Enhanced dynamics of HIV gp120 glycoprotein by small molecule binding

Evaluation of Phytopolyphenols for their gp120-CD4 Binding Inhibitory Properties by In Silico Molecular Modelling & In Vitro Cell Line Studies

Background:

Lack of effective early-stage HIV-1 inhibitor instigated the need for screening of novel gp120-CD4 binding inhibitor. Polyphenols, a secondary metabolite derived from natural sources are reported to have broad spectrum HIV-1 inhibitory activity. However, the gp120-CD4 binding inhibitory activity of polyphenols has not been analysed in silico yet.

Objectives:

To establish the usage of phytopolyphenols (Theaflavin, Epigallocatechin (EGCG), Ellagic acid and Gallic acid) as early stage HIV-1 inhibitor by investigating their binding mode in reported homology of gp120-CD4 receptor complex using in silico screening studies and in vitro cell line studies.

Methods:

The in silico molecular docking and molecular simulation studies were performed using Schrödinger 2013-2 suite installed on Fujitsu Celsius Workstation. The in vitro cell line studies were performed in the TZM-bl cell line using MTT assay and β-galactosidase assay.

Results:

The results of molecular docking indicated that Theaflavin and EGCG exhibited high XP dock score with binding pose exhibiting Van der Waals interaction and hydrophobic interaction at the deeper site in the Phe43 cavity with Asp368 and Trp427. Both Theaflavin and EGCG form a stable complex with the prepared HIV-1 receptor and their binding mode interaction is within the vicinity 4 Å. Further, in vitro cell line studies also confirmed that Theaflavin (SI = 252) and EGCG (SI = 138) exert better HIV-1 inhibitory activity as compared to Ellagic acid (SI = 30) and Gallic acid (SI = 34).

Conclusions:

The results elucidate a possible binding mode of phytopolyphenols, which pinpoints their plausible mechanism and directs their usage as early stage HIV-1 inhibitor.

Soluble-type small-molecule CD4 mimics as HIV entry inhibitors

Several small molecule CD4 mimics have been reported previously as HIV-1 entry inhibitors, which block the interaction between the Phe43 cavity of HIV-1 gp120 and the host CD4. Known CD4 mimics such as NBD-556 possess significant anti-HIV activity but are less soluble in water, perhaps due to their hydrophobic aromatic ring-containing structures. Compounds with a pyridinyl group in place of the phenyl group in these molecules have been designed and synthesized in an attempt to increase the hydrophilicity. Some of these new CD4 mimics, containing a tetramethylpiperidine ring show significantly higher water solubility than NBD-556 and have high anti-HIV activity and synergistic anti-HIV activity with a neutralizing antibody. The CD4 mimic that has a cyclohexylpiperidine ring and a 6-fluoropyridin-3-yl ring has high anti-HIV activity and no significant cytotoxicity. The present results will be useful in the future design and development of novel soluble-type molecule CD4 mimics.

Flexibility of small molecular CD4 mimics as HIV entry inhibitors

CD4 mimics such as YIR-821 and its derivatives are small molecules which inhibit the interaction between the Phe43 cavity of HIV-1 gp120 with host CD4, an interaction that is involved in the entry of HIV to cells. Known CD4 mimics generally possess three structural features, an aromatic ring, an oxalamide linker and a piperidine moiety. We have shown previously that introduction of a cyclohexyl group and a guanidine group into the piperidine moiety and a fluorine atom at the meta-position of the aromatic ring leads to a significant increase in the anti-HIV activity. In the current study, the effects of conformational flexibility were investigated by introduction of an indole-type group in the junction between the oxalamide linker and the aromatic moiety or by replacement of the oxalamide linker with a glycine linker. This led to the development of compounds with high anti-HIV activity, showing the importance of the junction region for the expression of high anti-HIV activity. The present data are expected to be useful in the future design of novel CD4 mimic molecules.

Small-Molecule CD4 Mimics Containing Mono-cyclohexyl Moieties as HIV Entry Inhibitors

CD4 mimics are small molecules that inhibit the protein-protein interaction between gp120 and CD4, which is a key interaction for the entry of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) into host immune cells. In the present study, mono-cyclohexyl-type CD4 mimics were designed to form hydrophobic and electrostatic interactions with Val430 and Asp368 located in the entrance of the Phe43 cavity of gp120, the interaction site of CD4. YIR-329, a novel 1-azaspiro[5.5]undecane derivative with a cyclohexyl ring attached to the piperidine ring, exhibited only slightly weaker anti-HIV activity than a previously described lead HAR-171, and modeling results indicated the formation of advantageous interactions by the para-chlorophenyl moiety of YIR-329. To introduce an electrostatic interaction with Asp368, derivatives with a guanidino group on the piperidine nitrogen atom were synthesized. Mono-cyclohexyl-type CD4 mimics with a guanidino group, such as YIR-819 (N(1) -(4-chlorophenyl)-N(2) -(1-(2-(N-(amidino)glycinamide)ethyl)-2-cyclohexylpiperidin-4-yl)oxalamide) and YIR-821 (1-(2-(5-guanidinovaleramide)ethyl derivative of YIR-819), were identified that exhibit approximately fivefold more potent anti-HIV activity than YIR-329. In combination with a neutralizing antibody, their anti-HIV activities were augmenting. Modeling results suggest that these compounds interact effectively with Val430 and either Asp368 or Asp474 in the gp120 Phe43 cavity. YIR-819 and YIR-821 represent useful lead compounds for the further development of HIV-1 entry inhibitors and could potentially be useful for co-administration with neutralizing antibodies for the treatment of HIV infection and AIDS.

