Endothelin receptor in virus-like particles: ligand binding observed by fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy

Advances in the application of fluorescence correlation spectroscopy to study detergent purified and encapsulated membrane proteins

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) is a quantitative spectroscopy technique which could potentially increase throughput and sensitivity of screening for ligand, substrate and inhibitor binding to membrane proteins in solution. However, the purification of membrane proteins in their active forms is complex, as the lipid bilayer provides stability and its removal often causes the protein to become conformationally unstable. This has limited the application of biophysical techniques such as FCS to study the function of membrane proteins. The recent application of native extraction techniques such as styrene maleic acid lipid particles (SMALPs) has resolved this issue and FCS has emerged as a powerful option for studying proteins extracted in this way. This review will discuss the application of FCS to study purified membrane proteins in detergent micelles, nanodiscs and SMALPs and its potential to be used routinely in membrane protein drug discovery.

Budded baculoviruses as a receptor display system to quantify ligand binding with TIRF microscopy

Studying mechanisms of receptor-ligand interactions has remained challenging due to several limitations of different measurement methods. Here we present a total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy-based method that maintains the right balance between retaining the receptors in the natural lipid environment, sufficient throughput for ligand screening, high sensitivity, and offering more detailed view into the ligand-binding process. The novel method combines G protein-coupled receptor display in budded baculovirus particles and the immobilization of the particles to a functionalized coverslip. We adapted and validated the functionalized coverslip preparation process to achieve selective immobilization of budded baculovirus particles. The selectivity of budded baculovirus immobilization was validated with budded baculovirus particles displaying either Frizzled 6 receptors labeled with mCherry or neuropeptide Y Y1 receptors. To scale the system for ligand binding assays, we developed both open-source multiwell systems and image analysis software SPOTNIC for flexible assay design. The neuropeptide Y Y1 receptor was used for further receptor-ligand binding studies with high-affinity TAMRA labeled fluorescent ligand UR-MC026. The affinities of the fluorescent ligand and four unlabeled ligands (BIBO3304, UR-MK299, PYY, pNPY) were obtained with the developed method and followed a similar trend with both the parallel measurements with fluorescence anisotropy method and the data published earlier. The novel method could be extended for various advanced assays utilizing multidimensional detection modes, integrating super-resolution methods for single molecule detection and microfluidic devices for kinetic measurements.

Modeling craniofacial development reveals spatiotemporal constraints on robust patterning of the mandibular arch

How does pattern formation occur accurately when confronted with tissue growth and stochastic fluctuations (noise) in gene expression? Dorso-ventral (D-V) patterning of the mandibular arch specifies upper versus lower jaw skeletal elements through a combination of Bone morphogenetic protein (Bmp), Endothelin-1 (Edn1), and Notch signaling, and this system is highly robust. We combine NanoString experiments of early D-V gene expression with live imaging of arch development in zebrafish to construct a computational model of the D-V mandibular patterning network. The model recapitulates published genetic perturbations in arch development. Patterning is most sensitive to changes in Bmp signaling, and the temporal order of gene expression modulates the response of the patterning network to noise. Thus, our integrated systems biology approach reveals non-intuitive features of the complex signaling system crucial for craniofacial development, including novel insights into roles of gene expression timing and stochasticity in signaling and gene regulation.

Biomimetic Chemical Sensing by Fluorescence Signals Using a Virus-like Particle-Based Platform

The chemical receptors present in living organisms are promising tools for developing biomimetic chemical sensors. However, these receptors require lipid membranes for functioning under physiological conditions, which prevents their utilization in the production of cell-free in vitro chemical sensing systems. Here, we report the development of a cell-free biomimetic sensing platform using virus-like particles (VLPs) with intact ligand-gated Ca²⁺ channels and genetically encoded Ca²⁺ indicator (GECI). We observed that targeting GECI to the plasma membrane was essential for efficient loading GECI in the VLPs. Although the physiological Ca²⁺ concentration [Ca²⁺] maintained in the cells was low (∼10 nM), the concentration in the VLPs was high. This prevented the detection of the increase in [Ca²⁺] caused by binding of the ligand to the receptor. To address this problem, we employed Lyn-R-CEPIA1, which had low affinity for Ca²⁺, and a membrane targeting sequence. Thus, we succeeded in monitoring the activation of cyclic nucleotide-gated channels (CNG) on the VLPs by measuring the increase in fluorescence of Lyn-R-CEPIA1. Our VLP-based sensing system can act as a fundamental platform for all kinds of ligand-gated channels.

