Chemical kinetic and proton magnetic resonance studies of 5'-adenosine monophosphate binding to ribonuclease A

Chemical synthesis and enzymatic properties of RNase A analogues designed to enhance second-step catalytic activity

In this paper, we have used total chemical synthesis of RNase A analogues in order to probe the molecular basis of enzyme catalysis. Our goal was to obligately fill the adenine-binding pocket on the enzyme molecule, and to thus pre-orient the imidazole side chain of His¹¹⁹ in its catalytically productive orientation. Two designed analogues of the RNase A protein molecule that contained an adenine moiety covalently bound to distinct amino acid side chains adjacent to the adenine binding pocket were prepared. A crystal structure of one analogue was determined at 2.3 Å resolution. Kinetic data for RNA transphosporylation and 2',3' cyclic mononucleotide hydrolysis were acquired for the adenine-containing RNase A analogue proteins. As anticipated, the presence of a covalently attached adenine on the enzyme molecule decreased the rate of transphosphorylation and increased the rate of hydrolysis, although the magnitude of the effects was small. This work illustrates the use of total protein synthesis to investigate the chemistry of enzyme catalysis in ways not possible through traditional biochemistry or molecular biology.

His ... Asp catalytic dyad of ribonuclease A: histidine pKa values in the wild-type, D121N, and D121A enzymes

Bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A) has a conserved His ... Asp catalytic dyad in its active site. Structural analyses had indicated that Asp121 forms a hydrogen bond with His119, which serves as an acid during catalysis of RNA cleavage. The enzyme contains three other histidine residues including His12, which is also in the active site. Here, 1H-NMR spectra of wild-type RNase A and the D121N and D121A variants were analyzed thoroughly as a function of pH. The effect of replacing Asp121 on the microscopic pKa values of the histidine residues is modest: none change by more than 0.2 units. There is no evidence for the formation of a low-barrier hydrogen bond between His119 and either an aspartate or an asparagine residue at position 121. In the presence of the reaction product, uridine 3'-phosphate (3'-UMP), protonation of one active-site histidine residue favors protonation of the other. This finding is consistent with the phosphoryl group of 3'-UMP interacting more strongly with the two active-site histidine residues when both are protonated. Comparison of the titration curves of the unliganded enzyme with that obtained in the presence of different concentrations of 3'-UMP shows that a second molecule of 3'-UMP can bind to the enzyme. Together, the data indicate that the aspartate residue in the His ... Asp catalytic dyad of RNase A has a measurable but modest effect on the ionization of the adjacent histidine residue.

The subsites structure of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A accounts for the abnormal kinetic behavior with cytidine 2',3'-cyclic phosphate

The kinetics of the hydrolysis of cytidine 2',3'-cyclic phosphate (C>p) to 3'-CMP by ribonuclease A are multiphasic at high substrate concentrations. We have investigated these kinetics by determining 3'-CMP formation both spectrophotometrically and by a highly specific and quantitative chemical sampling method. With the use of RNase A derivatives that lack a functional p2 binding subsite, evidence is presented that the abnormal kinetics with the native enzyme are caused by the sequential binding of the substrate to the several subsites that make up the active site of ribonuclease. The evidence is based on the following points. 1) Some of the unusual features found with native RNase A and C>p as substrate disappear when the derivatives lacking a functional p2 binding subsite are used. 2) The kcat/Km values with oligocytidylic acids of increasing lengths (ending in C>p) show a behavior that parallels the specific velocity with C>p at high concentrations: increase in going from the monomer to the trimer, a decrease from tetramer to hexamer, and then an increase in going to poly(C). 3) Adenosine increases the kcat obtained with a fixed concentration of C>p as substrate. 4) High concentrations of C>p protect the enzyme from digestion with subtilisin, which results in a more compact molecule, implying large substrate concentration-induced conformational changes. The data for the hydrolysis of C>p by RNase A can be fitted to a fifth order polynomial that has been derived from a kinetic scheme based on the sequential binding of several monomeric substrate molecules.

Bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A as a model of an enzyme with multiple substrate binding sites

Bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A is an enzyme that catalyses the depolymerization of RNA. This process involves the interaction of the enzyme with the polymeric substrate in the active site and its correct alignment on the surface of the enzyme through multiple binding subsites that essentially recognize the negatively charged phosphate groups of the substrate. The enzyme shows a strong specificity for pyrimidine bases at the 3'-position of the phosphodiester bond that is cleaved and a preference for purine bases at the 5'-position and, probably, for guanine at the next position. On the other hand, the enzyme shows a clear preference for polynucleotide substrates over oligonucleotides. In this review the contributions to the catalytic mechanism of some amino-acid residues that are located at non catalytic binding subsites are analysed.

1H-n.m.r. studies on the existence of substrate binding sites in bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A

The reaction of ribonuclease A with either 6-chloropurine riboside 5'-monophosphate or the corresponding nucleoside yields one derivative, with the reagent covalently bound to the alpha-amino group of Lys-1, called derivative II and derivative E, respectively. We studied by means of 1H-n.m.r. at 270 MHz the interaction of these derivatives with different purine ligands. The pK values of His-12- and -119 were obtained and compared with those resulting from the interaction with ribonuclease A. The results showed that the interaction of derivative E with 3'AMP is similar to that described for RNase A as the pK2 of His-12 is increased while that of His-119 remains unaltered. However, derivative II presents some differences as it was found an enhancement of the pK2 values of both His-12 and His-119. Interaction of derivative II and derivative E with dApdA increases the pK2 of His-119, whereas a decrease is found when it interacts with ribonuclease A. These results suggest that the phosphate group and the nucleoside of both derivatives are located in regions of the enzyme where natural substrate analogues have secondary interactions and they can be interpreted as additional binding sites.

Nucleotide binding and affinity labelling support the existence of the phosphate-binding subsite p2 in bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A

When the reaction of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A with 6-chloropurine riboside 5'-monophosphate was carried out in the presence of several natural mononucleotides, a decrease of 25-75% was found in the amount of the reaction product derivative II (the main product of the reaction which has the nucleotide label at the alpha-NH2 group of Lys-1). The efficiency of inhibition followed the order 3'-AMP greater than 5'CMP approximately equal to 5'AMP greater than 3'CMP. Previous studies indicate that this order reflects the extent of occupancy of p2, a phosphate-binding subsite adjacent to the catalytic centre. This finding suggests that derivative II is the result of affinity labelling and that the phosphate group of the halogenated nucleotide binds to p2 before the reaction takes place. The dissociation constants and stoichiometry of the interaction between native enzyme, derivative II and derivative E (homologous to derivative II, but labelled with a nucleoside instead of a nucleotide) with 3'AMP and 5'AMP at several pH values were also determined. Although in general one strong binding site was found, no strong binding occurs between 3'AMP and derivative II. It is concluded that the phosphate of the label occupies the same site p2, as the phosphate of 3'AMP. Finally, the pH dependence for the binding of 3'AMP and 5'AMP to RNAase A indicates that they bind to different protein groups. The results presented support the structure of the active site of ribonuclease A postulated previously (Parés, X., Llorens, R., Arús, C. and Cuchillo, C.M. (1980) Eur. J. Biochem. 105, 571-579).

15N- and 1H-NMR investigations of the active-site amino acids in semisynthetic RNase S' and RNase A

Extensive 15N-NMR investigations of active-site amino acids were made possible by the solid-phase synthesis of the N-terminal pentadecapeptide of RNase A with selectively 15N-enriched amino acids. On complexation with S-protein a fully active RNase S' complex was obtained. The 15N resonances of the side chains of lysine-7 (N epsilon), glutamine-11 (N gamma), and histidine-12 (N pi, tau) were studied in the free synthetic peptide, in the RNase S' complex and in the nucleotide complexes RNase S' with 2'CMP, 3'CMP, and 5'AMP. The analysis of the 15N-1H couplings, the 15N line broadenings due to proton exchange, and the chemical shift values showed that, while the imidazole ring is directly involved in the peptide-protein interaction, the side chains of Lys-7 and Gln-11 do not contribute to this interaction. In the nucleotide complexes the resonances of His-12 and Gln-11 are shifted downfield. In the 2'CMP complex a doublet for the N tau signal of His-12 indicates a stable H bond between this nitrogen and the phosphate group of nucleotide. The other nucleotide influence the resonances of the imidazole group much less, possibly due to a slightly different orientation of the phosphate group. The downfield shift of the Gln-11 resonance indicates an interaction between the carbonyl oxygen of the amide group and the phosphate moiety of the nucleotide. The only observable effect of nucleotide complexation on the Lys-7 signal is line broadening due to reduced proton exchange. For comparison with the 15N-NMR titration curves of His-12 in RNase S' the 1H-NMR titration curves of RNase A were also recorded. Both shape and pK values were very similar for the 15N and the 1H titration curves. An extensive analysis of the protonation equilibria with several fitting models showed that a mutual interaction of the imidazole groups of the active-site histidines results in flat titration curves. The Hill plots of all resonances of the imidazole rings, including the 15N resonances, show a small inflection in the pH range 5.8-6.4. Since the existence of a diimidazole system is most likely in this pH range, the inflection could be interpreted as a disturbance of the mutual electrostatic interaction of the active-site histidines by a partial H-bond formation between the imidazole groups.

