation kinetics by wheat germ RNA polymerase II

Kinetics of RNA chain elongation catalyzed by wheat germ RNA polymerase II have been studied using various synthetic DNA templates in the presence of excess dinucleotide monophosphate primers. With single- or double-stranded homopolymer templates, the double reciprocal plots 1/(velocity) as a function of 1/(nucleotide substrate) exhibit positive, negative or no curvature. With poly(dAT) as template, the mechanism of nucleoside monophosphate incorporation into RNA is not the ping-pong kinetic mechanism which was derived for E. coli RNA polymerase (6). Noncomplementary nucleoside triphosphates inhibit RNA transcription allosterically. Cordycepin triphosphate behaves as ATP, and not only inhibits AMP incorporation but also that of UMP and GMP on appropriate templates. The reason for this complex kinetic behavior is not yet understood. Possibilities are raised that there are several nucleoside triphosphate binding sites on wheat germ RNA polymerase II, that additional nucleoside triphosphate dependent enzymatic activities are required for reaction to occur or that the Km value for incorporation of a given nucleoside monophosphate into RNA is dependent on the length of the RNA chain and/or the nucleotide sequence surrounding the complementary base on the DNA template.