Studying GPCR Pharmacology in Membrane Microdomains: Fluorescence Correlation Spectroscopy Comes of Age

G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) are organised within the cell membrane into highly ordered macromolecular complexes along with other receptors and signalling proteins. Understanding how heterogeneity in these complexes affects the pharmacology and functional response of these receptors is crucial for developing new and more selective ligands. Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) and related techniques such as photon counting histogram (PCH) analysis and image-based FCS can be used to interrogate the properties of GPCRs in these membrane microdomains, as well as their interaction with fluorescent ligands. FCS analyses fluorescence fluctuations within a small-defined excitation volume to yield information about their movement, concentration and molecular brightness (aggregation). These techniques can be used on live cells with single-molecule sensitivity and high spatial resolution. Once the preserve of specialist equipment, FCS techniques can now be applied using standard confocal microscopes. This review describes how FCS and related techniques have revealed novel insights into GPCR biology.

Fluorescent approaches for understanding interactions of ligands with G protein coupled receptors

G protein coupled receptors are responsible for a wide variety of signaling responses in diverse cell types. Despite major advances in the determination of structures of this class of receptors, the underlying mechanisms by which binding of different types of ligands specifically elicits particular signaling responses remain unclear. The use of fluorescence spectroscopy can provide important information about the process of ligand binding and ligand dependent conformational changes in receptors, especially kinetic aspects of these processes that can be difficult to extract from X-ray structures. We present an overview of the extensive array of fluorescent ligands that have been used in studies of G protein coupled receptors and describe spectroscopic approaches for assaying binding and probing the environment of receptor-bound ligands with particular attention to examples involving yeast pheromone receptors. In addition, we discuss the use of fluorescence spectroscopy for detecting and characterizing conformational changes in receptors induced by the binding of ligands. Such studies have provided strong evidence for diversity of receptor conformations elicited by different ligands, consistent with the idea that GPCRs are not simple on and off switches. This diversity of states constitutes an underlying mechanistic basis for biased agonism, the observation that different stimuli can produce different responses from a single receptor. It is likely that continued technical advances will allow fluorescence spectroscopy to play an important role in continued probing of structural transitions in G protein coupled receptors. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Structural and biophysical characterisation of membrane protein-ligand binding.

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy in drug discovery: study of Alexa532-endothelin 1 binding to the endothelin ETA receptor to describe the pharmacological profile of natural products

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy and the newly synthesized Alexa532-ET1 were used to study the dynamics of the endothelin ET_A receptor-ligand complex alone and under the influence of a semisynthetic selective antagonist and a fungal extract on living A10 cells. Dose-dependent increase of inositol phosphate production was seen for Alexa532-ET1, and its binding was reduced to 8% by the selective endothelin ET_A antagonist BQ-123, confirming the specific binding of Alexa532-ET1 to the endothelin ET_A receptor. Two different lateral mobilities of the receptor-ligand complexes within the cell membrane were found allowing the discrimination of different states for this complex. BQ-123 showed a strong binding affinity to the “inactive” receptor state characterized by the slow diffusion time constant. A similar effect was observed for the fungal extract, which completely displaced Alexa532-ET1 from its binding to the “inactive” receptor state. These findings suggest that both BQ-123 and the fungal extract act as inverse agonists.

Stimuli of sensory-motor nerves terminate arterial contractile effects of endothelin-1 by CGRP and dissociation of ET-1/ET(A)-receptor complexes

Background

Endothelin-1 (ET-1), a long-acting paracrine mediator, is implicated in cardiovascular diseases but clinical trials with ET-receptor antagonists were not successful in some areas. We tested whether the quasi-irreversible receptor-binding of ET-1 (i) limits reversing effects of the antagonists and (ii) can be selectively dissociated by an endogenous counterbalancing mechanism.

Methodology/Principal findings

In isolated rat mesenteric resistance arteries, ET_A-antagonists, endothelium-derived relaxing factors and synthetic vasodilators transiently reduced contractile effects of ET-1 but did not prevent persistent effects of the peptide. Stimuli of peri-vascular vasodilator sensory-motor nerves such as capsaicin not only reduced but also terminated long-lasting effects of ET-1. This was prevented by CGRP-receptor antagonists and was mimicked by exogenous calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP). Using 2-photon laser scanning microscopy in vital intact arteries, capsaicin and CGRP, but not ET_A-antagonism, were observed to promote dissociation of pre-existing ET-1/ET_A-receptor complexes.

