Loop Sequence Dictates the Secondary Structure of a Human Membrane Protein Hairpin

Impact of cholesterol and Lumacaftor on the folding of CFTR helical hairpins

Cystic fibrosis (CF) is caused by mutations in the gene that codes for the chloride channel cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR). Recent advances in CF treatment have included use of small-molecule drugs known as modulators, such as Lumacaftor (VX-809), but their detailed mechanism of action and interplay with the surrounding lipid membranes, including cholesterol, remain largely unknown. To examine these phenomena and guide future modulator development, we prepared a set of wild type (WT) and mutant helical hairpin constructs consisting of CFTR transmembrane (TM) segments 3 and 4 and the intervening extracellular loop (termed TM3/4 hairpins) that represent minimal membrane protein tertiary folding units. These hairpin variants, including CF-phenotypic loop mutants E217G and Q220R, and membrane-buried mutant V232D, were reconstituted into large unilamellar phosphatidylcholine (POPC) vesicles, and into corresponding vesicles containing 70 mol% POPC +30 mol% cholesterol, and studied by single-molecule FRET and circular dichroism experiments. We found that the presence of 30 mol% cholesterol induced an increase in helicity of all TM3/4 hairpins, suggesting an increase in bilayer cross-section and hence an increase in the depth of membrane insertion compared to pure POPC vesicles. Importantly, when we added the corrector VX-809, regardless of the presence or absence of cholesterol, all mutants displayed folding and helicity largely indistinguishable from the WT hairpin. Fluorescence spectroscopy measurements suggest that the corrector alters lipid packing and water accessibility. We propose a model whereby VX-809 shields the protein from the lipid environment in a mutant-independent manner such that the WT scaffold prevails. Such 'normalization' to WT conformation is consistent with the action of VX-809 as a protein-folding chaperone.

Uncoupling Amphipathicity and Hydrophobicity: Role of Charge Clustering in Membrane Interactions of Cationic Antimicrobial Peptides

Peptides with a combination of high positive charge and high hydrophobicity have high antimicrobial activity, as epitomized by peptide venoms, which are designed by nature as disruptors of host membranes yet also display significant efficacy against pathogens. To investigate this phenomenon systematically, here we focus on ponericin W1, a peptide venom isolated from Pachycondyla goeldii ants (WLGSALKIGAKLLPSVVGLFKKKKQ) to examine whether Lys positioning can be broadly applied to optimize the functional range of existing natural sequences. We prepared sets of ponericin W1 analogues, where Lys residues were either distributed in an amphipathic manner throughout the sequence (PonAmp), clustered at the N-terminus (PonN), or clustered at the C-terminus (PonC), along with their counterparts of reduced hydrophobicity through 2-4 Leu-to-Ala replacements. We found that wild-type ponericin W1 and all three variants displayed toxicity against human erythrocytes, but hemolysis was eliminated by the replacement of two or more Leu residues by Ala residues. As well, peptides containing up to 3 Leu-to-Ala replacements retained antimicrobial activity against E. coli bacteria. Biophysical analyses of peptide-membrane interaction patterns by circular dichroism spectroscopy revealed a novel mode of cluster-dependent peptide positioning vis-à-vis the water-membrane interface, where PonAmp and PonC peptides displayed full or partial helical structures, while PonN peptides were unstructured, likely due, in part, to dynamic interchange between aqueous and membrane surface environments. The overall findings suggest that the lower membrane penetration of N-terminal charge-clustered constructs coupled with moderate sequence hydrophobicity may be advantageous for conferring enhanced target selectivity for bacterial versus mammalian membranes.

CFTR transmembrane segments are impaired in their conformational adaptability by a pathogenic loop mutation and dynamically stabilized by Lumacaftor

The cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) is an ion channel protein that is defective in individuals with cystic fibrosis (CF). To advance the rational design of CF therapies, it is important to elucidate how mutational defects in CFTR lead to its impairment and how pharmacological compounds interact with and alter CFTR. Here, using a helical-hairpin construct derived from CFTR's transmembrane (TM) helices 3 and 4 (TM3/4) and their intervening loop, we investigated the structural effects of a patient-derived CF-phenotypic mutation, E217G, located in the loop region of CFTR's membrane-spanning domain. Employing a single-molecule FRET assay to probe the folding status of reconstituted hairpins in lipid bilayers, we found that the E217G hairpin exhibits an altered adaptive packing behavior stemming from an additional GXXXG helix-helix interaction motif created in the mutant hairpin. This observation suggested that the misfolding and functional defects caused by the E217G mutation arise from an impaired conformational adaptability of TM helical segments in CFTR. The addition of the small-molecule corrector Lumacaftor exerts a helix stabilization effect not only on the E217G mutant hairpin, but also on WT TM3/4 and other mutations in the hairpin. This finding suggests a general mode of action for Lumacaftor through which this corrector efficiently improves maturation of various CFTR mutants.

