Single-molecule dynamics and mechanisms of metalloregulators and metallochaperones

Investigation of metal ion binding biomolecules one molecule at a time

Metal ions can perform multiple roles ranging from regulatory to structural and are crucial for cell function. While some metal ions like Na+ are ubiquitously present at high concentrations, other ions, especially Ca2+ and transition metals, such as Zn2+ or Cu+/2+ are regulated. The concentrations above or below the physiological range cause severe changes in the behavior of biomolecules that bind them and subsequently affect the cell wellbeing. This has led to the development of specialized protocols to study metal ion binding biomolecules in bulk conditions that mimic the cell environment. Recently, there is growing evidence of influence of post-transcriptional and post-translational modifications on the affinity of the metal ion binding sites. However, such targets are difficult to obtain in amounts required for classical biophysical experiments. Single molecule techniques have revolutionized the field of biophysics, molecular and structural biology. Their biggest advantage is the ability to observe each molecule's interaction independently, without the need for synchronization. An additional benefit is its extremely low sample consumption. This feature allows characterization of designer biomolecules or targets obtained coming from natural sources. All types of biomolecules, including proteins, DNA and RNA were characterized using single molecule methods. However, one group is underrepresented in those studies. These are the metal ion binding biomolecules. Single molecule experiments often require separate optimization, due to extremely different concentrations used during the experiments. In this review we focus on single molecule methods, such as single molecule FRET, nanopores and optical tweezers that are used to study metal ion binding biomolecules. We summarize various examples of recently characterized targets and reported experimental conditions. Finally, we discuss the potential promises and pitfalls of single molecule characterization on metal ion binding biomolecules.

Single Molecule Force Spectroscopy Studies on Metalloproteins: Opportunities and Challenges

Metalloproteins play important roles in a wide range of biological processes. Elucidating the mechanisms via which metalloproteins fold and constitute their metal centers is critical to the understanding of the functions and dynamics of metalloproteins. Owing to its superior force and length resolution, single-molecule force spectroscopy (SMFS) has evolved into a powerful tool to probe the unfolding and folding mechanisms of metalloproteins at the single level by forcing metalloproteins to unfold and then refold along a reaction coordinate defined by the applied stretching force. The folding of metalloproteins is complex and involves two interwound processes, the folding of the polypeptide chain and the constitution of the metal center. Experimental studies of the folding of metalloproteins are challenging. SMFS studies have allowed researchers to directly probe the folding and unfolding of metalloproteins at the single-molecule level and the effect of metal centers on the folding-unfolding energy landscape of metalloproteins. New mechanistic insights on the folding and unfolding of some metalloproteins have been obtained, demonstrating the power and unique advantages that SMFS techniques may offer. In this Perspective, using calcium-binding proteins and small iron-sulfur proteins as examples, I provide a concise overview of the information and insights that SMFS studies have provided to understand the folding and unfolding of metalloproteins. I also discuss the opportunities and challenges that are present in this fast-progressing area of research.

Comprehensive genomic and proteomic profiling reveal Acinetobacter johnsonii JH7 responses to Sb(III) toxicity

Antimony (Sb) pollution poses a severe health threat to ecosystems. However, the toxic effects of Sb on biota are far from being elucidated. One of the unresolved questions is the molecular signal pathways underlying microbial adaptation to excess antimonite or Sb(III) exposure. The response of a Sb(III)-resistant bacterium Acinetobacter. johnsonii JH7 to Sb(III) stress was investigated using genomic and proteomic profiling. Sb(III) induced the formation of reactive oxygen species thereby leading to oxidative stress and the up-regulation of antioxidant enzyme activities. In addition, two important operons (ars and pst) playing critical roles in this cellular response were identified. The ars proteins functioned cooperatively to expel Sb(III) thereby decreasing antimonite toxicity. Downregulation of the phosphate-specific transporter might reduce the uptake of Sb(V) while hindering phosphorus assimilation. Interaction of Sb(III) with JH7 strain cells also affected peptide syntheses and folding, energy conversion, and stability of the cellular envelope. The present study provides for the first time a global map of cellular adaptation to excess Sb(III). Such information is potentially useful to future Sb pollution remediation strategies.

