Effect of Chloride Binding on the Thermal Trimer−Monomer Conversion of Halorhodopsin in the Solubilized System

Structural insights into light-driven anion pumping in cyanobacteria

Transmembrane ion transport is a key process in living cells. Active transport of ions is carried out by various ion transporters including microbial rhodopsins (MRs). MRs perform diverse functions such as active and passive ion transport, photo-sensing, and others. In particular, MRs can pump various monovalent ions like Na+, K+, Cl-, I-, NO3-. The only characterized MR proposed to pump sulfate in addition to halides belongs to the cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp. PCC 7509 and is named Synechocystis halorhodopsin (SyHR). The structural study of SyHR may help to understand what makes an MR pump divalent ions. Here we present the crystal structure of SyHR in the ground state, the structure of its sulfate-bound form as well as two photoreaction intermediates, the K and O states. These data reveal the molecular origin of the unique properties of the protein (exceptionally strong chloride binding and proposed pumping of divalent anions) and sheds light on the mechanism of anion release and uptake in cyanobacterial halorhodopsins. The unique properties of SyHR highlight its potential as an optogenetics tool and may help engineer different types of anion pumps with applications in optogenetics.

Spectroscopic Characterization of Halorhodopsin Reconstituted into Nanodisks Using Native Lipids

We successfully reconstituted single Natronomonas pharaonis halorhodopsin (NpHR) trimers into a nanodisk (ND) using the native archaeal lipid (NL) and an artificial lipid having a zwitterionic headgroup, 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC). Incorporation of single trimeric NpHR into NDs was confirmed by sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, size-exclusion chromatography, and visible circular dichroism spectroscopy. The Cl^- binding affinity of NpHR in NDs using NL (NL-ND NpHR) or POPC (POPC-ND NpHR) was examined by absorption spectroscopy, showing that the Cl^--releasing affinities (K_d,N↔O) of these ND-reconstituted NpHRs are more than 10 times higher than that obtained from native NpHR membrane fragments (MFs) harvested from a NpHR-overexpressing archaeal strain (MF NpHR). The photoreaction kinetics of these ND-reconstituted NpHRs revealed that the Cl^- uptake was faster than that of MF NpHR. These differences in the Cl^--releasing and uptake properties of ND-reconstituted NpHRs and MF NpHR may arise from suppression of protein conformational changes associated with Cl^- release from the trimeric NpHR caused by ND reconstitution, conformational perturbation in the trimeric state, and loss of the trimer-trimer interactions. On the other hand, POPC-ND NpHR demonstrated accelerated Cl^- uptake compared to NL-ND NpHR, suggesting that the negative charge on the archaeal membrane surface regulates the photocycle of NpHR. Although NL-ND NpHR and MF NpHR are embedded in the same lipid, the lower Cl^--binding affinity at the initial state (K_d,initial) and faster recovering from the NpHR' state to the original state of the photoreaction cycle were observed for NL-ND NpHR, probably because of insufficient interactions with a chromophore in the native membrane, bacterioruberin in reconstituted NDs. Our results indicate that specific interactions of NpHR with surrounding lipids and bacterioruberin, structural flexibility of the membrane, and interactions between trimeric NpHRs may be necessary for efficient Cl^- pumping.

Three-Step Isomerization of the Retinal Chromophore during the Anion Pumping Cycle of Halorhodopsin

The anion pumping cycle of halorhodopsin from Natronomonas pharaonis ( pHR) is initiated when the all- trans/15- anti isomer of retinal is photoisomerized into the 13- cis/15- anti configuration. A recent crystallographic study suggested that a reaction state with 13- cis/15- syn retinal occurred during the anion release process, i.e., after the N state with the 13- cis/15- anti retinal and before the O state with all- trans/15- anti retinal. In this study, we investigated the retinal isomeric composition in a long-living reaction state at various bromide ion concentrations. It was found that the 13- cis isomer (^csHR'), in which the absorption spectrum was blue-shifted by ∼8 nm compared with that of the trans isomer (^taHR), accumulated significantly when a cold suspension of pHR-rich claret membranes in 4 M NaBr was illuminated with continuous light. Analysis of flash-induced absorption changes suggested that the branching of the trans photocycle into the 13- cis isomer (^csHR') occurs during the decay of an O-like state (O') with 13- cis/15- syn retinal; i.e., O' can decay to either ^csHR' or O with all- trans/15- anti retinal. The efficiency of the branching reaction was found to be dependent on the bromide ion concentration. At a very high bromide ion concentration, the anion pumping cycle is described by the scheme ^taHR -( hν) → K → L_1a ↔ L_1b ↔ N ↔ N' ↔ O' ↔ ^csHR' ↔ ^taHR. At a low bromide ion concentration, on the other hand, O' decays into ^taHR via O.