Nuclear magnetic resonance and neutron diffraction studies of the complex of ribonuclease A with uridine vanadate, a transition-state analogue

The complex of ribonuclease A (RNase A) with uridine vanadate (U-V), a transition-state analogue, has been studied with 51V and proton NMR spectroscopy in solution and by neutron diffraction in the crystalline state. Upon the addition of aliquots of U-V at pH 6.6, the C epsilon-H resonances of the two active-site histidine residues 119 and 12 decrease in intensity while four new resonances appear. Above pH 8 and below pH 5, these four resonances decrease in intensity as the complex dissociates. These four resonances are assigned to His-119 and His-12 in protonated and unprotonated forms in the RNase-U-V complex. These resonances do not titrate or change in relative area in the pH range 5-8, indicating a slow protonation process, and the extent of protonation remains constant with ca. 58% of His-12 and ca. 26% of His-119 being protonated. The results of diffraction studies show that both His-12 and His-119 occupy well-defined positions in the RNase-U-V complex and that both are protonated. However, while the classic interpretation of the mechanism of action of RNase based on the proposal of Findlay et al. [Findlay, D., Herries, D. G., Mathias, A. P., Rabin, B. R., & Ross, C. A. (1962) Biochem. J. 85, 152-153] requires both His-12 and His-119 to be in axial positions relative to the pentacoordinate transition state, in the diffraction structure His-12 is found to be in an equatorial position, while Lys-41 is close to an axial position. Hydrogen exchange data show that the mobility and accessibility of amides in the RNase-U-V complex do not significantly differ from what was observed in the native enzyme. The results of both proton NMR in solution and neutron diffraction in the crystal are compared and interpreted in terms of the mechanism of action of RNase.

The properties of the interaction between bovine pancreatic ribonuclease a and mononucleotides supports the existence of several binding sub-sites in the enzyme

The binding of 5'AMP, 5'GMP, 5'CMP, 3'CMP and Cl6RMP to RNAase A was studied by means of the gel filtration technique. It was found that only one molecule of 3'CMP binds strongly to the enzyme although a very unspecific binding is also present. The interaction of 5'AMP and 5'GMP with the enzyme shows one strong binding site and several weak binding sites, whereas two molecules of 5'CMP bind to RNAase A with equal strength. Cl6RMP shows an anomalous behaviour as both split peaks and troughs are found in the chromatogram. The Ka values for 3'CMP and the strong binding site of 5'AMP and 5'GMP are very similar whereas that for the two binding sites of 5'CMP is smaller (about 2.2 X 10(-4)M-1 and 0.5 X 10(-4)M-1, respectively at pH 5.5, I = 0.01 and 25 degrees C). The results are in general agreement with the known multiplicity of ligand-binding subsites in RNAase A.

Affinity chromatography study of the interaction of ribonucleotides with bovine pancreatic ribonuclease covalently bound to Sepharose 4B

The preparation of immobilized bovine pancreatic ribonuclease by covalent attachment to Sepharose 4B, with and without a spacer arm, is described. The coupling reaction was carried out at two different pH values, 8.5 and 10.5, and the different kinetic properties shown by the resulting preparations probably reflect the influence of the particular amino acid side-chains involved in the covalent coupling of the enzyme to the insoluble matrix. The strength of binding of mononucleotides, at 4 degrees C, as deduced from the salt concentration at which they are eluted from an immobilized RNAase column, follows the order 5'-GMP greater than 5'-AMP greater than 3'-UMP greater than 3'-CMP. When binary mixtures of a 3'-pyrimidine nucleotide and a 5'-purine nucleotide are chromatographed jointly, a co-operative effect is found and the elution of either or both ligands is retarded. This behaviour can be explained in terms of the preferential binding of each kind of nucleotide to different sub-sites in the enzyme. The stoichiometry and association constant for 3'-CMP and 5'-AMP at pH 7.0 were also determined.