A minimal helical-hairpin motif provides molecular-level insights into misfolding and pharmacological rescue of CFTR

Our meagre understanding of CFTR misfolding and its reversal by small-molecule correctors hampers the development of mechanism-based therapies of cystic fibrosis. Here we exploit a helical-hairpin construct—the simplest proxy of membrane-protein tertiary contacts—containing CFTR’s transmembrane helices 3 and 4 and its corresponding disease phenotypic mutant V232D to gain molecular-level insights into CFTR misfolding and drug rescue by the corrector Lumacaftor. Using a single-molecule FRET approach to study hairpin conformations in lipid bilayers, we find that the wild-type hairpin is well folded, whereas the V232D mutant assumes an open conformation in bilayer thicknesses mimicking the endoplasmic reticulum. Addition of Lumacaftor reverses the aberrant opening of the mutant hairpin to restore a compact state as in the wild type. The observed membrane escape of the V232D hairpin and its reversal by Lumacaftor complement cell-based analyses of the full-length protein, thereby providing in vivo and in vitro correlates of CFTR misfolding and drug-action mechanisms.

Georg Krainer and Antoine Treff et al. use a helical-hairpin construct derived from the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) to investigate misfolding caused by the disease-linked V232D mutation. Using single-molecule FRET, they show that the V232D hairpin assumes an open conformation in lipid bilayers, which is reversed by the pharmacological corrector Lumacaftor.

Structural effects of extracellular loop mutations in CFTR helical hairpins

Missense mutations constitute 40% of 2000 cystic fibrosis-phenotypic mutations in the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) database, yet the precise mechanism as to how a point mutation can render the entire 1480-residue CFTR protein dysfunctional is not well-understood. Here we investigate the structural effects of two CF-phenotypic mutations - glutamic acid to glycine at position 217 (E217G) and glutamine to arginine at position 220 (Q220R) - in the extracellular (ECL2) loop region of human CFTR using helical hairpin constructs derived from transmembrane (TM) helices 3 and 4 of the first membrane domain. We systematically replaced the wild type (WT) residues E217 and Q220 with the subset of missense mutations that could arise through a single nucleotide change in their respective codons. Circular dichroism spectra of E217G revealed that a significant increase in helicity vs. WT arises in the membrane-mimetic environment of sodium dodecylsulfate (SDS) micelles, while this mutant showed a similar gel shift to WT on SDS-PAGE gels. In contrast, the CF-mutant Q220R showed similar helicity but an increased gel shift vs. WT. These structural variations are compared with the maturation levels of the corresponding mutant full-length CFTRs, which we found are reduced to approx. 50% for E217G and 30% for Q220R vs. WT. The overall results with CFTR hairpins illustrate the range of impacts that single mutations can evoke in intramolecular protein-protein and/or protein-lipid interactions - and the levels to which corresponding mutations in full-length CFTR may be flagged by quality control mechanisms during biosynthesis.

Glycine-rich loop encompassing active site at interface of hexameric M. tuberculosis Eis protein contributes to its structural stability and activity

RvEis is a crucial thermostable hexameric aminoglycoside acetyltransferase of Mycobacterium tuberculosis, overexpression of which confers Kanamycin resistance in clinical strains. The thermostability associated with hexameric RvEis is important for the enhanced intracellular survival of mycobacteria. However, the structural determinants responsible for its thermal stability remain unexplored. In this study, we have assessed the role of glycines of conserved glycine-rich motif (G¹²³GIYG¹²⁷) present at the oligomeric interface in the hydrophobic core of RvEis in sustenance of its structural stability, oligomerization and functional activity. Substitution of glycines to alanine (G123A/G127A) result in significant decrease in melting temperature (T_m), reduction in the oligomerization with concomitant increase in the monomeric form and higher susceptibility towards the denaturants like GdmCl and urea relative to wild type. G123A/G127A mutant displayed lower catalytic efficiency (k_cat/K_m) and is completely inactive at 60 °C. ANS binding assay and the complete dissociation of hexameric complex into monomers at lower concentration of urea in G123A/G127A relative to wtRvEis suggests that altered hydrophobic environment could be the reason for its instability. In sum, these results demonstrate the role of G¹²³GIYG¹²⁷ motif in structural stability and activity of RvEis.

