Transient Aggregation and Stable Dimerization Induced by Introducing an Alzheimer Sequence into a Water-Soluble Protein

Theoretical and computational advances in protein misfolding

Misfolded proteins escape the cellular quality control mechanism and fail to fold properly or remain correctly folded leading to a loss in their functional specificity. Thus misfolding of proteins cause a large number of very different diseases ranging from errors in metabolism to various types of complex neurodegenerative diseases. A theoretical and computational perspective of protein misfolding is presented with a special emphasis on its salient features, mechanism and consequences. These insights quantitatively analyze different determinants of misfolding, that may be applied to design disease specific molecular targets.

Competition of individual domain folding with inter-domain interaction in WW domain engineered repeat proteins

Engineered repeat proteins have proven to be a fertile ground for studying the competition between folding, misfolding and transient aggregation of tethered protein domains. We examine the interplay between folding and inter-domain interactions of engineered FiP35 WW domain repeat proteins with n = 1 through 5 repeats. We characterize protein expression, thermal and guanidium melts, as well as laser T-jump kinetics. All experimental data is fitted by a global fitting model with two states per domain (U, N), plus a third state M to account for non-native states due to domain interactions present in all but the monomer. A detailed structural model is provided by coarse-grained simulated annealing using the AWSEM Hamiltonian. Tethered FiP35 WW domains with n = 2 and 3 domains are just slightly less stable than the monomer. The n = 4 oligomer is yet less stable, its expression yield is much lower than the monomer's, and depends on the purification tag used. The n = 5 plasmid did not express at all, indicating the sudden onset of aggregation past n = 4. Thus, tethered FiP35 has a critical nucleus size for inter-domain aggregation of n ≈ 4. According to our simulations, misfolded structures become increasingly prevalent as one proceeds from monomer to pentamer, with extended inter-domain beta sheets appearing first, then multi-sheet 'intramolecular amyloid' structures, and finally novel motifs containing alpha helices. We discuss the implications of our results for oligomeric aggregate formation and structure, transient aggregation of proteins whilst folding, as well as for protein evolution that starts with repeat proteins.

Selection on protein structure, interaction, and sequence

Characterizing the probabilities of observing amino acid substitutions at specific sites in a protein over evolutionary time is a major goal in the field of molecular evolution. While purely statistical approaches at different levels of complexity exist, approaches rooted in underlying biological processes are necessary to characterize both the context-dependence of sequence changes (epistasis) and to extrapolate to sequences not observed in biological databases. To develop such approaches, an understanding of the different selective forces that act on amino acid substitution is necessary. Here, an overview of selection on and corresponding modeling of folding stability, folding specificity, binding affinity and specificity for ligands, the evolution of new binding sites on protein surfaces, protein dynamics, intrinsic disorder, and protein aggregation as well as the interplay with protein expression level (concentration) and biased mutational processes are presented.

Slow and bimolecular folding of a de novo designed monomeric protein DS119

De novo protein design offers a unique means to test and advance our understanding of how proteins fold. However, most current design methods are native structure eccentric and folding kinetics has rarely been considered in the design process. Here, we show that a de novo designed mini-protein DS119, which folds into a βαβ structure, exhibits unusually slow and concentration-dependent folding kinetics. For example, the folding time for 50 μM of DS119 was estimated to be ~2 s. Stopped-flow fluorescence resonance energy transfer experiments further suggested that its folding was likely facilitated by a transient dimerization process. Taken together, these results highlight the need for consideration of the entire folding energy landscape in de novo protein design and provide evidence suggesting nonnative interactions can play a key role in protein folding.

Double mutant MBP refolds at same rate in free solution as inside the GroEL/GroES chaperonin chamber when aggregation in free solution is prevented

Under "permissive" conditions at 25°C, the chaperonin substrate protein DM-MBP refolds 5-10 times more rapidly in the GroEL/GroES folding chamber than in free solution. This has been suggested to indicate that the chaperonin accelerates polypeptide folding by entropic effects of close confinement. Here, using native-purified DM-MBP, we show that the different rates of refolding are due to reversible aggregation of DM-MBP while folding free in solution, slowing its kinetics of renaturation: the protein exhibited concentration-dependent refolding in solution, with aggregation directly observed by dynamic light scattering. When refolded in chloride-free buffer, however, dynamic light scattering was eliminated, refolding became concentration-independent, and the rate of refolding became the same as that in GroEL/GroES. The GroEL/GroES chamber thus appears to function passively toward DM-MBP.