Biphasic unbinding of a metalloregulator from DNA for transcription (de)repression in Live Bacteria

Microorganisms use zinc-sensing regulators to alter gene expression in response to changes in the availability of zinc, an essential micronutrient. Under zinc-replete conditions, the Fur-family metalloregulator Zur binds to DNA tightly in its metallated repressor form to Zur box operator sites, repressing the transcription of zinc uptake transporters. Derepression comes from unbinding of the regulator, which, under zinc-starvation conditions, exists in its metal-deficient non-repressor forms having no significant affinity with Zur box. While the mechanism of transcription repression by Zur is well-studied, little is known on how derepression by Zur could be facilitated. Using single-molecule/single-cell measurements, we find that in live Escherichia coli cells, Zur's unbinding rate from DNA is sensitive to Zur protein concentration in a first-of-its-kind biphasic manner, initially impeded and then facilitated with increasing Zur concentration. These results challenge conventional models of protein unbinding being unimolecular processes and independent of protein concentration. The facilitated unbinding component likely occurs via a ternary complex formation mechanism. The impeded unbinding component likely results from Zur oligomerization on chromosome involving inter-protein salt-bridges. Unexpectedly, a non-repressor form of Zur is found to bind chromosome tightly, likely at non-consensus sequence sites. These unusual behaviors could provide functional advantages in Zur's facile switching between repression and derepression.

How do DNA-bound proteins leave their binding sites? The role of facilitated dissociation

Dissociation of a protein from DNA is often assumed to be described by an off rate that is independent of other molecules in solution. Recent experiments and computational analyses have challenged this view by showing that unbinding rates (residence times) of DNA-bound proteins can depend on concentrations of nearby molecules that are competing for binding. This 'facilitated dissociation' (FD) process can occur at the single-binding site level via formation of a ternary complex, and can dominate over 'spontaneous dissociation' at low (submicromolar) concentrations. In the crowded intracellular environment FD introduces new regulatory possibilities at the level of individual biomolecule interactions.

The interplay of the metallosensor CueR with two distinct CopZ chaperones defines copper homeostasis in Pseudomonas aeruginosa

Copper homeostasis in pathogenic bacteria is critical for cuproprotein assembly and virulence. However, in vivo biochemical analyses of these processes are challenging, which has prevented defining and quantifying the homeostatic interplay between Cu⁺-sensing transcriptional regulators, chaperones, and sequestering molecules. The cytoplasm of Pseudomonas aeruginosa contains a Cu⁺-sensing transcriptional regulator, CueR, and two homologous metal chaperones, CopZ1 and CopZ2, forming a unique system for studying Cu⁺ homeostasis. We found here that both chaperones exchange Cu⁺, albeit at a slow rate, reaching equilibrium after 3 h, a time much longer than P. aeruginosa duplication time. Therefore, they appeared as two separate cellular Cu⁺ pools. Although both chaperones transferred Cu⁺ to CueR in vitro, experiments in vivo indicated that CopZ1 metallates CueR, eliciting the translation of Cu⁺ efflux transporters involved in metal tolerance. Although this observation was consistent with the relative Cu⁺ affinities of the three proteins (CopZ1 < CueR < CopZ2), in vitro and in silico analyses also indicated a stronger interaction between CopZ1 and CueR that was independent of Cu⁺ In contrast, CopZ2 function was defined by its distinctly high abundance during Cu²⁺ stress. Under resting conditions, CopZ2 remained largely in its apo form. Metal stress quickly induced CopZ2 expression, and its holo form predominated, reaching levels commensurate with the cytoplasmic Cu⁺ levels. In summary, these results show that CopZ1 acts as chaperone delivering Cu⁺ to the CueR sensor, whereas CopZ2 functions as a fast-response Cu⁺-sequestering storage protein. We propose that equivalent proteins likely play similar roles in most bacterial systems.

