Energy-linked reactions in photosynthetic bacteria. 3. Further studies on energy-linked nicotinamide-adenine dinucleotide reduction by Rhodospirillum rubrum chromatophores

Recollections

About 1939, Sam Ruben and Martin Kamen introduced me to the emergent application of artificial radio-isotopes in the study of photosynthesis. While my own experiments on CO2 fixation by isolated chloroplasts turned out to be negative, their laboratory provided me with an informative and exciting experience. Also, there were many stimulating contacts with Cornelis van Niel, Robert Emerson, Don DeVault and many other outstanding scientists. Efforts on my part to obtain a better understanding of intermediary metabolism, eventually led me to Fritz Lipmann's laboratory. There I was encouraged to study the metabolic activities of cell-free preparations of photosynthetic purple bacteria. Investigations of oxidative phosphorylation by isolated bacterial chromatophores in the dark raised questions about the possible effects of light on the phosphorylation activities of such preparations. Surprisingly, high rates of phosphorylation were observed in the light in the absence of molecular oxygen ('light-induced phosphorylation'). In this process, adenosine diphosphate (ADP) and inorganic phosphate (Pi) could be converted quantitatively into adenosine triphosphate (ATP). It was postulated that this process was 'cyclic' in nature, as only catalytic concentrations of added electron donors were required. Later, at Minnesota, it could be shown that similar chromatophore preparations, in the presence of suitable electron donors, could reduce nicotinamide-adenine dinucleotide (NAD(+)) to NADH in the light. It was then demonstrated that the chromatophores of Rhodospirilum rubrum, as well as the smaller membrane components derived from them, must contain the active metabolic components for these photosynthetic reactions.These observations, and studies on the kinetics of the formation and decay of light-induced free radicals, appeared to demonstrate the usefulness of bacterial chromatophores and of their membrane fragments in the study of partial reactions of bacterial photosynthesis. Since that time, numerous investigators elsewhere have carried out remarkable research on the purification and eventual crystallization of distinct bacterial membrane components, capable of carrying out well characterized photochemical and electron transport reactions.

Studies on the effect of NAD(H) on nitrogenase activity in Rhodospirillum rubrum

The effect of NAD(P) and analogs of this nucleotide on nitrogenase activity in Rhodospirillum rubrum has been studied. Addition of NAD+ to nitrogen fixing Rsp. rubrum leads to inhibition of nitrogenase. NADP+ has the same effect but NADH or analogs modified in the nicotinamide portion do not cause inhibition. In contrast to ammonium ions, addition of NAD+ leads to inhibition of nitrogenase in cells that have been N-starved under argon. The inhibitory effect of NAD+ is more pronounced at lower light intensities. Addition of NAD+ also leads to inhibition of glutamine synthetase, a phenomenon also occurring when "switch-off" is produced by the addition of effectors such as ammonium ions or glutamine. It is also shown that NAD+ is taken up by Rsp. rubrum cells.

delta pH driven energy-linked NAD+ reduction in Rhodospirillum rubrum chromatophores

An artificial proton gradient provided sufficient energy to drive reverse electron transport from succinate to NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase in chromatophores isolated from Rhodospirillum rubrum. The pH gradient created was able to reduce NAD+. In chromatophores, the optimal rate of NAD+ reduction was about 0.4-0.45 mumol NADH formed/min.mumol bacteriochlorophyll at delta pH 3. The presence of oligomycin was an obligate factor in the assay in order to observe the maximal rate of NAD+ reduction. The rate of NADH formation was dependent on the size of the induced pH gradient. The total NADH formed had a threshold value for the imposed delta pH. The effect of different inhibitors and uncouplers was demonstrated. Comparison between ATP, PPi, and light with the pH jump driven NAD+ reduction rate was studied.

Photoinactivation of photophosphorylation and dark ATPase in Rhodospirillum rubrum chromatophores

Preillumination of Rhodospirillum rubrum chromatophores with strong, far-red light in the presence of phenazine methosulfate under non-phosphorylation conditions results in a selective, irreversible inactivation (typically about 70%) of photophosphorylation and of uncoupler-stimulated dark ATPase. The time course of the photoinactivation is similar to the light-on kinetics of the light-induced proton uptake in the absence of ADP. Only little photoinactivation occurs when the uncoupler carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenyl hydrazone is present or when phenazine methosulfate is absent during the preillumination, indicating that the reaction occurs only when the membrane is energized. Phosphorylation conditions offer a practically complete protection against the photoinactivation. Inorganic phosphate, Mg2+ or ADP do not provide a significant protection against the photoinactivation, nor does ATP. The pH-dependence of the reaction(s) leading to photoinactivation may indicate that a partial reaction of the photophosphorylation process (perhaps only a conformational change of the coupling factor) precedes the photoinactivation.

A possible physiological function of the oxygen-photoreducing system of Rhodospirillum rubrum

Anaerobic suspensions of Rhodospirillum rubrum cells which had been grown in the dark under low oxygen tension showed only a small increase of their ATP content when illuminated for 30 s. The same suspensions failed to start immediate growth in the light. Both high light-induced ATP levels and immediate phototrophic growth were elicited by small amounts of oxygen which were insufficient by themselves to raise the ATP levels or to support growth in the dark. The oxygen requirement for growth disappeared after some time of anaerobic illumination and was not observed in suspensions of cells which had been grown in the light under anaerobiosis. Furthermore, these phototrophic cells reached the maximum levels of ATP when illuminated in the absence of oxygen. Strain F11, a mutant derivative of Rhodospirillum rubrum which lacked the ability to photoreduce oxygen in vitro, needed abnormally high amounts of oxygen to increase its ATP levels and to grow in the light. Besides, KCN inhibited the increase of ATP levels in illuminated mutant cells but not in wild type cells. An additional difference between both strains was that the oxygen requirement for growth did not disappear in the mutant after some time of anaerobic incubation in the light. To explain these observations, it is proposed that the photosynthetic system of semiaerobically-grown Rhodospirillum rubrum becomes overreduced under anaerobiosis. The oxygen-photoreducing system, which is impaired in the mutant is apparently used to oxidize the photosynthetic system to its optimal redox state, carrying electrons to oxygen or to other endogenous acceptors which are formed during incubation in the light. The mutant seems to replace the defective system by a cyanide-sensitive pathway which may reduce oxygen but not the alternative endogenous acceptors.