Comparative proton NMR studies of bovine semen and pancreas ribonucleases

The fine structure of bovine semen RNAase was studied with proton NMR spectroscopy making use of the four-protein system constituted by dimeric bovine semen RNAase, its catalytically active monomeric bis-(S-carboxymethyl-31,32) derivative, the naturally monomeric RNAase A from the pancrease of the same species, and dimerized RNAase A. Only four histidine C-2 H resonances were observed in the aromatic spectrum of bovine semen RNAase, which belong to the four histidine residues present in the sequence of bovine semen RNAase subunits at positions identical with those of the histidines of RNAase A. This is indicative of identical environments for the individual histidine residues in both subunits. These resonances were assigned (i) by comparing their titration curves with the corresponding curves obtained with RNAase A and with monomeric bovine semen RNAase and (ii) by evaluating the effects on their titration curves of nucleotide binding. Very similar NMR parameters were measured for His-105 and also for His-119 of seminal and pancreatic RNAase, while His-12 was found to have different environments in the two proteins. The distinctive NMR features of His-48 in bovine semen RNAase confirmed the role of the hinge regions of the subunits in maintaining the dimeric structure of the protein. While monomerization of the seminal enzyme reduced the differences between the histidine C-2 H resonances of RNAase A and bovine semen RNAase, dimerization of RNAase A did not affect the NMR spectrum of this protein, thus indicating as unlikely the possibility that the quaternary structure of bovine semen RNAase resembles that of dimerized RNAase A.

1H-NMR studies on the binding subsites of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A

The titration curves of the C-2 histidine protons of an RNAase derivative (a covalent derivative obtained by reaction of bovine pancreatic RNAase A (EC 3.1.27.5) with 6-chloropurine 9-beta-D-ribofuranosyl 5'-monophosphate) were studied by means of 1H-NMR spectroscopy at 270 MHz. The interaction of natural (5'AMP, 5'GMP, 5'IMP) and halogenated purine mononucleotides (cl6RMP, br8AMP) with RNAase A was also monitored by using the same technique. The slight change observed in the pK values of the active centre histidine residues of the RNAase derivative, with respect to those in the native enzyme, can be considered as evidence that the phosphate of the label does not interact directly either with His-12 or 119 in the p1 site, but the p2 site as proposed previously (Parés, X., Llorens, R., Arús, C. and Cuchillo, C.M. (1980) Eur. J. Biochem. 105, 571--579). Lys-7 and/or Arg-10 are proposed as part of the p2 phosphate-binding subsite. The pK values of His-12 and 119 and the shift of an aromatic resonance of the native enzyme found on interaction with some purine nucleotides, can be interpreted by postulating that the interaction of 5'AMP, 5'GMP and 5'IMP takes place not only in the so-called purine-binding site B2R2p1 but also in the primary pyrimidine-binding site B1R1 and p0 of RNAase A.

The reaction of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A with 6-chloropurineriboside 5'-monophosphate. Evidence on the existence of a phosphate-binding sub-site

The chemical modification of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A by 6-chloropurine 9-beta-D-ribofuranosyl 5'-monophosphate was studied under several reaction conditions. The reaction, at pH 7.3, 40 degrees C and a nucleotide: enzyme molar ratio of 60, showed a high degree of specificity in comparison to those corresponding to the base or the nucleoside. The main derivative was isolated by means of CM-cellulose chromatography. Subtilisin cleavage of this derivative showed that the substitution had taken place in the S-peptide moiety. Tryptic digestion of the S-peptide indicated that a lysine residue had been modified. Enzymatic and physico-chemical considerations showed that the actual site of reaction was the alpha-amino group of Lys-1. The structural and kinetic properties of the derivative are consistent with the existence of a phosphate-binding sub-site near the N-terminal region of the enzyme.