High Thermal Stability of Oligomeric Assemblies of Thermophilic Rhodopsin in a Lipid Environment

Thermophilic rhodopsin (TR) is a light-driven proton pump from the extreme thermophile Thermus thermophilus JL-18. Previous studies on TR solubilized with detergent showed that the protein exhibits high thermal stability and forms a trimer at room temperature but irreversibly dissociates into monomers when incubated at physiological temperature (75 °C). In the present study, we used resonance Raman (RR) spectroscopy, solid-state NMR spectroscopy, and high-speed atomic force microscopy to analyze the oligomeric structure of TR in a lipid environment. The obtained spectra and microscopic images demonstrate that TR adopts a pentameric form in a lipid environment and that this assembly is stable at the physiological temperature, in contrast to the behavior of the protein in the solubilized state. These results indicate that the thermal stability of the oligomeric assembly of TR is higher in a lipid environment than in detergent micelles. The observed RR spectra also showed that the retinal chromophore is strongly hydrogen bonded to an internal water molecule via a protonated Schiff base, which is characteristic of proton-pumping rhodopsins. The obtained data strongly suggest that TR functions in the pentameric form at physiological temperature in the extreme thermophile T. thermophilus JL-18. We utilized the high thermal stability of the monomeric form of solubilized TR and here report the first RR spectra of the monomeric form of a microbial rhodopsin. The observed RR spectra revealed that the monomerization of TR alters the chromophore structure: there are changes in the bond alternation of the polyene chain and in the hydrogen-bond strength of the protonated Schiff base. The present study revealed the high thermal stability of oligomeric assemblies of TR in the lipid environment and suggested the importance of using TR embedded in lipid membrane for elucidation of its functional mechanism.

Irreversible trimer to monomer transition of thermophilic rhodopsin upon thermal stimulation

Assembly is one of the keys to understand biological molecules, and it takes place in spatial and temporal domains upon stimulation. Microbial rhodopsin (also called retinal protein) is a membrane-embedded protein that has a retinal chromophore within seven-transmembrane α-helices and shows homo-, di-, tri-, penta-, and hexameric assemblies. Those assemblies are closely related to critical physiological properties such as stabilizing the protein structure and regulating their photoreaction dynamics. Here we investigated the assembly and disassembly of thermophilic rhodopsin (TR), which is a novel proton-pumping rhodopsin derived from a thermophile living at 75 °C. TR was characterized using size-exclusion chromatography and circular dichroism spectroscopy, and formed a trimer at 25 °C, but irreversibly dissociated into monomers upon thermal stimulation. The transition temperature was estimated to be 68 °C. The irreversible nature made it possible to investigate the photochemical properties of both the trimer and the monomer independently. Compared with the trimer, the absorption maximum of the monomer is blue-shifted by 6 nm without any changes in the retinal composition, pKa value for the counterion or the sequence of the proton movement. The photocycling rate of the monomeric TR was similar to that of the trimeric TR. A similar trimer-monomer transition upon thermal stimulation was observed for another eubacterial rhodopsin GR but not for the archaeal rhodopsins AR3 and HwBR, suggesting that the transition is conserved in bacterial rhodopsins. Thus, the thermal stimulation of TR induces the irreversible disassembly of the trimer.

