Analysis of protein-RNA complexes involving a RNA recognition motif engineered to bind hairpins with seven- and eight-nucleotide loops

An Evolved RNA Recognition Motif That Suppresses HIV-1 Tat/TAR-Dependent Transcription

Potent and selective recognition and modulation of disease-relevant RNAs remain a daunting challenge. We previously examined the utility of the U1A N-terminal RNA recognition motif as a scaffold for tailoring new RNA hairpin recognition and showed that as few as one or two mutations can result in moderate affinity (low μM dissociation constant) for the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) trans-activation response element (TAR) RNA, an RNA hairpin controlling transcription of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) genome. Here, we use yeast display and saturation mutagenesis of established RNA-binding regions in U1A to identify new synthetic proteins that potently and selectively bind TAR RNA. Our best candidate has truly altered, not simply broadened, RNA-binding selectivity; it binds TAR with subnanomolar affinity (apparent dissociation constant of ∼0.5 nM) but does not appreciably bind the original U1A RNA target (U1hpII). It specifically recognizes the TAR RNA hairpin in the context of the HIV-1 5'-untranslated region, inhibits the interaction between TAR RNA and an HIV trans-activator of transcription (Tat)-derived peptide, and suppresses Tat/TAR-dependent transcription. Proteins described in this work are among the tightest TAR RNA-binding reagents-small molecule, nucleic acid, or protein-reported to date and thus have potential utility as therapeutics and basic research tools. Moreover, our findings demonstrate how a naturally occurring RNA recognition motif can be dramatically resurfaced through mutation, leading to potent and selective recognition-and modulation-of disease-relevant RNA.

Synthetic RNA recognition motifs that selectively recognize HIV-1 trans-activation response element hairpin RNA

A multitude of RNA hairpins are directly implicated in human disease. Many of these RNAs are potentially valuable targets for drug discovery and basic research. However, very little is known about the molecular requirements for achieving sequence-selective recognition of a particular RNA sequence and structure. Although a relatively modest number of synthetic small to medium-sized RNA-binding molecules have been reported, rapid identification of sequence-selective RNA-binding molecules remains a daunting challenge. RNA recognition motif (RRM) domains may represent unique privileged scaffolds for the generation of synthetic proteins that selectively recognize structured disease-relevant RNAs, including RNA hairpins. As a demonstration of this potential, we mutated putative RNA-binding regions within the U1A RRM and a variant thereof and screened these synthetic proteins for affinity to HIV-1 trans-activation response (TAR) element hairpin RNA. Some of these U1A-derived proteins bind TAR with single-digit micromolar dissociation constants, and they do so preferentially over the native protein's original target RNA (U1hpII) and a DNA TAR variant. Binding affinity is not appreciably diminished by addition of 10 molar equivalents of cellular tRNAs from Escherichia coli. Taken together, our findings represent the first synthetic RRMs that selectively bind a disease-relevant RNA hairpin and may represent a general approach for achieving sequence-selective recognition of RNA hairpins, which are the focus of therapeutic discovery and basic research.

Comparison of the π-stacking properties of purine versus pyrimidine residues. Some generalizations regarding selectivity

Aromatic-ring stacking is pronounced among the noncovalent interactions occurring in biosystems and therefore some pertinent features regarding nucleobase residues are summarized. Self-stacking decreases in the series adenine > guanine > hypoxanthine > cytosine ~ uracil. This contrasts with the stability of binary (phen)(N) adducts formed by 1,10-phenanthroline (phen) and a nucleobase residue (N), which is largely independent of the type of purine residue involved, including (N1)H-deprotonated guanine. Furthermore, the association constant for (phen)(A)(0/4-) is rather independent of the type and charge of the adenine derivative (A) considered, be it adenosine or one of its nucleotides, including adenosine 5'-triphosphate (ATP(4-)). The same holds for the corresponding adducts of 2,2'-bipyridine (bpy), although owing to the smaller size of the aromatic-ring system of bpy, the (bpy)(A)(0/4-) adducts are less stable; the same applies correspondingly to the adducts formed with pyrimidines. In accord herewith, [M(bpy)](adenosine)(2+) adducts (M(2+) is Co(2+), Ni(2+), or Cu(2+)) show the same stability as the (bpy)(A)(0/4-) ones. The formation of an ionic bridge between -NH3 (+) and -PO3 (2-), as provided by tryptophan [H(Trp)(±)] and adenosine 5'-monophosphate (AMP(2-)), facilitates recognition and stabilizes the indole-purine stack in [H(Trp)](AMP)(2-). Such indole-purine stacks also occur in nature. Similarly, the formation of a metal ion bridge as occurs, e.g., between Cu(2+) coordinated to phen and the phosphonate group of 9-[2-(phosphonomethoxy)ethyl]adenine (PMEA(2-)) dramatically favors the intramolecular stack in Cu(phen)(PMEA). The consequences of such interactions for biosystems are discussed, especially emphasizing that the energies involved in such isomeric equilibria are small, allowing Nature to shift such equilibria easily.