Development of Small-molecule HIV Entry Inhibitors Specifically Targeting gp120 or gp41

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) envelope (Env) glycoprotein surface subunit gp120 and transmembrane subunit gp41 play important roles in HIV-1 entry, thus serving as key targets for the development of HIV-1 entry inhibitors. T20 peptide (enfuvirtide) is the first U.S. FDA-approved HIV entry inhibitor; however, its clinical application is limited by the lack of oral availability. Here, we have described the structure and function of the HIV-1 gp120 and gp41 subunits and reviewed advancements in the development of small-molecule HIV entry inhibitors specifically targeting these two Env glycoproteins. We then compared the advantages and disadvantages of different categories of HIV entry inhibitor candidates and further predicted the future trend of HIV entry inhibitor development.

A broad spectrum anti-HIV inhibitor significantly disturbs V1/V2 domain rearrangements of HIV-1 gp120 and inhibits virus entry

Inhibition of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) entry into target human cells is considered as a critical strategy for preventing HIV infection. Conformational shifts of the HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein (gp120) facilitates the attachment of the virus to target cells, therefore gp120 remains an attractive target for antiretroviral therapy development. Compound 18A has been recently identified as a broad-spectrum anti-HIV inhibitor. It was proposed that 18A disrupts rearrangements of V1/V2 region in gp120; however, the precise mechanism by which 18A interferes with the inherent motion of V1/V2 domain remains obscure. In this report, we elaborate on the binding mode of compound 18A to the closed conformation of a soluble cleaved gp120 and further examine the dynamic motion of V1/V2 region in both gp120 and the gp120-18A complex via all-atom molecular dynamics simulations. In this work, comparative molecular dynamic analyses revealed that 18A makes contact with Leu179, Ile194, Ile424, Met426 W427, E370 and Met475 in the main hydrophobic cavity of the unliganded gp120 and disrupts the restructuring of V1/V2 domain observed in apo gp120. The unwinding of α1 and slight inversion of β2 in gp120 leads to the shift of VI/V2 domain away from the V3 N-terminal regions and toward the outer domain. Stronger contacts between Trp425 and Trp112 rings may contribute to the reduced flexibility of α1 observed upon 18A binding thereby inhibiting the shifts of the V1/V2 region. Binding of 18A to gp120: (1) decreases the overall flexibility of the protein and (2) inhibits the formation a gp120 conformation that closely ressembles a CD4-bound-like conformation. Information gained from this report not only elaborates on important dynamic features of gp120, but will also assist with the future designs of potent gp120 inhibitors as anti-HIV.

Structural basis for highly effective HIV-1 neutralization by CD4-mimetic miniproteins revealed by 1.5 Å cocrystal structure of gp120 and M48U1

The interface between the HIV-1 gp120 envelope glycoprotein and the CD4 receptor contains an unusual interfacial cavity, the "Phe43 cavity", which CD4-mimetic miniproteins with nonnatural extensions can potentially utilize to enhance their neutralization of HIV-1. Here, we report cocrystal structures of HIV-1 gp120 with miniproteins M48U1 and M48U7, which insert cyclohexylmethoxy and 5-hydroxypentylmethoxy extensions, respectively, into the Phe43 cavity. Both inserts displayed flexibility and hydrophobic interactions, but the M48U1 insert showed better shape complementarity with the Phe43 cavity than the M48U7 insert. Subtle alteration in the gp120 conformation played a substantial role in optimizing fit. With M48U1, these translated into a YU2-gp120 affinity of 0.015 nM and neutralization of all 180 circulating HIV-1 strains tested, except clade-A/E isolates with noncanonical Phe43 cavities. Ligand chemistry, shape complementarity, surface burial, and gp120 conformation act in concert to modulate binding of ligands to the gp120-Phe43 cavity and, when optimized, can effect near-pan-neutralization of HIV-1.