Conclusions

Irreversible binding and activation of ET_A-receptors by ET-1 (i) occur at an antagonist-insensitive site of the receptor and (ii) are selectively terminated by endogenously released CGRP. Hence, natural stimuli of sensory-motor nerves that stimulate release of endogenous CGRP can be considered for therapy of diseases involving ET-1.

Zwitterionic biocompatible quantum dots for wide pH stability and weak nonspecific binding to cells

Applications of water-soluble quantum dots (QDs) in the life sciences are limited by their poor colloidal stability in physiological media and nonspecific interaction with biomatter, particularly cell membranes. We have studied colloidal stability and nonspecific interactions with living cells for zwitterionic d-penicillamine-coated QDs (DPA-QDs) and the traditionally used carboxylated 11-mercaptoundecanoic acid-coated QDs (MUA-QDs) and found clear advantages of DPA-QDs. In single molecule fluorescence experiments, DPA-QDs showed no aggregation over the physiologically relevant pH range of 5-9, whereas MUA-QDs showed significant aggregation below pH 9. Upon exposure to living Mono Mac 6 cells, DPA-QDs, which possess overall charge-neutral surfaces, exhibited weak interactions with the cell membrane and were easily removed by flushing with buffer. By contrast, the highly charged MUA-QDs strongly associated with the cells and could not be removed even by extensive rinsing with buffer solution. DPA-QDs exhibit a high chemical stability even in strongly oxidizing conditions, in contrast to cysteine-coated QDs reported earlier. This beneficial property may arise from reduced interactions between DPA ligands due to steric effects of the methyl groups on their beta-carbon atoms.

Characterizing stability properties of supported bilayer membranes on nanoglassified substrates using surface plasmon resonance

Supported bilayer membranes (SBMs) formed on solid substrates, in particular glass, provide an ideal cell mimicking model system that has been found to be highly useful for biosensing applications. Although the stability of the membrane structures is known to determine the applicability, the subject has not been extensively investigated, largely because of the lack of convenient methods to monitor changes of membrane properties on glass in real time. This work reports the evaluation of the stability properties of a series of SBMs against chemical and air damage by use of surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy and nanoglassified gold substrates. Seven SBMs composed of phosphatidylcholine and DOPC+, including single-component, mixed, protein-reinforced SBMs (rSBMs) and protein-tethered bilayer membranes (ptBLMs), are studied. The stability properties under various conditions, especially the effects of surfactants, organic solvents, and dehydration damage on the bilayers, are compared. PC membranes are found to be easily removed from the glassy surfaces using relatively low concentrations of the surfactants, while DOPC+ is markedly more stable toward nonionic surfactant. DOPC+ membranes also demonstrated remarkable air stability while PC films exhibited considerable damage from dehydration. Doping of cholesterol does not improve PC's stability against SDS and Triton but changes the lipid membrane packing enough to protect against dehydration damage. Although rSBMs and ptBLMs improve air stability to a certain degree, they are still quite susceptible to significant damage/removal from ionic and nonionic surfactants at lower concentrations. Overall, DOPC+ has noted higher stability on glass, likely due to the favorable electrostatic interaction between the silicate surface and the lipid headgroup, making it a good candidate for application. Nanoglassy SPR proves to be an attractive platform capable of rapidly screening film stability in real-time, providing critical information for future work using supported membranes for sensing applications.

Cell-Free Assay of G-Protein-Coupled Receptors Using Fluorescence Polarization

A recently developed nanotechnology, the Integral Molecular lipoparticle, provides an essentially soluble cell-free system in which G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) in their native conformations are concentrated within virus-like particles. As a result, the lipoparticle provides a means to overcome 2 common obstacles to the development of homogeneous, nonradioactive GPCR ligand-binding assays: membrane protein solubilization and low receptor density. The work reported here describes the first application of this nanotechnology to a fluorescence polarization (FP) molecular binding assay format. The GPCR chosen for these studies was the well-studied chemokine receptor CXCR4 for which a peptide ligand (T-22) has been previously characterized. The EC50 determined for the CXCR4-T-22 peptide interaction via FP with CXCR4 lipoparticles (15 nM) is consistent with the IC50 determined for the unlabeled T-22 peptide via competitive binding (59 nM). ( Journal of Biomolecular Screening 2008:424-429)

Nanoparticles as fluorescence labels: is size all that matters?