Occupancy of nonannular lipid binding sites on KcsA greatly increases the stability of the tetrameric protein

KcsA, a homotetrameric potassium channel from prokaryotes, contains noncovalently bound lipids appearing in the X-ray crystallographic structure of the protein. The binding sites for such high-affinity lipids are referred to as "nonannular" sites, correspond to intersubunit protein domains, and bind preferentially anionic phospholipids. Here we used a thermal denaturation assay and detergent-phospholipid mixed micelles containing KcsA to study the effects of different phospholipids on protein stability. We found that anionic phospholipids stabilize greatly the tetrameric protein against irreversible, heat-induced unfolding and dissociation into subunits. This occurs in a phospholipid concentration-dependent manner, and phosphatidic acid species with acyl chain lengths ranging 14 to 18 carbon atoms are more efficient than similar phosphatidylglycerols in protecting the protein. A docking model of the KcsA-phospholipid complex suggests that the increased protein stability originates from the intersubunit nature of the binding sites and, thus, interaction of the phospholipid with such sites holds together adjacent subunits within the tetrameric protein. We also found that simpler amphiphiles, such as alkyl sulfates longer than 10 carbon atoms, also increase the protein stability to the same extent as anionic phospholipids, although at higher concentrations than the latter. Modeling the interaction of these simpler amphiphiles with KcsA and comparing it with that of anionic phospholipids serve to delineate the features of a hydrophobic pocket in the nonannular sites. Such pocket is predicted to comprise residues from the M2 transmembrane segment of a subunit and from the pore helix of the adjacent subunit and seems most relevant to protein stabilization.

Minimalist design of water-soluble cross-beta architecture

Demonstrated successes of protein design and engineering suggest significant potential to produce diverse protein architectures and assemblies beyond those found in nature. Here, we describe a new class of synthetic protein architecture through the successful design and atomic structures of water-soluble cross-beta proteins. The cross-beta motif is formed from the lamination of successive beta-sheet layers, and it is abundantly observed in the core of insoluble amyloid fibrils associated with protein-misfolding diseases. Despite its prominence, cross-beta has been designed only in the context of insoluble aggregates of peptides or proteins. Cross-beta's recalcitrance to protein engineering and conspicuous absence among the known atomic structures of natural proteins thus makes it a challenging target for design in a water-soluble form. Through comparative analysis of the cross-beta structures of fibril-forming peptides, we identified rows of hydrophobic residues ("ladders") running across beta-strands of each beta-sheet layer as a minimal component of the cross-beta motif. Grafting a single ladder of hydrophobic residues designed from the Alzheimer's amyloid-beta peptide onto a large beta-sheet protein formed a dimeric protein with a cross-beta architecture that remained water-soluble, as revealed by solution analysis and x-ray crystal structures. These results demonstrate that the cross-beta motif is a stable architecture in water-soluble polypeptides and can be readily designed. Our results provide a new route for accessing the cross-beta structure and expanding the scope of protein design.

Simulation-based fitting of protein-protein interaction potentials to SAXS experiments

We present a new method for computing interaction potentials of solvated proteins directly from small-angle x-ray scattering data. An ensemble of proteins is modeled by Monte Carlo or molecular dynamics simulation. The global x-ray scattering of the whole model ensemble is then computed at each snapshot of the simulation, and averaged to obtain the x-ray scattering intensity. Finally, the interaction potential parameters are adjusted by an optimization algorithm, and the procedure is iterated until the best agreement between simulation and experiment is obtained. This new approach obviates the need for approximations that must be made in simplified analytical models. We apply the method to lambda repressor fragment 6-85 and fyn-SH3. With the increased availability of fast computer clusters, Monte Carlo and molecular dynamics analysis using residue-level or even atomistic potentials may soon become feasible.