Structural plasticity and conformational transitions of HIV envelope glycoprotein gp120

HIV envelope glycoproteins undergo large-scale conformational changes as they interact with cellular receptors to cause the fusion of viral and cellular membranes that permits viral entry to infect targeted cells. Conformational dynamics in HIV gp120 are also important in masking conserved receptor epitopes from being detected for effective neutralization by the human immune system. Crystal structures of HIV gp120 and its complexes with receptors and antibody fragments provide high-resolution pictures of selected conformational states accessible to gp120. Here we describe systematic computational analyses of HIV gp120 plasticity in such complexes with CD4 binding fragments, CD4 mimetic proteins, and various antibody fragments. We used three computational approaches: an isotropic elastic network analysis of conformational plasticity, a full atomic normal mode analysis, and simulation of conformational transitions with our coarse-grained virtual atom molecular mechanics (VAMM) potential function. We observe collective sub-domain motions about hinge points that coordinate those motions, correlated local fluctuations at the interfacial cavity formed when gp120 binds to CD4, and concerted changes in structural elements that form at the CD4 interface during large-scale conformational transitions to the CD4-bound state from the deformed states of gp120 in certain antibody complexes.

Novel mutations in gB and gH circumvent the requirement for known gD Receptors in herpes simplex virus 1 entry and cell-to-cell spread

Both entry and cell-to-cell spread of herpes simplex virus (HSV) involve a cascade of cooperative interactions among the essential glycoproteins D, B, and H/L (gD, gB, and gH/gL, respectively) initiated by the binding of gD to a cognate HSV entry receptor. We previously reported that a variant (D285N/A549T) of glycoprotein B (gB:NT) enabled primary virus entry into cells that were devoid of typical HSV entry receptors. Here, we compared the activities of the gB:NT variant with those of a newly selected variant of glycoprotein H (gH:KV) and a frequently coselected gB variant (gB:S668N). In combination, gH:KV and gB:S668N enabled primary virus entry into cells that lacked established HSV entry receptors as efficiently as did gB:NT, but separately, each variant enabled only limited entry. Remarkably, gH:KV uniquely facilitated secondary virus spread between cells that lacked canonical entry receptors. Transient expression of the four essential entry glycoproteins revealed that gH:KV, but not gB:NT, induced fusion between cells lacking the standard receptors. Because the involvement of gD remained essential for virus spread and cell fusion, we propose that gH:KV mimics a transition state of gH that responds efficiently to weak signals from gD to reach the active state. Computational modeling of the structures of wild-type gH and gH:KV revealed relatively subtle differences that may have accounted for our experimental findings. Our study shows that (i) the dependence of HSV-1 entry and spread on specific gD receptors can be reduced by sequence changes in the downstream effectors gB and gH, and (ii) the relative roles of gB and gH are different in entry and spread.

The investigations on HIV-1 gp120 bound with BMS-488043 by using docking and molecular dynamics simulations

BMS-488043, like its predecessor BMS-378806, is a small molecule that can block the interactions between gp120 and CD4, and has shown good clinical efficacy. However, the crystal structure of drug-gp120 complexes or the full-length gp120 free of bound ligand is unpublished until now. Docking combined with molecular dynamics simulation is used to investigate the binding mode between BMS-488043 and gp120. On the basis of the analysis of the simulated results, the plausible binding mode is acquired, such as the changes of binding mode in the trajectory and the calculated binding free energy. Subsequently, a number of residues which make contacts with the small molecule are studied by binding free energy decomposition to understand the mutation experiments, such as Trp427, Ser375, and Thr257 residues with the help of the acquired binding mode above. Especially, the importance of the hydrophobic groove formed by residues Ile371 and Gly472 which bind BMS-488043 is elaborated, which has not been explored much. In addition, theoretical investigations on the dynamics behavior of the gp120 associated with BMS-488043 enhanced binding are performed; the results indicate that the BMS-488043 may be more deeply inserted into the Phe43 cavity compared with the previous binding mode acquired by docking.

Spontaneous rearrangement of the β20/β21 strands in simulations of unliganded HIV-1 glycoprotein, gp120

Binding of the viral spike drives cell entry and infection by HIV-1 to the cellular CD4 and chemokine receptors with associated conformational change of the viral glycoprotein envelope, gp120. Crystal structures of the CD4-gp120-antibody ternary complex reveal a large internal gp120 cavity formed by three domains-the inner domain, outer domain, and bridging sheet domain-and are capped by CD4 residue Phe43. Several structures of gp120 envelope in complex with various antibodies indicated that the bridging sheet adopts varied conformations. Here, we examine bridging sheet dynamics using a crystal structure of gp120 bound to the F105 antibody exhibiting an open bridging sheet conformation and with an added V3 loop. The two strands of the bridging sheet β2/β3 and β20/β21 are dissociated from each other and are directed away from the inner and outer domains. Analysis of molecular dynamics (MD) trajectories indicates that the β2/β3 and β20/β21 strands rapidly rearrange to interact with the V3 loop and the inner and outer domains, respectively. Residue N425 on β20 leads the conformational rearrangement of the β20/β21 strands by interacting with W112 on the inner domain and F382 on the outer domain. An accompanying shift is observed in the inner domain as helix α1 exhibits a loss in helicity and pivots away from helix α5. The two simulations provide a framework for understanding the conformational diversity of the bridging sheet and the propensity of the β20/β21 strand to refold between the inner and outer domains of gp120, in the absence of a bound ligand.