Fluorescent labels are often used in bioassays as a means to detect and characterize ligand-receptor binding. This is due in part to the inherently high sensitivity of fluorescence-based technology and the relative accessibility of the technique. There is often little concern raised as to whether or not the fluorescent label itself affects the ligand-receptor binding dynamics and equilibrium. This may be particularly important when considering nanoparticle labels. In this study, we examine the affects of nanoparticle (quantum dots and polymer nanospheres) fluorescent labels on the streptavidin-biotin binding system. Since the nanoparticle labels are larger than the species they tag, one could anticipate significant perturbation of the binding equilibrium. We demonstrate, using fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy, that although the binding equilibria do change, the relative changes are largely predictable. We suggest that the nanoparticles' mesoscopic size and surface tension effects can be used to explain changes in streptavidin-biotin binding.

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy of finite-sized particles

A theory is presented to study fluorescence correlation spectroscopy for particles with size comparable to the beam waist of the observation volume. Analytical correlation curves are derived for some experimentally interesting particle geometries. It is found that the finiteness of the particle generally decreases the value of the correlation amplitude and increases the correlation time compared to a point particle model. Furthermore, not only the size but also the distribution of fluorophores affects the shape of the correlation function. This is experimentally demonstrated with surface and internally labeled fluorescent spheres. In addition, experiments are performed on fluorescent spheres of different radii to validate the model by comparing the results to theoretical predictions.

Pharmacology under the microscope: the use of fluorescence correlation spectroscopy to determine the properties of ligand-receptor complexes

Recent years have revealed a high degree of structural organisation in the way in which cell-surface receptors and their associated signalling complexes interact at a molecular level. Fluorescence-based techniques have been at the forefront of methodologies used to investigate this organisation and dissect the pharmacology of drug–receptor interactions at the single-cell level. One such technique, fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS), in conjunction with a fluorescent ligand or receptor, is capable of providing quantitative information about the number of receptors and their mobilities within small areas of the cell membrane that approach the size of some signalling domains. This article describes the use of FCS to perform subcellular quantitative pharmacology, with particular reference to G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs). In conjunction with other forms of fluctuation analysis, such as two-colour cross-correlation FCS and molecular brightness analysis, FCS provides the first opportunity to investigate the domain-specific nature of GPCR pharmacology.

Different species of alpha-synuclein oligomers induce calcium influx and seeding

Aggregation of alpha-synuclein (alpha-syn) has been linked to the pathogenesis of Parkinson's disease (PD) and other neurodegenerative diseases. Increasing evidence suggests that prefibrillar oligomers and protofibrils, rather than mature fibrils of alpha-syn, are the pathogenic species in PD. Despite extensive effort on studying oligomerization of alpha-syn, no studies have compared different oligomer species directly on a single-particle level and investigated their biological effects on cells. In this study, we applied a novel highly sensitive single molecule detection system that allowed a direct comparison of different oligomer types. Furthermore, we studied biological effects of different oligomer types on cells. For this purpose, we developed new oligomerization protocols, that enabled the use of these different oligomers in cell culture. We found that all of our three aggregation protocols resulted in heterogeneous populations of oligomers. Some types of oligomers induced cell death via disruption of cellular ion homeostasis by a presumably pore-forming mechanism. Other oligomer types could directly enter the cell resulting in increased alpha-syn aggregation. Based on our results, we propose that under various physiological conditions, heterogeneous populations of oligomeric forms will coexist in an equilibrium. These different oligomer types lead directly or indirectly to cell damage. Our data indicate that inhibition of early alpha-syn aggregation events would consequently prevent all alpha-syn oligomer related toxicities. This has important implications for the development of disease-modifying drugs for the treatment of PD and other synucleinopathies.