Fragments of the V1/V2 domain of HIV-1 glycoprotein 120 engineered for improved binding to the broadly neutralizing PG9 antibody

The V1/V2 domain of the HIV-1 envelope protein gp120 possesses two important epitopes: a glycan-dependent epitope recognized by the prototypic broadly neutralizing monoclonal antibody (bN-mAb), PG9, as well as an epitope recognized by non-neutralizing antibodies that has been associated with protection from HIV infection in the RV144 HIV vaccine trial. Because both of these epitopes are poorly immunogenic in the context of full length envelope proteins, immunization with properly folded and glycosylated fragments (scaffolds) represents a potential way to enhance the immune response to these specific epitopes. Previous studies showed that V1/V2 domain scaffolds could be produced from a few selected isolates, but not from many of the isolates that would be advantageous in a multivalent vaccine. In this paper, we used a protein engineering approach to improve the conformational stability and antibody binding activity of V1/V2 domain scaffolds from multiple diverse isolates, including several that were initially unable to bind the prototypic PG9 bN-mAb. Significantly, this effort required replicating both the correct glycan structure as well as the β-sheet structure required for PG9 binding. Although scaffolds incorporating the glycans required for PG9 binding (e.g., mannose-5) can be produced using glycosylation inhibitors (e.g., swainsonine), or mutant cell lines (e.g. GnTI(-) 293 HEK), these are not practical for biopharmaceutical production of proteins intended for clinical trials. In this report, we describe engineered glycopeptide scaffolds from three different clades of HIV-1 that bind PG9 with high affinity when expressed in a wildtype cell line suitable for biopharmaceutical production. The mutations that improved PG9 binding to scaffolds produced in normal cells included amino acid positions outside of the antibody contact region designed to stabilize the β-sheet and turn structures. The scaffolds produced address three major problems in HIV vaccine development: (1) improving antibody responses to poorly immunogenic epitopes in the V1/V2 domain; (2) eliminating antibody responses to highly immunogenic (decoy) epitopes outside the V1/V2 domain; and (3) enabling the production of V1/V2 scaffolds in a cell line suitable for biopharmaceutical production.

Design and characterization of a membrane protein unfolding platform in lipid bilayers

Accurate measurement of membrane protein stability—and particularly how it may vary as a result of disease-phenotypic mutations—ideally requires a denaturant that can unfold a membrane-embedded structure while leaving the solubilizing environment unaffected. The steric trap method fulfills this requirement by using monovalent streptavidin (mSA) molecules to unfold membrane proteins engineered with two spatially close biotin tags. Here we adapted this method to an 87-residue helix-loop-helix (hairpin) construct derived from helices 3 and 4 in the transmembrane domain of the human cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR), wherein helix-helix tertiary interactions are anticipated to confer a portion of construct stability. The wild type CFTR TM3/4 hairpin construct was modified with two accessible biotin tags for mSA-induced unfolding, along with two helix-terminal pyrene labels to monitor loss of inter-helical contacts by pyrene excimer fluorescence. A series of eight constructs with biotin tags at varying distances from the helix-terminal pyrene labels were expressed, purified and labeled appropriately; all constructs exhibited largely helical circular dichroism spectra. We found that addition of mSA to an optimized construct in lipid vesicles led to a complete and reversible loss in pyrene excimer fluorescence and mSA binding, and hence hairpin unfolding—results further supported by SDS-PAGE visualization of mSA bound and unbound species. While some dimeric/oligomeric populations persist that may affect quantitation of the unfolding step, our characterization of the design yields a promising prototype of a future platform for the systematic study of membrane protein folding in a lipid bilayer environment.

Pro-Gly mediated conformational switch of mycobacteriophage D29 holin transmembrane domain I is lipid concentration driven

Biophysical and spectroscopic analysis of synthetic transmembrane domain I (1) of mycobacteriophage D29 holin shows a lipid concentration dependent conformational switch from an α-helix to a β-sheet structure. The reversibility of this switch, upon change in the lipid-to-peptide ratio, requires a central Pro-Gly segment, and is abolished upon mutation to Ala-Ala or (D)Pro-Gly.