Protein tyrosine phosphatase oligomerization studied by a combination of 15N NMR relaxation and 129Xe NMR. Effect of buffer containing arginine and glutamic acid

15N NMR relaxation and 129Xe NMR chemical shift measurements offer complementary information to study weak protein-protein interactions. They have been applied to study the oligomerization equilibrium of a low-molecular-weight protein tyrosine phosphatase in the presence of 50 mM arginine and 50 mM glutamic acid. These experimental conditions are shown to enhance specific protein-protein interactions while decreasing nonspecific aggregation. In addition, 129Xe NMR chemical shifts become selective reporters of one particular oligomer in the presence of arginine and glutamic acid, indicating that a specific Xe binding site is created in the oligomerization process. It is suggested that the multiple effects of arginine and glutamic acid are related to their effective excluded volume that favors specific protein association and the destabilization of partially unfolded forms that preferentially interact with xenon and are responsible for nonspecific protein aggregation.

Minimalist protein model as a diagnostic tool for misfolding and aggregation

We propose a realistic coarse-grained protein model and a technique to "anchor" the model to available experimental data. We apply this procedure to characterize the effect of multiple mutations on the folding mechanism of protein S6. We show that the mutation of a few "gatekeeper" residues triggers significant changes on the folding landscape of S6. These results suggest that gatekeeper residues control the flexibility of critical regions of S6, that in turn regulates the delicate balance between folding and aggregation. Although obtained with a minimalist protein model, these results are fully consistent with experimental evidence and offer a clue to understand the interplay between folding and aggregation in protein S6.

HIV-1 Tat Is a Natively Unfolded Protein

Tat (transactivator of transcription) is a small RNA-binding protein that plays a central role in the regulation of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 replication and in approaches to treating latently infected cells. Its interactions with a wide variety of both intracellular and extracellular molecules is well documented. A molecular understanding of the multitude of Tat activities requires a determination of its structure and interactions with cellular and viral partners. To increase the dispersion of NMR signals and permit dynamics analysis by multinuclear NMR spectroscopy, we have prepared uniformly 15N- and 15N/13C-labeled Tat-(1-72) protein. The cysteine-rich protein is unambiguously reduced at pH 4.1, and NMR chemical shifts and coupling constants suggest that it exists in a random coil conformation. Line broadening and multiple peaks in the Cys-rich and core regions suggest that transient folding occurs in two of the five sequence domains. NMR relaxation parameters were measured and analyzed by spectral density and Lipari-Szabo approaches, both confirming the lack of structure throughout the length of the molecule. The absence of a fixed conformation and the observation of fast dynamics are consistent with the ability of Tat protein to interact with a wide variety of proteins and nucleic acid and support the concept of a natively unfolded protein.

How Evolutionary Pressure Against Protein Aggregation Shaped Chaperone Specificity

As protein aggregation is potentially lethal, control of protein conformation by molecular chaperones is essential for cellular organisms. This is especially important during protein expression and translocation, since proteins are then unfolded and therefore most susceptible to form non-native interactions. Using TANGO, a statistical mechanics algorithm to predict protein aggregation, we here analyse the aggregation propensities of 28 complete proteomes. Our results show that between 10% and 20% of the residues in these proteomes are within aggregating protein segments and that this represents a lower limit for the aggregation tendency of globular proteins. Further, we show that not only evolution strongly pressurizes aggregation downwards by minimizing the amount of strongly aggregating sequences but also by selectively capping strongly aggregating hydrophobic protein sequences with arginine, lysine and proline. These residues are strongly favoured at these positions as they function as gatekeepers that are most efficient at opposing aggregation. Finally, we demonstrate that the substrate specificity of different unrelated chaperone families is geared by these gatekeepers. Chaperones face the difficulty of having to combine substrate affinity for a broad range of hydrophobic sequences and selectivity for those hydrophobic sequences that aggregate most strongly. We show that chaperones achieve these requirements by preferentially binding hydrophobic sequences that are capped by positively charged gatekeeper residues. In other words, targeting evolutionarily selected gatekeepers allows chaperones to prioritize substrate recognition according to aggregation propensity.

Binary and ternary aggregation within tethered protein constructs

The free energy per monomer of a protein aggregate varies with the number of participating monomers n. The change of this free energy with aggregate size, DeltaDeltaG(n), is difficult to determine by sedimentation or concentration studies. We introduce a kinetic approach to quantitate the free energy of aggregates in the presence of tethers. By linking the protein U1A into dimers and trimers, a high effective concentration of the monomers is achieved, together with exact size control of the aggregates. We found that the free energy of the aggregate relative to the native monomer reached a maximum for n = 2, and decreased by DeltaDeltaG(2) = -3.1 kT between dimer and trimer.