Trapping intermediates in metal transfer reactions of the CusCBAF export pump of Escherichia coli

Escherichia coli CusCBAF represents an important class of bacterial efflux pump exhibiting selectivity towards Cu(I) and Ag(I). The complex is comprised of three proteins: the CusA transmembrane pump, the CusB soluble adaptor protein, and the CusC outer-membrane pore, and additionally requires the periplasmic metallochaperone CusF. Here we used spectroscopic and kinetic tools to probe the mechanism of copper transfer between CusF and CusB using selenomethionine labeling of the metal-binding Met residues coupled to RFQ-XAS at the Se and Cu edges. The results indicate fast formation of a protein-protein complex followed by slower intra-complex metal transfer. An intermediate coordinated by ligands from each protein forms in 100 ms. Stopped-flow fluorescence of the capping CusF-W44 tryptophan that is quenched by metal transfer also supports this mechanism. The rate constants validate a process in which shared-ligand complex formation assists protein association, providing a driving force that raises the rate into the diffusion-limited regime.

Quantifying the Oligomeric States of Membrane Proteins in Cells through Super-Resolution Localizations

Transitions between different oligomeric states of membrane proteins are essential for proper cellular functions. However, the quantification of their oligomeric states in cells is technically challenging. Here we developed a new method to quantify oligomeric state(s) of highly expressed membrane proteins using the probability density function of molecule density ( PDF_MD) calculated from super-resolution localizations. We provided the theoretical model of PDF_MD, discussed the effects of protein concentration, cell geometry, and photophysics of fluorescent proteins on PDF_MD, and provided experimental criteria for proper quantification of oligomeric states. This method was further validated using simulated single-molecule fluorescent movies and applied to two membrane proteins, UhpT and SbmA in E. coli. The study shows that PDF_MD is useful in quantifying oligomeric states of membrane proteins in cells that can help in understanding cellular tasks. Potential applications to proteins with higher oligomeric states under high concentration and limitations of our methodology were also discussed.

Facilitated Unbinding via Multivalency-Enabled Ternary Complexes: New Paradigm for Protein-DNA Interactions