Two-photon excitation fluorescence cross-correlation assay for ligand-receptor binding: cell membrane nanopatches containing the human micro-opioid receptor

Current ligand-receptor binding assays for G-protein coupled receptors cannot directly measure the system's dissociation constant, Kd, without purification of the receptor protein. Accurately measured Kd's are essential in the development of a molecular level understanding of ligand-receptor interactions critical in rational drug design. Here we report the introduction of two-photon excitation fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy (TPE-FCCS) to the direct analysis of ligand-receptor interactions of the human micro opioid receptor (hMOR) for both agonists and antagonists. We have developed the use of fluorescently distinct, dye-labeled hMOR-containing cell membrane nanopatches ( approximately 100-nm radius) and ligands, respectively, for this assay. We show that the output from TPE-FCCS data sets can be converted to the conventional Hill format, which provides Kd and the number of active receptors per nanopatch. When ligands are labeled with quantum dots, this assay can detect binding with ligand concentrations in the subnanomolar regime. Interestingly, conjugation to a bulky quantum dot did not adversely affect the binding propensity of the hMOR pentapeptide ligand, Leu-enkephalin.

A two-photon excitation fluorescence cross-correlation assay for a model ligand-receptor binding system using quantum dots

Two-photon excitation fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy (TPE-XCS) is a very suitable method for studying interactions of two distinctly labeled fluorescent molecules. As such, it lends itself nicely to the study of ligand-receptor interactions. By labeling the ligand with one color of fluorescent dye and the receptor with another, it is possible to directly monitor ligand binding rather than inferring binding by monitoring downstream effects. One challenge of the TPE-XCS approach is that of separating the signal due to the receptor from that of the ligand. Using standard organic fluorescent labels there is almost inevitably spectral cross talk between the detection channels, which must be accounted for in TPE-XCS data analysis. However, using quantum dots as labels for both ligand and receptor this limitation can be alleviated, because of the dot's narrower emission spectra. Using solely quantum dots as fluorescent labels is a novel approach to TPE-XCS, which may be generalizable to many pairs of interacting biomolecules after the proof of principle and the assessment of limitations presented here. Moreover, it is essential that relevant pharmacological parameters such as the equilibrium dissociation constant, K(d), can be easily extracted from the XCS data with minimal processing. Herein, we present a modified expression for fractional occupancy based on the auto- and cross-correlation decays obtained from a well-defined ligand-receptor system. Nanocrystalline semiconductor quantum dots functionalized with biotin (lambda(em) = 605 nm) and streptavidin (lambda(em) = 525 nm) were used for which an average K(d) value of 0.30 +/- 0.04 x 10(-9) M was obtained (cf. native system approximately 10(-15)). Additionally, the off-rate coefficient (k(off)) for dissociation of the two quantum dots was determined as 5 x 10(-5) s(-1). This off-rate is slightly larger than for native biotin-streptavidin (5 x 10(-6) s(-1)); the bulky nature of the quantum dots and restricted motion/orientation of functionalized dots in solution can account for differences in the streptavidin-biotin mediated dot-dot binding compared with those for native streptavidin-biotin.

G-protein-coupled receptors in drug discovery: nanosizing using cell-free technologies and molecular biology approaches

Signal transduction by G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) underpins a multitude of physiological processes. Ligand recognition by the receptor leads to activation of a generic molecular switch involving heterotrimeric G-proteins and guanine nucleotides. Signal transduction has been studied extensively with both cell-based systems and assays comprising isolated signaling components. Interest and commercial investment in GPCRs in areas such as drug targets, orphan receptors, high throughput screening, biosensors, and so on will focus greater attention on assay development to allow for miniaturization, ultra-high throughput and, eventually, microarray/biochip assay formats. Although cell-based assays are adequate for many GPCRs, it is likely that these formats will limit the development of higher density GPCR assay platforms mandatory for other applications. Stable, robust, cell-free signaling assemblies comprising receptor and appropriate molecular switching components will form the basis of future GPCR assay platforms adaptable for such applications as microarrays. The authors review current cell-free GPCR assay technologies and molecular biological approaches for construction of novel, functional GPCR assays.

Fluorophore-tagged GPCR ligands

Fluorescently tagged drug molecules can be successfully employed to visualize the location of their receptor target at the single-cell level. Furthermore, if their binding to the receptor is reversible, one can now obtain detailed pharmacological information such as affinity using single-molecule detection techniques. When coupled to the growing exploitation of fluorescence-based read-outs in high throughput and high content screening, it is clear that fluorescent molecules offer a safer, more powerful and more versatile alternative to radioligands in molecular pharmacology and drug discovery. GPCR pharmacology has benefited enormously from the application of fluorescence-based technologies and we now possess a much greater understanding of this receptor family's basic molecular mechanisms of action through the careful design and judicious use of fluorescent peptide and small-molecule-based ligands.