The specificity of the interaction of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A with natural and halogenated purine nucleotides

The interaction between bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (EC 3.1.4.22) and the purine nucleotides AMP, GMP, 6-chloropurine 5'-ribonucleotide and 8-bromoadenosine 5'-monophosphate was studied by u.v. difference spectroscopy. The stoicheiometry of the binding of the halogenated nucleotides to the enzyme shows a 1:1 ratio, as for the natural ones. The binding constants, Ka, for all four nucleotides at pH 5.5 were determined. They are within the same order of magnitude, though the nucleotides with a 6-amino group show a stronger interaction. The magnitude of the binding shows a reciprocal dependence on the ionic strength, which indicates an electrostatic interaction between ligand and enzyme. Finally, solvent-perturbation experiments show that all four nucleotides bind to the enzyme in a partially hydrophobic region. It is concluded that both halogenated and natural purine ribonucleotides interact in a similar manner with the enzyme molecule. The special synthesis and identification of 6-chloropurine 5'-ribonucleotide are discussed extensively. It is concluded that both halogenated and natural purine ribonucleotides interact in a similar manner with the enzyme molecule and thus the halogenated analogues are potential reagents for the affinity labelling of the purine-binding site.

1H NMR studies of the binding of EDTA to bovine pancreatic ribonuclease

EDTA binds at the active site of ribonuclease causing a selective downfield shift of the C2 proton resonance of His 12 at pH 5.5 (pH denotes an uncorrected glass electrode pH meter reading of a 2H2O solution). A dissociation constant for EDTA binding to ribonuclease of 1.70 mM was calculated from this chemical shift change. The pKa of His 12 increased from 5.79 in ribonuclease alone to 6.73 in the RNAase . EDTA complex. Compared to these effects, the other histidine residues were not significantly affected by EDTA. EDTA was shown to act as a competitive inhibitor of cytidine 2',3'-cyclic phosphate hydrolysis by ribonuclease with a Ki of 1.37 mM at pH 5.5, 25 degrees C. Molecular model building suggests that three of the four carboxyl groups of EDTA could simultaneously interact with histidine 12, lysine 41 and lysine 7. A complex of this type would account for the data described herein.

The role of lysine-41 in ribonuclease A studied by proton-magnetic-resonance spectroscopy of guanidinated ribonuclease A

Ribonuclease A has been guanidinated at the lysine residues and the nona-guanidinated and deca-guanidinated (fully substituted) products separated. In confirmation of an earlier report by Glick and Barnard (1970), it has been shown by chemical procedures that the former derivative is not reacted at lysine-41. Guanidination of lysine-41 to produce the fully substituted product causes loss of enzymic activity without any apparent change of conformation, as tested by conformational comparisons (using proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy) including (a) difference spectroscopy, evidence for the involvement of lysine-41 in a catalytic role in the enzyme. Dimethylation of lysine-41 of nona-guanidinated ribonuclease A produces sharp proton resonances which shifts as the dimethylamino group is titrated and allow the determination of an apparent pK of 8.8 for unsubstituted lysine-41.

Proton-magnetic-resonance studies of the lysine residues of ribonuclease A

The amino groups of ribonuclease A (RNase-A) have been methylated with formaldehyde and borohydride to provide observable resonances for proton magnetic resonance (PMR) studies. Although enzymatic activity is lost, PMR difference spectroscopy and PMR studies of thermal denaturation show native conformation is largely preserved in methylated RNase-A. Resonances corresponding to the NH2-terminal alpha-amino and 10 xi-amino N-methyl groups are titrated at 220 MHz to obtain pK values. After correction for the effects of methylation, using values previously derived from model compound studies, a pK of 6.6 is found for the alpha-amino group, a pK of 8.6 for the xi-amino group of lysine-41 and pK values ranging from 10.6 to 11.2 for the other lysine xi-amino groups. Interactions between lysine-7 and lysine-41 or between the alpha-amino and xi-amino groups of lysine-1 have been proposed to account for deviations from simple titration behaviour. The correct continuities for the titration curves of the histidine H-2 proton resonances have been confirmed by selective deuteration of the H-2 protons. Titration curves for the H-2 proton resonances of histidine-12 and histidine-119 of methylated RNase-A show deviations from the titration curves for the native enzyme, indicating some alteration of the active-site conformation. In the presence of phosphate, titration curves for the H-2 proton resonances of histidine-12 and histidine-119 of methylated RNase-A indicate binding of phosphate at the active site, but these curves continue to show deviations from the titration behaviour of native RNase-A. The titration curve for the N-methyl resonance of lysine-41 is perturbed considerably by the presence of phosphate, which indicates a possible catalytic role for lysine-41.