Dynamic protein-DNA interactions constitute highly robust cellular machineries to fulfill cellular functions. A vast number of studies have focused on how DNA-binding proteins search for and interact with their target DNA segments and on what cellular cues can regulate protein binding, for which protein concentration is a most obvious one. In contrast, how protein unbinding could be regulated by protein concentration has evaded attention because protein unbinding from DNA is typically a unimolecular reaction and thus concentration independent. Recent single-molecule studies from multiple research groups have uncovered that protein concentration can facilitate the unbinding of DNA-bound proteins, revealing regulation of protein unbinding as another mechanistic paradigm for gene regulation. In this Account, we review these recent in vitro and in vivo single-molecule experiments that uncovered the concentration-facilitated protein unbinding by multiple types of DNA-binding proteins, including sequence-nonspecific DNA-binding proteins (e.g., nucleoid-associated proteins, NAP), sequence-specific DNA-binding proteins (e.g., metal-responsive transcription regulators CueR and ZntR), sequence-neutral single-stranded DNA-binding proteins (e.g., Replication protein A, RPA), and DNA polymerases. For the in vitro experiments, Marko's group investigated the exchange of GFP-tagged DNA-bound NAPs with nontagged NAPs in solution of increasing concentration using single-molecule magnetic-tweezers fluorescence microscopy. The faster fluorescence intensity decrease with higher nontagged NAP concentrations suggests that DNA-bound NAPs undergo faster exchange with higher free NAP concentrations. Chen's group used single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer measurements to study the unbinding of CueR from its cognate oligomeric DNA. The average microscopic dwell times of DNA-bound states become shorter with increasing CueR concentrations in the surroundings, demonstrating that free CueR proteins can facilitate the unbinding of the incumbent one on DNA through either assisted dissociation or direct substitution. Greene's group studied the unbinding of RPAs from single-stranded DNA using total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy and DNA curtain techniques. The fluorescence intensity versus time traces show faster decay with higher wild-type RPA concentrations, indicating that DNA-bound RPAs can undergo a concentration-facilitated exchange when encountering excess free RPA. van Oijen's group investigated the leading/lagging-strand polymerase exchange events in the bacteriophage T7 and E. coli replication systems using a combination of single-molecule fluorescence microscopy and DNA-flow-stretching assay. The processivity was observed to have larger decrease when the concentration of the Y526F polymerase mutant increases, indicating that the unbinding of the polymerase is also concentration-dependent. Using stroboscopic imaging and single-molecule tracking, Chen's group further advanced their study into living bacterial cells. They found CueR, as well as its homologue ZntR, shows concentration-enhanced unbinding from its DNA-binding site in vivo. Mechanistic consensus has emerged from these in vitro and in vivo single-molecule studies that encompass a range of proteins with distinct biological functions. It involves multivalent contacts between protein and DNA. The multivalency enables the formation of ternary complexes as intermediates, which subsequently give rise to concentration-enhanced protein unbinding. As multivalent contacts are ubiquitous among DNA-interacting proteins, this multivalency-enabled facilitated unbinding mechanism thus provides a potentially general mechanistic paradigm in regulating protein-DNA interactions.

The Copper Efflux Regulator CueR Is Subject to ATP-Dependent Proteolysis in Escherichia coli

The trace element copper serves as cofactor for many enzymes but is toxic at elevated concentrations. In bacteria, the intracellular copper level is maintained by copper efflux systems including the Cue system controlled by the transcription factor CueR. CueR, a member of the MerR family, forms homodimers, and binds monovalent copper ions with high affinity. It activates transcription of the copper tolerance genes copA and cueO via a conserved DNA-distortion mechanism. The mechanism how CueR-induced transcription is turned off is not fully understood. Here, we report that Escherichia coli CueR is prone to proteolysis by the AAA+ proteases Lon, ClpXP, and ClpAP. Using a set of CueR variants, we show that CueR degradation is not altered by mutations affecting copper binding, dimerization or DNA binding of CueR, but requires an accessible C terminus. Except for a twofold stabilization shortly after a copper pulse, proteolysis of CueR is largely copper-independent. Our results suggest that ATP-dependent proteolysis contributes to copper homeostasis in E. coli by turnover of CueR, probably to allow steady monitoring of changes of the intracellular copper level and shut-off of CueR-dependent transcription.

Concentration- and chromosome-organization-dependent regulator unbinding from DNA for transcription regulation in living cells

Binding and unbinding of transcription regulators at operator sites constitute a primary mechanism for gene regulation. While many cellular factors are known to regulate their binding, little is known on how cells can modulate their unbinding for regulation. Using nanometer-precision single-molecule tracking, we study the unbinding kinetics from DNA of two metal-sensing transcription regulators in living Escherichia coli cells. We find that they show unusual concentration-dependent unbinding kinetics from chromosomal recognition sites in both their apo and holo forms. Unexpectedly, their unbinding kinetics further varies with the extent of chromosome condensation, and more surprisingly, varies in opposite ways for their apo-repressor versus holo-activator forms. These findings suggest likely broadly relevant mechanisms for facile switching between transcription activation and deactivation in vivo and in coordinating transcription regulation of resistance genes with the cell cycle.

Binding and unbinding of transcription regulators at operator sites regulates gene expression. By single-molecule tracking of metal-sensing regulators, here the authors show that the unbinding kinetics depends on regulator concentration and chromosome condensation, and varies with their metal-binding states.