Homotrimer formation and dissociation of pharaonis halorhodopsin in detergent system

Halorhodopsin from NpHR is a light-driven Cl(-) pump that forms a trimeric NpHR-bacterioruberin complex in the native membrane. In the case of NpHR expressed in Escherichia coli cell, NpHR forms a robust homotrimer in a detergent DDM solution. To identify the important residue for the homotrimer formation, we carried out mutation experiments on the aromatic amino acids expected to be located at the molecular interface. The results revealed that Phe(150) was essential to form and stabilize the NpHR trimer in the DDM solution. Further analyses for examining the structural significance of Phe(150) showed the dissociation of the trimer in F150A (dimer) and F150W (monomer) mutants. Only the F150Y mutant exhibited dissociation into monomers in an ionic strength-dependent manner. These results indicated that spatial positions and interactions between F150-aromatic side chains were crucial to homotrimer stabilization. This finding was supported by QM calculations. In a functional respect, differences in the reaction property in the ground and photoexcited states were revealed. The analysis of photointermediates revealed a decrease in the accumulation of O, which is important for Cl(-) release, and the acceleration of the decay rate in L1 and L2, which are involved in Cl(-) transfer inside the molecule, in the trimer-dissociated mutants. Interestingly, the affinity of them to Cl(-) in the photoexcited state increased rather than the trimer, whereas that in the ground state was almost the same without relation to the oligomeric state. It was also observed that the efficient recovery of the photocycle to the ground state was inhibited in the mutants. In addition, a branched pathway that was not included in Cl(-) transportation was predicted. These results suggest that the trimer assembly may contribute to the regulation of the dynamics in the excited state of NpHR.

Characteristics of halorhodopsin-bacterioruberin complex from Natronomonas pharaonis membrane in the solubilized system

Halorhodopsin is a retinal protein with a seven-transmembrane helix and acts as an inward light-driven Cl(-) pump. In this study, structural state of the solubilized halorhodopsin (NpHR) from the biomembrane of mutant strain KM-1 of Natronomonas pharaonis in nonionic detergent was investigated. A gel filtration chromatography monitored absorbances at 280 and 504 nm corresponding to the protein and a lipid soluble pigment of bacterioruberin (BR), respectively, has clearly detected an oligomer formation of the NpHRs and a complex formation between the NpHR and BR in the solubilized system. A molar ratio of NpHR:BR in the solubilized complex was close to 1:1. Further SDS-PAGE analysis of the solubilized NpHR cross-linked by 1% glutaraldehyde has revealed that the NpHR forms homotrimer in detergent system. Although this trimeric structure was stable in the presence of NaCl, it was dissociated to the monomer by the heat treatment at 45 °C in the desalted condition. The same tendency has been reported in the case of trimeric NpHR expressed heterologously on the E. coli membrane, leading to a conclusion that the change of strength of the trimeric association dependent on the ion binding is a universal feature of the NpHR. Interestingly, the trimer dissociation on the NpHR was accompanied by the complete dissociation of the BR molecule from the protein, indicated that the cavity formed by the NpHR protomers in the trimeric conformation is important for tight binding of the BR. Because the binding affinity for Cl(-) and the resistance to hydroxylamine under light illumination showed only minor differences between the NpHR in the solubilized state and that on the biomembrane, the influences of solubilization to the tertiary structure and function of the protein are thought to be minor. This NpHR-BR complex in the solubilized system has a potential to be a good model system to investigate the intermolecular interaction between the membrane protein and lipid.

Expression of salinarum halorhodopsin in Escherichia coli cells: solubilization in the presence of retinal yields the natural state

Salinarum halorhodopsin (HsHR), a light-driven chloride ion pump of haloarchaeon Halobacterium salinarum, was heterologously expressed in Escherichia coli. The expressed HsHR had no color in the E. coli membrane, but turned purple after solubilization in the presence of all-trans retinal. This colored HsHR was purified by Ni-chelate chromatography in a yield of 3-4 mg per liter culture. The purified HsHR showed a distinct chloride pumping activity by incorporation into the liposomes, and showed even in the detergent-solubilized state, its typical behaviors in both the unphotolyzed and photolyzed states. Upon solubilization, HsHR expressed in the E. coli membrane attains the proper folding and a trimeric assembly comparable to those in the native membranes.